WEBVTT

00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:00.000


00:03:04.804 --> 00:03:06.804
now you I'm we don't time sir I

00:03:07.305 --> 00:03:09.305
gotta go.

00:03:10.243 --> 00:03:12.243
Told me.

00:03:12.412 --> 00:03:14.212
If you're. A good afternoon I am
calling the hearing of the.

00:03:14.480 --> 00:03:16.547
Assembly education committee to
order as a sub committee were

00:03:16.547 --> 00:03:18.450
going to start as a subcommittee
because we do not as of yet have

00:03:19.118 --> 00:03:21.118
a quorum.

00:03:21.520 --> 00:03:23.987
The secretary will call the
roll and I do we notice there's

00:03:24.890 --> 00:03:26.825
potential for a quorum.
Are we have thirty seven bills

00:03:27.192 --> 00:03:29.193
on file today three armed
consent for have been pulled the

00:03:30.263 --> 00:03:32.965
consent items are. As follows I
never twenty nine ab twenty

00:03:32.965 --> 00:03:35.599
eight ninety one by Mister All
my don't over thirty two eighty

00:03:36.660 --> 00:03:38.402
three zero five eight by me.
Item number thirty seven ab

00:03:38.703 --> 00:03:41.173
thirty two thirty three by
Mister Kiley of the consent

00:03:41.173 --> 00:03:44.740
items the bills that have been
pulled r. A. B.. I'm sorry item
number seventeen twenty five

00:03:44.143 --> 00:03:46.177
seventy five minister santiago
item number twenty three ab

00:03:47.779 --> 00:03:50.714
twenty six seventy three of us
reyes.
I and number twenty six ab

00:03:50.882 --> 00:03:52.916
twenty seven fifty two aye mr
gipson item number thirty five.

00:03:54.252 --> 00:03:56.686
Ab thirty to sixty minister
kiley that leaves
thirty bills to be heard that's
a lot of bills.

00:03:57.221 --> 00:03:59.357
Arm.
We will take testimony and let

00:03:59.357 --> 00:04:01.691
me they make this clear to
everyone we will take testimony

00:04:02.693 --> 00:04:04.693
from two witnesses support and

00:04:06.662 --> 00:04:08.565
two witnesses in opposition only.
And the serb.

00:04:10.301 --> 00:04:12.350
Just of a prior arrangement.
In this to each measure each

00:04:13.102 --> 00:04:15.372
witness will have to minutes the
come up nearly all of two
minutes.

00:04:15.372 --> 00:04:17.640
we are the two witnesses well
all others in support or

00:04:17.875 --> 00:04:19.875
opposition are welcome to come

00:04:20.770 --> 00:04:22.712
the microphone and only do this.
Only give your name.

00:04:23.682 --> 00:04:25.915
Affiliation and position on the
bill is any more conversation

00:04:26.750 --> 00:04:28.750
you will be cut off.

00:04:28.952 --> 00:04:31.220
That as they the the the two
witnesses they're coming forth

00:04:31.521 --> 00:04:33.322
with the two minutes are the
ones that are going to give the

00:04:34.924 --> 00:04:37.600
d.. Tail discussion again ever
coming up to the mike afterwards

00:04:37.600 --> 00:04:39.195
lining up.
You only say whether or not you

00:04:39.195 --> 00:04:41.898
are in supporter opposition of
that.

00:04:41.898 --> 00:04:44.465
I whatever rather for our first
order of business and that is mr

00:04:45.100 --> 00:04:47.936
medina.
And that is.
.

00:04:49.710 --> 00:04:51.239
Hold on a second.
File item number one.

00:04:57.460 --> 00:04:59.946
Ab twenty seven fifty six.
I don't a violin number one ab

00:05:00.849 --> 00:05:02.250
twenty seven fifty six by mr
medina you May.

00:05:04.219 --> 00:05:06.219
.

00:05:16.263 --> 00:05:18.263
Proceed when ready.

00:05:19.100 --> 00:05:21.201
No.
Impetus beginning.

00:05:21.501 --> 00:05:24.271
A.
From a.
Very.

00:05:25.390 --> 00:05:27.390
.

00:05:27.420 --> 00:05:29.420
A.

00:05:29.444 --> 00:05:31.444
Notorious case in in my district

00:05:31.945 --> 00:05:34.481
the turban case that happened in
the city. Of paris that I

00:05:35.782 --> 00:05:38.718
represent.
I I won a state for the record

00:05:39.385 --> 00:05:41.620
that I have been a.
Public school teacher for thirty

00:05:42.422 --> 00:05:44.422
four years.

00:05:44.892 --> 00:05:47.795
.
Someone who values education and

00:05:48.796 --> 00:05:51.597
all the choices that there are
in education.

00:05:52.834 --> 00:05:54.834
someone who realizes that not

00:05:54.900 --> 00:05:56.836
one size fits all when it comes
to education someone who

00:05:57.903 --> 00:06:00.574
believes.
That that parents and students

00:06:01.140 --> 00:06:03.741
should have a choice.
And how they educate their

00:06:04.878 --> 00:06:07.746
children.
I myself was educated in private

00:06:08.180 --> 00:06:10.180
schools attending.

00:06:11.451 --> 00:06:13.451
Parochial catholic schools for.

00:06:13.653 --> 00:06:15.653
Nine years.

00:06:15.820 --> 00:06:18.390
So I think that means that my
parents were willing to.

00:06:20.526 --> 00:06:22.526
Sacrifice to make sure that.

00:06:22.795 --> 00:06:25.764
Their four children had the kind
of schooling that they wanted.

00:06:26.799 --> 00:06:28.799
So as I present today I wanna be

00:06:29.435 --> 00:06:31.435
clear. That I value home

00:06:32.638 --> 00:06:34.638
schooling that I do not see this

00:06:35.374 --> 00:06:37.374
bill and anyway. As an attack on

00:06:37.376 --> 00:06:39.943
home schooling I've enjoyed the
conversations that with my

00:06:41.947 --> 00:06:44.781
colleagues a james gallagher who
himself. A home schooled his.

00:06:45.983 --> 00:06:48.753
Children.
The bill was amended.

00:06:49.721 --> 00:06:51.721
.

00:06:51.757 --> 00:06:53.757
After those discussions.

00:06:54.326 --> 00:06:56.427
And I I I think it's a a better
bill now.

00:06:57.260 --> 00:06:58.796
Than it was before those
discussions with Mister

00:06:59.431 --> 00:07:02.366
Gallagher.
So today I present assembly bill

00:07:03.835 --> 00:07:06.169
twenty seven fifty six.
In california home schools are

00:07:06.871 --> 00:07:09.406
classified under the umbrella of
private schools

00:07:09.739 --> 00:07:11.739
and there is little information

00:07:12.376 --> 00:07:15.112
known about homes schools.
And the type of private school

00:07:16.614 --> 00:07:19.490
programs throughout the state.
All private schools including

00:07:20.251 --> 00:07:22.251
home schools.

00:07:22.586 --> 00:07:24.586
Filed the private school out

00:07:24.588 --> 00:07:26.389
affidavit annually to the
california department of

00:07:27.456 --> 00:07:29.456
education.

00:07:29.593 --> 00:07:32.562
A private school affidavit is a
registration document.

00:07:34.398 --> 00:07:36.398
Required to be filled annually.

00:07:36.633 --> 00:07:38.633
By operators of private school

00:07:38.935 --> 00:07:41.704
or home school. To ensure that
there is no violation. Of the

00:07:43.173 --> 00:07:45.841
truancy la.
Information collected on the

00:07:46.543 --> 00:07:48.543
private school affidavit.

00:07:48.977 --> 00:07:51.847
Is geared toward an institution.
And as a result. We have very

00:07:52.449 --> 00:07:54.449
little information.

00:07:54.651 --> 00:07:57.618
On the nature or the types of
private school programs.

00:07:57.720 --> 00:07:59.720
And the numbers associated with

00:07:59.889 --> 00:08:01.889
them.

00:08:02.358 --> 00:08:04.358
Outside of making assumptions.

00:08:04.494 --> 00:08:06.494
Based on enrollment numbers

00:08:06.595 --> 00:08:09.296
we do not have the definitive
way. To know that what the

00:08:09.832 --> 00:08:12.401
numbers are.
Associated with different types

00:08:13.969 --> 00:08:16.170
of programs.
Assembly bill twenty seven fifty

00:08:17.272 --> 00:08:19.272
six.

00:08:19.675 --> 00:08:21.675
Clarifies the definition.

00:08:22.344 --> 00:08:24.211
A private school in california.
Helps to dis aggregate

00:08:25.113 --> 00:08:27.582
information
collected on the private school

00:08:28.383 --> 00:08:31.850
affidavit.
By adding a field.

00:08:32.219 --> 00:08:34.219
On the affidavit that would

00:08:34.222 --> 00:08:36.222
require the filer.

00:08:36.758 --> 00:08:38.926
Self select.
The nature of the private school

00:08:40.795 --> 00:08:43.163
from a list of options.
And I think I you all.

00:08:43.998 --> 00:08:45.998
Will have a a copy of that

00:08:46.767 --> 00:08:49.469
affidavit.
This information would then be

00:08:49.736 --> 00:08:51.736
added to the directory a private

00:08:51.873 --> 00:08:54.808
school.
Six or more students that is

00:08:56.760 --> 00:08:58.511
already listed publicly.
On the california department of

00:08:58.612 --> 00:09:00.612
education.

00:09:03.500 --> 00:09:05.216
Website.
I understand that there has been

00:09:06.860 --> 00:09:08.853
confusion.
On whether the bill.

00:09:08.989 --> 00:09:10.989
we'll impact the privacy of

00:09:11.224 --> 00:09:13.224
schools.

00:09:14.795 --> 00:09:16.662
Five or fewer children enroll.
It is not the intent of this

00:09:17.463 --> 00:09:19.463
bill.

00:09:19.633 --> 00:09:21.633
To include information of those

00:09:22.350 --> 00:09:24.350
schools publicly.

00:09:24.904 --> 00:09:27.439
To make this explicitly clear.
I have requested amendments from

00:09:29.430 --> 00:09:31.430
the legislative counsel.

00:09:31.144 --> 00:09:33.144
These amendments insurer.

00:09:35.299 --> 00:09:37.716
That any school
five or fewer students
will absolutely not.

00:09:38.751 --> 00:09:40.552
The public
on the department of education

00:09:42.689 --> 00:09:44.689
website.

00:09:44.690 --> 00:09:46.690
I believe that it's important.

00:09:47.192 --> 00:09:49.192
Print educational options.

00:09:49.795 --> 00:09:51.795
To meet the unique is the unique

00:09:51.964 --> 00:09:54.699
needs of each child.
Also believe it's important to

00:09:55.434 --> 00:09:57.468
have more information.
On the type of programs in the

00:09:58.103 --> 00:10:00.472
state.
So that we as a state can be

00:10:00.472 --> 00:10:02.472
held accountable.

00:10:03.574 --> 00:10:06.510
For our students.
With me today in support is dr

00:10:07.279 --> 00:10:09.612
ron reynolds.
Executive director of the

00:10:10.181 --> 00:10:12.181
california association of

00:10:12.851 --> 00:10:14.851
private schools organization.

00:10:15.153 --> 00:10:17.354
Statewide association of twenty
four private schools service

00:10:17.889 --> 00:10:20.858
agencies.
And administrative units

00:10:21.192 --> 00:10:23.860
that serve approximately one
thousand

00:10:24.262 --> 00:10:26.830
five hundred and fifty private
schools.

00:10:28.199 --> 00:10:31.167
Enrolling roughly four hundred
thousand students

00:10:32.735 --> 00:10:34.735
in grades k. Through twelve.

00:10:35.407 --> 00:10:37.407
I'm also joined by jeff baca.

00:10:37.408 --> 00:10:39.408
Chief governmental relations

00:10:39.608 --> 00:10:41.608
officer for the riverside county

00:10:44.715 --> 00:10:47.216
office of education.
But the assembly member.

00:10:47.985 --> 00:10:50.786
Chairman O'donnell and committee
members good afternoon.

00:10:51.721 --> 00:10:54.223
Ron reynolds cap so.
We are approaching the one

00:10:54.858 --> 00:10:57.393
hundredth anniversary of the
landmark u. S. Supreme court

00:10:58.128 --> 00:11:00.863
decision in pierce versus
society of sisters.

00:11:01.197 --> 00:11:03.499
The decision that firmly
establishes the fundamental

00:11:04.434 --> 00:11:06.533
right of parents
to direct the education of their

00:11:07.300 --> 00:11:09.169
children.
In its unanimous ruling the

00:11:09.906 --> 00:11:12.107
court declared.
The fundamental theory of

00:11:12.373 --> 00:11:14.373
liberty upon which all

00:11:14.377 --> 00:11:16.810
governments of this union rest.
Excludes any general power of

00:11:18.147 --> 00:11:20.682
the state.
Standardize its children by

00:11:20.950 --> 00:11:22.984
forcing them to accept
instruction from public teachers

00:11:23.619 --> 00:11:26.589
only.
Child is not the mere creature

00:11:27.423 --> 00:11:29.658
of the state.
Those to nurture him and direct

00:11:30.727 --> 00:11:32.727
his destiny have the right

00:11:32.861 --> 00:11:34.861
coupled with the high duty. To

00:11:34.896 --> 00:11:37.130
recognize and prepare him for
additional obligations.

00:11:37.466 --> 00:11:40.267
However.
The ruling.

00:11:41.969 --> 00:11:44.400
Contained on additional finding
that is no less significant and

00:11:44.972 --> 00:11:47.908
I quote.
No question is raised

00:11:48.276 --> 00:11:51.100
concerning the power of the
state.

00:11:51.579 --> 00:11:53.812
Reasonably to regulate all
schools

00:11:54.848 --> 00:11:56.848
to inspect.

00:11:57.385 --> 00:12:00.520
Supervise and examine them their
teachers and pupils.

00:12:00.823 --> 00:12:02.823
To require that all children of

00:12:04.900 --> 00:12:06.900
proper age attend some school.

00:12:07.326 --> 00:12:08.862
That teachers be of good moral
character and patriotic

00:12:09.763 --> 00:12:11.865
disposition that certain studies
plainly essential to good

00:12:13.334 --> 00:12:15.334
citizenship must be taught. And

00:12:15.637 --> 00:12:17.804
that nothing be taught which is
manifestly inimical.

00:12:19.371 --> 00:12:21.371
The public welfare.

00:12:21.441 --> 00:12:24.343
One cannot uphold one tenet
while ignoring or rejecting the

00:12:24.745 --> 00:12:26.745
other.

00:12:26.747 --> 00:12:29.447
Both parents and the state
possess rights

00:12:30.217 --> 00:12:32.217
that must be balanced

00:12:32.919 --> 00:12:34.453
through cooperative efforts.
See that regulation is

00:12:34.921 --> 00:12:37.190
reasonable.
I certainly believe that such a

00:12:37.724 --> 00:12:40.693
balance has long been maintained
in california. And I believe

00:12:41.694 --> 00:12:43.694
that ab twenty seven fifty six

00:12:43.696 --> 00:12:45.696
the bill before you is nothing

00:12:45.898 --> 00:12:47.898
if not reasonable.

00:12:48.566 --> 00:12:50.566
Our schools are private.

00:12:51.437 --> 00:12:54.372
They're not secret.
We are happy to disclose our

00:12:55.241 --> 00:12:57.608
essential nature to the public.
And we are pleased to support ab

00:12:57.608 --> 00:12:59.608
twenty seven fifties

00:13:00.546 --> 00:13:02.546
thank you.

00:13:02.948 --> 00:13:05.483
Thank you Mister Chairmembers
and staff.
Jeff baca with the riverside

00:13:05.784 --> 00:13:08.190
county office of education
representing.

00:13:08.754 --> 00:13:11.589
Riverside county superintendent
of schools dr judy white.

00:13:12.658 --> 00:13:15.426
This is not normally an issue
that we would engage and. As I'm

00:13:15.827 --> 00:13:17.827
sure you're all aware county

00:13:18.328 --> 00:13:20.328
offices of education do not have

00:13:20.432 --> 00:13:23.366
statutory role in either the
establishment or the oversight

00:13:24.235 --> 00:13:27.137
of private schools.
Our involvement in engagement

00:13:27.705 --> 00:13:30.107
with the issue reap resulted
from the.

00:13:30.842 --> 00:13:32.842
Turpin case that assembly

00:13:33.211 --> 00:13:35.644
member medina referenced.
And very quickly we.

00:13:36.246 --> 00:13:38.246
Heard from a lot of our

00:13:38.282 --> 00:13:40.817
partners and local government
including law enforcement.

00:13:42.285 --> 00:13:44.285
Department of social services.

00:13:44.321 --> 00:13:46.956
This morning to find out what
were that responsibilities with

00:13:48.826 --> 00:13:51.160
respect to oversight of home
schools that were private

00:13:52.960 --> 00:13:54.960
schools. Was there anything that

00:13:54.331 --> 00:13:57.133
could be done to prevent
something like this from
happening.

00:13:57.601 --> 00:13:59.601
We've continued to play a role

00:14:00.370 --> 00:14:02.838
as the months have interceded in
working with he court appointed

00:14:03.605 --> 00:14:05.908
attorneys for the children. As
well as the court appointed

00:14:08.780 --> 00:14:10.780
public guardian in order to.

00:14:10.213 --> 00:14:12.213
Identify options for a sound

00:14:12.415 --> 00:14:15.184
educational program for these
children many of whom are now

00:14:15.818 --> 00:14:18.554
adults so it has proven to be a
bit of a challenge.

00:14:18.755 --> 00:14:21.289
We haven't done that because
we're we're required to do that

00:14:22.240 --> 00:14:24.392
by statute. We've done that
because we felt it was the right

00:14:25.394 --> 00:14:27.394
thing to do in working with our

00:14:27.762 --> 00:14:30.364
partners in riverside county.
As we talks to our school

00:14:31.801 --> 00:14:33.567
districts and answer the
inquiries that we are getting

00:14:34.870 --> 00:14:37.572
from. Our local partners about
the rolls of districts county

00:14:37.840 --> 00:14:39.707
offices as well as the
california department of

00:14:40.109 --> 00:14:42.910
education.
Ave became clear to us that

00:14:43.946 --> 00:14:46.646
there are some gaps in the
information that is available.

00:14:47.649 --> 00:14:49.649
And in some instances you have

00:14:50.252 --> 00:14:52.920
the unfortunate case where. A
school attendance review the

00:14:53.488 --> 00:14:55.488
person responsible for school

00:14:55.757 --> 00:14:57.757
attendance review wonder statute

00:14:57.924 --> 00:15:00.694
does play a very small role with
respect to verifying the

00:15:01.896 --> 00:15:03.963
existence of private schools.
Within the boundaries of the

00:15:04.999 --> 00:15:07.968
school district did not know
what the existence of certain

00:15:08.503 --> 00:15:10.503
home private schools.

00:15:10.738 --> 00:15:13.707
So while it's certainly not our
intent to infringe on the rights

00:15:14.709 --> 00:15:17.210
of parents to educate there's
children and I setting that they

00:15:18.913 --> 00:15:20.913
believe is most proper for them.

00:15:21.481 --> 00:15:23.516
The right and high duty that the
previous speaker mentioned.

00:15:25.452 --> 00:15:28.119
We do see ab twenty seven fifty
six as a modest attempt.

00:15:28.756 --> 00:15:31.557
To provide more information than
is currently available.

00:15:32.392 --> 00:15:34.559
With this if you could summarize
perhaps worry with this have

00:15:35.160 --> 00:15:37.762
made a difference in the turban
case I don't think any of us can

00:15:37.963 --> 00:15:40.933
answer that.
But we as I previously stated we

00:15:42.135 --> 00:15:44.970
believe that the bill is the
right thing to do and we.

00:15:45.372 --> 00:15:47.873
Thank you. Thank you are
opposition are there any

00:15:52.746 --> 00:15:55.180
witnesses in opposition.
So to ed is opposition two

00:15:58.651 --> 00:16:00.651
minutes for each witness.

00:16:00.820 --> 00:16:02.820
You did not ask for other

00:16:03.890 --> 00:16:05.557
witnesses and and I I you know I
you're right I'm. I'm not will

00:16:05.658 --> 00:16:07.658
practice today.

00:16:08.427 --> 00:16:10.427
Other witnesses in support

00:16:10.496 --> 00:16:12.597
use a good skater sit down.
Other witnesses in support.

00:16:13.332 --> 00:16:15.701
.
Seeing no other witnesses in

00:16:15.701 --> 00:16:18.302
support.
It's good to the opposition

00:16:18.470 --> 00:16:20.505
house one of two witnesses two
minutes.

00:16:23.142 --> 00:16:25.142
Each thank you.

00:16:25.310 --> 00:16:27.611
Is is michael I've yes up when a
missile they singleton I'm home

00:16:27.612 --> 00:16:29.547
schooling parents speaking for
the california home school

00:16:29.614 --> 00:16:32.383
network.
First

00:16:34.190 --> 00:16:36.190
we oppose ab two seven five six

00:16:36.688 --> 00:16:38.822
for privacy reasons.
The california legislature has

00:16:39.557 --> 00:16:42.358
worked hard to keep.
The names and addresses of

00:16:43.194 --> 00:16:45.529
school age children private.
The department of education does

00:16:45.663 --> 00:16:47.663
not now published directory

00:16:47.665 --> 00:16:50.670
information on private schools
with five or fewer children

00:16:50.670 --> 00:16:52.869
which are presumed to be home
schools.

00:16:54.500 --> 00:16:56.500
If ab two seven five six passes

00:16:56.207 --> 00:16:58.375
as written school specifically
identified as home schools will

00:16:58.375 --> 00:17:00.777
be posted on the department of
it.

00:17:01.979 --> 00:17:04.147
Excuse me education website.
The information will include the

00:17:04.615 --> 00:17:06.949
families.
Address and the number of

00:17:07.251 --> 00:17:08.551
children in each grade.
This is a.

00:17:09.253 --> 00:17:11.253
.

00:17:11.455 --> 00:17:13.455
Privacy and safety issue.

00:17:13.857 --> 00:17:15.857
Second.

00:17:17.828 --> 00:17:20.529
We oppose ab two seven five six.
Because it mandates additional

00:17:20.964 --> 00:17:22.964
data collection from

00:17:23.333 --> 00:17:25.599
homeschooling families.
That are individually

00:17:27.350 --> 00:17:29.471
identifiable from the data.
This data is not needed to

00:17:30.807 --> 00:17:33.742
administer any existing law or
solve an existing problem it is

00:17:35.912 --> 00:17:37.912
not appropriate to base a policy.

00:17:38.748 --> 00:17:41.216
On alarm ism and headlines.
Decades of studies

00:17:41.817 --> 00:17:43.985
show that homeschoolers are
thriving particularly in

00:17:44.220 --> 00:17:46.688
california which has been a
leader in establishing

00:17:49.240 --> 00:17:50.925
alternative forms of education.
History shows the data

00:17:51.660 --> 00:17:53.660
collection.

00:17:53.862 --> 00:17:56.230
Nationwide has and will become a
pretext for harassment of

00:17:57.198 --> 00:17:59.198
homeschooling families.

00:17:59.468 --> 00:18:01.468
And a prelude to regulation the

00:18:01.536 --> 00:18:03.571
sole function of which is to
eliminate flexibility from

00:18:04.473 --> 00:18:06.340
education.
I'd like to thank the

00:18:06.741 --> 00:18:09.143
legislature for this chance to
share our views and I hope

00:18:09.544 --> 00:18:11.345
you'll reach out to its if you
have additional questions thank

00:18:12.847 --> 00:18:14.847
you. The here next witness.

00:18:15.617 --> 00:18:17.516
Well Mister Chairman.
members of the committee my name

00:18:18.318 --> 00:18:20.654
is nathan pierce private home
educators of california.

00:18:21.220 --> 00:18:23.924
We've all heard of the alleged
abuse in riverside county and
are appalled.

00:18:25.158 --> 00:18:27.628
.
Some have taken the position

00:18:27.628 --> 00:18:30.195
that what happened there is
something to be remedied by for

00:18:31.650 --> 00:18:33.733
the legislation of home based
private education california.

00:18:34.335 --> 00:18:37.103
Hello however my colleagues and
I would not be here today if

00:18:37.738 --> 00:18:39.806
there was not more to the story.
I'm here with solving singleton

00:18:40.307 --> 00:18:43.420
of.
California homeschool network

00:18:44.440 --> 00:18:46.145
also with debbie schwarzer.
Home school association of

00:18:47.470 --> 00:18:49.749
california.
And amend ever of christian home

00:18:50.315 --> 00:18:52.585
educators association of
california and with darren jones

00:18:52.686 --> 00:18:54.987
of home school legal defense
association.

00:18:56.122 --> 00:18:58.457
We are all here today with one
voice to ask you to consider a

00:18:59.459 --> 00:19:01.992
few points.
And to not pass ab twenty seven

00:19:03.463 --> 00:19:06.196
fifty six.
Initial stated intent of this

00:19:07.333 --> 00:19:09.368
bill was to address safety
concerns for home schooled

00:19:10.200 --> 00:19:12.971
students.
Prom and recent study comparing

00:19:13.372 --> 00:19:15.574
the frequency of abuse and
neglect to privately home school

00:19:16.740 --> 00:19:18.710
children in low medium and high
regulation states found that the

00:19:19.311 --> 00:19:21.311
frequency was the same in each

00:19:21.447 --> 00:19:24.150
category. Showing clearly that
more regulation will not impact

00:19:24.617 --> 00:19:27.218
the frequency of the views or
neglecting california.

00:19:27.720 --> 00:19:30.221
The tragic case of the turbine
family in riverside county from

00:19:30.456 --> 00:19:32.723
which so much interest and
concern private home schooling

00:19:33.358 --> 00:19:36.127
has been stirred up doesn't
reflect the homeschooling
community.

00:19:36.895 --> 00:19:39.830
According to the statistics this
type of abuse isn't prevented by

00:19:40.532 --> 00:19:43.167
increased regulations and it
would not have been prevented by

00:19:43.368 --> 00:19:46.235
the type of data collected by
this bill.

00:19:47.339 --> 00:19:49.106
The claim that the ata gathered
will be helpful.

00:19:50.141 --> 00:19:52.910
To.
School officials will not

00:19:53.778 --> 00:19:55.778
actually be realized in a real

00:19:57.281 --> 00:20:00.500
sense as today. Arm currently
the truancy officers in

00:20:01.180 --> 00:20:03.853
california do have access to the
data relating to the private

00:20:04.488 --> 00:20:06.924
school affidavits for those
schools. All schools including

00:20:06.924 --> 00:20:08.924
those with five or fewer

00:20:09.392 --> 00:20:11.392
students.

00:20:12.620 --> 00:20:14.330
Ab twenty five.
Ab twenty seven fifty six is

00:20:15.466 --> 00:20:17.466
unnecessary.

00:20:17.801 --> 00:20:20.269
I make this brief filed by then
attorney general jerry sure he
could summarize.

00:20:21.805 --> 00:20:24.441
Sir.
Should not set policy out of

00:20:24.808 --> 00:20:27.643
sensationalism I will be
available to answer questions

00:20:28.178 --> 00:20:30.579
and respectfully ask for no vote
thank you thank you very much
thank you.

00:20:30.981 --> 00:20:33.416
.
Without another some that did

00:20:33.416 --> 00:20:35.651
not make it the room's these a
large line out there who wanted

00:20:36.319 --> 00:20:39.288
to support.
I this I'm gonna go back the
sport then I'm gonna go to other

00:20:40.223 --> 00:20:42.724
opposition so you just please
come a microphone and if there's

00:20:43.126 --> 00:20:45.694
any others if they could come
through. In support. Only right

00:20:46.295 --> 00:20:48.964
now.
Very briefly Mister Chair I'm

00:20:49.265 --> 00:20:51.967
elizabeth espinosa here on
behalf of the riverside county

00:20:52.368 --> 00:20:55.103
board of supervisors in support
of. Assembly member medina spill

00:20:55.571 --> 00:20:57.571
thank you thank you.

00:20:57.573 --> 00:21:00.900
Seeing no others in support
inside or outside.

00:21:00.900 --> 00:21:02.900
We will.

00:21:04.712 --> 00:21:07.215
Now go to opposition.
May come to the microphone state

00:21:07.216 --> 00:21:09.684
your name affiliation and
position on the bill only this

00:21:09.750 --> 00:21:11.285
committee did you what I think
you're gonna make some

00:21:12.487 --> 00:21:14.155
amendments did you want to did
you want to discuss those right

00:21:15.900 --> 00:21:16.824
now are no.
If you want to clarify though so

00:21:18.930 --> 00:21:20.662
people on it here tonight today.
Yeah would allow. So you might

00:21:20.662 --> 00:21:23.629
want to listen to what Mister
Brady's going to say right now
because it is important when we

00:21:24.165 --> 00:21:26.165
see a man that means he is going

00:21:26.768 --> 00:21:29.336
to change the bill take
something out typically.

00:21:29.869 --> 00:21:32.471
Well amendments of ready been
given.

00:21:33.274 --> 00:21:35.542
To redwood judicial.
Legislative counsel.

00:21:36.744 --> 00:21:38.744
To make it.

00:21:39.512 --> 00:21:42.282
Explicitly clear.
A that the amendments would

00:21:43.170 --> 00:21:45.318
insure.
That any school with five or

00:21:46.420 --> 00:21:48.955
fewer students
would absolutely not.

00:21:49.723 --> 00:21:51.589
Be made public.
On the department of education

00:21:52.660 --> 00:21:54.927
website.
And and that is amendment to

00:21:56.296 --> 00:21:58.296
clarify the intent and what the

00:21:58.699 --> 00:22:01.101
bill does.
Thank you thank you just saw

00:22:01.101 --> 00:22:03.402
there were some other
individuals aye him.

00:22:03.403 --> 00:22:05.269
Who came in later of Mister
Calderon it?

00:22:06.640 --> 00:22:08.841
Has pulled ab twenty five sep
twenty five seventy two has been

00:22:09.308 --> 00:22:11.844
pull that's file item number
sixteen were now going to go to

00:22:12.178 --> 00:22:15.470
opposition your name affiliation
and position on the bill only

00:22:16.820 --> 00:22:18.650
only please. Like darren jones
attorney with home school legal

00:22:19.185 --> 00:22:21.887
defense association we oppose
this bill.

00:22:22.688 --> 00:22:25.230
Any both Chairman Of sacramento
christian organization a parent

00:22:26.959 --> 00:22:29.128
educators we oppose this bill.
Andrew vandiver from the

00:22:29.128 --> 00:22:32.970
christian home educators
association of california and

00:22:33.699 --> 00:22:36.135
also the selah a support group
from silicon valley and from.

00:22:36.135 --> 00:22:38.169
Assemblyman color colors
district and.

00:22:39.238 --> 00:22:41.973
We oppose the bill.
Christopher said now our home

00:22:42.341 --> 00:22:45.900
school graduate I oppose this
bill.

00:22:45.430 --> 00:22:47.430
Western potter homeschool

00:22:47.179 --> 00:22:49.448
graduate and I oppose this bill.
Jessica called liam a private

00:22:49.448 --> 00:22:51.615
home schooler and I oppose this
bill.

00:22:52.149 --> 00:22:54.351
Amber healy I serve on the board
of trustees of subtle but

00:22:54.985 --> 00:22:57.386
christian academy which is a p.
S. P. In orange county and we

00:22:58.490 --> 00:23:00.891
oppose the bill as amended.
Beverly wall to bake with park

00:23:01.393 --> 00:23:03.594
academy home school group in
temple city california we oppose

00:23:04.596 --> 00:23:07.364
the bill.
Evelyn chavez garcia I'm a

00:23:07.532 --> 00:23:09.665
private home schooler and also
with from foundation cristian

00:23:10.467 --> 00:23:12.702
academy.
Of glendora california we oppose

00:23:13.102 --> 00:23:15.405
this bill.
My name is paul tam and I

00:23:15.905 --> 00:23:18.106
represent the gates christian
home school from victorville

00:23:18.107 --> 00:23:20.942
california and I oppose this
bill.

00:23:21.679 --> 00:23:23.945
My name is darla tam and I also
represent the gate christian

00:23:25.115 --> 00:23:27.950
school. In victorville and I
oppose this bill.

00:23:28.319 --> 00:23:30.319
My name is michelle bracero

00:23:30.454 --> 00:23:32.454
represent a revival christian

00:23:32.456 --> 00:23:34.757
academy in riverside county
menifee and we.

00:23:36.425 --> 00:23:38.995
Oppose this bill.
Tanya salinas solely chen

00:23:39.463 --> 00:23:41.463
christian school riverside and I

00:23:41.663 --> 00:23:44.166
oppose this bill.
Dianne padgett christian home

00:23:44.434 --> 00:23:47.202
educators association of
california we oppose this bill

00:23:48.972 --> 00:23:51.730
as amended.
Tatiana doria's.

00:23:51.706 --> 00:23:54.443
Homeschool mother of six from
riverside california and aye

00:23:55.245 --> 00:23:57.980
opposed spell. Great thank you
you have two lines you can light

00:23:58.448 --> 00:24:00.981
up right be on the other person.
Thank you please continue kayla

00:24:01.952 --> 00:24:03.518
darius home school student of
riverside california and I

00:24:04.620 --> 00:24:07.522
oppose this bill.
Hannah williams up private home

00:24:07.857 --> 00:24:09.857
school student riverside

00:24:10.590 --> 00:24:12.425
california I oppose this bill.
Taylor joba home still student I

00:24:13.629 --> 00:24:15.697
oppose this bill victoria green
home school student and I oppose

00:24:17.399 --> 00:24:19.399
this bill.

00:24:19.535 --> 00:24:21.535
Tammy green and home school mom

00:24:22.938 --> 00:24:25.473
of three and I oppose this bill.
In riverside county california.

00:24:25.474 --> 00:24:27.474
Lisa drove off riverside

00:24:27.741 --> 00:24:30.711
california in a home school
moment I oppose this bill.

00:24:31.345 --> 00:24:34.490
France to glaze private home
schooler la mirada and I oppose

00:24:34.490 --> 00:24:36.782
this bill amanda kleiss
classical conversations

00:24:37.352 --> 00:24:39.921
supporting southern california.
And I oppose this bill as

00:24:40.880 --> 00:24:42.880
amended.

00:24:43.659 --> 00:24:46.293
On fiscal.
And.

00:24:46.894 --> 00:24:48.894
Bob was.

00:24:51.332 --> 00:24:53.934
Bill.
Angela last home school parent

00:24:54.268 --> 00:24:56.836
representing foundation
christian school from long run

00:24:57.238 --> 00:24:59.238
to california and I oppose this

00:24:59.273 --> 00:25:01.940
bill as amended.
Kill blush from foundation
christian school oppose this

00:25:03.310 --> 00:25:06.279
bill.
Jesse pocket from foundation

00:25:06.680 --> 00:25:09.380
christian school and I oppose
this bill. Jordan lash

00:25:09.950 --> 00:25:11.884
homeschool graduate from
foundation christian school and

00:25:13.453 --> 00:25:15.788
I oppose this bill. Nancy packet
foundation christian school

00:25:17.570 --> 00:25:19.391
administrator at home school mom
I oppose this bill as amended.

00:25:20.393 --> 00:25:22.761
Jennifer mendoza foundation
christian school I'm also oppose

00:25:23.564 --> 00:25:25.564
a spell.

00:25:25.664 --> 00:25:27.866
Nathan mendez I am a I I am a
private home schooler and I

00:25:29.736 --> 00:25:31.736
oppose this bill.

00:25:31.804 --> 00:25:33.804
Valley espinoza homeschool

00:25:33.938 --> 00:25:35.974
graduate in a strongly opposes.
Michelle espinoza home school

00:25:36.676 --> 00:25:39.770
mother five and I strongly
oppose this bill. Michael

00:25:40.790 --> 00:25:42.514
espinoza homeschool graduate and
I strongly oppose this bill.

00:25:42.882 --> 00:25:45.830
I am julia camp and I'm from the
gate questions going to oppose

00:25:45.583 --> 00:25:47.485
this bill.
My name's jennifer obvious I'm a

00:25:48.419 --> 00:25:50.855
private home school mom from
senator dole and I put this bill

00:25:52.910 --> 00:25:54.292
as amended.
My name is jamie some modeling

00:25:54.560 --> 00:25:57.600
and with the christian military
homeschoolers of san diego and

00:25:58.197 --> 00:26:00.231
we oppose this bill.
My name is john gallon home

00:26:00.698 --> 00:26:03.334
school parent also representing
grayson glory academy from

00:26:04.501 --> 00:26:06.501
corona we oppose this bill.

00:26:06.771 --> 00:26:08.771
Kill my gallon home school and I

00:26:09.474 --> 00:26:11.474
oppose this bill.

00:26:11.576 --> 00:26:13.844
Josh from a gallon.
Home school student and aye

00:26:14.377 --> 00:26:16.377
opposed bill.

00:26:17.480 --> 00:26:19.480
Good afternoon my name is one

00:26:20.251 --> 00:26:22.919
dollar trees I represent right
what the community of right wood

00:26:23.420 --> 00:26:25.420
and we oppose.

00:26:26.390 --> 00:26:29.258
Ab twenty seven fifty six.
My name is julie mcgowan I'm a

00:26:29.459 --> 00:26:31.629
former home school as well as
holes mostly my children now and

00:26:31.629 --> 00:26:33.629
I'm from chronic california I

00:26:36.267 --> 00:26:38.267
oppose this bill.

00:26:42.338 --> 00:26:44.338
Kiley mean is clara. And.

00:26:44.374 --> 00:26:46.374
This afternoon my name is

00:26:47.811 --> 00:26:50.646
barbaric. Our honesty.
Ambassador and the status home

00:26:52.781 --> 00:26:54.583
school supply. In chino and.
After the five hundred opposes

00:26:55.986 --> 00:26:58.887
this bill.
It.
Inlet.
Home school parents and I

00:26:58.989 --> 00:27:01.690
oppose this bill as amended.
April dela cruz I am a

00:27:02.592 --> 00:27:05.294
representative.
From the city of chino of

00:27:06.396 --> 00:27:08.163
calvary chapel of chino hills
and our ten thousand

00:27:09.999 --> 00:27:12.367
constituents oppose this bill.
My name is sandra up I am a

00:27:12.368 --> 00:27:14.368
private home school student and

00:27:14.936 --> 00:27:17.607
I oppose this bill.
I am just left and I'm a private

00:27:17.607 --> 00:27:20.340
home schooler student and I
oppose this bill.

00:27:21.430 --> 00:27:23.478
Cecilia chafin representing
seats christian family schools

00:27:25.147 --> 00:27:27.147
the san diego county. And we

00:27:27.182 --> 00:27:30.840
oppose this bill as amended.
Sandy corrosion President Of

00:27:30.719 --> 00:27:33.387
california parents involved in
education and we oppose this

00:27:34.489 --> 00:27:36.557
bill.
Beth's one also a member of

00:27:36.825 --> 00:27:39.527
california parents voted
education and a homeschooling

00:27:40.562 --> 00:27:43.264
mom and we oppose this bill for
President Health. Items esto

00:27:44.399 --> 00:27:46.834
moralis I am a home schooler and
I oppose this bill.

00:27:47.902 --> 00:27:49.902
My name is lucas wells I'm I'm

00:27:49.936 --> 00:27:52.673
score and I pose this bill.
My name is July wells I'm home

00:27:52.841 --> 00:27:55.676
schooler and aye opposed to
spell my name is diego for us I

00:27:56.311 --> 00:27:58.377
am a homeschooling I oppose this
bill.

00:27:58.778 --> 00:28:00.981
My name is melinda wells and I'm
a parent homeschoolers. And I

00:28:02.150 --> 00:28:04.952
oppose this bill.
But aims look mccreight I'm
privately homeschooled and I

00:28:04.952 --> 00:28:07.220
oppose this bill.
My name is million it cramped

00:28:07.488 --> 00:28:09.488
have home schooling and I also

00:28:09.490 --> 00:28:11.825
was this.
My name is if I'm create.

00:28:15.902 --> 00:28:18.131
Private home schooler and I've
opposes bills.
I'm low limon cram privates

00:28:18.132 --> 00:28:20.700
homeschoolers student and I
oppose this bill.

00:28:21.100 --> 00:28:23.369
My name is a bonta mcrae and I'm
a private home school parents

00:28:24.438 --> 00:28:26.205
and I pose a spell. As amended
my name is saying inventive in

00:28:26.772 --> 00:28:29.208
I'm a private home school
student and I oppose this bill.

00:28:30.110 --> 00:28:32.912
My name is anthony vander veen I
am a private home school student

00:28:34.613 --> 00:28:37.116
and I oppose bill ab twenty
seven fifty six.

00:28:37.484 --> 00:28:39.486
I'm josh bender vienen I'm a
privately homeschooled students

00:28:39.486 --> 00:28:41.520
and I oppose this bill as
amended.

00:28:42.388 --> 00:28:44.388
My name is eliana duggar I am a

00:28:44.991 --> 00:28:46.991
home school private student and

00:28:47.600 --> 00:28:49.361
I oppose the spell.
My name is breanna vander veen

00:28:49.562 --> 00:28:51.562
I'm a private home educator and

00:28:53.599 --> 00:28:55.599
I oppose the spell.

00:28:56.569 --> 00:28:58.569
My name is molly duggar and I am

00:28:59.505 --> 00:29:01.840
a private school student.
La police to spell.

00:29:02.474 --> 00:29:05.143
My name is kimberly dagger I'm a
homeschool graduate and home

00:29:05.411 --> 00:29:07.811
schooled other of six that I
oppose this bill.

00:29:09.248 --> 00:29:11.248
My name is mia duggar and.

00:29:11.350 --> 00:29:13.350
I am.

00:29:13.651 --> 00:29:16.487
A. Home school student and that
puts a spell.

00:29:17.454 --> 00:29:19.454
My name is mark duggar.

00:29:19.925 --> 00:29:21.925
I am a home school student and I

00:29:22.260 --> 00:29:23.961
oppose this bill.
My name is carrie of lavenham

00:29:24.863 --> 00:29:27.364
from sunnyvale california I'm a
former homeschoolers of to

00:29:27.699 --> 00:29:29.699
professional athletes and I

00:29:30.340 --> 00:29:32.603
oppose this bill.
My name is gerry salinas I am a

00:29:32.770 --> 00:29:35.639
private home schooler and I
oppose this bill.

00:29:35.873 --> 00:29:37.873
I'm san and friedman I'm a home

00:29:38.142 --> 00:29:40.142
school educator and I oppose

00:29:40.344 --> 00:29:42.344
this bill even as amended.

00:29:42.947 --> 00:29:44.947
My name is eli friedman and I

00:29:46.884 --> 00:29:48.585
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is angela warner I'm a

00:29:49.190 --> 00:29:51.190
private home school parent and

00:29:51.422 --> 00:29:53.422
aye opposed.

00:29:53.524 --> 00:29:55.524
My name is harrison warner I am

00:29:58.328 --> 00:30:00.162
homeschooled. I oppose.
My name is michelle burke chen

00:30:01.365 --> 00:30:03.365
aye private home school educator

00:30:03.567 --> 00:30:05.567
and I oppose the bill as amended.

00:30:07.722 --> 00:30:08.966
My names abbey meyers I'm a home
schooler and. Pose this bill.

00:30:09.972 --> 00:30:11.972
I renee meyer apparent and I

00:30:13.430 --> 00:30:15.430
opposes.

00:30:16.846 --> 00:30:18.846
In case my. And I am a home

00:30:19.249 --> 00:30:21.249
school student and I purchased.

00:30:21.850 --> 00:30:23.850
I am scared inclined I am home

00:30:23.852 --> 00:30:26.389
school soon and post this bill.
I'm kathleen dan quinn from
roseville california I am a

00:30:26.389 --> 00:30:29.191
homeschooling parent and I
oppose this bill strongly even

00:30:30.159 --> 00:30:33.128
as amended. By michelle dan
crying I'm a home school student

00:30:34.163 --> 00:30:36.898
I oppose this bill.
I can really dan klein I'm a
homeschool graduate and I oppose

00:30:36.999 --> 00:30:39.133
this bill.
My name is gonna anderson I'm

00:30:39.133 --> 00:30:41.602
here with parents united for
kids. I'm a former home school

00:30:41.904 --> 00:30:43.904
and college graduate was suma

00:30:44.600 --> 00:30:46.600
laude honors and I strongly

00:30:46.475 --> 00:30:49.800
oppose this bill even as amended.
My name is stephanie fetzer and

00:30:49.144 --> 00:30:51.811
home school mother of three
children and the co founder of

00:30:52.481 --> 00:30:55.470
parents united for kids. A
grassroots organization

00:30:55.817 --> 00:30:57.817
committed to protecting parents'

00:30:57.886 --> 00:31:00.453
rights I do represent your
twenty three thousand people.

00:31:01.589 --> 00:31:04.458
Think your name evaluation a
position on the bill thank you.

00:31:05.193 --> 00:31:07.327
Everybody's done so well. Is
please keep it on we want to

00:31:07.327 --> 00:31:08.962
hear we wanna hear your opinion
we do as a thank you for being

00:31:09.364 --> 00:31:11.264
here.
My name shauna lambert I am a

00:31:11.799 --> 00:31:13.799
mom and with parents nay for

00:31:14.802 --> 00:31:17.237
kids I oppose this bill.
Hi my name is julie makeshift

00:31:18.390 --> 00:31:20.372
men I represent over five forty
five hundred families with the

00:31:20.775 --> 00:31:22.775
homeschool association of

00:31:22.877 --> 00:31:25.178
california. And three hundred
families from ran home schoolers

00:31:26.547 --> 00:31:29.182
and I oppose this bill.
My name is lindsay trost I am a

00:31:29.883 --> 00:31:31.818
second generation homeschool
homeschoolers.

00:31:32.451 --> 00:31:34.451
And I oppose this bill I'm from

00:31:34.822 --> 00:31:37.190
ripping california.
My name is riley trust I'm from

00:31:37.190 --> 00:31:39.959
ripping california and I put a
spell.

00:31:40.930 --> 00:31:42.695
Hi my name su zi born I'm a
veteran home school mother for

00:31:42.896 --> 00:31:45.329
since nineteen eighty eight and
I oppose this bill ripping

00:31:46.333 --> 00:31:49.134
california. I am today born
homeschool mom of three and I

00:31:50.700 --> 00:31:52.369
oppose this bill.
I'm tyler born for ripping

00:31:53.873 --> 00:31:55.541
california a second generation
home schooler and I oppose this

00:31:56.207 --> 00:31:58.143
bill.
I'm elizabeth shilling for

00:31:58.410 --> 00:32:00.410
ripping california I'm a home

00:32:00.580 --> 00:32:02.882
school mother for and I am with
central valley advocates for

00:32:02.882 --> 00:32:05.483
parental rights and we oppose
this bill.

00:32:05.850 --> 00:32:07.786
And jason showing for written
california homeschool father

00:32:09.687 --> 00:32:11.687
oppose this bill.

00:32:11.924 --> 00:32:14.324
I'm w. Shores are from los altos
california with the homeschool

00:32:15.194 --> 00:32:17.662
association of california and
all that also the gifted

00:32:19.330 --> 00:32:21.330
homeschoolers forum and we

00:32:21.867 --> 00:32:23.868
oppose this bill as amended.
Pretty green representing

00:32:24.636 --> 00:32:26.504
pacific justice institute in
sacramento and we oppose this

00:32:28.507 --> 00:32:30.406
bill.
My name is hilly macmillan for

00:32:31.420 --> 00:32:33.809
modesto california and I have
two boys that I home school and

00:32:39.584 --> 00:32:41.884
we oppose this bill.
I am battling gonzalez from

00:32:42.200 --> 00:32:44.200
modesto california I oppose this

00:32:44.220 --> 00:32:46.220
bill.

00:32:48.173 --> 00:32:50.594
I'm lacy gonzalez from modesto
california and I oppose this
bill.
Take your property modesto

00:32:52.630 --> 00:32:54.297
california formerly usd in while
their future and aye opposed to

00:32:56.233 --> 00:32:58.668
spell.
My name is laura career I'm a

00:32:58.968 --> 00:33:00.937
homeschool mom from modesto
california and I oppose this

00:33:05.420 --> 00:33:07.442
bill.
My name's iris cheney from

00:33:07.678 --> 00:33:10.313
modesto california and I oppose
this bill.

00:33:11.181 --> 00:33:13.648
My name is jessica van how hard
here from modesto and I am a

00:33:13.917 --> 00:33:15.917
homeschooling mom of two boys

00:33:17.788 --> 00:33:20.288
and I oppose this bill thank you.
I am sawyer part of.

00:33:20.624 --> 00:33:23.592
Homeschooling modesto
california and I oppose this
bill.

00:33:24.600 --> 00:33:26.829
The river there's two mikes up
there so I might say behind each
might.

00:33:27.130 --> 00:33:29.363
Rachel williams and I'm a
homeschool mom for riverbank

00:33:29.599 --> 00:33:31.599
california and my family and I

00:33:31.935 --> 00:33:34.236
oppose this bill.
My members of saddam hernandez

00:33:34.871 --> 00:33:36.871
for mobile city california and

00:33:43.212 --> 00:33:45.212
aye opposed his bill.

00:33:45.581 --> 00:33:47.581
Hi my name is allison jaswant.

00:33:48.820 --> 00:33:50.752
I am a home school student and I
oppose this bill jamie heston

00:33:51.850 --> 00:33:53.655
representing three hundred fifty
families with bay area gifted

00:33:54.189 --> 00:33:56.189
homeschoolers I'm also home

00:33:57.925 --> 00:34:00.361
school parent I oppose.
Hi my name is leased out one a

00:34:00.529 --> 00:34:02.897
homeschooling mom and I oppose
this bill.

00:34:03.432 --> 00:34:05.565
Maria palatal family law
attorney sacramento county and I

00:34:06.501 --> 00:34:08.569
oppose this bill.
I'm aaron swanson from stockton

00:34:09.137 --> 00:34:11.839
california a mother and
grandmother of home schooled

00:34:12.674 --> 00:34:15.209
kids nay oppose this bill.
Olivia microsoft rose going home

00:34:17.111 --> 00:34:19.346
schooling mother nay oppose.
I might any smarter call though

00:34:20.248 --> 00:34:22.716
and I'm from volatile california
I'm at home schooling motor the

00:34:23.551 --> 00:34:25.551
former university instructor and

00:34:27.710 --> 00:34:29.623
I oppose this bill.
When he was joshua coleman from
roseville california and I

00:34:32.293 --> 00:34:34.293
oppose this bill we theorists.

00:34:34.328 --> 00:34:37.300
My name is gabrielle mercer and
I oppose this bill. I my name

00:34:37.431 --> 00:34:40.300
shannon sturges of sacramento
california homeschooling mom of

00:34:41.669 --> 00:34:44.237
three I oppose this bill.
Hi my name is stacy nicholson

00:34:44.638 --> 00:34:46.873
I'm from temple city and I
represent my own power private

00:34:47.708 --> 00:34:49.708
study wilderness road academy

00:34:49.877 --> 00:34:51.811
and. My group that are part of
cults fundamentals in monrovia

00:34:52.412 --> 00:34:54.412
thank you.

00:34:56.816 --> 00:34:59.184
So sorry and I oppose this bill.
My neighbors desiree donald's
and I'm a private home school

00:35:00.387 --> 00:35:02.955
educator from dublin california
and I oppose this bill.

00:35:03.256 --> 00:35:05.256
Good afternoon my name is mike

00:35:05.391 --> 00:35:07.391
brown and I oppose this bill

00:35:08.270 --> 00:35:10.561
even as amended.
Hi I'm sherry hannemann from

00:35:12.650 --> 00:35:14.766
merced and I oppose this bill.
I american men from merced and I

00:35:15.234 --> 00:35:17.736
pose this bill.
Holly groza classical

00:35:18.271 --> 00:35:20.305
conversations of redlands May
strongly oppose this bill as

00:35:21.173 --> 00:35:23.341
amended.
the we have two microphones so

00:35:23.576 --> 00:35:25.743
comply behi behind each
microphone please just walk up

00:35:27.446 --> 00:35:29.446
every walk on a.

00:35:29.648 --> 00:35:31.549
Hi my name is mike it in.
I am a homeschool sierra poses

00:35:32.317 --> 00:35:34.685
bill.
Jamie kamali are my host school

00:35:35.354 --> 00:35:37.889
graduate a homeschool mom of
three and I represent josh's

00:35:37.889 --> 00:35:39.889
brings academy of ps skiing up

00:35:40.392 --> 00:35:42.827
about california. And I oppose
this bill as amended.

00:35:43.128 --> 00:35:45.128
My name is karen richardson from

00:35:45.196 --> 00:35:47.698
yucca valley. I am a previous
home schooler and I oppose this

00:35:48.633 --> 00:35:51.468
bill as amended.
I'm linda see fuentes from

00:35:52.402 --> 00:35:54.402
concord california miami home

00:35:54.437 --> 00:35:57.275
school educator and I oppose
this bill as amended.

00:35:57.641 --> 00:35:59.876
I am policy find this I'm a
private home schooler and I

00:36:00.511 --> 00:36:02.647
oppose this bill.
And had a nose and I am a

00:36:02.647 --> 00:36:05.315
private homes fuller and I
oppose this bill.

00:36:06.784 --> 00:36:09.753
I am aley garvin and private
home school and I oppose this
bill.

00:36:09.820 --> 00:36:12.155
My name is nina mills I
privately home school and I

00:36:13.124 --> 00:36:15.124
oppose this bill as amended.

00:36:15.459 --> 00:36:17.459
I'm just a guy man I'm a private

00:36:18.128 --> 00:36:20.430
home school and I opposes.
I'm gracie plant is in a private

00:36:20.464 --> 00:36:23.232
home schooler and oppose this
bill. I am clear mounds name

00:36:23.901 --> 00:36:25.768
privately homeschooled and I
oppose this bill.

00:36:26.937 --> 00:36:29.105
My name is sandra kim and I am a
private home school educator and

00:36:30.107 --> 00:36:32.575
I oppose this bill.
My name is elliot cam I'm

00:36:33.900 --> 00:36:35.900
homeschooled soon and I oppose

00:36:35.745 --> 00:36:38.347
this bill.
I'm alex kim a home school

00:36:39.182 --> 00:36:41.150
student I oppose this bill.
My name is brandon cam I'm a

00:36:41.417 --> 00:36:43.417
homeschool graduate and I pose

00:36:43.453 --> 00:36:46.155
this bill as amended.
My name is justin cam I am a

00:36:46.155 --> 00:36:48.155
private home school student and

00:36:48.957 --> 00:36:51.426
I oppose this bill has been.
I stephanie burden and I am a

00:36:51.594 --> 00:36:53.594
home school teacher and I oppose

00:36:54.931 --> 00:36:57.632
this bill.
I marin burger in number them

00:36:59.301 --> 00:37:01.835
school student I pose this bill.
Technical group staff private

00:37:02.137 --> 00:37:04.706
home to cater to a three from
mountain view in naples

00:37:05.140 --> 00:37:07.140
spokesman and.

00:37:07.343 --> 00:37:09.343
To learn gives tat I and a

00:37:11.446 --> 00:37:14.282
private home schoolers stated.
That.

00:37:15.484 --> 00:37:17.917
Hi my name is nay any well main
and up private home school

00:37:19.821 --> 00:37:22.122
student I oppose this bill.
And since he gave staff and the

00:37:23.325 --> 00:37:25.325
private home school students in

00:37:25.627 --> 00:37:27.627
I oppose this beth. Came allen

00:37:27.729 --> 00:37:29.729
grapes can.

00:37:30.597 --> 00:37:33.399
I am a private pubs cooler and I
pledge to speak. And can I have

00:37:34.268 --> 00:37:36.268
iraq and I'm a program of school

00:37:36.671 --> 00:37:38.739
and posted spell. And the tail
para I am a private home

00:37:40.441 --> 00:37:42.909
schooler to and I oppose this
bill as amended.

00:37:43.276 --> 00:37:45.445
I am ellen chen home school
student from san jose I

00:37:45.913 --> 00:37:48.820
absolutely oppose this bill.
I nuys susan tran I'm a private

00:37:48.820 --> 00:37:50.115
home school educator from san
jose and I oppose this bill as

00:37:50.684 --> 00:37:52.684
amended.

00:37:53.200 --> 00:37:55.188
I am a private home schooler and
I oppose this bill my name such

00:38:00.127 --> 00:38:02.127
entrant.

00:38:02.529 --> 00:38:04.330
Ennoble.
And.

00:38:06.466 --> 00:38:08.734
Then.
Many am is carla here where I am

00:38:09.703 --> 00:38:11.703
a private home school parents of

00:38:13.855 --> 00:38:16.175
for an a and amend oppose this
bill as amended.
My name is john the roman drive

00:38:17.944 --> 00:38:19.944
a host of programs cooler and

00:38:21.140 --> 00:38:23.582
opposes do.
my name is carlos harriman.

00:38:23.715 --> 00:38:26.585
Homeschool father of four and I
oppose this bill.

00:38:27.253 --> 00:38:29.521
One of agrees to line's you can
live behind either broke from my

00:38:30.220 --> 00:38:32.356
name is kristen chevrolet I'm a
homeschooling mother of five.

00:38:33.292 --> 00:38:36.940
The oldest is a graduate from
college in computer science.

00:38:36.629 --> 00:38:38.629
The second graduate at the top

00:38:39.980 --> 00:38:41.799
of her class in neuroscience.
And now has will inject so I

00:38:42.167 --> 00:38:44.770
will have your name affiliation
imposition of the bill only.

00:38:44.770 --> 00:38:47.338
Okay I oppose this bill thank
you thank you.

00:38:47.940 --> 00:38:50.374
Mining salas who I'm a mother
and grandmother I strongly

00:38:50.842 --> 00:38:52.842
oppose this bill I'm from that

00:38:53.278 --> 00:38:55.946
member california thank you.
But isn't michael where vote di

00:38:56.448 --> 00:38:58.448
mubarak we east devotees

00:38:58.515 --> 00:39:01.485
stromboli definitely opposes
bill.

00:39:01.920 --> 00:39:04.754
My name is paul along an from
concord california and the home

00:39:04.889 --> 00:39:07.157
school mother and I run a
tutoring business and I click

00:39:08.426 --> 00:39:10.993
oppose this bill.
My name is karen shelton I been

00:39:11.696 --> 00:39:14.164
sent here by to homeowners
ventura county the associated

00:39:14.532 --> 00:39:16.532
christian home educators of

00:39:17.902 --> 00:39:20.603
ventura. And the christian
attack advocates support
association of camerino and the

00:39:21.372 --> 00:39:24.207
hundreds of families that are in
those groups have sent me here

00:39:24.942 --> 00:39:26.942
to let you know that we oppose

00:39:28.379 --> 00:39:30.379
this bill as amended.

00:39:32.883 --> 00:39:35.219
Rooms even though. Purposeless
bear.

00:39:35.219 --> 00:39:37.320
I'm holly larson from cambria
california private home school

00:39:38.422 --> 00:39:40.422
are also part of the chief of

00:39:40.589 --> 00:39:42.825
ventura county and conserve
cameroon I oppose this bill

00:39:43.792 --> 00:39:45.792
isn't it.

00:39:46.730 --> 00:39:48.730
And circulation and have that

00:39:48.830 --> 00:39:50.830
home schooling a close dispensed.

00:39:51.701 --> 00:39:54.268
public hill arson.
I'm a pro homeschooling and I

00:39:54.870 --> 00:39:57.106
funds them. And stephanie
departamento mission viejo I

00:39:57.106 --> 00:39:59.341
represent costs will
conversations around to santa

00:39:59.708 --> 00:40:01.708
margarita and oppose this bill

00:40:02.110 --> 00:40:04.110
as amended and joshua to borrow

00:40:05.313 --> 00:40:08.183
and private school home school
and I oppose this bill.

00:40:08.250 --> 00:40:09.950
I know than to bar on the
private home school parents

00:40:11.953 --> 00:40:13.953
oppose this bill.

00:40:15.557 --> 00:40:18.459
They married staff and say.
Yeah she knew nam bonnie werner
and then el dorado hills

00:40:18.527 --> 00:40:20.762
california. I oppose ab twenty
seven fifty six am thank you for

00:40:20.828 --> 00:40:22.897
having us today.
Good afternoon my name is hannah

00:40:22.998 --> 00:40:25.600
burner I'm from older to host
california and I am firmly
opposed to ab twenty seven fifty

00:40:27.169 --> 00:40:29.537
six thank you.
I'm sam over my this time from

00:40:30.605 --> 00:40:32.605
redondo beach I'm a homeschool

00:40:32.741 --> 00:40:35.708
graduate and I oppose this bill.
My name is efren sylvia I'm from

00:40:35.844 --> 00:40:37.778
lawndale I'm home school
graduate and I strongly oppose

00:40:38.947 --> 00:40:41.716
this bill.
Lauren mafra monty from redondo

00:40:43.384 --> 00:40:45.719
beach and I oppose this bill.
My name as quaint rafferty nine

00:40:46.321 --> 00:40:48.321
from lake out california and I

00:40:48.556 --> 00:40:50.556
oppose this bill.

00:40:51.359 --> 00:40:53.727
My name is nicole rafferty idea
of home school from lake era
this.

00:40:54.962 --> 00:40:57.864
Actual data analyst we are not
data anomalies and I strongly

00:40:59.767 --> 00:41:02.435
oppose this bill as amended.
Lisa cervantes billy orange

00:41:03.404 --> 00:41:05.404
county.

00:41:05.406 --> 00:41:07.406
Home school mother twenty years

00:41:08.642 --> 00:41:10.977
since four strongly oppose ab.
Twenty seven fifty six as

00:41:12.646 --> 00:41:14.880
amended thank you.
Name is dirty but no I and I'm a

00:41:14.915 --> 00:41:17.817
former home schooler and a
grandmother little schools to.

00:41:17.884 --> 00:41:19.884
And I'm a member of a large

00:41:20.620 --> 00:41:22.620
voting block of senior voters

00:41:23.388 --> 00:41:25.388
who strongly oppose a blank

00:41:25.458 --> 00:41:27.458
clear seven forty six thank you.

00:41:27.527 --> 00:41:30.427
My name is clearly lopez I. M.
Of private home schoolers and I

00:41:31.965 --> 00:41:33.965
oppose this bill.

00:41:34.200 --> 00:41:36.200
My name is joseph lopes and I am

00:41:36.302 --> 00:41:38.302
from fotolia california nay

00:41:39.380 --> 00:41:41.440
oppose this bill.
But it is one though pass from

00:41:41.440 --> 00:41:43.776
my side california I pose this
bill.

00:41:43.776 --> 00:41:46.478
See lopez from face value
california and I strongly oppose

00:41:47.945 --> 00:41:49.945
this bill as amended.

00:41:50.490 --> 00:41:52.984
Hello my name is sherry waleran
from bethel island I represent

00:41:54.286 --> 00:41:56.954
hearthstone christian academy
and we strongly oppose this bill

00:41:57.823 --> 00:42:00.158
think you.
My name is sandy abelson of from

00:42:00.559 --> 00:42:02.559
turn like california and I

00:42:03.195 --> 00:42:04.827
oppose this bell as amended I'm
a homeschooling mother of six

00:42:05.597 --> 00:42:07.898
children.
Hi my name is silly olson and

00:42:08.934 --> 00:42:11.670
home schooled.
And I'm thrilled to a california

00:42:11.803 --> 00:42:13.803
and I oppose this bill.

00:42:14.390 --> 00:42:15.639
I am carrying davis from merced
california and I oppose this

00:42:16.106 --> 00:42:18.742
bill.
My name is denise lester I'm

00:42:21.894 --> 00:42:23.746
from lakewood california and I
am a teacher of. One homeschool

00:42:25.283 --> 00:42:27.684
graduate who has special needs
and one other twelve year old

00:42:27.852 --> 00:42:30.754
list you name seventh grade
solution.

00:42:31.522 --> 00:42:33.890
Affiliation a position on the
roman please I am care the

00:42:34.291 --> 00:42:36.291
husqvarna homeschooling but

00:42:36.360 --> 00:42:38.627
therefore in center monning aye
oppose this bill.

00:42:39.263 --> 00:42:41.898
My name's paloma shook from.
Center on california I'm

00:42:41.999 --> 00:42:43.999
private home schooler I oppose

00:42:44.101 --> 00:42:45.735
this bill.
hello I'm take a shotgun

00:42:47.271 --> 00:42:49.972
approach five a home schooler
from san ramon aye opposed.

00:42:50.741 --> 00:42:52.608
John shook engineering manager
homeschooling debt for and I

00:42:55.144 --> 00:42:57.144
strongly oppose this bill.

00:42:57.214 --> 00:43:00.182
Eventually angeles for patterson
california. Aye.

00:43:01.151 --> 00:43:04.860
And a home schooled grand
mother of eight and I oppose

00:43:04.654 --> 00:43:07.389
this bill.
Hello my name is able in I'm a

00:43:08.658 --> 00:43:10.658
home schooler and I oppose

00:43:10.793 --> 00:43:13.495
eighty twenty seven fifty six.
Bloom is david angeles

00:43:13.930 --> 00:43:15.930
sacramento california. I oppose

00:43:16.532 --> 00:43:19.100
this bill.
Please two lines there's two

00:43:19.100 --> 00:43:21.603
microphones come down come down
come down I am a home school

00:43:23.390 --> 00:43:25.206
mother of five in a possess bill
and I appreciate assemblyman

00:43:26.642 --> 00:43:28.642
gallagher.

00:43:30.544 --> 00:43:33.481
I mean it's I can and I. And. I
oppose ab trains emphasis.

00:43:34.450 --> 00:43:36.450
I my name is ryan lawler from

00:43:37.384 --> 00:43:39.384
out violent I oppose this bill.

00:43:39.921 --> 00:43:41.921
My name is dan neighbors spam.

00:43:41.990 --> 00:43:44.258
Who pan?
Hi my name is rebecca berg I'm a

00:43:45.560 --> 00:43:47.728
private home school teacher from
danville california and I oppose

00:43:49.130 --> 00:43:51.130
the spell.

00:43:51.232 --> 00:43:52.900
Hi I'm alleged berg and I'm a
home schooler and I oppose this

00:43:53.401 --> 00:43:55.501
bill.
Hi am cheryl I'm a homeschooling

00:43:56.370 --> 00:43:58.839
mother of five in a fiercely
oppose this bill.

00:43:59.407 --> 00:44:02.109
Hi I'm by script is from sing
many and I oppose this bill.

00:44:02.477 --> 00:44:04.845
I am john griffith from thank
many of private home schooler

00:44:06.179 --> 00:44:08.179
and I pose is still.

00:44:08.883 --> 00:44:10.883
My name friday daly of graphics

00:44:10.918 --> 00:44:13.319
and I've.
I mean the second as a grateful

00:44:13.554 --> 00:44:16.550
smile oppose this bill.
My name is joanne mickelson I'm

00:44:16.523 --> 00:44:19.240
from carlsbad california I'm a
former public school teacher and

00:44:19.526 --> 00:44:21.526
a current home schooler and I

00:44:21.695 --> 00:44:24.297
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is amanda michael cinema

00:44:24.965 --> 00:44:26.933
and I am from because by cal
california and I oppose this

00:44:27.935 --> 00:44:30.101
bill.
My name is samantha mickelson

00:44:30.537 --> 00:44:32.738
I'm santiago county and I oppose
this bill.

00:44:33.406 --> 00:44:35.406
My name is jessica mickelson I

00:44:35.775 --> 00:44:37.541
strongly oppose this bill. My
needs natalie fletcher I'm a

00:44:38.111 --> 00:44:40.450
home schooler from san diego
county and I strongly opposes

00:44:40.779 --> 00:44:43.810
bill.
And my name's john fletcher also

00:44:43.950 --> 00:44:45.950
from san diego county. And I

00:44:46.953 --> 00:44:49.154
stand in opposition to this bill.
Maybe say goals not prepare

00:44:49.522 --> 00:44:52.357
ought california that pose this
bill. My name is logan olson on

00:44:52.825 --> 00:44:55.794
the home schooler from tele
california and I oppose this
bill.

00:44:56.362 --> 00:44:59.197
My name is laurie fletcher home
swing parent of a proud college

00:45:00.466 --> 00:45:02.466
students and high school student.

00:45:02.768 --> 00:45:04.335
And I strongly oppose bill
twenty seven fifty six as

00:45:04.870 --> 00:45:07.710
amended.
My name is lucas story I'm from

00:45:07.138 --> 00:45:09.138
san diego county and I strongly

00:45:09.708 --> 00:45:11.708
oppose this bill.

00:45:11.777 --> 00:45:14.111
My name is connor fletcher from
san diego county california.

00:45:14.680 --> 00:45:16.680
Typos the senate bill two seven

00:45:17.416 --> 00:45:19.884
five six.
My name is arianna dilatory from

00:45:20.252 --> 00:45:22.252
whittier I'm a homeschool mom

00:45:22.819 --> 00:45:25.689
and I strongly opposes.
Hello my name is ralph dilatory.

00:45:26.791 --> 00:45:28.457
Homeschool father a political
appointee and I strongly oppose

00:45:29.561 --> 00:45:32.396
this bill.
Hello my name is nina easily and

00:45:32.397 --> 00:45:34.965
I am from the galley a
california and I have a

00:45:35.498 --> 00:45:37.498
bachelor's degree for teaching

00:45:38.101 --> 00:45:40.203
kids and home school five kids.
and I one hundred percent oppose

00:45:44.375 --> 00:45:47.111
this bill.
This is two microphones you come

00:45:47.111 --> 00:45:48.845
down to have my license to lie
henshin I'm from portable county

00:45:49.280 --> 00:45:51.614
for california and I oppose this
bill.

00:45:52.349 --> 00:45:54.830
I'm hannah resilient I'm from
mcgill you california and I

00:45:55.686 --> 00:45:58.540
oppose this bill.
My name is nicholas clinton I am

00:45:58.420 --> 00:46:00.210
homeschooled import for
california and I oppose this

00:46:01.257 --> 00:46:03.858
bill.
My name's lori falabella from

00:46:04.328 --> 00:46:06.328
livermore california I am the

00:46:06.363 --> 00:46:08.597
director of tribal explorers
home school support group that

00:46:09.132 --> 00:46:11.499
is in alameda and contra costa
counties six hundred forty

00:46:12.168 --> 00:46:14.168
members strong and we all oppose

00:46:14.304 --> 00:46:16.537
this bill. Thank you.
My name's john harris amend

00:46:17.273 --> 00:46:19.140
doubling california my wife and
I home school our three kids and

00:46:21.344 --> 00:46:23.412
we oppose this bill.
We name is emily chill from

00:46:23.813 --> 00:46:25.980
petaluma california I'm a
certified teacher and a home

00:46:25.980 --> 00:46:28.884
school parent and I oppose this
bill.

00:46:29.850 --> 00:46:31.850
My name is summer jesse from

00:46:31.654 --> 00:46:34.189
sacramento county I home school
through a public school charter

00:46:35.857 --> 00:46:37.926
and I oppose this bill.
My name is the same and I oppose

00:46:38.427 --> 00:46:40.427
this bill.

00:46:40.829 --> 00:46:42.997
My name is sally jesse and I am
from school and I am in

00:46:43.332 --> 00:46:46.000
sacramento and I strongly oppose
this bill.

00:46:46.333 --> 00:46:48.703
My name is lindsay all dag from
union city california

00:46:49.271 --> 00:46:51.606
homeschooling mother of two and
I strongly oppose this bill as

00:46:52.708 --> 00:46:55.309
amended.
Julianne lost in from orange

00:46:56.176 --> 00:46:58.679
county parent of two public
school children and I oppose

00:47:00.480 --> 00:47:02.480
this bill as amended.

00:47:02.150 --> 00:47:04.952
my name is canada all dagen en
poses.

00:47:04.953 --> 00:47:07.488
I mckenna hamilton a military
wife and home school educators I

00:47:13.995 --> 00:47:16.329
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is courtney thirteen now

00:47:16.998 --> 00:47:19.320
and I'm from fairfield
california and I oppose this

00:47:26.907 --> 00:47:29.343
bill.
Thank you judy and I.

00:47:29.343 --> 00:47:31.411
My name is how johansen I'm a
home school teacher I'm also

00:47:31.612 --> 00:47:34.380
part of the tracy home school
academy and I oppose this bill

00:47:37.751 --> 00:47:40.353
as amended.
My name is nicholas johansson as

00:47:40.853 --> 00:47:43.689
somebody who still believes in
this country and in freedom

00:47:45.920 --> 00:47:47.426
kitty surprise closer to lassen
and they you know you.

00:47:48.293 --> 00:47:50.293
If you want to editorialize.

00:47:50.764 --> 00:47:52.931
There's not a time for thank you.
Is not a position my name is

00:47:53.400 --> 00:47:56.333
kendra ryan emphasis soon city
I'm a home school educator and I

00:47:57.971 --> 00:47:59.971
oppose this bill.

00:48:00.171 --> 00:48:02.542
I am very of our as and I oppose
this bill. How my name is

00:48:03.174 --> 00:48:05.576
samantha fear I'm a home
schooler from discovery bay and

00:48:07.680 --> 00:48:09.680
I strongly oppose this bill?

00:48:09.949 --> 00:48:12.184
My aim is anthony fear I'm homes
clerk aye opposed to spell.

00:48:12.184 --> 00:48:14.651
My name is don murray I'm a
homeschool graduate a journalist

00:48:14.753 --> 00:48:17.488
in home schooling mother and I
oppose the spell my name is

00:48:18.524 --> 00:48:21.326
stephanie fear. I'm a home
schooler and I oppose the spell.

00:48:21.560 --> 00:48:23.893
My name is jennifer minds I'm
from brentwood california contra

00:48:24.295 --> 00:48:26.295
costa county and I oppose this

00:48:27.966 --> 00:48:30.801
bill as amended.
Hi my name is cynthia saunders

00:48:31.837 --> 00:48:33.437
from brent what california I
strongly oppose this bill as

00:48:38.143 --> 00:48:40.143
amended.

00:48:41.611 --> 00:48:43.380
My name is leann.
My name is here let that royal

00:48:44.414 --> 00:48:46.414
from brentwood california and i

00:48:49.587 --> 00:48:51.587
oppose this bill as amended.

00:48:53.558 --> 00:48:55.692
My name is jerry and less nine
the homes glad her face.

00:48:55.692 --> 00:48:58.595
My name is michelle rash I'm a
homeschool mom and I oppose this

00:48:59.300 --> 00:49:01.498
bill as amended by name the
scalar.

00:49:02.660 --> 00:49:04.660
Rash and from that would grant

00:49:05.402 --> 00:49:08.138
wood and I poses bill as amended
my name is bobby chau meters. In

00:49:08.138 --> 00:49:10.138
I'm a home schooler from

00:49:10.674 --> 00:49:13.374
brentwood california nypost
spill.

00:49:13.977 --> 00:49:16.411
My name is rachel tell me does I
am I home school parent of soon

00:49:16.980 --> 00:49:18.581
to be six in brentwood
california and I oppose this

00:49:19.383 --> 00:49:21.383
bill.

00:49:22.180 --> 00:49:24.180
My name is thomas cool cole and

00:49:24.253 --> 00:49:26.253
the home school student. That I

00:49:26.556 --> 00:49:29.258
posed this village amended.
My name is carrie call I'm a
private home schooler from brit

00:49:30.160 --> 00:49:32.761
what california and I strongly
oppose this bill as amended.

00:49:33.528 --> 00:49:35.929
Analysts fiscal from brentwood
california and I oppose this

00:49:37.900 --> 00:49:40.368
bill as amended.
My name is george r. Dozer. I'm

00:49:40.670 --> 00:49:42.670
from oakley california and I

00:49:44.740 --> 00:49:46.740
pose this bill.

00:49:48.511 --> 00:49:50.511
My name's vannatter says they'll.

00:49:50.946 --> 00:49:53.581
Let me make care act aye poses
no my name is josh and I

00:49:54.248 --> 00:49:56.684
strongly oppose the spell. My
name is alice that oppose this

00:49:56.919 --> 00:49:59.153
bill.
My name is justin ray goes and a

00:50:00.550 --> 00:50:02.550
from oakley california and I

00:50:02.391 --> 00:50:05.259
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is kimberly low defazio

00:50:05.994 --> 00:50:07.994
I'm for discovery bay california

00:50:10.265 --> 00:50:12.800
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is catherine anderson

00:50:13.201 --> 00:50:16.300
and from oakley california I'm
homeschooling mom and I strongly

00:50:17.472 --> 00:50:19.472
oppose this bill as amended.

00:50:21.623 --> 00:50:24.511
My name is henry johnny and I
oppose this bill was a pair as
amended.
i'm parker centenarian I oppose

00:50:25.113 --> 00:50:27.714
this bill as a man. I million
jolene I oppose this bill as

00:50:28.216 --> 00:50:30.383
amended.
I mean we send send a home

00:50:31.218 --> 00:50:33.987
school educator in a small
business owner and I oppose this

00:50:34.722 --> 00:50:36.723
bill as amended.
I'm kathy while still

00:50:37.191 --> 00:50:39.250
grandmother of home schoolers I
strongly oppose this bill as

00:50:39.894 --> 00:50:42.829
amended.
I'm jennifer jolly and from

00:50:42.997 --> 00:50:45.432
discovery bay homeschool moms
small business owner and I

00:50:45.432 --> 00:50:47.900
strongly oppose this bill as
amended.

00:50:48.735 --> 00:50:51.704
I'm sherry combs real county and
I oppose this bill.

00:50:52.973 --> 00:50:55.574
My name is tara content I
strongly opposes bill my name is

00:50:56.243 --> 00:50:58.609
max martin and I strongly oppose
this bill. My name is casey

00:50:59.379 --> 00:51:02.460
muffin I represent contra costa
ballistic learners a hundred and

00:51:02.516 --> 00:51:04.917
twenty five families and we
oppose this bill.

00:51:05.885 --> 00:51:07.885
I madeline muffin and I strongly

00:51:09.122 --> 00:51:11.790
oppose the spell.
My name is christian aye goes I

00:51:12.691 --> 00:51:14.793
am a oppose this bill.
My name is cured and fly and I

00:51:18.970 --> 00:51:20.165
oppose this bill.
Calling watson and the home

00:51:20.199 --> 00:51:22.199
school parent

00:51:23.690 --> 00:51:25.690
only because this.

00:51:25.710 --> 00:51:27.138
My name is still watson and I am
a home school student and closed

00:51:28.540 --> 00:51:30.643
his bill.
Mimes dot the watson and the

00:51:30.643 --> 00:51:33.410
home school student and I oppose
this bill my name is melanie
hanson from carmichael

00:51:33.545 --> 00:51:35.880
california and I strongly oppose
this bill as amended.

00:51:36.381 --> 00:51:38.381
My name is olivia hanson and I

00:51:38.383 --> 00:51:41.180
oppose this bill.
Chris hansen fireman paramedic

00:51:41.653 --> 00:51:43.653
home school dad and I strongly

00:51:44.623 --> 00:51:46.623
oppose the bill as amended.

00:51:46.658 --> 00:51:48.658
my name is rachel huntington and

00:51:49.600 --> 00:51:51.428
I absolutely oppose this bill.
My name is ramana hold back

00:51:51.928 --> 00:51:54.698
through the gal I'm a homeschool
mom of four and a business owner

00:51:54.732 --> 00:51:56.732
and I strongly oppose this bill

00:51:57.135 --> 00:51:59.836
as amended.
My name is patrick silly go

00:52:00.104 --> 00:52:02.104
follow for.

00:52:02.340 --> 00:52:04.340
I strongly oppose this bill as

00:52:04.542 --> 00:52:07.242
amended also a business owner
and a high and.

00:52:09.880 --> 00:52:12.415
Developer.
Mercedes chase back bill. I am

00:52:13.250 --> 00:52:16.190
also an administrator for a home
school group representing over a

00:52:16.554 --> 00:52:18.555
hundred families and we strongly
oppose this bill as amended

00:52:19.590 --> 00:52:21.991
thank you.
Can lines oakland california

00:52:22.559 --> 00:52:24.560
homeschooling mom and former
public school teacher I oppose

00:52:24.962 --> 00:52:27.263
this bill.
My name is kai stewart home

00:52:27.664 --> 00:52:30.565
schooler of oakland california
and I strongly oppose this bill.

00:52:31.435 --> 00:52:33.768
My name is to marry roman home
schooler of five children and I

00:52:38.241 --> 00:52:41.420
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is josh a roaming ummah

00:52:41.478 --> 00:52:43.478
private home schooler. And I

00:52:43.780 --> 00:52:45.780
oppose this bill.

00:52:46.149 --> 00:52:48.149
An image of on a roman and I am

00:52:49.519 --> 00:52:51.153
from san jose. I hope the press
home schooler now oppose this

00:52:51.654 --> 00:52:53.654
bill.

00:52:54.230 --> 00:52:56.230
And mason marin home. Fairfax I

00:52:58.294 --> 00:53:00.961
oppose this bill.
My name is david broder and I am

00:53:01.330 --> 00:53:03.330
a home school student and I

00:53:03.364 --> 00:53:05.565
oppose this bill.
My name is digging alloy and I

00:53:06.735 --> 00:53:09.137
oppose this bill.
My name is heidi healthlink

00:53:10.506 --> 00:53:12.506
bronner. And I oppose this bill

00:53:12.541 --> 00:53:14.809
I'm from oakley california.
My name is karen reset from

00:53:15.877 --> 00:53:17.478
oakley california I part of it
at national group called

00:53:17.979 --> 00:53:20.915
possible conversations and we
have over a hundred thousand
home school students and I

00:53:22.317 --> 00:53:24.317
oppose the spell. My name is

00:53:25.620 --> 00:53:28.455
calories and opposes.
I'm dineen heinz I'm with marin

00:53:29.357 --> 00:53:30.958
homeschoolers are from sausalito
california and I oppose this

00:53:34.996 --> 00:53:37.963
bill.
My name is samuel and I oppose

00:53:38.699 --> 00:53:41.168
this bill. My name is jennifer
how help of california I'm a

00:53:41.736 --> 00:53:43.736
private home school parent the

00:53:43.971 --> 00:53:45.971
and I close the spell.

00:53:46.400 --> 00:53:48.875
My name is matthew howell. On
and the home school student and

00:53:50.420 --> 00:53:52.879
I oppose this bill as amended.
I'm joshua how. I'm home school

00:53:53.747 --> 00:53:56.150
student and I oppose this bill.
I'm katie hell and I oppose the

00:53:56.583 --> 00:53:58.985
spell.
I'm melissa devore home school

00:53:59.887 --> 00:54:01.887
parent from elk grove california

00:54:01.956 --> 00:54:03.956
and I oppose this bill. As a

00:54:04.825 --> 00:54:07.158
dove or and I oppose this bill.
My name is soon enough marin

00:54:07.359 --> 00:54:10.262
health calls for and I oppose
this bill name is miriam and I

00:54:10.831 --> 00:54:13.465
oppose this bill. My name is
brittany man I'm private home

00:54:14.100 --> 00:54:16.680
school mom and I oppose this
bill.

00:54:16.102 --> 00:54:18.370
My name is tiffany clark on an
attorney and private home school

00:54:19.305 --> 00:54:22.274
educator and I strongly oppose
this bill even as amended.

00:54:23.343 --> 00:54:25.677
Hello I'm la clark I m. A
private home schooled student

00:54:27.146 --> 00:54:29.748
and I strongly opposes bill as
amended. I am keen clark on a

00:54:30.481 --> 00:54:32.481
private home school student and

00:54:33.653 --> 00:54:36.319
I oppose this bill as amended.
I am janet napolitano marin home

00:54:40.259 --> 00:54:42.259
schoolers and oppose this bill.

00:54:42.828 --> 00:54:44.828
From kept burke. Ever strongly

00:54:46.231 --> 00:54:48.231
oppose this bill.

00:54:48.567 --> 00:54:50.567
Yeah my name is emily gallo and

00:54:51.236 --> 00:54:53.804
I strongly opposes both amended.
My name is kristen gallo I am a

00:54:54.106 --> 00:54:56.106
former california public school

00:54:56.108 --> 00:54:58.309
teacher my husband is also my
mother was also in my dad taught

00:54:59.100 --> 00:55:01.812
at uc davis.
I strongly oppose this bill as

00:55:01.946 --> 00:55:03.946
amended I am a home school

00:55:04.810 --> 00:55:06.810
educator.

00:55:06.316 --> 00:55:09.190
Hi I'm karen dark water and I'm
home school alumni I'm here on

00:55:09.354 --> 00:55:11.655
behalf of the coalition for
responsible home education and

00:55:11.921 --> 00:55:14.424
the over one thousand members
and supporters of it. In support

00:55:15.927 --> 00:55:18.261
of this bill.
My name is kim fifteen and I'm

00:55:19.330 --> 00:55:21.264
from calaveras county and I
strongly oppose this bill as

00:55:21.899 --> 00:55:24.599
amended.
My name is liberty and I oppose

00:55:26.470 --> 00:55:28.470
this bill.

00:55:28.838 --> 00:55:31.640
My name's destiny schemes and I.
Oppose this bill.

00:55:32.900 --> 00:55:34.811
My name is mallory scheme I
strongly oppose this bill.

00:55:34.812 --> 00:55:36.812
My name is wesley skin I

00:55:42.819 --> 00:55:44.887
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is wendy sites from

00:55:45.889 --> 00:55:47.490
yellow county and I strongly
oppose because this bill as

00:55:47.891 --> 00:55:49.891
amended.

00:55:49.926 --> 00:55:51.926
My name is elizabeth states and

00:55:53.296 --> 00:55:56.165
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is philip stott to an

00:55:57.433 --> 00:55:59.433
opera and I strongly oppose this

00:55:59.834 --> 00:56:01.834
bill as amended.

00:56:02.271 --> 00:56:04.271
Brian hanley spain and I style

00:56:05.700 --> 00:56:07.509
clay posted the.
I.

00:56:10.112 --> 00:56:12.112
With to know.

00:56:14.417 --> 00:56:16.417
My. Studies have. Strongly

00:56:16.452 --> 00:56:18.452
opposed his pale.

00:56:19.154 --> 00:56:22.560
My name is emily state slash
strongly opposes both amend. My

00:56:23.459 --> 00:56:26.940
name's logic I strongly opposes
bellis me.

00:56:26.940 --> 00:56:27.695
My name several starts in a
strongly oppose this bill as

00:56:29.865 --> 00:56:32.733
amended.
My name is kayla while been from

00:56:33.401 --> 00:56:35.770
ukiah california.
I'm a home educator and I

00:56:36.271 --> 00:56:38.271
strongly oppose this bill as

00:56:40.742 --> 00:56:42.976
amended.
Hello my name is jack I'm a home

00:56:43.778 --> 00:56:46.513
schooler familiar california and
aye opposed his bill.

00:56:46.814 --> 00:56:48.914
Hi my name is brough I'm a
homeschooling mother of two from

00:56:49.217 --> 00:56:50.817
whittier california and I
strongly oppose this bill as

00:56:54.455 --> 00:56:56.455
amended.

00:56:58.626 --> 00:57:00.626
My name is julia and I suppose.

00:57:00.728 --> 00:57:02.728
Monies falco listen I strongly.

00:57:03.796 --> 00:57:05.796
Opposes.

00:57:06.500 --> 00:57:09.102
The bill was amended.
Rick grieco homeschooling data

00:57:09.937 --> 00:57:12.905
from la mirada california that
poses bill as amended.

00:57:13.707 --> 00:57:15.707
And really luis and I strongly

00:57:16.543 --> 00:57:19.512
oppose this bill as amended.
I'm emily luis and I strongly

00:57:24.451 --> 00:57:27.386
oppose this bill as amended.
I strongly oppose imposes bill

00:57:31.891 --> 00:57:34.590
as amended yeah for california and I
strongly oppose this bill as

00:57:35.528 --> 00:57:38.230
amended thank you.
My name is sherry skate I am

00:57:39.432 --> 00:57:41.432
strongly opposed to ab two seven

00:57:45.404 --> 00:57:47.505
five six as amended thank you.
Hello my name is conveyance gave

00:57:47.840 --> 00:57:50.409
I am fourteen years old and a
high school graduate currently

00:57:50.409 --> 00:57:52.409
working on the engineering

00:57:52.511 --> 00:57:55.179
degree. And I strongly oppose
this bill.

00:57:55.481 --> 00:57:57.481
Hello my name is scott skate

00:57:57.715 --> 00:57:59.516
from santa rosa california and I
strongly oppose this bill as

00:58:02.254 --> 00:58:04.889
amended.
The name is erica for andrea we

00:58:06.124 --> 00:58:07.758
privately homeschooling san luis
obispo county and oppose this

00:58:08.992 --> 00:58:10.992
bill.

00:58:11.129 --> 00:58:13.129
My name is vivian flank jean I

00:58:14.266 --> 00:58:16.266
persist that.

00:58:16.568 --> 00:58:18.568
High end and really plan on who

00:58:21.306 --> 00:58:23.540
school firm yucaipa and mayor
purses para.

00:58:23.541 --> 00:58:25.609
Hello my name is chris so we've
done and I am a homeschooling

00:58:26.444 --> 00:58:28.444
mom from yucaipa. And I oppose

00:58:29.781 --> 00:58:31.781
this bill as amended.

00:58:32.683 --> 00:58:34.683
hi my name's renee wheatland I

00:58:37.622 --> 00:58:39.723
from the kaiba. At a oppose this
bill as amended.

00:58:39.723 --> 00:58:42.258
I am patrick woodland I'm it
current public school educator

00:58:42.760 --> 00:58:45.495
and I of chills know home school
my four kids my strongly oppose

00:58:47.131 --> 00:58:50.670
this bill as amended.
Hello my name is on a key dickey
I am a homeschooling parent as

00:58:50.670 --> 00:58:52.268
well as a board member of a
cooperative in in marin county.

00:58:52.536 --> 00:58:55.371
And I strongly oppose this bill
as amended.

00:58:56.872 --> 00:58:59.141
Below here I'm sonia de I'm
thirteen years old in texas cal

00:58:59.543 --> 00:59:01.944
and I strongly oppose this bill
as amended.

00:59:02.780 --> 00:59:04.790
I'm jan id
and I spot

00:59:04.614 --> 00:59:06.614
strongly oppose this bill as

00:59:07.851 --> 00:59:10.619
amended I'm my id and I strongly
oppose this bill as amended.

00:59:10.687 --> 00:59:12.687
I'm rooster enough from lake

00:59:13.923 --> 00:59:15.923
county california and I oppose

00:59:16.726 --> 00:59:18.726
this bill as amended.

00:59:19.262 --> 00:59:21.896
I am john sterna. Of from a
hidden del have like california.

00:59:21.998 --> 00:59:24.866
And extensive experience in
policy.

00:59:26.330 --> 00:59:28.937
That in the washington dc area.
I strongly oppose this bill.

00:59:29.838 --> 00:59:32.272
Twenty seven.
Skinner twenty seven fifty six

00:59:33.409 --> 00:59:36.377
as amended.
My name is alex school day I'm a

00:59:36.510 --> 00:59:38.846
private home schooler who was
also doing rolled at a private

00:59:39.781 --> 00:59:41.781
university and I strongly oppose

00:59:42.784 --> 00:59:44.784
this bill as amended.

00:59:44.853 --> 00:59:46.853
My name is stacy gilday and I'm

00:59:46.855 --> 00:59:49.230
a homeschool mom of seven and I
strongly oppose this bill as

00:59:54.496 --> 00:59:57.970
amended.
Hi my name is jennifer massey

00:59:57.599 --> 00:59:59.566
from makers for california I'm a
home school mother of four

01:00:00.266 --> 01:00:03.680
children and I strongly oppose
this bill as amended.

01:00:05.390 --> 01:00:07.390
Hi my name is joseph massey.

01:00:07.475 --> 01:00:09.475
i'ma kern county some home

01:00:09.509 --> 01:00:11.509
school student trash strongly

01:00:12.380 --> 01:00:14.814
oppose this bill oct mindy.
Hello my name is thomas massie

01:00:16.283 --> 01:00:18.283
and I.

01:00:21.689 --> 01:00:24.589
Trong. Does this bill asmund.
My name is christina smith I'm

01:00:25.559 --> 01:00:28.327
from bakersfield california. And
I am a private home schooler of

01:00:29.129 --> 01:00:32.640
fuller and I strongly oppose
this bill as amended.

01:00:32.799 --> 01:00:34.799
My name is michelle hi that's

01:00:35.101 --> 01:00:37.101
and I am home schooled student I

01:00:37.337 --> 01:00:40.239
pose this bill as amended. My
name is leslie horvath on
homeschooling parent from

01:00:41.241 --> 01:00:43.241
bakersfield california strongly

01:00:43.376 --> 01:00:45.944
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is a tiny casket aye

01:00:47.113 --> 01:00:49.982
vote from marysville california
I'm a licensed social worker and

01:00:50.416 --> 01:00:52.416
a homeschool mom. My name is

01:00:52.952 --> 01:00:55.554
elijah cast him from marysville
californian I pose this bill.

01:00:56.322 --> 01:00:58.322
My name is mike a caskey and I

01:00:59.580 --> 01:01:01.224
oppose this.
My name is daniel meter I'm an

01:01:02.128 --> 01:01:04.996
airline pilot ninety strongly
big my wife tell the school our

01:01:05.830 --> 01:01:08.433
kids so I can be with them not
lousy maybe two days a week I

01:01:08.767 --> 01:01:11.402
might be held without.
Rather than being in school so I
strongly oppose anything that

01:01:12.171 --> 01:01:14.473
messes with my wife's very hard
work. And very serious

01:01:14.473 --> 01:01:16.473
responsibility

01:01:16.742 --> 01:01:18.743
oppose this bill.
My name is rachel meter I'm a

01:01:19.211 --> 01:01:21.211
licensed physical therapist and

01:01:21.213 --> 01:01:24.114
home school educator to children
I strongly oppose this bill as

01:01:25.617 --> 01:01:28.352
amended thank you.
My name is shannon roberts from

01:01:28.553 --> 01:01:30.553
brown. And a home schooling

01:01:30.722 --> 01:01:32.722
parent of four and I strongly

01:01:33.230 --> 01:01:35.230
oppose this bill as amended.

01:01:36.260 --> 01:01:38.260
My name is healing disrupt birds.

01:01:38.696 --> 01:01:41.199
I live in california and I
strongly most this.

01:01:41.199 --> 01:01:43.199
opposed bill.

01:01:46.137 --> 01:01:49.500
And.
My name is olivia robertson from

01:01:50.106 --> 01:01:52.375
bradley california and I
strongly oppose schools and.

01:01:52.676 --> 01:01:55.612
My name is dale robertson
utility supervisor and home

01:01:56.280 --> 01:01:59.215
school father for and I pose
this bills amended.

01:02:00.884 --> 01:02:02.884
My name is loren roberts I am

01:02:03.353 --> 01:02:05.353
from brentwood california. And I

01:02:06.690 --> 01:02:08.690
strongly of I'm a I'm a private

01:02:09.590 --> 01:02:11.795
homes where and it's only oppose
this bill.
My name is edward shock I am an

01:02:11.795 --> 01:02:14.610
off duty california peace
officer appearing today as a

01:02:14.197 --> 01:02:16.832
private citizen and not
representing my department.

01:02:17.600 --> 01:02:20.202
I am from concord california and
I'm home school graduate I am

01:02:20.370 --> 01:02:23.500
also the father of three home
school children. I oppose this

01:02:23.905 --> 01:02:26.575
bill as amended.
Hello my name is key to shaw I'm

01:02:28.779 --> 01:02:31.460
the organizer of mount diablo.
Home school group in contra

01:02:32.114 --> 01:02:33.915
costa county I am I home school
graduate and homes when mother

01:02:34.750 --> 01:02:36.750
of three and I strongly oppose

01:02:36.784 --> 01:02:39.154
this bill as amended.
My name is megan armstrong thank

01:02:39.789 --> 01:02:42.422
the co organizer.
Of the diablo valley homeschool

01:02:43.259 --> 01:02:45.760
group I'm a homeschool graduate
psa mom of two.

01:02:45.761 --> 01:02:47.761
And I strongly oppose this bill

01:02:48.363 --> 01:02:50.932
as amended.
My name is katie to county and

01:02:51.833 --> 01:02:54.135
I'm from any california. And I
certainly oppose this bill as

01:02:54.902 --> 01:02:56.902
amended.

01:02:57.639 --> 01:02:59.639
My name is diana and strong.

01:03:00.909 --> 01:03:02.909
I am a home schooler and a

01:03:05.613 --> 01:03:08.415
strong puts a spell as amended.
My name is chloe armstrong.

01:03:09.751 --> 01:03:11.751
I and a home school.

01:03:12.200 --> 01:03:13.819
Learn.
Say.

01:03:16.422 --> 01:03:18.422
For.

01:03:19.694 --> 01:03:21.929
and I. Opposes bill and of those
so as amended.

01:03:26.600 --> 01:03:28.601
I strongly oppose.
Prepayment scanning my name is

01:03:30.700 --> 01:03:32.205
jd harris I strongly oppose this
bill as amended.

01:03:36.110 --> 01:03:37.910
The risk.
My name's separate cicconi am a

01:03:38.846 --> 01:03:41.800
music educator and a husband of
that wonderful wife over there

01:03:41.448 --> 01:03:43.581
with the three home school kids
and I strongly oppose this bill

01:03:51.291 --> 01:03:53.892
as well.
My name is justin here some of

01:03:54.561 --> 01:03:56.561
whom school debt student from

01:03:57.662 --> 01:03:59.965
san diego. And I oppose this
bill as amended.

01:04:00.498 --> 01:04:03.680
Hello my name is leila harris
I'm a real estate broker and a

01:04:04.270 --> 01:04:06.270
home school mom and I strongly

01:04:06.606 --> 01:04:09.241
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is nielsen huxley m.

01:04:10.341 --> 01:04:12.477
From roseville california and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:04:13.245 --> 01:04:15.680
amended.
My name is ken huxley I'm an

01:04:15.714 --> 01:04:17.781
attorney and homeschooling
parents from roseville

01:04:18.783 --> 01:04:20.783
california and I strongly oppose

01:04:20.986 --> 01:04:22.986
this bill as amended. My name is

01:04:23.880 --> 01:04:25.880
a my she even I strongly oppose

01:04:26.230 --> 01:04:28.230
this bill that is amended.

01:04:29.361 --> 01:04:32.970
I'm.
Even higher mcchrystal.

01:04:32.970 --> 01:04:34.865
I'm for french can california
and I strongly oppose this bill

01:04:36.668 --> 01:04:38.869
as amended.
Hello my name's john mcfarland

01:04:40.205 --> 01:04:42.205
from bay point california I'm a

01:04:42.407 --> 01:04:44.808
homeschool father and I would
strongly oppose this bill as
amended.

01:04:45.410 --> 01:04:47.978
I am very clerk I home school
parent from twenty county and I

01:04:47.978 --> 01:04:49.978
strongly oppose this bill as

01:04:50.380 --> 01:04:52.516
amended.
My name is matt clark also

01:04:52.650 --> 01:04:55.118
control me county and I oppose
this bill.

01:04:55.953 --> 01:04:58.388
My name is chris city mono I'm
from no and I strongly oppose

01:04:59.457 --> 01:05:02.125
this bill.
My name is dennis even though

01:05:03.994 --> 01:05:06.596
from you know and I pleases them.
My name is sarah seem order from
colonel and I strongly oppose

01:05:08.165 --> 01:05:10.433
this bill.
My name is timothy myers in a

01:05:10.534 --> 01:05:12.969
pharmacist and homeschool father
of over twenty years that very

01:05:13.700 --> 01:05:15.805
much opposed to still.
Hi my name is amy myers I'm also

01:05:16.440 --> 01:05:18.440
home school mom twenty plus

01:05:18.741 --> 01:05:20.741
years and morgan for california

01:05:21.478 --> 01:05:23.478
and I oppose this bill.

01:05:25.781 --> 01:05:28.684
How meaningless three pj and I
of per? Year. Hi my name is into

01:05:32.420 --> 01:05:34.990
three different more he
california and I oppose this
bill.

01:05:35.910 --> 01:05:37.458
Hi my name is shannon roatan I'm
a private home school parent

01:05:37.760 --> 01:05:39.895
from fresno california and the
administrator of liberty

01:05:40.396 --> 01:05:43.297
christian cooperative. And I
strongly oppose this bill.

01:05:44.299 --> 01:05:47.235
Hi my name is thomas are can and
I'm home school student from
fresno california and I oppose

01:05:47.803 --> 01:05:49.971
this bill.
Hi my name is abbas notam a

01:05:50.338 --> 01:05:53.410
private home school and I
strongly oppose this bill.

01:05:53.574 --> 01:05:55.574
Hello my name is sasha noon yes

01:05:56.478 --> 01:05:59.130
I'm a private home school parent
and. Aye school school by three

01:05:59.515 --> 01:06:02.283
daughters and we oppose this
bill adamantly.

01:06:02.918 --> 01:06:05.353
Hi my name is a civil unions and
I'm a home schooler and I oppose

01:06:05.721 --> 01:06:08.220
this bill strongly.
Hello my name is alexis news

01:06:08.590 --> 01:06:11.125
from fresno california I'm a
proud home schooling I strongly

01:06:11.526 --> 01:06:13.127
oppose this bill in light of our
constitutional rights in the

01:06:13.662 --> 01:06:15.963
amendments.
Hi my name is lou unionists.

01:06:17.632 --> 01:06:19.632
I'm from fresno california and

01:06:19.801 --> 01:06:21.801
I'm a proud host co student and

01:06:21.935 --> 01:06:24.536
i strongly oppose this bill.
Hi my name is that younger of

01:06:24.606 --> 01:06:26.739
yeah I'm from spain and I'm
being happily hosted by a

01:06:27.173 --> 01:06:29.900
homeschooling family and aye
opposed is to be a.

01:06:29.677 --> 01:06:32.780
Hi my name is sophia racht
homeschool mom to two wonderful

01:06:33.314 --> 01:06:36.282
kids in san diego and I strongly
oppose this bill as amended.

01:06:36.951 --> 01:06:39.753
I am serena we I'm a home school
students since twenty thirteen

01:06:40.354 --> 01:06:42.354
and I along with my friends and

01:06:42.655 --> 01:06:45.224
family strongly oppose this bill.
Hi my name is angelina lee I'm a

01:06:45.392 --> 01:06:47.392
home school student and they

01:06:47.795 --> 01:06:49.795
strongly oppose this bill.

01:06:49.963 --> 01:06:51.963
Hi my name is cheney ran forever

01:06:53.300 --> 01:06:56.268
is there.
I mean this class then laughed

01:06:58.305 --> 01:07:00.539
and post this bill.
My name's wendy lamb I'm a

01:07:01.341 --> 01:07:03.542
homeschool parent I strongly
oppose this bill at cemented the

01:07:05.376 --> 01:07:07.712
queue.
Hi my name is paul May pose this

01:07:09.148 --> 01:07:12.490
bill.
My name is angela lee I'm part

01:07:12.251 --> 01:07:14.251
of a class of conversation in

01:07:14.619 --> 01:07:16.619
fremont. And also parents of.

01:07:16.922 --> 01:07:19.356
Students at still debate and we
strongly oppose this bill as

01:07:20.392 --> 01:07:23.920
amended thank you.
My name is chris coach hay from

01:07:24.940 --> 01:07:26.940
vallejo california I home school

01:07:26.164 --> 01:07:27.998
my two daughters and we are.
Extremely opposed to this

01:07:29.332 --> 01:07:31.734
ballots amended.
Tell you could say and I

01:07:32.704 --> 01:07:35.380
strongly oppose this bill.
I'm autumn entertain I strongly

01:07:37.275 --> 01:07:39.775
opposed to this bill.
My name is celeste more and I

01:07:40.545 --> 01:07:42.912
live in brentwood california and
I strongly oppose this bill I'm

01:07:46.584 --> 01:07:48.584
a parent of one.

01:07:48.619 --> 01:07:50.619
My name is joseph more with the.

01:07:50.653 --> 01:07:53.222
My name is joseph more. I live
in brentwood and I strongly

01:07:54.900 --> 01:07:56.910
oppose this bill.
when his mark more from alameda

01:07:56.910 --> 01:07:58.995
county I strongly oppose this
bill.

01:08:00.163 --> 01:08:03.650
My name's jessie gala and I live
in any up and I strongly oppose
this bill.

01:08:03.667 --> 01:08:05.301
My name is isaac allen I
strongly oppose this bill as a

01:08:05.702 --> 01:08:07.702
man.

01:08:08.400 --> 01:08:10.400
Hello my name is sonya golla and

01:08:10.240 --> 01:08:12.240
I live in antioch and I have

01:08:12.776 --> 01:08:15.711
graduated three adult children
now onto a which our share of

01:08:16.279 --> 01:08:18.513
deputies for san francisco. My
husband is a police officer in

01:08:19.148 --> 01:08:22.840
san francisco and that has been
only. The reason we can home

01:08:22.785 --> 01:08:24.785
school because my husband has a

01:08:25.880 --> 01:08:27.880
worked. Long and hard to make it

01:08:27.190 --> 01:08:29.457
possible for us and I strongly
oppose this bill as amended

01:08:30.590 --> 01:08:32.590
think money was just typing data

01:08:32.927 --> 01:08:35.328
element anya california and I
strongly oppose this bill as
amended.

01:08:35.831 --> 01:08:38.766
Hi my name is ralph panetta not
from any aken I posed this bill

01:08:39.702 --> 01:08:42.168
as amended hi tanya pennetta
home school parent of fuller

01:08:42.805 --> 01:08:44.805
from antioch california. And I

01:08:46.981 --> 01:08:49.777
strongly oppose this bill as
amended.
Hi I'm the net at least that
allows I am from oakley

01:08:50.245 --> 01:08:52.245
californian I home school two

01:08:52.413 --> 01:08:54.882
children and I strongly oppose
this bill as amended.

01:08:55.750 --> 01:08:58.352
Hi my name is alicia cordova I'm
from antioch california and I

01:08:58.553 --> 01:09:00.553
strongly oppose this bill as

01:09:01.222 --> 01:09:03.424
amended.
My name is hayden veteran

01:09:04.325 --> 01:09:06.460
carrillo and I strongly oppose
this bill months.

01:09:08.263 --> 01:09:10.797
My name is faith cordova and I
I'm from any are california and

01:09:10.832 --> 01:09:12.832
I strongly oppose this bill as

01:09:14.936 --> 01:09:16.936
amended.

01:09:18.390 --> 01:09:20.390
My name is natalie and phone a

01:09:22.219 --> 01:09:24.711
up california and I oppose this
bill as a man.
Hi my name is nadia on it

01:09:25.611 --> 01:09:27.213
homeschool mother of two and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:09:31.952 --> 01:09:33.952
amended.

01:09:34.655 --> 01:09:36.655
My name is david. And. I come

01:09:36.957 --> 01:09:38.957
from antioch and I strongly

01:09:41.395 --> 01:09:44.363
oppose this bill as amended.
Good afternoon my name is
wolfgang what.

01:09:44.631 --> 01:09:46.631
I'm come from antioch of the

01:09:47.000 --> 01:09:49.668
business owner. I'm father of to
home school children and aye

01:09:49.736 --> 01:09:51.736
opposed bill as amended thank

01:09:52.272 --> 01:09:55.500
you.
My name is daniel act aye from

01:09:55.206 --> 01:09:57.542
antioch.
And had been homeschooled my

01:09:58.277 --> 01:10:00.450
whole life and I.
Oppose this bill strongly as

01:10:02.810 --> 01:10:03.915
amended.
Many of us let's bit per field

01:10:04.550 --> 01:10:07.484
I'm a homeschool graduate
college graduate mortgage broker

01:10:10.652 --> 01:10:12.323
I home school my four children
in antioch california and I
strongly oppose this bill as
amended.

01:10:13.524 --> 01:10:16.194
I am evelyn. And I am a home
schooler.

01:10:18.329 --> 01:10:20.329
For.

01:10:22.000 --> 01:10:24.567
In any out california.
Hello my name is diane pfeifer

01:10:24.870 --> 01:10:27.438
and from brentwood california
and I strongly oppose this bill

01:10:28.240 --> 01:10:30.240
as amended.

01:10:32.244 --> 01:10:34.443
Hi my name is joseph for I am a.
I'm home school student from

01:10:34.947 --> 01:10:37.181
brentwood california and I
strongly opposes. The bill as

01:10:38.480 --> 01:10:40.918
amended.
Hi my name is karen reina from

01:10:41.119 --> 01:10:43.686
brentwood california and a small
business owner and home school

01:10:45.880 --> 01:10:46.723
mom and I oppose this bill as
amended thanks for hearing us

01:10:47.492 --> 01:10:49.760
today.
Hello my name is cheryl ma'am

01:10:50.228 --> 01:10:53.163
I'm from brentwood california
home school my look three and i

01:10:53.297 --> 01:10:55.297
strongly oppose this bill as

01:10:55.299 --> 01:10:57.566
amended.
Good afternoon my name is

01:10:58.269 --> 01:11:00.269
caltrain equipment and I oppose

01:11:00.671 --> 01:11:02.671
this bill ab twenty seven fifty

01:11:02.940 --> 01:11:05.775
six as amended thank you.
Air my neighbors closeness and I

01:11:06.210 --> 01:11:08.244
am from brent woods I oppose
this bill.

01:11:08.244 --> 01:11:10.244
I am.

01:11:10.914 --> 01:11:13.470
A mother of six home schooled
all of them and they strongly

01:11:14.151 --> 01:11:16.952
oppose this bill as amended.
Hello I'm deborah lyrica from

01:11:17.721 --> 01:11:19.721
any california home school

01:11:20.223 --> 01:11:22.223
educator of six and I strongly

01:11:22.959 --> 01:11:24.959
oppose this bill as amended.

01:11:25.610 --> 01:11:27.329
Hi I'm on naval erica and I come
from any are california I'm a

01:11:29.332 --> 01:11:30.899
threat. Problem school student
and I oppose this bill as

01:11:31.634 --> 01:11:34.136
amended.
Hello I'm dominique three now my

01:11:35.104 --> 01:11:38.730
family california home schooled
hearing. And I strongly oppose

01:11:39.709 --> 01:11:42.677
this bill ab t. Seven five six
as amended thank you.

01:11:42.745 --> 01:11:45.480
I'm pave sweet nam and I come
from brentwood california and I

01:11:45.981 --> 01:11:47.981
oppose this bill.

01:11:48.820 --> 01:11:50.180
Hi my name is faith gala and I
am old school stay into

01:11:52.421 --> 01:11:54.589
california. And I oppose this
bill as an and.

01:11:55.391 --> 01:11:58.192
Hi my name is kill bella I'm a
whole school student. And I live

01:11:58.627 --> 01:12:00.627
in and how california and I

01:12:00.829 --> 01:12:03.563
strongly oppose this bill as
amended.

01:12:05.267 --> 01:12:07.267
My name is is it out there and I

01:12:08.103 --> 01:12:10.471
oppose this bill ivan nagy.
My name is rosy gala I'm a

01:12:10.905 --> 01:12:13.674
homeschool mom of night kids
good to graduates.

01:12:13.708 --> 01:12:16.577
And I oppose this bill as
amended.

01:12:17.745 --> 01:12:19.745
Hi my name is william and.

01:12:20.949 --> 01:12:22.949
And.

01:12:23.351 --> 01:12:25.351
I oppose this bill. Of.

01:12:25.987 --> 01:12:27.987
As elaine.

01:12:28.689 --> 01:12:31.240
hello my name is yet I gala.
And I oppose this bill as

01:12:32.360 --> 01:12:35.228
amended.
Hi I'm kelly occurred in home

01:12:35.429 --> 01:12:38.640
schooling mother from sacramento
california and I oppose this

01:12:38.499 --> 01:12:40.967
bill as amended.
I am kristin shepherd I'm from

01:12:41.902 --> 01:12:44.704
orange california as a former
public school educator I oppose

01:12:45.739 --> 01:12:47.306
this bill and I represent over
hundred families in orange

01:12:48.175 --> 01:12:50.776
county.
Hello I'm sandra bronze from

01:12:51.144 --> 01:12:53.846
livermore california I am a
private.

01:12:54.581 --> 01:12:57.281
Home schooler and I oppose this
bill as amended.

01:12:57.551 --> 01:12:59.551
Hi my name is similar aye

01:12:59.853 --> 01:13:01.853
randolph and I strongly oppose

01:13:03.490 --> 01:13:05.424
this bill as amended thinking.
Hi good morning my name is

01:13:06.292 --> 01:13:08.292
jessica clan I hannah a. M. From

01:13:08.360 --> 01:13:10.929
fullerton california I am a
public middle school counselor

01:13:11.197 --> 01:13:13.197
in garden grove unified school

01:13:13.366 --> 01:13:16.334
district and I am a future home
schooling mother and I strongly

01:13:17.602 --> 01:13:19.904
oppose this bill as amended.
I am person takamori from

01:13:21.600 --> 01:13:22.607
westminster home school mom to
four and I oppose this bill

01:13:23.175 --> 01:13:25.810
thinking.
Hello my name is danny smith and

01:13:27.246 --> 01:13:29.981
I am from oakley california I
have graduated my children from

01:13:30.315 --> 01:13:32.315
home education they have

01:13:32.584 --> 01:13:34.584
multiple masters and bachelors

01:13:34.718 --> 01:13:36.718
degrees I am now a. Second

01:13:36.855 --> 01:13:38.855
generation home educator we

01:13:39.491 --> 01:13:41.859
oppose this bill.
Hello my name is theresa good

01:13:42.960 --> 01:13:45.361
man I'm from oakley california
representing belvedere academy

01:13:45.463 --> 01:13:47.331
in home school mother and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:13:47.966 --> 01:13:50.501
amended.
Hello my name is of all good men

01:13:51.569 --> 01:13:53.470
I am from oakley I'm home school
student and I strongly oppose

01:13:55.673 --> 01:13:58.342
this bill as amended.
I am unclear follow and the home

01:13:59.811 --> 01:14:02.450
educator from concord california.
And I strongly oppose this bill

01:14:07.618 --> 01:14:10.153
as amended.
I no longer overall and I.

01:14:10.720 --> 01:14:13.656
The home school student I oppose
this bill.

01:14:14.525 --> 01:14:16.525
Thanks no.

01:14:16.694 --> 01:14:18.694
My status element travis allen I

01:14:18.961 --> 01:14:21.664
am the california citizen ab
twenty seven fifty six. Is

01:14:23.367 --> 01:14:25.367
absolutely wrong it must fail it

01:14:29.272 --> 01:14:31.839
must failed to day. California's.
No afford used parents and our

01:14:33.900 --> 01:14:35.645
children have a right to the
very best education.

01:14:35.645 --> 01:14:37.645
They this state could possibly

01:14:37.814 --> 01:14:40.215
ride whether it's public schools
public charter schools Mister

01:14:41.840 --> 01:14:43.117
I'm house not clinton's name
affiliation position on that

01:14:43.853 --> 01:14:45.853
precisely as I understand it

01:14:45.955 --> 01:14:48.323
they was on my of the part. One
I I've been importance draws
many times let me tell you

01:14:49.192 --> 01:14:51.993
something I and the california
citizens here. By the way to

01:14:55.298 --> 01:14:57.298
flora allen I'm sorry but we

01:14:57.900 --> 01:15:00.336
need to get on to the next.
Ab twenty seven fifty six must

01:15:00.336 --> 01:15:02.235
be aware right education
california travis allen

01:15:03.138 --> 01:15:05.138
huntington beach proud father of

01:15:09.178 --> 01:15:11.178
to vote no.

01:15:12.247 --> 01:15:14.249
That's a tough act to follow and
my.

01:15:14.249 --> 01:15:16.784
My name's danielle levers I'm a
homeschool mom of four in

01:15:17.986 --> 01:15:19.954
brentwood california. And we
strongly oppose this bill as

01:15:24.259 --> 01:15:27.270
amended.
Hi my name is slanted levers I'm

01:15:28.930 --> 01:15:30.930
from brentwood and I strongly.

01:15:34.268 --> 01:15:36.603
Oppose this bill as amended.
I am shannon surely from bring

01:15:36.971 --> 01:15:38.971
one california I'm a home

01:15:40.374 --> 01:15:42.374
educator of two and I strongly

01:15:46.547 --> 01:15:48.547
oppose this bill as amended.

01:15:50.170 --> 01:15:52.170
Hi my little zachary. And.

01:15:53.520 --> 01:15:55.520
i'm from threaten to california.

01:15:56.123 --> 01:15:58.570
And. I.
Oppose.

01:16:00.360 --> 01:16:02.360
This

01:16:02.896 --> 01:16:04.896
well as amended.

01:16:05.332 --> 01:16:08.134
Those shouldn't share.
And have chiang ncurses doesn't

01:16:12.906 --> 01:16:14.906
mean.

01:16:15.175 --> 01:16:17.175
I and autolycus I can from

01:16:17.343 --> 01:16:19.877
oakley california and I oppose
this bill as amended.

01:16:20.580 --> 01:16:22.580
I chau via del crews from

01:16:23.349 --> 01:16:25.349
wealthy california and I.

01:16:25.585 --> 01:16:28.552
A purchased this bill from. As
amended.

01:16:29.255 --> 01:16:31.723
Hi am erica I'm from op
california I home school three

01:16:32.790 --> 01:16:34.790
girls and I strongly oppose this

01:16:35.829 --> 01:16:38.296
bill as amended.
Hello I am amanda barracks I'm a

01:16:38.631 --> 01:16:41.299
home educator for moraga
california and I oppose this

01:16:43.268 --> 01:16:46.137
bill as amended.
I am and how.

01:16:50.842 --> 01:16:52.842
And I am thrilled fell admin.

01:16:53.879 --> 01:16:55.879
I arianna home schooler and see

01:16:57.883 --> 01:16:59.883
saul landau county and I oppose

01:17:01.519 --> 01:17:03.721
this bill as amended.
I'm francis not all on

01:17:04.923 --> 01:17:07.224
homeschooling mom of solano
county they oppose this bill as

01:17:12.230 --> 01:17:14.230
amended.

01:17:15.867 --> 01:17:17.867
I'm still on owns cooler and I

01:17:19.370 --> 01:17:21.938
applaud.
Six printer total register their

01:17:22.506 --> 01:17:24.808
public information homeschoolers
are not criminals I've a

01:17:25.876 --> 01:17:27.876
heavenly oppose this bill as

01:17:28.110 --> 01:17:30.680
amended regardless of amendment.
I'm robin day from rippin I'm a

01:17:31.749 --> 01:17:34.617
home educator of three and we
oppose this bill.

01:17:36.587 --> 01:17:39.455
I matthew day among her a home
schooler ash on the post this
bill.

01:17:40.424 --> 01:17:43.159
I'm julie beth wham wham pen
homeschool ministries from
oakdale california and we oppose

01:17:44.294 --> 01:17:46.962
this bill.
Hi I'm christy anderson from

01:17:47.630 --> 01:17:49.898
oakdale california and I oppose
this bill.

01:17:50.967 --> 01:17:53.769
I mean we anderson for moto
california aye opposed no.

01:17:53.903 --> 01:17:56.405
I'm natalie chapelle from oakley
california realtor and a

01:17:57.774 --> 01:17:59.908
homeschool mom and I oppose ab
twenty seven fifty six as

01:18:01.210 --> 01:18:03.210
amended.

01:18:03.746 --> 01:18:05.746
I'm caitlin chapelle from oakley

01:18:05.948 --> 01:18:08.817
california I'm my name's test
when he was.

01:18:09.218 --> 01:18:11.218
My name's tessa quinn bmi mother

01:18:11.687 --> 01:18:13.687
of to and I strongly oppose as.

01:18:13.856 --> 01:18:16.189
Ab two seven five six and I
will never accept it I will let

01:18:17.292 --> 01:18:20.193
everyone know we will not stop
coming back stop trying to take.

01:18:22.698 --> 01:18:24.698
Trying to point.

01:18:26.768 --> 01:18:29.268
I'm.
I am is haley pearson I'm from

01:18:31.706 --> 01:18:33.706
nampa idaho. I strongly opposes.

01:18:34.508 --> 01:18:36.508
Oppose ab two seven five six

01:18:36.510 --> 01:18:38.512
if you pass this bill.
Then you do not have the home

01:18:38.512 --> 01:18:40.512
schooled children's best

01:18:41.182 --> 01:18:43.182
interests.

01:18:48.560 --> 01:18:50.560
I've speak as it went on.

01:18:50.570 --> 01:18:52.226
Hi my name is daniel year and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:18:52.226 --> 01:18:54.226
amended.

01:18:55.896 --> 01:18:58.665
Well.
Hi I'm alisha peterson and I

01:18:59.834 --> 01:19:02.802
strongly oppose ab two seven
five six.

01:19:03.269 --> 01:19:05.638
The ban on home school and
private schools I will never

01:19:06.740 --> 01:19:09.609
accept this bill.
I'm stephen gear and from

01:19:09.943 --> 01:19:12.378
sacramento california and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:19:13.680 --> 01:19:15.680
amended.

01:19:16.450 --> 01:19:19.319
Hi my name is joseph gear and
strongly opposed his bill as a
man.

01:19:20.200 --> 01:19:22.787
I'm austin bennett I'm a father
five home schooled all of them

01:19:23.323 --> 01:19:25.891
all I'm also a m..
Candidate for state senate for

01:19:26.860 --> 01:19:28.860
the six district. As the bill

01:19:28.928 --> 01:19:31.464
was written it violated the
third the fourth.

01:19:31.464 --> 01:19:34.433
The thirteenth and fourteenth
amendment
and.

01:19:35.835 --> 01:19:38.680
Raskin the representatives to
start representing the people

01:19:43.142 --> 01:19:45.344
and remember euro.
L. Remember your oath to the

01:19:45.344 --> 01:19:47.344
people to uphold the

01:19:53.118 --> 01:19:55.118
constitution.

01:19:55.654 --> 01:19:58.560
Name is michael gear.
Here from sacramento california

01:20:01.860 --> 01:20:03.561
we oppose the bill isn't.
My name is heather martinson I'm

01:20:05.970 --> 01:20:07.331
from your paper california and I
am a member of the california

01:20:07.599 --> 01:20:10.000
homeschool network their home
school association. Of

01:20:11.236 --> 01:20:13.637
california and I'm area rep for
a tune all the alternative

01:20:14.406 --> 01:20:16.406
education resource organization

01:20:17.707 --> 01:20:19.743
I own oc home schooling dot com.
And I run celebration education.

01:20:20.543 --> 01:20:22.543
And I oppose this bill as

01:20:23.614 --> 01:20:25.649
amended thinking.
I'm lee martin syndrome yucaipa

01:20:26.918 --> 01:20:29.853
california san bernardino county
and senior benefits consultant I

01:20:30.154 --> 01:20:32.154
oppose this bill twenty seven

01:20:33.124 --> 01:20:35.125
fifty six.
I'm harrison martinson from

01:20:37.940 --> 01:20:39.940
yucaipa I am home schooled and I

01:20:39.730 --> 01:20:41.730
oppose this bill as amended.

01:20:41.732 --> 01:20:44.534
I rarely marcussen from yucaipa
california sending you know

01:20:45.135 --> 01:20:48.400
county I was former home
schoolers and I oppose boot bill

01:20:48.704 --> 01:20:51.240
as amended.
My nearest size trafford I'm

01:20:52.941 --> 01:20:55.878
from sacramento california in I
oppose this bill.

01:20:57.470 --> 01:20:59.470
My name's joel radford I am also

01:20:59.249 --> 01:21:02.170
from sacramento california and I
strongly refuse to support this
bill.

01:21:02.285 --> 01:21:04.721
My name is kate radford where
small business owners and home

01:21:04.721 --> 01:21:07.289
educators and we oppose this
bill.

01:21:07.422 --> 01:21:10.920
i am christie low per from
clovis california homeschool

01:21:10.193 --> 01:21:12.961
mama and I oppose this bill as
amended.

01:21:13.730 --> 01:21:16.431
I'mabigail brodsky I'm home
school student and I oppose this

01:21:17.100 --> 01:21:19.434
bill even as amended.
I am sure what's he from share

01:21:20.370 --> 01:21:22.637
from fresno california home
school mom of five and I

01:21:22.872 --> 01:21:25.206
strongly oppose this bill even
as amended.

01:21:25.875 --> 01:21:27.875
My name is josiah folio from

01:21:28.342 --> 01:21:31.312
clovis california and I strongly
oppose this bill even as amended.

01:21:32.140 --> 01:21:34.781
My name is abigail puglia from
clovis california and I strongly

01:21:36.784 --> 01:21:39.420
oppose this bill even as amended.
My name is christy foglia I

01:21:39.421 --> 01:21:41.822
support.
My house christian schooling

01:21:41.822 --> 01:21:43.822
here.

01:21:45.260 --> 01:21:47.260
On their behalf and I strongly

01:21:48.230 --> 01:21:50.230
oppose this bill even as amended.

01:21:50.298 --> 01:21:52.366
Hi my name's y. Have very and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:21:52.967 --> 01:21:54.967
amended.

01:21:55.403 --> 01:21:57.403
Stacey howry from fresno and I

01:21:57.438 --> 01:21:59.438
oppose this bill as amended.

01:21:59.707 --> 01:22:02.541
My name is ian can terrace and
I'm a home school students. From

01:22:03.644 --> 01:22:05.644
fresno california and I strongly

01:22:05.814 --> 01:22:08.682
oppose this bill.
Hi my name's kim can terrace

01:22:08.981 --> 01:22:11.783
thank you for your time today
swan encouraged you to oppose

01:22:12.860 --> 01:22:14.521
the spell even as amended thank
you.

01:22:14.855 --> 01:22:17.490
Hi I'm matthew smith.
And aye opposed to spell even

01:22:18.692 --> 01:22:21.427
as amended.
I melissa remington I'm a dental

01:22:22.796 --> 01:22:24.796
hygienist and a home educator. I

01:22:24.863 --> 01:22:26.863
strongly oppose this bill I'm

01:22:27.634 --> 01:22:30.202
from sutter cat and county.
My name is duncan remington I'm

01:22:30.871 --> 01:22:33.380
a home schooler from sutter
county and I strongly oppose

01:22:33.573 --> 01:22:36.410
this bill.
My name is alya dare tongue I'm

01:22:36.509 --> 01:22:38.577
a proud home school graduate
credential teacher and even

01:22:38.912 --> 01:22:40.912
prouder homeschool mom and I

01:22:42.549 --> 01:22:44.716
oppose this bill.
My name is carrie or from to

01:22:44.951 --> 01:22:46.919
make you california and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:22:50.570 --> 01:22:52.570
amended.

01:22:52.825 --> 01:22:54.825
Hi and and or from tech to make

01:22:55.227 --> 01:22:57.227
a california I oppose this bill

01:22:57.563 --> 01:23:00.331
as amended.
My name is audrey or and I pose

01:23:03.836 --> 01:23:05.836
this bill even as amended.

01:23:06.171 --> 01:23:08.171
Hi my name is alex down thing I

01:23:08.440 --> 01:23:10.875
oppose this bill as amended.
Hi my name is donna stump I'm a

01:23:11.542 --> 01:23:13.678
registered nurse and home
educator from winchester

01:23:14.313 --> 01:23:16.313
california and I oppose this

01:23:16.815 --> 01:23:19.517
bill strongly.
Harmon is russell stump and a

01:23:19.584 --> 01:23:22.119
retired police sergeant
riverside california I strongly

01:23:22.687 --> 01:23:24.687
oppose this bill. If it ain't

01:23:26.324 --> 01:23:28.559
broke don't fix it.
Hi my name is a daniel myers

01:23:29.227 --> 01:23:30.828
from berkeley california and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:23:33.310 --> 01:23:35.310
amended.

01:23:35.498 --> 01:23:38.201
Hi my name is fattah y. And I'm
a homeschooling mother of three

01:23:38.469 --> 01:23:40.469
I oppose this bill even as

01:23:41.906 --> 01:23:44.107
amended.
Hi my name is turn like telling

01:23:46.770 --> 01:23:48.770
someone a tougher and many happy

01:23:49.246 --> 01:23:51.246
home schooling in I oppose this

01:23:51.682 --> 01:23:53.682
bell and.

01:23:55.170 --> 01:23:57.353
Now miami miami.
Spf in ninety.

01:23:57.419 --> 01:23:59.419
My name is all in the severe

01:23:59.423 --> 01:24:01.423
from lawndale california and I

01:24:01.592 --> 01:24:03.592
oppose this bill as amended.

01:24:03.593 --> 01:24:06.395
My name is danielle said br from
lawndale california in our la

01:24:07.998 --> 01:24:10.599
county I am an admin for south
bay home school network and a

01:24:11.167 --> 01:24:13.569
board member for right he says
he said me outside the customer

01:24:14.237 --> 01:24:16.572
does all the vast. And I oppose
this bill.

01:24:17.600 --> 01:24:19.540
hi my name is anna quizzing me
steidle and I'm a secular

01:24:19.909 --> 01:24:22.477
homeschooling mom from los
angeles and I strongly oppose

01:24:23.813 --> 01:24:26.615
this bill as amended.
Hi my name is heather jerome I'm

01:24:27.317 --> 01:24:29.484
a homeschool mom of three I
strongly appeal.

01:24:30.786 --> 01:24:33.588
This bill.
My name is those who give in and

01:24:35.524 --> 01:24:38.930
I strongly oppose this bill.
Hello my name is eva mcginn from

01:24:38.127 --> 01:24:40.127
us commuter california strongly

01:24:42.765 --> 01:24:45.633
opposes bill.
My name is passed down and I

01:24:49.336 --> 01:24:51.773
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is my cousins and from

01:24:51.773 --> 01:24:53.773
brazil and I oppose this bill as

01:24:53.974 --> 01:24:56.444
amended.
And a Mister Chau I'm sen am I

01:24:56.611 --> 01:24:58.712
home school soon and I've flows
of spill.

01:24:59.547 --> 01:25:01.148
Mindy adams in roles will
california and I oppose this

01:25:03.752 --> 01:25:06.520
bill.
I'm evan hines and I am home

01:25:10.657 --> 01:25:12.858
schooled and I oppose this bill.
The name is suzanne hein some

01:25:13.261 --> 01:25:15.494
from rocklin california in a
home school moment I oppose this

01:25:16.296 --> 01:25:19.132
bill as amended.
I am was with little I am home

01:25:19.867 --> 01:25:21.867
school student and I strongly

01:25:22.103 --> 01:25:24.571
oppose this bill. I'm megan long
and I'm a homeschool graduate of

01:25:25.506 --> 01:25:27.506
twenty eighteen and I strongly

01:25:27.773 --> 01:25:30.900
oppose this bill.
And carol edwards for bigger so

01:25:30.711 --> 01:25:33.679
california I filed the private
school affidavit for the last

01:25:34.448 --> 01:25:36.448
twelve years and I represent

01:25:36.815 --> 01:25:38.451
home educators resource center.
I'm thomas edwards not oppose

01:25:39.218 --> 01:25:41.954
this bill.
My name is david widow I won I

01:25:42.540 --> 01:25:44.455
was home schooled and I'm in
college I strongly oppose bill

01:25:45.457 --> 01:25:47.793
two seven five six.
My name is stephanie heard I've

01:25:47.928 --> 01:25:50.396
been a california credentialed
teacher for over thirty years

01:25:50.730 --> 01:25:53.565
I'm the director of peach
blossom school. And also the

01:25:54.330 --> 01:25:56.401
director of san jose home
schoolers which represents

01:25:57.170 --> 01:25:59.737
thirteen hundred homeschooling
families in silicon valley and

01:26:01.240 --> 01:26:04.430
we oppose this bill.
Hi I'm sharon bargain and I home

01:26:04.430 --> 01:26:06.430
school my son and I oppose peace

01:26:12.885 --> 01:26:15.386
deal.
Yeah she did chen contact. The

01:26:17.523 --> 01:26:20.158
home schooler from san jose and
I oppose this bill.

01:26:21.393 --> 01:26:23.928
How many machine kitty shankar
among homeschoolers insane as an

01:26:24.329 --> 01:26:26.230
a pluses del?
Hi I'm cindy though shankar

01:26:26.330 --> 01:26:28.666
homeschooling mom to two goes
from san jose and I oppose this

01:26:28.667 --> 01:26:30.701
bill.
Hi my name's kept thomas on the

01:26:30.769 --> 01:26:32.769
home school parent from santa

01:26:33.338 --> 01:26:35.338
clara california. And I oppose

01:26:35.640 --> 01:26:37.974
this a bill as amended as well.
My name is james one garden I'm

01:26:38.610 --> 01:26:40.610
a quick from developer in sexual

01:26:40.811 --> 01:26:43.460
designer and I am hopeful father
one and I strongly oppose this

01:26:46.684 --> 01:26:49.251
ill conceived legislation.
Hello I'm finesse areas I am a

01:26:49.452 --> 01:26:52.289
homeschooling mom of two
children. One of which has

01:26:52.857 --> 01:26:54.558
special needs and greatly
benefits from being home

01:26:55.993 --> 01:26:57.993
schooled. I'm also the organizer

01:26:58.129 --> 01:27:00.330
and sam cisco of. A group of
homeschooling group of comprised

01:27:01.650 --> 01:27:03.650
of forty families I'm here to

01:27:03.267 --> 01:27:05.969
represent them we. Oppose this
bill strongly as amended thank

01:27:07.710 --> 01:27:09.906
you.
Hi my name is elena tracey m.

01:27:10.973 --> 01:27:13.843
From right wet. And I'm a
educators my two children I

01:27:15.646 --> 01:27:17.914
oppose this bill.
I'm lee tracy from wrightwood

01:27:18.413 --> 01:27:20.413
california speaking to oppose

01:27:20.750 --> 01:27:23.686
this bill thank you.
I'm terrace one from torrance

01:27:25.880 --> 01:27:27.488
california and I strongly oppose
assembly bill two seven five six

01:27:30.910 --> 01:27:32.761
as amended.
My name is astrid anger low from

01:27:34.300 --> 01:27:36.300
torrance I am home schooled and

01:27:36.650 --> 01:27:38.932
I oppose this bill as amended.
I'm renee wilcox from buena park

01:27:39.502 --> 01:27:41.937
california I'm a liberal
democrat my oppose this bill as

01:27:42.971 --> 01:27:44.940
amended.
I am sorry for.

01:27:48.810 --> 01:27:50.779
Felina part and I oppose.
I'm que lucier and I oppose this

01:27:56.485 --> 01:27:58.485
bill.

01:27:58.787 --> 01:28:00.787
Little thing.

01:28:01.924 --> 01:28:04.191
I thought we will kern.
And.

01:28:04.926 --> 01:28:06.926
For.

01:28:10.232 --> 01:28:12.232
And I'm.

01:28:15.704 --> 01:28:17.704
No.

01:28:22.844 --> 01:28:25.345
And this bill.
I am denny from joshua tree

01:28:25.612 --> 01:28:27.612
california and aye opposed to

01:28:28.516 --> 01:28:30.650
spell.
I'm catherine this year.

01:28:30.650 --> 01:28:32.650
I am.

01:28:33.286 --> 01:28:35.286
Liberal democrat and I oppose

01:28:36.390 --> 01:28:38.690
this bill is meant.
I am angela up all early boost

01:28:39.228 --> 01:28:42.610
thosei am a homeschooling
mother for and I strongly oppose

01:28:46.165 --> 01:28:48.668
this bill.
My name is ca penitentiary and

01:28:50.337 --> 01:28:53.390
I'm six great home schooler and
I oppose this bill.

01:28:53.473 --> 01:28:55.473
Scientific gantry and I oppose

01:28:56.608 --> 01:28:58.777
this bill.
My name is carrie we demeyer

01:28:59.579 --> 01:29:01.646
entry I'm a homeschool mom of
seven from morgan hill

01:29:02.415 --> 01:29:04.415
california and I strongly oppose

01:29:04.684 --> 01:29:06.684
this bill as amended.

01:29:07.530 --> 01:29:08.787
My name is kelly nj am a fifth
grader and I strongly opposed to

01:29:09.389 --> 01:29:12.257
spell. My name is kind know
andrew I'm a high school senior

01:29:12.859 --> 01:29:15.930
and I strongly oppose this bill
my name's cho injury and the

01:29:15.527 --> 01:29:17.662
home school student as strongly
oppose this bill.

01:29:17.763 --> 01:29:20.398
hi my name is keith answer from
morgan hill california and the

01:29:21.100 --> 01:29:23.735
father consul father seven and I
strongly oppose this bill.

01:29:24.804 --> 01:29:27.505
Hi I'm a home educator my name
is jacqueline wood from san jose

01:29:28.307 --> 01:29:30.307
and I strongly opposed to spell.

01:29:30.309 --> 01:29:32.844
My name is political was and I
oppose this bill. I'm doctor

01:29:33.312 --> 01:29:35.613
katie steps guy and phd from
stanford university school of

01:29:36.482 --> 01:29:38.382
education and I strongly oppose
this bill.

01:29:38.750 --> 01:29:41.180
Hi my name is don cole and a
home school mother of nineteen

01:29:41.820 --> 01:29:44.455
years of two children college a
graduating senior five kids to

01:29:44.956 --> 01:29:46.956
home I'm a college student I'm a

01:29:47.259 --> 01:29:49.259
military wife. And I strongly

01:29:49.628 --> 01:29:51.895
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is christopher cole and

01:29:52.329 --> 01:29:54.329
ash and I oppose this bill as

01:29:54.899 --> 01:29:56.899
amended my name is rachel call

01:29:57.235 --> 01:29:59.235
and I strongly opposes buzzing.

01:29:59.537 --> 01:30:02.105
My name is matthew cole and I
oppose this bill as amended my

01:30:02.273 --> 01:30:04.606
name is maddie call in high
school senior and I oppose this

01:30:04.909 --> 01:30:07.177
bill as amended.
My name is heather because I am

01:30:07.745 --> 01:30:09.879
a home schooled student in high
school and I oppose this bill as

01:30:11.182 --> 01:30:13.616
amended.
My name is beverly senate you

01:30:14.483 --> 01:30:16.920
from anya california I oppose
this bill as amended have been

01:30:17.922 --> 01:30:19.922
homeschooling. Of homeschooling

01:30:20.958 --> 01:30:23.426
mom for fifteen years.
Hi my name is lisa and a diego.

01:30:24.727 --> 01:30:26.727
And I'm from any up california

01:30:26.962 --> 01:30:29.398
and I oppose this bill.
My name is casey tear from

01:30:29.933 --> 01:30:31.834
orangeville homeschool mom of
two and a strongly oppose this

01:30:33.100 --> 01:30:35.971
bill. My name is diana de has of
sacramento california future

01:30:37.307 --> 01:30:39.307
home school mom and I strongly

01:30:39.441 --> 01:30:42.344
oppose this bill as amended.
I means tomar cervantes from

01:30:42.912 --> 01:30:45.614
sacramento california and i
strongly oppose this bill my

01:30:48.911 --> 01:30:51.685
name's emily guest learn I
strongly oppose this bill.
My name julia gessler I am
twelve years old and I strongly

01:30:52.388 --> 01:30:54.321
opposes the.
Many of us can really kessler

01:30:55.240 --> 01:30:57.359
been homeschooling for ten years
or also small business owners

01:30:58.694 --> 01:31:00.295
and tracy california and we
strongly oppose this bill as

01:31:02.264 --> 01:31:04.832
amended.
My name is actually vizag school

01:31:06.669 --> 01:31:08.569
next alley oppose the spell.
My name is howie precisely from

01:31:09.104 --> 01:31:10.705
orangeville californian I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:31:11.440 --> 01:31:13.541
amended.
There's two microphone so we can

01:31:13.841 --> 01:31:15.841
have to lines come down keep

01:31:15.978 --> 01:31:18.913
coming keep walking.
I'm clout at coconut our of back

01:31:19.848 --> 01:31:22.490
a bill california I represent
home schooling parents in

01:31:23.283 --> 01:31:25.986
california I strongly oppose
this bill.

01:31:26.520 --> 01:31:28.756
Hi my name is joanne and I'm
from very baptist church home

01:31:29.390 --> 01:31:31.390
school group and we strongly

01:31:32.293 --> 01:31:34.428
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is melody and from

01:31:35.161 --> 01:31:36.830
fairview baptist home school
group and I strongly oppose this

01:31:39.700 --> 01:31:41.835
bill.
I mean it's all over gonzalez

01:31:42.503 --> 01:31:44.971
from san francisco california
homeschool father three nay

01:31:47.740 --> 01:31:49.241
strongly opposes bill.
Hi my name's passed a roger he

01:31:49.743 --> 01:31:52.345
man as I represent the very
baptist church home school group

01:31:52.847 --> 01:31:55.214
on behalf of our fifty members
I'm here to say we oppose this

01:31:56.116 --> 01:31:58.116
bill. And we appreciate you

01:32:00.554 --> 01:32:02.355
staying on your back you.
Name is david santiago

01:32:02.921 --> 01:32:05.491
sacramento kind of california
home schooled data six strongly

01:32:07.194 --> 01:32:09.261
oppose this bill.
Aurora from sacramento

01:32:10.430 --> 01:32:12.430
california mother of six and we

01:32:12.499 --> 01:32:14.499
strongly oppose this bill.

01:32:14.534 --> 01:32:17.100
Hello session davis from elk
grove I strongly oppose this

01:32:17.971 --> 01:32:20.939
bill I was home schooled myself
and went on to receive my

01:32:21.908 --> 01:32:24.876
masters of social work at sex
state.
I think it's a government

01:32:25.211 --> 01:32:27.211
overreach annecy con thank you

01:32:27.413 --> 01:32:29.581
thank you thank you.
Nathan davis from elk grove

01:32:30.810 --> 01:32:32.810
california.

01:32:33.619 --> 01:32:36.221
Strongly oppose this bill.
Infrastructure I do think that.

01:32:36.489 --> 01:32:38.624
My name's molinos lost a purses
from santa ana california I've

01:32:38.624 --> 01:32:40.624
been home schooled my whole

01:32:40.626 --> 01:32:43.360
seventeen years I strongly
oppose this bill as amended.

01:32:43.961 --> 01:32:45.961
My name's tallulah to purchase

01:32:46.397 --> 01:32:49.167
and and the home school student.
And I strongly oppose this bill.

01:32:49.635 --> 01:32:52.136
My name's casey to persist from
orange county california home

01:32:52.804 --> 01:32:54.972
school mother of four and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:32:56.541 --> 01:32:59.109
amended thank you.
I'm julie obviously.

01:32:59.911 --> 01:33:02.460
San juan capistrano and I
strongly oppose this bill

01:33:03.348 --> 01:33:06.216
amended.
My name is jennifer.
Section I'm from san juan

01:33:07.218 --> 01:33:09.953
capistrano and I strongly oppose
this bill as amended.

01:33:10.421 --> 01:33:13.122
My aim is to annual jorgensen
I'm from walkie california and I

01:33:14.726 --> 01:33:17.328
strongly oppose this bill.
I'm sure I'll and I've heard of

01:33:17.328 --> 01:33:19.262
this.
My name is lee line jorgenson

01:33:19.764 --> 01:33:22.532
I'm the unlikely home schooler
with degrees from cal duke and

01:33:23.567 --> 01:33:25.567
pan and I strongly oppose this

01:33:26.904 --> 01:33:29.305
bill. As amended.
My name's heather green crews

01:33:29.673 --> 01:33:32.543
and I have a master's degree in
education I'm a california

01:33:32.543 --> 01:33:35.511
credentialed teacher for high
school aye for home school kids

01:33:35.646 --> 01:33:38.548
and I direct a coop of
homeschool moms and I strongly

01:33:39.416 --> 01:33:41.716
oppose this bill as amended.
Hello my name is similar over

01:33:42.452 --> 01:33:45.421
from california I strongly
oppose this bill as amended.

01:33:45.989 --> 01:33:47.989
Laney hello my name is have the

01:33:48.458 --> 01:33:50.426
gas guy from I would california
and they home school sixth grade

01:33:51.261 --> 01:33:53.561
and I strongly oppose this lies
in making.

01:33:54.130 --> 01:33:57.320
Hello my name is sean sousa I am.
Seventh grade home schooler

01:33:58.134 --> 01:34:00.134
from brown california and I

01:34:00.169 --> 01:34:02.169
strongly opposes bills amended.

01:34:03.500 --> 01:34:05.173
Hi my name is qila sky I. A home
schooler from graham would have

01:34:05.975 --> 01:34:08.675
eighth grade at and I strongly
oppose this billas amended.

01:34:09.477 --> 01:34:11.579
Hi my name is katie since I am
home schooled fifth grader for

01:34:11.879 --> 01:34:13.879
it would californian I strongly

01:34:14.183 --> 01:34:16.885
oppose this bill.
Hi my name is an arabian from

01:34:17.853 --> 01:34:19.853
granite bay california and I'm a

01:34:20.890 --> 01:34:22.256
home educator graduated from uc
davis and I strongly oppose this

01:34:23.625 --> 01:34:25.660
bill amended.
Hi my name is katie most

01:34:25.894 --> 01:34:28.529
nineteen from cameraria and I
home school for children and we

01:34:29.898 --> 01:34:32.398
strongly oppose this bill.
Hi my name is joey moose and I

01:34:37.172 --> 01:34:39.873
strongly oppose this bill.
Hi my name is isaac motion I

01:34:41.910 --> 01:34:43.910
strongly opposed to spill.

01:34:44.179 --> 01:34:46.179
I mean this I ness and strongly

01:34:46.981 --> 01:34:49.314
opposed.
Hello my name is rebecca newson

01:34:49.916 --> 01:34:52.486
from san jose california I'm a
home educator and musician and I

01:34:53.654 --> 01:34:56.389
strongly oppose this bill.
Hi my name is alex mission I and

01:34:58.693 --> 01:35:01.227
I oppose this bill.
My name is jacob notion and I

01:35:03.531 --> 01:35:05.531
oppose this bill.

01:35:06.467 --> 01:35:09.302
My name is malcolm militant nam
persist.
Hi my name is becky henry I'm a

01:35:09.470 --> 01:35:11.636
homeschool mom of four from
sutter creek and I oppose this

01:35:12.673 --> 01:35:15.341
bill as amended.
My name is owing henry and I

01:35:15.874 --> 01:35:18.411
oppose this bill cemented.
Hello my name is ella henry a

01:35:18.812 --> 01:35:21.447
ninth grader I mean nights great
home schooler and I oppose this

01:35:24.417 --> 01:35:26.417
bill as amended.

01:35:29.122 --> 01:35:32.240
Few. And I am home schooled.
Does this bill.

01:35:32.759 --> 01:35:34.893
I'm so he back then and I oppose
this bill as amended.

01:35:35.610 --> 01:35:37.595
I'm claire brocklin high
schooler and I'm home schooled

01:35:37.595 --> 01:35:40.399
and aye opposed this bill as
amended.

01:35:41.334 --> 01:35:43.368
Hi my name is script mcqueen I
strongly opposes.

01:35:43.635 --> 01:35:45.937
Hi myname's jennifer murphy and
from back of all california and

01:35:46.505 --> 01:35:48.606
cofounder of iron home school
academy and one of the four

01:35:48.941 --> 01:35:50.941
members and I strongly oppose

01:35:51.544 --> 01:35:54.780
this bill as amended.
High and just sired that and I

01:35:54.179 --> 01:35:56.179
strongly oppose this bill as

01:35:56.281 --> 01:35:59.830
amended.
My name's natalie arnett I'm

01:35:59.718 --> 01:36:02.653
from san luis obispo county I
represent slow home schoolers

01:36:03.754 --> 01:36:05.754
and I strongly oppose this bill

01:36:06.158 --> 01:36:08.459
as amended thank you.
My name is james hill and I

01:36:09.270 --> 01:36:11.662
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is daniel hill it

01:36:12.898 --> 01:36:15.666
california. Teacher and a home
schooler and I strongly oppose

01:36:16.633 --> 01:36:19.340
this bill as amended.
My name is caitlyn hell eight

01:36:19.971 --> 01:36:22.239
screen from the health pro
californians strongly opposes

01:36:22.774 --> 01:36:25.742
amended.
My name is castella promoting

01:36:26.210 --> 01:36:28.210
california and I strongly oppose

01:36:28.511 --> 01:36:31.348
this bill. My name is caitlyn to
selling I strongly oppose this

01:36:32.490 --> 01:36:34.417
bill. My name is larissa passed
down from both the california

01:36:34.885 --> 01:36:36.885
strong oppose this bill. Famous

01:36:37.922 --> 01:36:40.256
meghan of elk grove california
and I strongly oppose this bill.

01:36:41.458 --> 01:36:43.458
I'm carry beauchamp from folsom

01:36:43.527 --> 01:36:45.527
california. And a home educator

01:36:45.562 --> 01:36:47.562
with classical conversations and

01:36:47.865 --> 01:36:50.600
I oppose this bill as amended.
Like my name is david dunn chain

01:36:52.536 --> 01:36:54.536
cho. I'm a home schooler.

01:36:56.440 --> 01:36:58.641
In a strongly opposed his bill.
My name is josh what though

01:37:00.543 --> 01:37:02.478
typical that opposed his bill.
My name is even done shingo from

01:37:02.646 --> 01:37:04.646
citrus heights and I strongly

01:37:04.647 --> 01:37:06.914
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is audrey buyers from

01:37:07.349 --> 01:37:10.850
lincoln california and I
strongly oppose this bill as
amended.

01:37:11.287 --> 01:37:14.890
Hello my name is eating curtis
and I strongly oppose this bill

01:37:15.580 --> 01:37:17.325
as amended. Hello my name is
christine curtis a credential

01:37:17.527 --> 01:37:20.328
california teacher and a
homeschool mom of three and I

01:37:22.300 --> 01:37:24.366
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is kelly webster I'm a

01:37:25.267 --> 01:37:26.868
homeschool mom of three and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:37:30.239 --> 01:37:32.239
amended.

01:37:33.275 --> 01:37:35.275
Our purpose.

01:37:36.245 --> 01:37:38.646
My name is.
The nimitz eliana fish year

01:37:39.348 --> 01:37:41.782
oppose.
My name is geral in fisher I'm

01:37:42.549 --> 01:37:44.549
from citrus heights and I have

01:37:46.795 --> 01:37:47.962
for strides children that I home
school myself and I strongly

01:37:50.225 --> 01:37:52.926
oppose this bill as amended.
Hello my name is lydia shuts off

01:37:53.461 --> 01:37:55.461
and I'm a homeschool mom of two

01:37:55.697 --> 01:37:57.697
from sacramento and I strongly

01:37:58.967 --> 01:38:01.134
oppose this bill as amended.
Good afternoon and julie jones

01:38:02.680 --> 01:38:04.604
and I oppose.
My name is wendy jones and I

01:38:10.745 --> 01:38:13.111
strongly oppose this bill.
Hi my name is matthew suzuki in

01:38:13.481 --> 01:38:16.316
I'm a home schooler from concord
california and I vehemently

01:38:19.420 --> 01:38:21.420
oppose this bill.

01:38:21.922 --> 01:38:23.922
my name is l. C. Jones and I

01:38:24.491 --> 01:38:26.791
oppose.
Hello my name is maria peterson

01:38:27.527 --> 01:38:29.495
from concord california and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:38:30.290 --> 01:38:32.732
amended.
Hi I'm cindy herman from concord

01:38:32.933 --> 01:38:34.933
I'm a homeschool mom of four

01:38:35.635 --> 01:38:38.269
kids and I oppose.
Hi elizabeth herman.

01:38:38.738 --> 01:38:41.306
I've been home schooled for
almost ten years and I strongly

01:38:41.306 --> 01:38:43.306
upon this oppose this bill as

01:38:43.643 --> 01:38:46.310
amended.
Heinz chili caro from anya

01:38:47.614 --> 01:38:50.582
california and I strongly oppose
this bill has mind.

01:38:50.817 --> 01:38:52.817
Hello my name is samantha

01:38:53.585 --> 01:38:55.585
caroline from antioch california.

01:38:55.821 --> 01:38:58.156
I am a homeschooling eleventh
grader and I oppose this bill as

01:38:59.925 --> 01:39:02.328
amended.
Hi I am mentioning that carol

01:39:02.328 --> 01:39:04.963
and I oppose this bill as
amended.

01:39:06.131 --> 01:39:09.330
How name my name is lisa y.
Learned I'm from union city? And

01:39:09.467 --> 01:39:12.170
I strongly oppose this bill as
amended.

01:39:12.437 --> 01:39:14.437
My name is jonathan weiland and

01:39:14.673 --> 01:39:17.375
I oppose this bill.
My name is joanna while
internationally oppose this bill

01:39:19.244 --> 01:39:21.779
is meant.
My name is dave weiland

01:39:22.981 --> 01:39:25.516
applications engineer.
I strongly oppose the bill.

01:39:28.686 --> 01:39:30.986
Very very much so.
Hi my name is sarah gorlin and I

01:39:32.560 --> 01:39:34.223
strongly opposes.
Hi my name is recount for when

01:39:34.259 --> 01:39:36.893
I'm from oakley california I
oppose this bill.

01:39:37.950 --> 01:39:39.496
My name is michael moore I
listen I strongly oppose this

01:39:40.298 --> 01:39:42.432
bill as amended.
Many major bottom row center

01:39:42.733 --> 01:39:44.733
strongly oppose this bill as

01:39:45.169 --> 01:39:47.370
amended. My name is fast rallies
from late that california's san

01:39:48.406 --> 01:39:51.241
joaquin county and I strongly
oppose this bill as amended.

01:39:52.900 --> 01:39:54.900
My name's status I gonzalez I am

01:39:54.143 --> 01:39:56.713
from rates up and I strongly
oppose this bill as amended.

01:39:57.848 --> 01:39:59.848
My name is isabel and they

01:40:03.854 --> 01:40:05.854
shrunk the. M.. En masse gate.

01:40:06.490 --> 01:40:08.725
Shall we oppose this bill as a
member.
My name's carrying gravity home

01:40:08.725 --> 01:40:11.600
school three kids from break
california and I strongly oppose

01:40:12.262 --> 01:40:14.862
this bill as amended.
My neighbor is kiley gravel I

01:40:15.999 --> 01:40:18.400
strongly oppose this bill as
amended. Minimis jesse cara from

01:40:19.569 --> 01:40:21.837
anya california I home school my
eight children and I strongly

01:40:22.205 --> 01:40:24.205
oppose the stuff.

01:40:24.574 --> 01:40:26.141
Cristina parker from sacramento
and I oppose this bill as

01:40:27.942 --> 01:40:29.942
amended.

01:40:30.413 --> 01:40:32.581
I mean that. Does and I strongly
opposes doesn't mind.

01:40:33.820 --> 01:40:35.216
My name is ali scully and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:40:35.551 --> 01:40:37.619
amended.
My name is charity I'm a

01:40:37.753 --> 01:40:39.989
homeschool mom of four from
placentia california and they

01:40:39.989 --> 01:40:41.989
strongly oppose this bill as

01:40:44.250 --> 01:40:46.494
amended.
Hi my name is natalie via from

01:40:47.696 --> 01:40:49.297
fontana california and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:40:50.264 --> 01:40:52.264
amended.

01:40:52.466 --> 01:40:54.466
When it is dan kay's father

01:40:54.636 --> 01:40:56.237
homeschool parent of three young
men that'll stand before you

01:40:56.638 --> 01:40:58.572
today.
San jose resident physician

01:40:59.207 --> 01:41:01.207
announcer.

01:41:01.309 --> 01:41:03.943
I strongly oppose it no.
Lara run uk's san jose

01:41:05.213 --> 01:41:07.213
california home schooling mother

01:41:07.715 --> 01:41:09.982
of three one graduate files to
represent a path private school

01:41:10.952 --> 01:41:13.860
satellite program review sending
fifty families and a hundred and
fifty

01:41:13.688 --> 01:41:15.688
students. We all strongly oppose

01:41:16.290 --> 01:41:19.224
this bill.
My name is andrew kay's proud

01:41:20.590 --> 01:41:21.660
homeschool graduate and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:41:23.297 --> 01:41:25.297
amended.

01:41:25.299 --> 01:41:28.134
I as I said grass and I strongly
oppose this guy's amended.

01:41:28.335 --> 01:41:30.571
My name is max located some home
schooler from san jose and I

01:41:30.571 --> 01:41:32.571
strongly oppose this bill is a

01:41:33.173 --> 01:41:35.540
man.
I never school referrers and I.

01:41:37.110 --> 01:41:39.445
Oppose this bill.
My name's crap to lassen I

01:41:43.683 --> 01:41:46.184
strongly oppose a spell.
My name is stephanie press from

01:41:47.154 --> 01:41:49.154
to macula california mother of

01:41:49.456 --> 01:41:51.590
nine currently homeschooling six
home schooling for nineteen

01:41:51.858 --> 01:41:53.858
years and I strongly oppose this

01:41:56.290 --> 01:41:58.764
bill.
Hello my name is doctor about it

01:42:00.333 --> 01:42:03.680
and I oppose this bill.
Hello my name is eva braun and

01:42:04.203 --> 01:42:07.172
from an amazing home school I
strongly oppose this bill.

01:42:08.641 --> 01:42:10.641
Tracy brown any up california.

01:42:10.710 --> 01:42:12.710
And aye oppose and rebuke this

01:42:14.847 --> 01:42:17.415
bill in jesus name.
My name is genocide mariposas

01:42:17.917 --> 01:42:20.518
feel.
My name is nick hearing now so

01:42:21.920 --> 01:42:23.920
and I oppose this bill. My name

01:42:25.190 --> 01:42:27.558
is running the nurse now and I
found me a person spell. My name

01:42:27.926 --> 01:42:29.926
is holly salas are in the home

01:42:30.395 --> 01:42:33.262
school of three and I strongly
oppose this bill.
My name is pedro awesome from

01:42:33.265 --> 01:42:35.265
oakley california and I oppose

01:42:36.568 --> 01:42:38.568
this bill.

01:42:39.971 --> 01:42:41.971
Various press serious.

01:42:43.140 --> 01:42:45.776
An alien america leann and
pleases still.

01:42:46.576 --> 01:42:49.546
My name is joyce hinkle and
purple sam and I felt to spell.

01:42:49.647 --> 01:42:52.249
My name is leah goslin I live in
hercules california I home

01:42:54.318 --> 01:42:56.318
educate two boys and I strongly

01:42:56.320 --> 01:42:58.320
oppose this bill as amended.

01:42:59.222 --> 01:43:01.222
Hello I am children osborne and

01:43:01.692 --> 01:43:04.259
I oppose this bill.
Hello I am isabel osborne in the

01:43:04.328 --> 01:43:07.163
home schooler nay opposes those
amended.

01:43:07.398 --> 01:43:10.333
I am during osborne from el
cerrito I homeschool three

01:43:11.100 --> 01:43:13.836
wonderful children if we oppose
this bill as amended.

01:43:14.336 --> 01:43:16.806
Hi my name is the mosque board I
oppose to oppose this bill

01:43:18.508 --> 01:43:20.508
amended.

01:43:20.744 --> 01:43:22.744
Hi I am a chechen del and I

01:43:23.513 --> 01:43:26.282
oppose this bill as amended.
Hi my name think the machine no

01:43:26.483 --> 01:43:28.483
and I'm home indicator to

01:43:28.485 --> 01:43:30.485
children and I strongly oppose

01:43:30.854 --> 01:43:33.880
this amended.
My name is elliot xin no I'm a

01:43:33.655 --> 01:43:36.291
home schooler and I strongly
oppose this bill as amended.

01:43:37.459 --> 01:43:39.328
My name is serenity and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:43:40.530 --> 01:43:43.131
amended. Names paxton
regulations bear.

01:43:43.132 --> 01:43:45.267
I'm serious when of anyone
california and I oppose this

01:43:46.269 --> 01:43:48.236
bill as amended.
My name is ricky hernandez aye

01:43:49.400 --> 01:43:51.207
oppose this bill.
I am jeremias when and I

01:43:51.207 --> 01:43:54.108
strongly oppose this bill as
amended.

01:43:54.743 --> 01:43:57.612
My name is paul of ontario I
oppose this bill as amended.

01:43:58.614 --> 01:44:00.648
My name is john eisenhower on a
private home school and I

01:44:02.851 --> 01:44:05.553
strongly purchase go.
Hi my name is kim eyes nam a

01:44:06.521 --> 01:44:09.490
small business owner I represent
valley home educators nine

01:44:09.591 --> 01:44:12.159
hundred families in modesto
california we opposed strongly

01:44:14.729 --> 01:44:16.964
this bill.
My name is let me commence from

01:44:17.365 --> 01:44:19.433
san is a california homeschool
much of three with one in

01:44:19.968 --> 01:44:21.968
college and I strongly oppose

01:44:21.970 --> 01:44:24.438
this bill as amended.
my name is christian men's I'm a

01:44:24.807 --> 01:44:27.140
home schooler I am from san jose
california and I strongly oppose

01:44:28.876 --> 01:44:31.344
this bill.
My name is a muscle she a come

01:44:32.790 --> 01:44:34.790
from south san jose and I

01:44:34.582 --> 01:44:36.582
strongly opposed bill is a main.

01:44:36.784 --> 01:44:39.170
Highway me with iran I strongly
oppose the bill.

01:44:39.353 --> 01:44:41.955
Hi my name is jasmine the jag
come from.

01:44:43.256 --> 01:44:46.920
Senate a californian I strongly
oppose this bill.

01:44:47.127 --> 01:44:49.929
Hi my name is elise preschooler
him from south central is a and

01:44:50.832 --> 01:44:53.650
a home schooler a homeschool mom
of two and I strongly oppose

01:44:53.500 --> 01:44:56.235
this bill.
Hi my name is kira urban of

01:44:56.871 --> 01:44:59.472
davis california home schooler
three kids one grown and I

01:44:59.539 --> 01:45:01.539
strongly oppose this bill as

01:45:05.577 --> 01:45:08.412
amended.
Hi my name is kevin shea I am

01:45:09.549 --> 01:45:12.510
from menlo park california home
school parent of two and I

01:45:12.510 --> 01:45:14.510
strongly oppose this bill as

01:45:15.688 --> 01:45:18.523
amended.
Hi my name is calling.

01:45:18.558 --> 01:45:21.426
And her own school from menlo
park california and I strongly

01:45:23.562 --> 01:45:26.264
oppose this bill.
Hi my name is beth do black eye

01:45:26.599 --> 01:45:29.330
from sacramento and the nurse
practitioner and a mandated

01:45:29.902 --> 01:45:32.335
reporter. I'm a homeschooling
mother for twelve years and I

01:45:32.404 --> 01:45:34.404
oppose this bill thank you for

01:45:34.506 --> 01:45:36.506
having us.

01:45:36.809 --> 01:45:38.809
My name is still you blah. And I

01:45:39.110 --> 01:45:41.479
am a home schooler I am a proud
eleven year olds home schooler.

01:45:42.681 --> 01:45:44.681
And I'm learning a lot today.

01:45:49.219 --> 01:45:51.587
And I strongly oppose this bill.
My name is rebecca rosenheim

01:45:52.887 --> 01:45:54.887
from los gatos california I home

01:45:55.425 --> 01:45:57.425
school to. Children sixteen and

01:45:57.760 --> 01:45:59.760
nine and I strongly oppose this

01:46:00.830 --> 01:46:03.730
bill as amended.
My name is amy reader from the

01:46:04.500 --> 01:46:06.500
council california.

01:46:07.403 --> 01:46:09.403
And a.

01:46:09.438 --> 01:46:11.873
I have seven children. Have been
homeschooling from the beginning

01:46:12.341 --> 01:46:14.341
and I strongly oppose this bill

01:46:14.476 --> 01:46:16.878
as amended.
My name is wendy dahle I'm from

01:46:17.980 --> 01:46:20.615
fremont california I'm home.
Mother and I strongly oppose

01:46:22.751 --> 01:46:25.286
this bill in any form whatsoever.
My name is devon ryan dog and I

01:46:26.988 --> 01:46:29.223
pose this bill.
When sam gloria and home school

01:46:29.457 --> 01:46:31.659
and I oppose this bill.
My name is jennifer corbitt I'm

01:46:32.160 --> 01:46:34.160
a massive public really a public

01:46:34.629 --> 01:46:36.629
affairs and I'm a home schooler.

01:46:36.998 --> 01:46:39.800
And I oppose this bill.
Hi my name's tammy oil la I'm a

01:46:40.535 --> 01:46:43.437
former public educator and I
strongly oppose this bill.

01:46:44.605 --> 01:46:47.374
Hymenium it's interface and I
strongly oppose this bet.

01:46:47.508 --> 01:46:50.208
Hi my name is amber mustn't I
strongly oppose this bill in any

01:46:50.778 --> 01:46:53.480
form with think you hi my name
is michael horan speak and I

01:46:53.981 --> 01:46:55.981
oppose the spell.

01:46:56.784 --> 01:46:58.784
Vannatter.

01:46:59.860 --> 01:47:01.354
Opposes them.
My name is as erotic and I

01:47:01.922 --> 01:47:04.223
oppose the spell.
My name is piper planet nine the

01:47:05.526 --> 01:47:07.560
home school and aye opposed a
spell.

01:47:07.828 --> 01:47:10.296
My name is christina bretton I'm
a small business owner and I

01:47:11.598 --> 01:47:14.133
oppose this bill.
My name is linda sappington I'm

01:47:14.366 --> 01:47:17.102
a home schooler in san leandro
california and I oppose this

01:47:18.170 --> 01:47:20.706
bill. As amended.
Hello my name is son nicholas

01:47:22.342 --> 01:47:24.342
sappington. And I'm a home

01:47:24.377 --> 01:47:26.377
school student from san leandro

01:47:27.130 --> 01:47:29.130
california and aye opposed to

01:47:30.316 --> 01:47:32.751
spelman.
And salinas sappington I'm a

01:47:33.653 --> 01:47:36.454
home school student I'm from san
leandro california and I oppose

01:47:37.590 --> 01:47:39.590
this bill as amended.

01:47:39.658 --> 01:47:41.658
Am I so I ever other and.

01:47:42.394 --> 01:47:44.394
I'm a home school student and I

01:47:45.898 --> 01:47:48.990
oppose this bill as amended.
I mean six rather auto and the

01:47:48.701 --> 01:47:50.701
home school student from here in

01:47:51.703 --> 01:47:53.703
california. Ipod poses bill as

01:47:54.573 --> 01:47:56.908
amended.
Hello my name is autumn as that

01:47:57.642 --> 01:48:00.209
I though and I am I home school
parent. I.

01:48:00.946 --> 01:48:03.814
Working health information
specialist and I oppose this

01:48:04.516 --> 01:48:07.418
bill as amended.
Hello my name is melissa noll I

01:48:07.852 --> 01:48:10.521
from castro valley california
and I oppose this bill as

01:48:11.888 --> 01:48:13.888
amended. Mimi scaring spring

01:48:15.193 --> 01:48:17.895
anthem sound into and strongly
oppose this bill.

01:48:17.895 --> 01:48:20.797
My name is always bringing from
san lorenzo and I strongly

01:48:21.699 --> 01:48:23.765
oppose this bill as amended. My
name is does a springer from

01:48:24.435 --> 01:48:26.536
somewhere and so and I represent
the da vinci home school group a

01:48:28.339 --> 01:48:30.974
seventy three families and I
strongly oppose this bill as
amended.

01:48:31.876 --> 01:48:34.544
And kristin rushes off I'm from
south fremont and I strongly

01:48:37.181 --> 01:48:39.647
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is pat many nagraj from

01:48:39.917 --> 01:48:41.917
castro valley I strongly oppose

01:48:42.419 --> 01:48:44.253
this bill.
My name is sarah mayes from

01:48:45.550 --> 01:48:47.857
modesto california and I have
three children and we strongly

01:48:52.280 --> 01:48:54.664
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is jan I think the one I

01:48:54.664 --> 01:48:56.664
think good and I live in

01:48:56.965 --> 01:48:58.965
waterford and I oppose this bill.

01:49:13.149 --> 01:49:14.382
Flights
.

01:49:15.584 --> 01:49:17.986
Good afternoon I'm got school
and I'm home schooled student

01:49:19.555 --> 01:49:21.623
student the saratoga california
and I oppose this bill as

01:49:22.691 --> 01:49:24.691
amended.

01:49:25.160 --> 01:49:27.160
Good our afternoon.

01:49:27.262 --> 01:49:29.262
i am federal lands I love home

01:49:29.932 --> 01:49:32.800
schooling and I strongly oppose
this bill asthma and.

01:49:33.350 --> 01:49:35.469
My name is aaron roland I'm
homeschooling mother from

01:49:36.371 --> 01:49:38.371
saratoga california and I pose

01:49:38.540 --> 01:49:40.540
this bill as amended.

01:49:41.409 --> 01:49:43.711
Hello my name is evelyn rule and
I home school in saratoga

01:49:48.383 --> 01:49:50.383
california. And strongly.

01:49:52.353 --> 01:49:54.353
Oppose this bill as amended.

01:49:54.489 --> 01:49:56.857
I meander ferris some land of
from lancaster california am a

01:49:58.793 --> 01:50:01.560
degreed r. F. Engineer I was
home schooled and I oppose this
bill.

01:50:02.630 --> 01:50:04.630
I'm safety ferris from lancaster

01:50:04.465 --> 01:50:06.533
california and I stay home mom
of one who has a future home

01:50:06.667 --> 01:50:09.601
school mom and I oppose this
bill.

01:50:10.471 --> 01:50:13.306
My name is dana hartley and I am
from the poem california and I

01:50:14.740 --> 01:50:16.740
strongly oppose this bill.

01:50:16.743 --> 01:50:18.743
Hi my name is elizabeth hurley

01:50:21.548 --> 01:50:23.717
and I. Am not perfect.
Various.

01:50:23.717 --> 01:50:25.717
My name is rachelle hartley and

01:50:26.718 --> 01:50:29.388
I oppose this bill as amended.
Hi my name is sarah stearman

01:50:30.190 --> 01:50:33.158
from martinez california. And
that's my son mike esterman and

01:50:33.358 --> 01:50:35.358
we strongly oppose this bill as

01:50:35.995 --> 01:50:38.162
amended thank you.
My name is rick array goes and

01:50:38.563 --> 01:50:41.300
I'm from merced california and I
oppose this bill.

01:50:41.800 --> 01:50:43.435
I my name is oliver little
sanchez and I strongly oppose

01:50:44.337 --> 01:50:46.638
this bill.
My name is doctor nautical had

01:50:47.306 --> 01:50:49.507
three licensed psychologist I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:50:49.942 --> 01:50:52.642
amended.
My name is regina nelson I'm

01:50:53.345 --> 01:50:55.345
from carmichael california.

01:50:55.414 --> 01:50:57.280
And I strongly oppose this bill
I represent.

01:50:57.616 --> 01:51:00.351
Christian home schoolers of the
foothills and probably about

01:51:03.222 --> 01:51:06.190
fifty families think you.
My name is gordon I'm a home

01:51:06.357 --> 01:51:08.357
schooler from petaluma

01:51:08.694 --> 01:51:10.694
california and I strongly oppose

01:51:11.530 --> 01:51:13.530
this bill claiming the saqlain.

01:51:13.899 --> 01:51:15.899
I am from the hubble california.

01:51:16.301 --> 01:51:19.360
I am a home school student and I
oppose this.

01:51:19.738 --> 01:51:21.738
They'll ask me.

01:51:22.307 --> 01:51:24.307
Hi my name is madison ryan and I

01:51:25.842 --> 01:51:27.842
oppose his bill as amended.

01:51:28.878 --> 01:51:31.615
Hi my name is look cryin I'm
from harper california. Claiming

01:51:32.683 --> 01:51:35.585
home school student and I oppose
his bill as amend.

01:51:35.987 --> 01:51:38.688
My name is lauren ryan I'm from
la habra california I am home

01:51:39.322 --> 01:51:41.322
school mom of four and I oppose

01:51:41.725 --> 01:51:43.726
this bill as amended.
How many with and you via and I

01:51:44.528 --> 01:51:46.996
am from la habra california home
school student and I oppose the

01:51:48.766 --> 01:51:50.867
bill as amended?
My name is timothy beall im from

01:51:51.668 --> 01:51:54.170
la jolla california retired
union electricians. And I'll

01:51:54.571 --> 01:51:57.406
homeschool grandpa. I
respectfully and.

01:51:57.639 --> 01:52:00.309
Strongly oppose the bill as
amended thank you. Primicia

01:52:00.343 --> 01:52:03.770
adrin I'm from bellflower
california and they strongly

01:52:04.790 --> 01:52:06.790
oppose this bill.

01:52:10.687 --> 01:52:12.687
An initiation adrin I come from I'm thomas lincoln.

01:52:13.189 --> 01:52:15.324
From norwalk california I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:52:21.430 --> 01:52:23.231
amended.
I'm can really contrast like in

01:52:23.766 --> 01:52:25.367
norwalk california and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:52:26.535 --> 01:52:29.137
amended.
I am I worth a from foundation

01:52:30.673 --> 01:52:32.673
christian school and aye poses

01:52:34.777 --> 01:52:37.378
bras amended. I'm isaiah work
the and.

01:52:38.747 --> 01:52:40.747
I'm a student from foundation

01:52:42.284 --> 01:52:44.284
christian school I oppose this

01:52:46.421 --> 01:52:48.989
bill as amended.
I am as a out or tax and I'm

01:52:50.125 --> 01:52:52.893
from fund asian christian school
and I oppose this bill as

01:52:54.563 --> 01:52:56.931
amended.
My name is danielle worth that

01:52:56.931 --> 01:52:59.799
from foundation christian school
and what you're california and I
strongly oppose the spell as

01:53:01.936 --> 01:53:03.936
amended.

01:53:12.460 --> 01:53:14.281
And my name is medi salah morale is
I am a. Biomedical mechanical

01:53:14.849 --> 01:53:17.450
engineer by professional I am a
media publisher and a homeschool

01:53:18.352 --> 01:53:20.352
mom and I oppose this bill as

01:53:21.922 --> 01:53:24.290
amended.
My name is deborah wallace I'm a

01:53:24.992 --> 01:53:27.527
homeschool mom through a charter
school in I oppose this bill as

01:53:32.899 --> 01:53:34.899
amended.

01:53:35.369 --> 01:53:37.369
I am kim email an from castro

01:53:37.836 --> 01:53:39.836
valley in a oppose this bill.

01:53:41.975 --> 01:53:44.109
I am alex. So. I am home school
student I strongly oppose this

01:53:49.582 --> 01:53:51.582
bill.

01:53:52.485 --> 01:53:55.287
And you marry.
Lara.

01:53:55.754 --> 01:53:57.656
I persist para.
I'm carolyn melon I am a home

01:53:58.124 --> 01:54:00.124
school educator and I strongly

01:54:00.493 --> 01:54:02.493
oppose this bill as amended.

01:54:03.194 --> 01:54:05.194
For passed rally behind my name

01:54:08.320 --> 01:54:10.669
is skinner owns and I am a
homeschooling aye opposed.

01:54:10.669 --> 01:54:12.570
I am amy ends from hayward
california I'm a home school

01:54:14.600 --> 01:54:16.600
educator and I oppose this bill.

01:54:17.875 --> 01:54:19.979
And county marion and I strongly
oppose them.

01:54:22.112 --> 01:54:24.548
I.
Hummus gotta noni I am a

01:54:26.485 --> 01:54:29.190
registered nurse by profession
aye we home school gets.

01:54:30.880 --> 01:54:32.880
And from castro valley interview

01:54:32.524 --> 01:54:35.459
not strongly opposes bill.
Hi I'm said bashed me and no

01:54:38.795 --> 01:54:40.795
money. And I strongly at. A

01:54:41.466 --> 01:54:43.466
pound this bill.

01:54:43.768 --> 01:54:46.403
I am lady and noni I home school
for kids and I strongly oppose

01:54:48.105 --> 01:54:50.740
this bill.
High and mighty sela monday on
is from bakersfield california

01:54:55.711 --> 01:54:57.711
and I strongly oppose this bill.

01:54:59.115 --> 01:55:01.984
I posted it via the.
Hi I my cell our piece from

01:55:03.654 --> 01:55:05.654
bakers fail and I oppose this

01:55:06.789 --> 01:55:08.590
bill.
I am cindy mcclatchy.

01:55:09.591 --> 01:55:11.827
From hayward california we are
private home school and the

01:55:12.896 --> 01:55:14.896
homeschool graduate and I oppose

01:55:18.368 --> 01:55:20.536
this bill as amended.
My name is as in riviera maya

01:55:20.737 --> 01:55:23.172
homeschooled I school from
sacramento california and I

01:55:25.508 --> 01:55:27.476
strongly oppose this bill.
And as lisa to so I am a

01:55:27.644 --> 01:55:29.644
homeschooling mom here in

01:55:29.746 --> 01:55:31.746
sacramento ca california and I

01:55:32.582 --> 01:55:34.582
strongly oppose this bill.

01:55:35.117 --> 01:55:37.852
I mashed instrument toy you from
ceremony california and I

01:55:38.421 --> 01:55:41.122
strongly oppose this bill as
amended.

01:55:42.892 --> 01:55:44.892
I'm addison's steamer tell you.

01:55:45.192 --> 01:55:48.970
From san ramon and I oppose this
bill as amended.

01:55:48.970 --> 01:55:50.970
My name's aksana stem a toy you

01:55:50.431 --> 01:55:52.431
I am a home educator and aye

01:55:57.105 --> 01:55:59.974
oppose this bill as amended.
Hi I'm gethsemane does a

01:56:02.777 --> 01:56:04.178
strongly oppose this their.
Hi I nella.

01:56:07.147 --> 01:56:08.916
He.
Higher yeah then.

01:56:09.750 --> 01:56:12.319
Now.
I'm daniel mendoza and from the

01:56:12.687 --> 01:56:15.289
way her california home school
educator and I strongly oppose

01:56:16.491 --> 01:56:18.791
this bill as amended.
Hi my name is chris wong I'm

01:56:19.127 --> 01:56:21.528
from dublin california I'm a
small business owner and my wife

01:56:22.630 --> 01:56:24.830
I home school our three kids.
And I strongly oppose ab two

01:56:27.902 --> 01:56:30.537
seven five six as amended.
Hi my name is dana long I am

01:56:31.772 --> 01:56:33.772
from set and doubling california

01:56:38.645 --> 01:56:40.645
and I strongly oppose this bill.

01:56:41.381 --> 01:56:43.381
Hi my name is. Joshua center

01:56:44.510 --> 01:56:46.510
from a ceremony california.

01:56:46.985 --> 01:56:49.755
And I strongly oppose.
eight be twenty seven fifty six

01:56:51.240 --> 01:56:53.240
as amended.

01:56:53.930 --> 01:56:55.761
Hi my name is ian sarah and I
come from of san ramon

01:56:56.396 --> 01:56:58.396
california and I strongly oppose

01:56:59.632 --> 01:57:01.632
this bill as amended.

01:57:01.801 --> 01:57:03.801
Hi my name is gina santa I'm a.

01:57:05.138 --> 01:57:07.705
Educator of complicated and I
strongly oppose the bill ab.

01:57:07.705 --> 01:57:09.705
Twenty six twenty five twenty

01:57:10.108 --> 01:57:12.844
seven fifty six.
Highlighted clara had aye

01:57:13.613 --> 01:57:16.147
opposes.
Tim salado for many a california

01:57:16.147 --> 01:57:18.683
and I oppose this bill as
amended.

01:57:19.285 --> 01:57:21.686
Hi my name is sherry salado from
antioch california and I

01:57:23.489 --> 01:57:25.489
absolutely oppose this bill.

01:57:27.920 --> 01:57:29.961
Ab two seven five six.
Hello my name is enact a then

01:57:31.530 --> 01:57:33.530
mass latimes they strongly

01:57:42.306 --> 01:57:44.306
opposes building.

01:57:44.542 --> 01:57:46.509
This is just a cover line.
My name is victoria kovalainen

01:57:46.711 --> 01:57:49.613
from limits california I'm a
homeschool parent and I strongly

01:57:50.140 --> 01:57:52.140
oppose this bill as amended.

01:57:52.349 --> 01:57:54.751
Hi my name is katherine and
collect catherine cover line and

01:57:56.888 --> 01:57:59.756
I strongly oppose this bill as
amended.
I am rarely chamberlain and I

01:58:00.823 --> 01:58:03.760
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is carissa chamberlain I

01:58:05.696 --> 01:58:08.298
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is amy chamberlain and I

01:58:08.664 --> 01:58:10.664
am a home school parent and I

01:58:15.406 --> 01:58:17.373
strongly oppose this bill.
Hello my name is anarchy

01:58:18.375 --> 01:58:20.776
stockton california and I
strongly oppose this spell God

01:58:22.120 --> 01:58:24.914
bless america.
Hi my name is winifred or tease

01:58:27.170 --> 01:58:29.784
and I strongly oppose this bill.
Hi my name is alberto teeth.

01:58:33.289 --> 01:58:34.923
A mechanic and home and home
schooling father I strongly

01:58:36.960 --> 01:58:38.794
opposes ab seven.
Five to.

01:58:39.495 --> 01:58:41.462
twenty five five six.
I'm my name is katherine webb

01:58:41.898 --> 01:58:43.898
and I am a home school parents

01:58:44.967 --> 01:58:46.902
and I oppose this bill.
My name is ada web allender I am

01:58:48.303 --> 01:58:51.104
from brentwood california and I
strongly opposes bill.

01:58:52.441 --> 01:58:54.441
Hi my name is wendy web out

01:58:55.143 --> 01:58:57.143
under. I am a home school kid I

01:59:01.982 --> 01:59:03.982
strongly oppose this bill.

01:59:06.540 --> 01:59:08.540
And jamison are staggering.

01:59:09.591 --> 01:59:11.591
Yes.

01:59:11.625 --> 01:59:13.527
They're all thought I put oppose
this bill.

01:59:13.795 --> 01:59:15.429
My name is alisa ortega I'm a
home schooler and I strongly

01:59:18.665 --> 01:59:20.665
oppose this bill.

01:59:24.304 --> 01:59:27.274
And he'll be here I came. In a
strong their purchase.

01:59:29.711 --> 01:59:31.711
Hello my name is joshua had a

01:59:32.747 --> 01:59:34.681
sure May persist for.
My name is beth retainers has a

01:59:34.981 --> 01:59:37.180
california recent retired police
sergeant and I oppose this bill.

01:59:37.180 --> 01:59:39.319
My name is kelly are state
ortega homeschool mom and I
strongly oppose this bill as

01:59:40.254 --> 01:59:42.989
amended.
My name is an eagle men I am I'm
schools data and I strongly

01:59:43.357 --> 01:59:46.192
opposes.
My name is emily goldman I'm a
homeschool parent and I strongly

01:59:46.859 --> 01:59:49.296
oppose this bill. My name is
samir goodman I'm home school

01:59:49.296 --> 01:59:51.731
students and I strongly oppose
this bill.

01:59:51.832 --> 01:59:54.567
My name is lani goldman a
business lawyer from san carlos

01:59:57.671 --> 01:59:59.704
and I oppose this bill.
And then they.

02:00:01.274 --> 02:00:03.274
This bill.

02:00:03.777 --> 02:00:05.777
Hi am brandon I'm nine years old

02:00:06.778 --> 02:00:09.281
and I opposed to fill.
I and their baby from hollister

02:00:10.617 --> 02:00:12.170
california.
And.
And.

02:00:12.786 --> 02:00:15.554
.
Strongly opposes bill.

02:00:16.155 --> 02:00:18.822
my name is rebecca batey from
hollister california I was

02:00:19.625 --> 02:00:21.625
homeschooled thirty years ago.

02:00:21.627 --> 02:00:23.660
And in college graduates and I'm
a home educator and I oppose

02:00:28.801 --> 02:00:30.901
this bill.
My name is angela o. St I'm from

02:00:31.502 --> 02:00:33.705
lodi california I'm a home
educator and I strongly oppose

02:00:35.641 --> 02:00:37.641
this bill.

02:00:39.376 --> 02:00:41.376
Leann state.

02:00:41.847 --> 02:00:43.847
Yeah the of. Strongly opposes

02:00:45.217 --> 02:00:47.585
fair.
My name is todd does and I'm a

02:00:48.453 --> 02:00:50.453
correctional tenet. Out of lodi

02:01:03.868 --> 02:01:05.868
and I oppose this bill.

02:01:08.606 --> 02:01:10.907
You have namely pauses para.
My name is helen prints on a

02:01:11.809 --> 02:01:13.809
private school educator and aye

02:01:13.811 --> 02:01:15.811
opposed strongly oppose this

02:01:16.280 --> 02:01:18.681
bill a twenty something six.
My name is thomas prince and I

02:01:19.450 --> 02:01:21.450
oppose this bill.

02:01:21.852 --> 02:01:23.852
Hello my name is rebecca prince

02:01:23.988 --> 02:01:25.988
I am a home school student I

02:01:25.989 --> 02:01:28.891
ardently opposed this bill.
Hi my name is hannah prints on

02:01:29.326 --> 02:01:31.694
the home school student and I
oppose the spell.

02:01:32.950 --> 02:01:34.696
My name is a and t. Garden I'm a
home educator and I represent

02:01:37.849 --> 02:01:40.600
hard academy from san jose and I
oppose this bill as amended.

02:01:40.536 --> 02:01:42.238
Hi I'm kristin teagarden I'm a
home schooled student from santa

02:01:43.573 --> 02:01:45.573
clara and I strongly oppose this

02:01:45.842 --> 02:01:48.776
bill as amended.
Hi I'm just site you garden I am

02:01:49.578 --> 02:01:51.578
home school student and I

02:01:51.714 --> 02:01:54.415
strongly oppose this bill.
Hi my name is esther beal and

02:01:55.351 --> 02:01:58.253
from foster city california I am
a business owner at home school

02:01:59.188 --> 02:02:01.723
parent of four children and I
strongly oppose the amended bill

02:02:02.925 --> 02:02:05.560
two seven five six.
My name is sophia path this I'm

02:02:06.362 --> 02:02:08.362
a private home school student

02:02:08.364 --> 02:02:10.364
and I oppose this bill.

02:02:10.599 --> 02:02:12.599
Hi my name is david pappas and

02:02:13.369 --> 02:02:15.369
i'm. Home school students and I

02:02:15.936 --> 02:02:18.372
hope I oppose this bill.
Hello my name is christine

02:02:19.174 --> 02:02:22.760
pappas and I am a private home
school educator and I strongly

02:02:22.678 --> 02:02:25.279
oppose this bill.
My name is jonathan pappas and

02:02:25.414 --> 02:02:27.581
the private home school student
an entrepreneur and I strongly

02:02:29.251 --> 02:02:31.251
oppose this bill.

02:02:31.286 --> 02:02:33.286
Leann.

02:02:37.392 --> 02:02:40.930
I oppose this bill.
I oppose this no.

02:02:40.528 --> 02:02:43.950
And my name is michelle telford
fresno california and I oppose

02:02:44.766 --> 02:02:47.234
this bill as amended.
My name is matt about how for

02:02:49.700 --> 02:02:51.700
fresno california and I oppose

02:02:51.472 --> 02:02:53.740
this bill as amended.
My name is kristin grossman I'm

02:02:54.408 --> 02:02:57.343
a homeschool mom from danville
california and I oppose this
bill.

02:02:57.678 --> 02:03:00.213
My name is samantha cressman I'm
I'm schools today and I strongly

02:03:02.783 --> 02:03:05.510
oppose this bill.
My name is brooke nests per from

02:03:05.719 --> 02:03:07.954
the scary big california I'm a
home educator and I.

02:03:09.323 --> 02:03:11.824
Strongly oppose this bill.
My name is will learn math

02:03:12.592 --> 02:03:14.892
spirit and I strongly opposes
del.

02:03:19.899 --> 02:03:22.101
And the whole school student.
I'm a news richard death rumors

02:03:24.838 --> 02:03:26.838
go bad I oppose this bill.

02:03:26.906 --> 02:03:29.420
My name is elijah missus and I
put this bill.

02:03:29.420 --> 02:03:31.677
Hi I'm jody Miss The sin from
garden valley and.
Home school for children and we

02:03:32.879 --> 02:03:35.447
oppose this bill.
My name is london missus and I

02:03:36.883 --> 02:03:39.184
oppose this bill.
My name is erica wilcox from

02:03:40.119 --> 02:03:42.119
brentwood and I home school and

02:03:47.159 --> 02:03:49.159
I was this bill as amended.

02:03:50.796 --> 02:03:53.599
Hi. This is.
He steinorth his mere.

02:03:53.599 --> 02:03:55.601
Hi my name is bianca mayorga
from oakley california and I

02:03:55.601 --> 02:03:58.235
strongly oppose eighty twenty
seven fifty six as amended.

02:03:58.270 --> 02:04:00.570
Hi my name is sarah lean and I'm
a homeschool mom from brentwood

02:04:01.390 --> 02:04:03.841
california and I oppose this
bill as amended.

02:04:04.900 --> 02:04:06.810
My name is daniel lane from
brentwood california and I

02:04:08.146 --> 02:04:10.146
oppose this bill as amended.

02:04:10.248 --> 02:04:12.248
My name is wendy sanabria from

02:04:12.415 --> 02:04:14.415
any on california and I oppose

02:04:14.586 --> 02:04:16.586
this bill as amended.

02:04:16.955 --> 02:04:19.489
My name is my solano.
And I oppose this bill.

02:04:20.792 --> 02:04:22.792
As amended.

02:04:23.227 --> 02:04:25.227
My name is christian arena and I

02:04:25.563 --> 02:04:27.729
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is my case look from

02:04:28.632 --> 02:04:31.167
antelope california and I am we
homeschool bed.

02:04:31.235 --> 02:04:33.235
Educator and author and I

02:04:33.904 --> 02:04:36.739
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is generally hazelton I

02:04:38.108 --> 02:04:40.608
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is any price and I

02:04:41.745 --> 02:04:43.745
oppose the spell. My name is

02:04:44.548 --> 02:04:46.882
kyle price May oppose the spell.
My name is harley price nypost

02:04:47.617 --> 02:04:50.320
this bill. My name is rebecca
price I represent my husband and

02:04:50.320 --> 02:04:53.222
myself jimmy price were from
falls in california and we

02:04:54.424 --> 02:04:57.326
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is jana being men there.

02:04:58.595 --> 02:05:00.595
Ab no sling for nine years and

02:05:02.699 --> 02:05:04.833
I strongly oppose this bill.
My name is and I be even better

02:05:05.401 --> 02:05:07.436
I represent about five hundred
members of the circle of

02:05:07.637 --> 02:05:09.604
homeschoolers group and my
husband and myself my children

02:05:09.906 --> 02:05:12.274
we homeschooled for ten years
and we strongly oppose this bill

02:05:13.276 --> 02:05:15.310
as amended.
My name is jay competing manner

02:05:15.678 --> 02:05:18.790
on the home school student and
of ten years and I strongly

02:05:19.381 --> 02:05:21.381
oppose this bill as amended.

02:05:21.449 --> 02:05:23.449
My name is jc beaten bang their.

02:05:24.119 --> 02:05:26.870
i persons.
My name is linking coddling home

02:05:26.455 --> 02:05:28.589
school graduate and I strongly
oppose this bill.

02:05:28.824 --> 02:05:31.491
My name is emily flannel home
school student at ten years and

02:05:32.461 --> 02:05:34.950
I strongly oppose this bill.
Many zeke flame I oppose this

02:05:36.632 --> 02:05:38.731
bill.
My name is christina donovan the

02:05:39.434 --> 02:05:41.434
home school parent I oppose this

02:05:43.638 --> 02:05:46.473
bill as amended.
Winning is mike and beams aaron

02:05:46.807 --> 02:05:48.807
low who school student from

02:05:49.770 --> 02:05:51.845
misato. And I oppose bills
amended.

02:05:52.880 --> 02:05:54.880
My name is naomi dames on a

02:05:54.882 --> 02:05:57.150
person's del.
My name is emma being some home

02:05:58.619 --> 02:06:00.619
educators from nevada california

02:06:01.222 --> 02:06:03.230
I pose this bill as amended.
Many of his own schneider in a

02:06:03.524 --> 02:06:05.524
private home schooler I oppose

02:06:06.193 --> 02:06:08.461
this bill as amended.
My name is make schneider and I

02:06:09.697 --> 02:06:11.865
oppose this bill.
My name is helen slater I'm a

02:06:12.266 --> 02:06:14.534
credentialed teacher and home
educator and I oppose this bill

02:06:15.367 --> 02:06:17.367
as amended.

02:06:19.873 --> 02:06:22.541
When I was voter because and I.
Most of houses bill as amended.

02:06:23.377 --> 02:06:25.377
My name is phoebe her call from

02:06:25.445 --> 02:06:27.546
san rafael and home school
parent and I oppose this bill.

02:06:28.148 --> 02:06:30.148
As amended.

02:06:30.150 --> 02:06:32.818
My name is david bengal I'm from
a.

02:06:34.554 --> 02:06:37.322
Four fulsome california. And I
strongly oppose this bill.

02:06:38.124 --> 02:06:40.524
My name isesther bengal. I'm
also from full them and I

02:06:43.328 --> 02:06:45.328
strongly oppose this bill.

02:06:45.398 --> 02:06:47.398
Hi my name is he an everyman aye

02:06:49.549 --> 02:06:52.300
in the home school student and I.
Live and auburn california and I

02:06:53.706 --> 02:06:56.141
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is sarah hood and I

02:06:56.709 --> 02:06:58.309
living redding california and I
strongly oppose this bill as

02:06:59.411 --> 02:07:01.779
amended.
My name's mary beth heard and

02:07:02.114 --> 02:07:04.114
I'm from redding california home

02:07:04.683 --> 02:07:07.351
school for children and I
strongly oppose this bill as
amended.

02:07:08.654 --> 02:07:11.550
Hello my name is john hood I am
a fifth grade home school

02:07:11.823 --> 02:07:14.358
student in redding california. I
strongly oppose this bill as

02:07:14.960 --> 02:07:16.960
amended kill the bill.

02:07:18.729 --> 02:07:21.632
My hope.
My name is jones verne I am

02:07:24.200 --> 02:07:26.904
eleven years. And I am from.
Anderson californian I strongly

02:07:28.139 --> 02:07:30.941
oppose this bill as a man. Hi my
name is iris a very and nine and

02:07:32.910 --> 02:07:35.312
for many california. And I
strongly opposes the us mandate.

02:07:35.480 --> 02:07:37.714
Hi I'm jessica server earn a
represents a homeschool

02:07:38.149 --> 02:07:39.883
community of over a hundred
families culturally mason

02:07:41.552 --> 02:07:43.787
reading and we strongly oppose
this bill as amended.

02:07:44.622 --> 02:07:47.157
My name is obvious of our. And
home schooling steven I plan to

02:07:47.424 --> 02:07:49.592
keep being homeschooled so I
strongly oppose this bill as

02:07:50.394 --> 02:07:52.895
amended.
My name is elizabeth quite us I

02:07:53.931 --> 02:07:56.532
came home educator in fact bill
california and they strongly

02:07:57.901 --> 02:08:00.802
oppose this bill as amended.
Hi I'm our printer quick james

02:08:02.672 --> 02:08:04.874
kleenex and I strongly oppose
this bill as amended.

02:08:05.750 --> 02:08:07.750
Hi my name is sophia cuevas and

02:08:07.611 --> 02:08:09.611
from vacaville california and I

02:08:10.947 --> 02:08:13.215
strongly opposes bill as amended.
Fire machel ridge on

02:08:13.983 --> 02:08:16.510
homeschooling parent and I
strongly oppose this bill as

02:08:18.860 --> 02:08:20.860
amended.

02:08:21.390 --> 02:08:24.159
Hi.
By sitek. From chico california

02:08:26.696 --> 02:08:28.730
oppose this bill as amended.
Good afternoon my name is aaron

02:08:29.331 --> 02:08:32.166
hailing from west sacramento
california and I pose this bill.

02:08:32.166 --> 02:08:34.166
my name is chris hammond and I

02:08:34.802 --> 02:08:37.572
oppose the stuff.
I am does re fetch from davis

02:08:38.273 --> 02:08:40.575
california I'm a licensed
marriage and family therapists

02:08:40.909 --> 02:08:42.909
have been homeschooling for six

02:08:43.412 --> 02:08:45.913
years apart home spun. Out of
the house home schoolers in

02:08:46.181 --> 02:08:48.181
preschool at home and I oppose

02:08:48.183 --> 02:08:50.483
this bill.
Hi my name is dan hall from san

02:08:51.586 --> 02:08:53.586
jose I'm a father and home

02:08:54.550 --> 02:08:56.550
school. Educators the psp I

02:08:56.424 --> 02:08:58.424
oppose it this bill as amended.

02:08:58.626 --> 02:09:01.595
Primary hall from san jose aye
poses don't think you.

02:09:02.831 --> 02:09:04.831
I am sri vega from vallejo and I

02:09:08.690 --> 02:09:10.437
oppose this bill.
My name is rafi vega and I

02:09:12.106 --> 02:09:14.374
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is is even yeah and I'm

02:09:15.441 --> 02:09:18.243
a knife great home schooler and
I strongly oppose this bill is
meant.

02:09:18.546 --> 02:09:20.546
My name is tomasi william man

02:09:20.880 --> 02:09:22.880
and I come from sacramento ca

02:09:23.500 --> 02:09:25.500
california initially opposed

02:09:25.352 --> 02:09:27.352
this bill as amended.

02:09:28.789 --> 02:09:30.789
Finally seaman and I strongly

02:09:31.158 --> 02:09:33.158
oppose this bill has been.

02:09:33.959 --> 02:09:36.929
I teddy men and.
And.

02:09:37.831 --> 02:09:40.499
I am basing thurmond and I've of
cathcart california. And I

02:09:40.867 --> 02:09:43.536
strongly opposes.
I am amber man.

02:09:43.970 --> 02:09:46.505
And I've been homeschooling for
nine years from kemper

02:09:47.439 --> 02:09:49.439
california and I strongly oppose

02:09:50.610 --> 02:09:52.978
this bill as amended.
My name is nicole garcia from

02:09:53.413 --> 02:09:55.414
pleasant hill california and I
strongly oppose this bill as

02:09:55.815 --> 02:09:57.815
amended.

02:09:57.882 --> 02:09:59.718
My name is lucas garcia and I
strongly oppose this bill as

02:10:02.154 --> 02:10:04.889
amended.
My name's gavin garcia and I

02:10:05.624 --> 02:10:07.958
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is denise leto I'm from

02:10:08.359 --> 02:10:10.328
richmond california I've been
homeschooling educator for

02:10:10.996 --> 02:10:12.996
thirteen years and I strongly

02:10:16.680 --> 02:10:18.680
oppose this bill as amended.

02:10:18.670 --> 02:10:21.720
My name is emily in little
a staples.

02:10:22.207 --> 02:10:24.207
My name is elizabeth I'm living

02:10:24.309 --> 02:10:26.309
alameda in a strongly. Oppose

02:10:26.945 --> 02:10:29.547
this bill as amended.
My name is wendy fresh. And I

02:10:30.315 --> 02:10:32.315
strongly oppose this bill as

02:10:32.851 --> 02:10:35.718
amended. My name cleanup part
miami and park in a strongly

02:10:39.491 --> 02:10:42.920
oppose those. By.
I mean no part a strong oppose

02:10:51.435 --> 02:10:53.737
this bill as amended.
My name is.

02:10:55.206 --> 02:10:57.574
This bill as amended.
My name is holly memoriam I

02:10:58.475 --> 02:11:00.475
strongly oppose this bill.

02:11:01.110 --> 02:11:03.813
My name is blown marty and I
pushed spillways mended.

02:11:04.548 --> 02:11:06.548
My name is cash bias and I

02:11:06.817 --> 02:11:08.817
strongly oppose this bill.

02:11:10.220 --> 02:11:12.220
My name is cool bison aye. Uc.

02:11:12.556 --> 02:11:15.900
I opposed the bill.
My name is jennifer bias and

02:11:16.259 --> 02:11:18.259
from san diego california I'm a

02:11:18.695 --> 02:11:20.695
home educator and I strongly

02:11:20.996 --> 02:11:23.699
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is heidi etheridge I'm

02:11:24.134 --> 02:11:26.235
from el dorado county and I
strongly oppose this bill as

02:11:27.300 --> 02:11:29.371
amended.
My name is china etheridge I'm

02:11:29.706 --> 02:11:31.706
from outer on a county and I

02:11:33.910 --> 02:11:35.910
strongly oppose this bill.

02:11:38.614 --> 02:11:40.614
I am kathryn kern. Aye and from.

02:11:42.818 --> 02:11:44.818
For a step california in a.

02:11:44.919 --> 02:11:46.919
Aaron came home schooled in a

02:11:49.124 --> 02:11:50.792
clash the opposes spell I send
men.

02:11:51.193 --> 02:11:53.961
My name is shannon hi and I'm
from later california I've been

02:11:54.963 --> 02:11:57.665
a home educator for eight years
and I strongly oppose this bill

02:11:59.735 --> 02:12:01.969
as amended.
My name is kristin first I'm the

02:12:02.404 --> 02:12:04.572
director of our private school
we've been homeschooling for ten

02:12:04.638 --> 02:12:06.638
years and I strongly oppose this

02:12:07.274 --> 02:12:09.777
bill.
I'm my name is jessica hall and

02:12:10.477 --> 02:12:12.477
for fair oaks california and I

02:12:12.479 --> 02:12:14.513
made charter home school teacher
and I oppose this bill as

02:12:16.618 --> 02:12:18.618
amended think you.

02:12:20.353 --> 02:12:22.353
I mean this and you and. I am

02:12:23.324 --> 02:12:26.226
funding for it and. I heard this
bill.
Hi my name is elaine arnold I'm

02:12:26.993 --> 02:12:29.763
from lake forest.
And I strongly oppose this bill

02:12:30.631 --> 02:12:32.998
as amended.
My name is erica hides a I home

02:12:33.534 --> 02:12:36.340
school my four children in
contra costa county I've been a

02:12:36.303 --> 02:12:38.303
home educator for six years have

02:12:38.472 --> 02:12:40.730
maybe a liberal studies and I
strongly oppose this bill as

02:12:40.473 --> 02:12:42.473
amended.

02:12:42.509 --> 02:12:45.378
I am and like a high tech from
atlanta georgia and. Aye opposed

02:12:46.747 --> 02:12:48.747
to spell.

02:12:49.249 --> 02:12:51.516
My name is vano and enjoy home
schooling and to keep the home

02:12:53.151 --> 02:12:55.521
schooling I strongly opposes
para. My name is tom take a

02:12:56.189 --> 02:12:58.189
because they and I continue I

02:12:58.591 --> 02:13:00.591
continue to strongly oppose this

02:13:01.461 --> 02:13:04.329
bill as amended.
I noticed adrin of a guy from
some of the california I home

02:13:05.531 --> 02:13:07.531
school for my kids and I

02:13:08.301 --> 02:13:10.634
strongly oppose those with.
Hi my name is around of a gun I

02:13:11.170 --> 02:13:13.772
strongly oppose this bill
hyman's rebekah vagana strongly

02:13:15.308 --> 02:13:17.308
opposes bill. I ran a park I was

02:13:17.576 --> 02:13:20.345
home schooled the now in school
and I oppose this bill make you.

02:13:21.280 --> 02:13:23.280
Can bag well from enact.

02:13:23.649 --> 02:13:25.483
I oppose the bill as amended.
Ambush wander from valley

02:13:26.150 --> 02:13:28.150
springs california strongly

02:13:30.255 --> 02:13:32.255
oppose this bill as amended.

02:13:32.457 --> 02:13:34.457
Michelle de ocampo from san jose

02:13:34.591 --> 02:13:36.894
california I had to college
graduates and I'm home schooling

02:13:38.296 --> 02:13:40.296
my third. And I strongly oppose

02:13:41.660 --> 02:13:43.901
this bill as amended.
I am orinda matthews I am from

02:13:45.635 --> 02:13:47.638
california san jose.
And I'm in the eleventh grade

02:13:49.607 --> 02:13:51.607
and I strongly opposes.

02:13:53.544 --> 02:13:55.544
I'm jill matthews from san jose.

02:13:56.140 --> 02:13:58.248
I strongly opposes bill.
I am laurie matthews I'd been

02:13:59.183 --> 02:14:01.183
homeschooling for twenty one

02:14:01.551 --> 02:14:03.220
years and I oppose this bill.
Hi my name is there yeah.

02:14:07.525 --> 02:14:09.525
And.

02:14:10.270 --> 02:14:12.328
Outside current spent.
Hi my name is sarah y. Marin

02:14:12.730 --> 02:14:15.398
from rescue california been
homeschooling for seven years

02:14:15.866 --> 02:14:18.734
and I strongly oppose this bill
if mended.

02:14:19.703 --> 02:14:21.703
Hi my name is skinner I strongly

02:14:22.271 --> 02:14:24.472
oppose this bill as amended.
My name's emma wimer and I

02:14:26.410 --> 02:14:28.710
surely. Pillows and.
Hi my name is megan lopez a

02:14:28.710 --> 02:14:30.710
homeschooling fell last five

02:14:31.181 --> 02:14:33.748
years and I strongly oppose this
bill as amended.

02:14:35.518 --> 02:14:37.518
My name is tener lopez and I

02:14:37.552 --> 02:14:39.922
poses doesn't mandate.
My name's interlopers from

02:14:40.223 --> 02:14:42.457
martinez night oppose this bill
as amended.

02:14:43.260 --> 02:14:45.360
Hi my name is don holton I'm a
former elementary school

02:14:45.428 --> 02:14:47.529
educator in the public school
system and I have been

02:14:48.297 --> 02:14:50.831
homeschooling. My children for
the past thirteen years and I

02:14:51.534 --> 02:14:53.534
strongly oppose this bill as

02:14:53.936 --> 02:14:56.670
amended thank you.
I am juniper banks.

02:14:57.373 --> 02:14:59.373
I live in oakland california

02:14:59.542 --> 02:15:02.100
I've been home schooled for my
entire life and I strongly

02:15:03.746 --> 02:15:05.746
oppose this bill.

02:15:06.782 --> 02:15:08.782
Hi emil holton and I'm from

02:15:08.851 --> 02:15:10.851
emeryville california I strongly

02:15:10.951 --> 02:15:12.951
oppose this bill as amended.

02:15:13.987 --> 02:15:16.957
My name is slam holton and.
I shirley posts bill.

02:15:17.125 --> 02:15:19.527
Good afternoon my name is janice
taurus around us and I left my

02:15:20.262 --> 02:15:22.262
career fifteen years ago to

02:15:23.640 --> 02:15:25.640
become the main teacher.

02:15:26.301 --> 02:15:28.301
Counselor coach cook janitor.

02:15:28.736 --> 02:15:30.304
Transportation coordinator thank
you just our whole senior

02:15:30.838 --> 02:15:33.607
position I oppose this bill
thank you.

02:15:34.507 --> 02:15:36.507
My name is cleverness and

02:15:37.345 --> 02:15:40.146
homeschooling in sacramento is
close this bill as a man.

02:15:40.181 --> 02:15:42.948
My name is joseph grannis I'm
from sacramento california nine

02:15:43.184 --> 02:15:45.510
spokesman.
Hi my name is easy kill james

02:15:45.586 --> 02:15:47.586
thornberg.

02:15:47.888 --> 02:15:50.789
And they can them from. Crime
california and I strongly oppose

02:15:51.558 --> 02:15:54.294
this bill.
Hi I'm just go thornberg hand

02:15:54.294 --> 02:15:56.762
I've been homeschooling for
three years and I strongly

02:15:58.198 --> 02:16:00.299
oppose this bill as amended.
Hi my name is so I sure

02:16:01.168 --> 02:16:04.360
thornberg in a strongly oppose
this bill as amended.

02:16:04.504 --> 02:16:06.939
Hi my name is nicole abou from
hayward california I'm home

02:16:07.541 --> 02:16:09.541
school educator for eighteen

02:16:09.708 --> 02:16:11.708
years and I strongly oppose this

02:16:11.710 --> 02:16:13.846
bill even as amended.
My name is lindsay will brough

02:16:14.881 --> 02:16:16.881
and I strongly oppose this bill

02:16:17.217 --> 02:16:20.180
even as amended.
Hi my name is catherine lawler

02:16:20.319 --> 02:16:23.289
I'm from livermore california
I'm a lifelong. Private home

02:16:23.923 --> 02:16:25.923
school student and I strongly

02:16:25.958 --> 02:16:28.526
oppose this bill even as amended.
My name is audrey lawler I'm a

02:16:28.861 --> 02:16:31.620
private home school student from
livermore california and I

02:16:31.629 --> 02:16:33.629
strongly oppose this bill even

02:16:34.200 --> 02:16:36.866
as amended my name's lauren la
boo and I oppose this bill is in
the.

02:16:38.370 --> 02:16:40.838
Hi my name as rebekah lawler
I've been homeschooling mother.

02:16:41.400 --> 02:16:43.274
And homes going educated for
eighteen years.

02:16:43.776 --> 02:16:46.577
from livermore california and I
strongly. Disapprove of this

02:16:48.213 --> 02:16:50.213
bill even as amended.

02:16:51.830 --> 02:16:53.349
Tara pharaoh director wild west
guy learning centers san

02:16:54.152 --> 02:16:56.253
francisco california I strongly
oppose this bill as amended

02:16:56.821 --> 02:16:58.821
think you.

02:16:59.900 --> 02:17:01.492
Kristin hamilton director of the
private home school. For the

02:17:02.560 --> 02:17:04.595
fire academy in palo alto and I
strongly oppose this bill as

02:17:07.165 --> 02:17:09.633
amended.
Hi my name is dmitry differ sure

02:17:10.835 --> 02:17:12.769
heard I'm a home school parents
and I strongly oppose this bill

02:17:13.805 --> 02:17:16.172
as amended.
My name is dan echo albrecht and

02:17:18.576 --> 02:17:20.576
I oppose this bill.

02:17:21.245 --> 02:17:23.213
I am making had and I stand here
per se their.

02:17:23.946 --> 02:17:25.547
My name is robbie albrecht home
school mom and I oppose this

02:17:28.519 --> 02:17:30.519
bill.

02:17:30.521 --> 02:17:32.521
My name is thurmond July and.

02:17:34.558 --> 02:17:37.393
I'm a home schooler and posters.
My name is determine ronson I'm

02:17:38.128 --> 02:17:40.128
a translator and to home school

02:17:40.130 --> 02:17:43.320
parents and I oppose this bill
as amended.

02:17:44.340 --> 02:17:46.467
My name is jesse lion from
oakland california quirk is a

02:17:46.902 --> 02:17:49.371
merton see nurse and that the
home school educator and I

02:17:50.173 --> 02:17:52.474
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is are no fun among

02:17:53.341 --> 02:17:56.111
homeschooled students aye
opposed to spills amended.

02:17:56.479 --> 02:17:59.414
My name is santiago I'm home
schooled student and I oppose

02:18:00.216 --> 02:18:02.918
this bill as amended.
My name is sarah ocal I'm home

02:18:03.853 --> 02:18:05.853
school educator and I strongly

02:18:07.422 --> 02:18:09.992
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is claire sweeney and I

02:18:09.992 --> 02:18:11.992
strongly oppose this bill as

02:18:12.361 --> 02:18:15.163
amended.
My name is kate sweeney and the
home school student and I

02:18:16.980 --> 02:18:18.980
strongly. Oppose this bill even

02:18:18.634 --> 02:18:21.569
as amended.
I melissa sweeney home educator

02:18:22.170 --> 02:18:24.170
in solano county and I strongly

02:18:25.941 --> 02:18:28.409
oppose this bill as amended.
My name's mo johnson idea fair

02:18:28.844 --> 02:18:30.844
oaks california and I oppose

02:18:30.912 --> 02:18:33.514
this bill as amended.
Hi my name is ron at wilson I

02:18:33.515 --> 02:18:36.182
represent classical
conversations of sacramento I've

02:18:36.851 --> 02:18:38.851
been a long time home school mom

02:18:38.953 --> 02:18:40.953
and I oppose this bill even as

02:18:42.390 --> 02:18:44.390
amended thank you.

02:18:46.259 --> 02:18:48.563
My name's and the contract so
that my proposed.

02:18:48.563 --> 02:18:50.563
My name is rei's wilson I am a.

02:18:50.965 --> 02:18:53.133
Home school student and.
Jim clancy classical

02:18:53.267 --> 02:18:55.267
conversations and I pose this

02:18:56.102 --> 02:18:58.805
bill even as amended.
My name is rebecca alice for.

02:19:01.410 --> 02:19:03.410
I'm from rescue and I oppose

02:19:05.790 --> 02:19:07.947
this bill even as men.
My name's angelica alla
corporate informasi than I

02:19:12.853 --> 02:19:15.154
possess. Even as amended.
I am camino florida of lotus

02:19:15.589 --> 02:19:18.124
californian I pose this bill as
amended.

02:19:19.326 --> 02:19:22.161
Amanda carlson fresno california
home school educator opposes

02:19:23.940 --> 02:19:25.729
bill as amended.
Navistar five and I oppose this

02:19:26.397 --> 02:19:29.232
bill as amended.
I am happy killing and I oppose

02:19:29.767 --> 02:19:32.469
this bill as amended.
I'm chad five and I oppose this

02:19:33.136 --> 02:19:35.171
bill as amended. My name is
emily five have been

02:19:35.706 --> 02:19:38.410
homeschooling for seven years I
strongly oppose this bill as

02:19:39.410 --> 02:19:42.780
amended.
My name is shelly laying aye

02:19:42.513 --> 02:19:45.448
person spell. My name is janelle
holberg scotts valley I'm a

02:19:45.549 --> 02:19:47.549
homeschool graduate

02:19:47.551 --> 02:19:49.719
homeschooling parent and I
oppose this bill as amended.

02:19:50.454 --> 02:19:52.388
My name is jennifer lange and I
oppose this bill as amended

02:19:54.456 --> 02:19:56.456
thank you.

02:19:57.327 --> 02:19:59.327
My name is bela car norris and I

02:19:59.695 --> 02:20:02.564
oppose this bill eyes and.
Money was salim jones I'm from

02:20:03.199 --> 02:20:05.199
okay california and I strongly

02:20:05.735 --> 02:20:07.636
oppose this bill.
My name's alaina snyder from

02:20:08.204 --> 02:20:10.772
oakland california and the
proper progressive voter an

02:20:11.700 --> 02:20:13.375
activist and I oppose this bill
as amended.

02:20:13.709 --> 02:20:16.110
My name is the v. John's I'm
unschooling from oakland

02:20:16.546 --> 02:20:18.546
california and I strongly oppose

02:20:20.249 --> 02:20:23.840
this bill as amended.
My name is this lean qatar I'm a

02:20:23.519 --> 02:20:25.653
homeschool parent to have three
children who have all been home

02:20:26.210 --> 02:20:28.210
schooled and I strongly oppose

02:20:29.240 --> 02:20:31.626
this bill. As amended.
Pam telling President California

02:20:32.594 --> 02:20:34.594
home school network we oppose

02:20:35.330 --> 02:20:37.598
this bill as amended.
My name is carol taylor I'm for

02:20:37.933 --> 02:20:40.201
member to the california I'm the
grandmother by homeschooling

02:20:41.169 --> 02:20:44.400
family and I oppose this bill as
amended.

02:20:44.137 --> 02:20:46.137
Veronica taylor from castro

02:20:46.141 --> 02:20:48.800
valley mom of two home schoolers
and I oppose.

02:20:51.978 --> 02:20:53.978
This I bill as amended.

02:20:54.682 --> 02:20:57.251
The nearest cheney feel. Alarmed
her since birth in maine. And I

02:20:57.285 --> 02:21:00.187
had the whole dinner I'm homes
school educator of five children

02:21:05.159 --> 02:21:07.194
nine because this bill even as
amended.
Amy call representing old school

02:21:07.194 --> 02:21:09.996
learning in oakley california
and we oppose this bill even as

02:21:11.132 --> 02:21:13.132
amended. My name is sandy hi I'm

02:21:14.635 --> 02:21:17.400
from beckley california and I
oppose this bill even as an.

02:21:17.400 --> 02:21:19.390
My name is rebecca hart I'm a
homeschool parent in the
director of the classical

02:21:19.390 --> 02:21:21.807
conversations in brentwood
california and I oppose this

02:21:25.177 --> 02:21:27.847
bill even as amended.
mayes brand higher from britain

02:21:28.281 --> 02:21:30.281
california home school parent I

02:21:31.318 --> 02:21:33.385
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is kate reynolds I am I

02:21:33.520 --> 02:21:35.520
home school graduate in

02:21:35.522 --> 02:21:37.522
homeschooling parent I oppose

02:21:39.993 --> 02:21:42.270
this bill even as amended.
Hi my name is matthew reynolds

02:21:43.196 --> 02:21:45.364
and I oppose a spell.
My name is protect I'm a

02:21:45.531 --> 02:21:47.966
homeschool graduate and home
school parent I oppose this bill

02:21:49.769 --> 02:21:51.769
even as amended.

02:21:52.380 --> 02:21:54.380
My name is william randall I am

02:21:54.640 --> 02:21:56.941
homeschooled I oppose this bill.
I envision a cheney from it was

02:21:57.610 --> 02:21:59.610
a california and the home school

02:21:59.745 --> 02:22:01.745
graduate and pat and I oppose

02:22:01.747 --> 02:22:03.747
this bill as amended.

02:22:03.814 --> 02:22:05.814
My name is bob collins.

02:22:05.884 --> 02:22:07.884
I am a home school parent. And a

02:22:07.886 --> 02:22:10.688
recently retired public educator
after forty years of service.

02:22:10.855 --> 02:22:12.855
And I oppose this bill as

02:22:13.580 --> 02:22:15.793
amended.
My name's monika cross a home

02:22:15.994 --> 02:22:18.596
school parent from sammy no
county and I strongly oppose

02:22:22.667 --> 02:22:25.402
this bill even as amended.
My name is benton caution I

02:22:26.671 --> 02:22:29.406
strongly meant.
They're strongly oppose this
bill as amended.

02:22:29.841 --> 02:22:32.409
Hi my name is dave across some
home school student and I

02:22:34.312 --> 02:22:36.812
strongly oppose this bill.
Hi my name is charles class and

02:22:37.480 --> 02:22:39.214
the home school student and I
strongly oppose this bill as a

02:22:42.220 --> 02:22:45.188
man.
My name is bad I am I home

02:22:46.570 --> 02:22:48.570
school shooting I strongly

02:22:52.796 --> 02:22:54.796
oppose police bill as a man game.

02:22:54.898 --> 02:22:57.532
Hi my name is heather lopez I'm
a homeschool mom I currently

02:22:57.801 --> 02:22:59.969
hold a california state teaching
credential I had the pleasure of

02:23:00.237 --> 02:23:03.720
working in california schools
for fifteen years. And I

02:23:03.772 --> 02:23:05.373
strongly oppose this measure.
and this and this measure as

02:23:07.277 --> 02:23:09.277
amended.

02:23:12.382 --> 02:23:14.382
Hello hello my name maintain.

02:23:17.720 --> 02:23:20.322
I never and julia despair.
Hello my name's eric lopez home

02:23:20.957 --> 02:23:23.258
school farther from hollister
california and oppose this bill

02:23:24.761 --> 02:23:26.761
as amended thank you.

02:23:28.265 --> 02:23:30.265
Right.

02:23:30.932 --> 02:23:33.635
Hi my name is or.
Lara posers.

02:23:33.936 --> 02:23:35.936
Hi my name is savannah mercer

02:23:36.138 --> 02:23:38.607
and I pose this bill as amended.
I am abraham mershon the home

02:23:38.607 --> 02:23:41.542
school student I oppose this
bill as amended.

02:23:42.111 --> 02:23:44.846
My name as kim mercer from
livermore california and I

02:23:49.170 --> 02:23:51.886
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is loose ganon danville

02:23:53.221 --> 02:23:56.560
california I am a retired
california teacher. Teaching

02:23:57.526 --> 02:23:59.526
credential. All who home

02:23:59.961 --> 02:24:02.496
schooled my children and now the
proud grandmother of.

02:24:02.697 --> 02:24:04.697
Children who are being home

02:24:05.990 --> 02:24:07.990
schooled by my daughter.

02:24:07.567 --> 02:24:10.169
I strongly oppose a. Be two
seven five six as amended thank

02:24:11.571 --> 02:24:13.907
you.
My name is jessica dutra from

02:24:15.760 --> 02:24:17.760
hollister hollister california.

02:24:17.178 --> 02:24:18.778
Among homeschooling mother and I
strongly oppose this bill as

02:24:20.246 --> 02:24:23.830
amended.
My name is age eighteen chat and

02:24:27.321 --> 02:24:29.321
I opposes del.

02:24:34.560 --> 02:24:37.429
I clearly. Heard.
Hi I'm tiny collins from rocklin

02:24:37.729 --> 02:24:39.729
california.

02:24:40.765 --> 02:24:42.765
I oppose this bill as amended

02:24:44.368 --> 02:24:46.368
and I am not a home schooler.

02:24:46.539 --> 02:24:49.500
Hi my name is kathleen mcgready
I'm from brentwood california a

02:24:49.742 --> 02:24:52.343
california public school teacher
turned homeschool teacher and I

02:24:53.278 --> 02:24:55.278
strongly oppose ab two seven

02:24:55.781 --> 02:24:58.247
five six as amended thank you.
Hello my name is priscilla

02:24:58.449 --> 02:25:00.449
garcia arm from benicia

02:25:00.586 --> 02:25:02.586
california home school parent

02:25:02.754 --> 02:25:04.754
and I strongly oppose this bill.

02:25:06.523 --> 02:25:08.592
Ab two seven five six thank you.
My name is heather gibbons we

02:25:08.994 --> 02:25:11.462
live in with in california and a
home school mother of six

02:25:11.629 --> 02:25:13.629
children we've been doing this

02:25:13.731 --> 02:25:16.200
for six years. And I strongly
oppose this bill.

02:25:16.868 --> 02:25:19.202
Hello I'm tami givens I'm a home
schooler and aye opposed to

02:25:21.305 --> 02:25:23.806
spell.
Many david givens I am a proud

02:25:24.275 --> 02:25:26.275
father six beautiful intelligent

02:25:26.711 --> 02:25:28.711
little children and we all very

02:25:32.516 --> 02:25:34.516
very strongly oppose this bill.

02:25:38.550 --> 02:25:40.550
Rainn.

02:25:46.362 --> 02:25:48.362
Rainn. Close to.

02:25:49.232 --> 02:25:51.232
My name is greg gardner and.

02:25:52.202 --> 02:25:54.202
I am posehn.

02:25:58.908 --> 02:26:00.908
Five six as amended.

02:26:11.686 --> 02:26:13.686
And.

02:26:16.760 --> 02:26:19.260
Yeah.
My name is john a gardener I am

02:26:20.262 --> 02:26:22.230
a homeschooling mother of six
wonderful children for nine

02:26:23.999 --> 02:26:25.999
years. I strongly oppose this

02:26:27.503 --> 02:26:29.503
bill as amended.

02:26:32.708 --> 02:26:34.708
Nonna now them okay yeah.

02:26:39.781 --> 02:26:41.515
Opposes fair. And now and then.
My name is stacy brown martin

02:26:42.317 --> 02:26:44.551
I'm from carson california I am
a homeschooling mom of two
beautiful daughters and I

02:26:44.853 --> 02:26:46.853
strongly oppose this bill as

02:26:49.224 --> 02:26:51.859
amended.
My name is eli as God knows I am

02:26:52.493 --> 02:26:54.493
from long beach california. And

02:26:55.997 --> 02:26:57.997
aye opposed this bill as amended.

02:26:58.990 --> 02:27:00.999
Monies cager gardiner I'm a
father of six homeschooled

02:27:02.169 --> 02:27:04.169
children and a current public is

02:27:04.372 --> 02:27:06.372
a school teacher and I oppose

02:27:07.709 --> 02:27:09.709
his bill as amended.

02:27:09.877 --> 02:27:11.877
My name is devon martin parson

02:27:13.614 --> 02:27:16.182
and aye opposes bill as amended.
My name is joseph pile and I

02:27:20.420 --> 02:27:22.420
pose this bill is in and.

02:27:24.240 --> 02:27:26.240
I israel pile aye pool despair

02:27:26.759 --> 02:27:28.759
as a baby.

02:27:29.796 --> 02:27:32.364
my catalina file I of a medicaid
my children because I was sent.

02:27:32.364 --> 02:27:34.364
And I oppose this bill. As

02:27:35.200 --> 02:27:38.360
amended.
My name is pearl pile and I pose

02:27:42.875 --> 02:27:44.875
this bill as amended.

02:27:46.112 --> 02:27:48.580
My name is anything.
I live in california.

02:27:50.650 --> 02:27:53.510
And I opposed to spell.
My name is aaron since area live

02:27:53.486 --> 02:27:55.486
in roseville california and I

02:27:58.791 --> 02:28:01.590
oppose the bill as amended.
Hello my name's dulcinea while

02:28:02.795 --> 02:28:05.263
is and I'm from mendocino county.
And I strongly oppose this bill

02:28:05.664 --> 02:28:07.664
as amended.

02:28:08.330 --> 02:28:10.330
My name is eva lopez and I'm

02:28:10.435 --> 02:28:12.802
from make develop and I strongly
opposes span.

02:28:13.705 --> 02:28:16.474
My name is ruth lopez I am a
homeschool mom of five including

02:28:17.641 --> 02:28:20.444
two graduates and I'm from
victorville and I oppose this
bill.

02:28:22.247 --> 02:28:25.115
My name is vincent lopez and I
strongly oppose this bill.

02:28:25.450 --> 02:28:27.450
My name is carol hearn I'm from

02:28:27.819 --> 02:28:30.654
has very california christian
academy and I strongly oppose.

02:28:31.956 --> 02:28:34.725
This bill as amended thinking.
My name is witney hearn I'm a

02:28:34.826 --> 02:28:36.826
home schooler knows very

02:28:36.894 --> 02:28:38.894
california and I strongly oppose

02:28:39.497 --> 02:28:41.698
this bill.
My name is mallory herein I'm

02:28:42.990 --> 02:28:44.990
thirteen and I live in his very

02:28:44.335 --> 02:28:46.970
california and I strongly oppose
this bill as amended.

02:28:47.171 --> 02:28:49.272
My name is janna lopez I'm a
high school I'm a homeschool

02:28:49.373 --> 02:28:51.874
graduate from victorville
california and I strongly

02:28:52.176 --> 02:28:54.176
opposes bill in any form

02:28:54.211 --> 02:28:57.780
whatsoever. My name is sophia
lopez and I strongly oppose this

02:28:59.149 --> 02:29:01.417
bill.
My name is going hard and I'm

02:29:01.717 --> 02:29:04.190
from newcastle californian I
strongly oppose this bill as

02:29:05.320 --> 02:29:07.723
amended.
good afternoon I'm valerie

02:29:08.580 --> 02:29:10.580
harlem a private home school

02:29:10.493 --> 02:29:13.295
educator from plaster county and
I strongly oppose this bill in

02:29:13.830 --> 02:29:15.830
its amended format in any format

02:29:17.399 --> 02:29:19.901
thank you.
Hello my name is tiffany luka

02:29:20.903 --> 02:29:23.672
and I'm a private home educator
also register dahle hygienist.

02:29:25.274 --> 02:29:28.176
And I oppose this bill as
amended thank you warning for.

02:29:28.676 --> 02:29:31.478
Good afternoon my name is mark
luka from benicia california I

02:29:31.879 --> 02:29:34.349
oppose this bill and.
Respect your.

02:29:36.952 --> 02:29:38.952
Your service thank you.

02:29:39.221 --> 02:29:42.155
Hello my name is christina quan.
I am a homeschool mom from san

02:29:43.292 --> 02:29:45.893
jose california and I also
represent more than a hundred

02:29:47.262 --> 02:29:49.964
families from the silicon valley.
Basic home school support group

02:29:49.965 --> 02:29:51.965
and I'm here to oppose this bill

02:29:51.999 --> 02:29:54.535
thank you.
My name is jennifer randall him

02:29:56.235 --> 02:29:58.938
from oakley california. Ima ten
year home school mom of two

02:29:59.773 --> 02:30:01.841
teenage boys and I'm the high
school counselor from the

02:30:03.110 --> 02:30:05.877
fremont christian school psp. My
husband steven and I both

02:30:06.880 --> 02:30:08.880
strongly oppose this bill in any

02:30:08.949 --> 02:30:10.949
form thank you.

02:30:13.887 --> 02:30:16.290
I.
I'm janette conklin in I'm

02:30:16.923 --> 02:30:19.725
homeschooling privately for
three years.

02:30:20.627 --> 02:30:22.627
With this guy telescope and we

02:30:24.464 --> 02:30:26.464
oppose this bill thank you.

02:30:26.466 --> 02:30:28.466
I'm barbara.

02:30:28.568 --> 02:30:30.568
Lara.

02:30:31.137 --> 02:30:33.137
In I'm. From.

02:30:33.471 --> 02:30:35.471
Fong.

02:30:37.810 --> 02:30:39.810
Not hole there.

02:30:44.550 --> 02:30:46.550
Nnamdi. Persist bear.

02:30:51.657 --> 02:30:53.657
Rainn.

02:30:56.165 --> 02:30:57.492
And our friends are from.
Says.

02:31:01.231 --> 02:31:03.231
And I. Don't dahle per se spare.

02:31:03.602 --> 02:31:05.602
My name is kathy let some I'm a

02:31:05.770 --> 02:31:08.405
home school educator. And in
sam's distill county and I

02:31:10.730 --> 02:31:12.474
strongly oppose this bill.
Good afternoon I'm joanne leon

02:31:13.578 --> 02:31:16.480
and I'm from san mateo county
I'm a homeschool parent and I

02:31:17.548 --> 02:31:20.830
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is dee dee and the home

02:31:20.718 --> 02:31:23.687
school student from sandia
county and I strongly oppose

02:31:25.122 --> 02:31:27.490
this bill. As amended.
One is robert jones I'm from san

02:31:28.659 --> 02:31:30.659
diego county as strongly oppose

02:31:30.993 --> 02:31:32.993
ab two seven five six. As

02:31:33.263 --> 02:31:35.430
amended thank you for listening.
My name is laura jones I'm from

02:31:36.366 --> 02:31:38.366
san diego county I strongly

02:31:38.368 --> 02:31:40.703
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is nancy kim and I'm

02:31:41.470 --> 02:31:44.373
from dianne by california and
I'm fellow listed cushion psp

02:31:45.575 --> 02:31:48.210
firm foundation. And a bunch of
other home schooling friends in

02:31:49.120 --> 02:31:51.615
orange county in la county and
separate you know county and I

02:31:51.615 --> 02:31:53.615
strongly oppose this bill

02:31:54.851 --> 02:31:57.151
thinking. Hello I mean eighteen
knocked on a shamli at those

02:31:58.922 --> 02:32:00.922
guys and then. And I'll aye name

02:32:02.959 --> 02:32:04.959
is timothy can't. And I oppose

02:32:04.961 --> 02:32:06.762
the bill.
Hello my name is arthur marc

02:32:07.263 --> 02:32:09.898
rich record of the california
I'm a homeschool parent father

02:32:10.366 --> 02:32:12.366
of three and a strongly oppose

02:32:12.568 --> 02:32:14.803
ab two seven five six was
amended. Thank you.

02:32:15.237 --> 02:32:17.572
I've had remarked home school
student from rancho cordova

02:32:22.144 --> 02:32:24.946
california. I oppose this bill.
My name is samuel mark I'm a

02:32:24.980 --> 02:32:27.747
home school student from rancho
cordova california and I

02:32:29.184 --> 02:32:31.986
strongly oppose this bill.
Hi my name is samantha what jeff

02:32:32.721 --> 02:32:34.755
I'm here from ceres california.
And I am a homeschool parents

02:32:35.524 --> 02:32:38.580
through a charter school and not
a psa I strongly oppose this

02:32:40.729 --> 02:32:42.729
bill.

02:32:43.398 --> 02:32:45.398
i am roman woodruff's.

02:32:46.134 --> 02:32:48.134
And I am home school students in

02:32:48.770 --> 02:32:50.770
a strongly oppose this bill as

02:32:51.306 --> 02:32:53.674
amended.
My name is travis woodrow from

02:32:54.800 --> 02:32:56.209
home school far from serious
california works for the

02:32:56.444 --> 02:32:59.450
department of corrections and I
strongly oppose this bill as

02:33:00.140 --> 02:33:02.182
amended.
Daniel column with capital

02:33:02.383 --> 02:33:05.118
resource instantly oppose this
bill thinking.

02:33:06.200 --> 02:33:08.200
Brandy falcon from redwood city

02:33:12.459 --> 02:33:15.161
and I oppose this bill.
My name is she hole in lood I

02:33:16.629 --> 02:33:19.230
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is May vets have days

02:33:20.567 --> 02:33:22.567
and home school and I strongly

02:33:24.838 --> 02:33:26.838
opposes spam.

02:33:32.612 --> 02:33:34.612
The.

02:33:36.683 --> 02:33:39.510
All time. Harper thanks man.
My name is jennifer top us from

02:33:39.185 --> 02:33:42.540
part of the california I'm
homeschooling mom and I strongly

02:33:42.955 --> 02:33:45.123
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is isaac chavez

02:33:45.258 --> 02:33:48.193
homeschooling father a portable
california nay strongly opposes

02:33:49.462 --> 02:33:51.796
bill as a as amended.
My name is lara leyva rivero

02:33:52.731 --> 02:33:55.300
from runner park california home
schooling parents and I strongly

02:33:56.267 --> 02:33:58.803
a bill that oppose this bill as
amended. Thank you.

02:33:59.671 --> 02:34:02.105
I'm carl rivero.
And I'm the home school student

02:34:02.274 --> 02:34:04.274
from runner park and I oppose

02:34:04.810 --> 02:34:06.810
this bill.

02:34:06.812 --> 02:34:09.413
Hi andy and leyva from salaries
_ california I strongly oppose

02:34:10.820 --> 02:34:12.316
this bill.
Hi and dishonor I am

02:34:13.840 --> 02:34:15.286
homeschooling mother of five in
a home school ministry leader in

02:34:16.210 --> 02:34:17.621
hayward california and I
strongly opposes the bill as

02:34:18.188 --> 02:34:20.357
amended.
Good afternoon my name is renee

02:34:20.959 --> 02:34:23.193
script like I'm a home school
mother of three including two

02:34:24.262 --> 02:34:27.300
graduates and I strongly oppose
this bill as amended thank you.

02:34:27.298 --> 02:34:29.298
My name is jenny knorr nam from

02:34:29.534 --> 02:34:31.534
martinez california and I oppose

02:34:31.569 --> 02:34:33.569
this bill as amended.

02:34:33.703 --> 02:34:36.673
I am tener script naked and I
strongly oppose this bill.

02:34:37.800 --> 02:34:39.943
My name is lucy read year I've
been homeschooled my whole life
and I oppose this bill as

02:34:40.444 --> 02:34:42.812
amended.
My name is laurie ridge zero I'm

02:34:43.280 --> 02:34:45.848
a home school educator from
danville california and I oppose

02:34:46.582 --> 02:34:48.684
this bill as amended.
My name is and married zero and

02:34:52.256 --> 02:34:54.256
I am oppose this bill as amended.

02:34:54.258 --> 02:34:56.258
My name is lee and day and I

02:34:56.593 --> 02:34:59.528
strongly oppose this bill.
My name is jacqueline day.

02:35:00.497 --> 02:35:02.497
I.

02:35:03.600 --> 02:35:06.267
I'm will schooler. I should I
strongly opposes spell.

02:35:07.737 --> 02:35:09.737
My name is jamie center nice

02:35:11.441 --> 02:35:14.376
burn. Homeschoolingand I.
Oppose this bill.

02:35:14.877 --> 02:35:17.579
My name is tiffany day from
walnut creek california I'm now

02:35:17.880 --> 02:35:19.880
a homeschooling mother and

02:35:20.490 --> 02:35:22.490
former tech executive and I

02:35:22.583 --> 02:35:24.583
strongly oppose this bill.

02:35:24.887 --> 02:35:27.655
Hi my name is heidi gleisner I'm
from one that creek I'm a small

02:35:28.724 --> 02:35:30.724
business owner and in addition I

02:35:30.759 --> 02:35:32.759
home school my two children I

02:35:33.295 --> 02:35:35.997
oppose this bill. It would with
the amendments as well I oppose

02:35:38.433 --> 02:35:41.335
it. And this made out of real.
My name is abigail surround I am

02:35:41.837 --> 02:35:44.605
an educator and I'm a home
school educator and I strongly

02:35:46.340 --> 02:35:48.340
oppose this bill. And this is.

02:35:49.743 --> 02:35:51.912
Kind mere turnover in a in a
home school student in a.

02:35:53.748 --> 02:35:55.748
Personally. I.

02:35:59.530 --> 02:36:01.855
Dispel thank you.
I mean a saver.

02:36:03.725 --> 02:36:05.725
And I'm a home schooler in a

02:36:06.994 --> 02:36:08.728
strongly oppose despair.
hi my name is wendy vienna

02:36:09.130 --> 02:36:11.498
waiver from benicia california
I'm an accountant as well as a

02:36:12.166 --> 02:36:14.768
home school my mother for three
years and I strongly oppose this

02:36:19.640 --> 02:36:21.640
bill as amended.

02:36:21.709 --> 02:36:23.709
Iron es para.

02:36:29.449 --> 02:36:31.980
Room.
My name is jessica crew del

02:36:32.190 --> 02:36:34.190
hammam educator from danville

02:36:34.420 --> 02:36:36.420
california and our family

02:36:39.492 --> 02:36:41.492
opposed to list them.

02:36:51.370 --> 02:36:53.370
Yeah.

02:36:54.592 --> 02:36:56.592
Hi my name is alex and I

02:36:58.770 --> 02:37:00.770
strongly opposes bill.

02:37:00.112 --> 02:37:02.647
Well because he had grinned on.
My son jonathan sir how jonathan

02:37:02.882 --> 02:37:05.216
high. And.
We strongly opposes but my wife

02:37:07.186 --> 02:37:09.186
and I were homeschooled trace

02:37:18.462 --> 02:37:20.462
california.

02:37:20.599 --> 02:37:22.599
I'm tina jansen from los angeles

02:37:23.340 --> 02:37:25.340
california my family strongly

02:37:26.737 --> 02:37:29.106
opposes this bill.
My name is ruby jan st I'm a

02:37:32.409 --> 02:37:35.780
home school student and I
strongly oppose this bill as
amended.
My name is matthew nine oppose

02:37:37.981 --> 02:37:39.981
this bill.

02:37:42.754 --> 02:37:44.754
My name is leanne anna.

02:37:45.556 --> 02:37:47.556
And. Gray I strongly oppose this

02:37:47.792 --> 02:37:49.793
bill.
My name is jessica eagles I'm

02:37:50.177 --> 02:37:52.177
from san jose and we strongly

02:37:55.320 --> 02:37:57.533
oppose this bill.
My name is jessica terrence I'm

02:37:58.268 --> 02:38:00.268
from los gatos and I strongly

02:38:04.808 --> 02:38:07.410
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is christine dorn from

02:38:08.177 --> 02:38:10.680
brentwood california and I am a
homeschooling mom of five and I

02:38:11.214 --> 02:38:13.983
strongly oppose this bill as
amended. My name is burke going

02:38:15.510 --> 02:38:18.500
from berlin california and I
strongly oppose this bill as
amended.

02:38:19.200 --> 02:38:21.723
My name is joshua during nay
opposes polls amended.

02:38:22.257 --> 02:38:24.226
Hi monday was your mind torn and
i strongly oppose this bill as

02:38:25.328 --> 02:38:27.328
amended.

02:38:27.730 --> 02:38:29.798
Hi I'm just aye gonzalez and I'm
a high school student from

02:38:30.967 --> 02:38:33.300
antioch california and I
strongly oppose this bill as

02:38:34.303 --> 02:38:37.172
amended.
My name is jones also from india

02:38:39.809 --> 02:38:41.443
california. Rural showing
opposes spellers amend.

02:38:42.770 --> 02:38:44.412
My name is marriage has gonzales
I'm a homeschooling parent for

02:38:45.314 --> 02:38:47.314
for children in a. Previous

02:38:47.383 --> 02:38:49.383
public school educator and I

02:38:52.120 --> 02:38:55.890
oppose the spell as amended.
My name is judy geronimo I'm a

02:38:57.464 --> 02:39:00.590
home schooler from. American
canyon and I oppose this bill as

02:39:01.563 --> 02:39:03.563
amended. I'm almost eighty trong

02:39:06.167 --> 02:39:08.168
tomorrow. I'm a home schooler.
And.

02:39:08.503 --> 02:39:10.604
Hi my name is jennifer kuna home
school mom and I have a child

02:39:10.937 --> 02:39:13.207
with special needs also and I'm
from fresno californian I pose

02:39:13.875 --> 02:39:16.430
this bill.
I am an immensely sixty seven

02:39:16.176 --> 02:39:18.176
I'm a former public school

02:39:18.178 --> 02:39:21.148
teacher. Current charter school
teacher homeschool mama and a

02:39:21.716 --> 02:39:23.716
President Of freedom christian

02:39:23.918 --> 02:39:25.918
cooper corporation and on behalf

02:39:26.420 --> 02:39:28.420
of fifty families we oppose this

02:39:29.290 --> 02:39:31.290
bill as amended.

02:39:34.930 --> 02:39:36.529
Our main means can see.
And per.

02:39:36.597 --> 02:39:38.765
My name is katie ever from
concord california and our

02:39:41.734 --> 02:39:44.535
entire family opposes the spell.
Hi my name is christine colder

02:39:45.205 --> 02:39:47.673
and the parents and with
experience public school and

02:39:48.508 --> 02:39:50.442
home schooling. I strongly
oppose this bill where from

02:39:50.810 --> 02:39:52.810
fresno.

02:39:53.146 --> 02:39:55.914
My name is gabriel can tell a in
a strongly oppose this bill.

02:39:56.349 --> 02:39:58.884
My name is ron contoh a from
fresno and my family opposes

02:40:00.720 --> 02:40:03.654
this bill thank you.
my name is rachel mainland and I

02:40:05.992 --> 02:40:08.927
oppose this bill as amended.
My name is jessica amy lynn and

02:40:10.620 --> 02:40:12.630
I strongly oppose this bill.
My name is rebecca maitland were

02:40:12.565 --> 02:40:14.966
from aisle to california and we
strongly oppose this bill as

02:40:16.350 --> 02:40:18.303
amended thank you.
My name is martha caramandi

02:40:19.692 --> 02:40:22.674
again and I oppose this bill as
amended.

02:40:23.108 --> 02:40:26.440
My name is adam beach of a home
schooling parent from davis
california and I oppose this

02:40:28.780 --> 02:40:31.315
bill.
I'm aaron king from davis

02:40:32.317 --> 02:40:35.860
california and I oppose this
bill as amended.

02:40:35.652 --> 02:40:37.652
Hello my name is does he mean

02:40:37.889 --> 02:40:39.889
peach oppose cooler from davis

02:40:40.158 --> 02:40:42.158
californian your cartoons I

02:40:43.328 --> 02:40:45.328
strongly opposes pilsen and.

02:40:46.300 --> 02:40:48.699
Hello my name is carla mira I'm
from penn valley california I am

02:40:49.600 --> 02:40:51.600
a steam educator in home

02:40:51.703 --> 02:40:54.604
schooling thirteen years and I
home schooled both my sons I

02:40:55.440 --> 02:40:58.208
strongly oppose this bill as
amended. Think you hello I am

02:40:58.876 --> 02:41:01.778
skyler mira I'm a home schooler
from penn valley and I strongly

02:41:03.314 --> 02:41:05.314
oppose this bill.

02:41:05.950 --> 02:41:07.950
Hi my name is alyssa haskin I'm

02:41:08.819 --> 02:41:10.819
twelve almost thirteen and. A.

02:41:11.822 --> 02:41:14.190
Oppose this bill.
Finally I have skin in my oppose

02:41:14.591 --> 02:41:17.393
this bill.
Kill my name is rachel haskin

02:41:18.462 --> 02:41:20.563
I'm from fremont california
homeschooling my children about

02:41:21.965 --> 02:41:24.500
seven of them with me today we
strongly opposes del thank you.

02:41:25.334 --> 02:41:27.836
My name's just asking and I
oppose this bill as amended.

02:41:28.805 --> 02:41:31.572
I'm rebekah hoskin oppose this
bill as amended. I am william

02:41:32.342 --> 02:41:34.276
asking I oppose this bill as
amended.

02:41:34.878 --> 02:41:36.878
My name is mary aragon from san

02:41:36.980 --> 02:41:39.314
diego county. As a home educator
of six children I strongly

02:41:40.149 --> 02:41:42.149
oppose this bill.

02:41:42.250 --> 02:41:45.520
Hi I'm kimberly black of home
educator from san diego county

02:41:46.550 --> 02:41:48.550
california and I oppose this

02:41:50.159 --> 02:41:52.727
bill amended.
Hello my name is heidi I'm from

02:41:53.696 --> 02:41:55.696
discovery bay and I am a mother

02:41:56.130 --> 02:41:58.266
of five we home school and I
strongly oppose this bill as

02:42:00.167 --> 02:42:02.167
amended.

02:42:03.380 --> 02:42:05.380
Hi my name is sunday I am from

02:42:05.372 --> 02:42:07.372
that. And cal.

02:42:07.676 --> 02:42:09.676
Sacramento california and I

02:42:09.745 --> 02:42:12.346
strongly oppose the spam.
My name is not steeper I'm a

02:42:12.581 --> 02:42:15.349
home schooler in sacramento
california we strongly oppose

02:42:17.319 --> 02:42:19.820
this bill thinking.
I'm rose killian from castro

02:42:20.255 --> 02:42:23.560
valley in home school parent and
I strongly oppose this bill.

02:42:24.250 --> 02:42:26.250
My name is effort from martinez

02:42:26.828 --> 02:42:29.563
and I strongly oppose this bill.
My name is brianna from.

02:42:30.565 --> 02:42:33.660
Castro valley and I strongly
oppose this bill.

02:42:33.366 --> 02:42:35.803
My name is blake killian from
castro valley I'm a home

02:42:35.803 --> 02:42:38.338
schooler and I strongly oppose
this bill.

02:42:38.406 --> 02:42:40.640
My name is michael travis
killian a homeschooling parents

02:42:41.242 --> 02:42:43.877
who castro valley california and
I oppose this bill.

02:42:44.144 --> 02:42:46.879
My name is christy dese and lead
a home school network in san

02:42:50.170 --> 02:42:52.170
francisco and I oppose this bill.

02:42:53.153 --> 02:42:55.153
Okay nam. And really keeps. A

02:42:55.322 --> 02:42:57.322
person's para.

02:42:58.458 --> 02:43:00.458
Hello my name is jericho beats.

02:43:00.726 --> 02:43:03.395
I am school in san francisco.
I strongly oppose this bill.

02:43:04.698 --> 02:43:07.365
Hello ladies la kia.
From san francisco ash wrong we.

02:43:11.204 --> 02:43:13.204
Have.

02:43:13.873 --> 02:43:16.508
Opposes him.
My name is carter keel I am home

02:43:17.343 --> 02:43:20.112
schooled in san francisco and I
strongly oppose this bill. Hello

02:43:20.613 --> 02:43:22.614
my name is making beats and I am
school home schooled in san

02:43:23.382 --> 02:43:25.382
francisco and I strongly oppose

02:43:26.786 --> 02:43:28.520
this bill as amended.
Hello my name is greg karen

02:43:29.555 --> 02:43:31.956
again.
And I'm here with my youngest

02:43:33.124 --> 02:43:35.827
son timothy whom. I his mother
and I home school he's a future

02:43:36.628 --> 02:43:39.297
voter and just about a decade
and a little bit of change.

02:43:40.399 --> 02:43:42.399
We are here to express our

02:43:42.668 --> 02:43:44.668
opposition to twenty seven fifty

02:43:45.237 --> 02:43:47.104
six even as amended.
And in thank you sir thank you

02:43:47.805 --> 02:43:49.805
next.

02:43:51.943 --> 02:43:54.678
Come up to the microphone.
Hi my name is kathy cramps from

02:43:56.314 --> 02:43:58.782
gilroy california I strongly
oppose this bill as amended.

02:43:59.830 --> 02:44:01.830
Thank you for your service to

02:44:01.452 --> 02:44:04.540
this diverse state.
Hi my name is savannah sharp and

02:44:04.989 --> 02:44:07.322
I live in brent woods california
and I'm a homeschool mom and I

02:44:07.658 --> 02:44:09.658
strongly oppose this bill as

02:44:10.161 --> 02:44:12.161
amended.

02:44:12.163 --> 02:44:14.163
Hi my name is karina and ae

02:44:16.670 --> 02:44:18.859
strongly opposes bill as amended.
Hi my name is kiana.
Sharp.

02:44:19.802 --> 02:44:21.802
.

02:44:22.773 --> 02:44:24.773
Npr california and I strongly

02:44:29.780 --> 02:44:31.714
oppose this bill as amended.
Hello thank you for hearing us

02:44:32.549 --> 02:44:35.483
today. My name is a and also and
I'm from dixon california and I

02:44:35.986 --> 02:44:37.986
am a home school mom that

02:44:38.121 --> 02:44:40.121
strongly opposes the bill as

02:44:44.360 --> 02:44:46.360
amended. Thank you.

02:44:49.432 --> 02:44:51.432
.

02:44:53.870 --> 02:44:56.603
I'm ryan jim.
Is I'm brian nelson from dick's

02:44:56.739 --> 02:44:59.606
in california.
And I oppose this bill as

02:45:01.143 --> 02:45:04.790
amended.
My name is christine nelson from

02:45:04.480 --> 02:45:07.182
dick's thing california I'm the
home school student and I oppose

02:45:08.482 --> 02:45:11.185
this bill as amended.
my name is katherine in music I
am.

02:45:13.220 --> 02:45:15.220
Home educating mom of six

02:45:15.122 --> 02:45:17.122
from sacramento I oppose this

02:45:17.493 --> 02:45:19.760
bill as amended.
When years on la music I home

02:45:20.529 --> 02:45:22.997
school student and I oppose this
bill as amended.

02:45:23.665 --> 02:45:26.400
My name is joseph sterrett and I
oppose this bill as amended. By

02:45:26.935 --> 02:45:28.736
name is julia davis quarter I
have been a home school student

02:45:29.838 --> 02:45:32.439
for eight years and I strongly
oppose this bill as amended.

02:45:33.800 --> 02:45:35.509
My name is audrey stare at a
previous california credentialed

02:45:36.277 --> 02:45:38.277
teacher and home school teacher

02:45:38.813 --> 02:45:40.981
for ten years and I strongly
oppose the spell as amended.

02:45:42.750 --> 02:45:45.284
Thank you.
Many of scott got from

02:45:46.200 --> 02:45:48.200
sacramento. And the home school

02:45:49.257 --> 02:45:52.920
dan and I oppose this bill.
My name is lydia rivera I'm from

02:45:53.494 --> 02:45:55.494
sacramento I'm home school law

02:45:56.797 --> 02:45:59.399
and I. Proposes fill as amended.
My name is julie cast data am a

02:45:59.934 --> 02:46:02.135
homeschooling mother of three
from oroville and I oppose this

02:46:06.106 --> 02:46:08.107
bill as amended.
I am denise bird I'm a

02:46:08.208 --> 02:46:10.977
registered nurse and a
homeschool mom and I oppose this

02:46:11.912 --> 02:46:14.478
bill as amended.
Hi I'm kim I'm from stockton

02:46:14.548 --> 02:46:17.349
california I'm a home school
educator and a university

02:46:18.118 --> 02:46:20.185
adjunct faculty member and I
oppose this bill even is

02:46:20.987 --> 02:46:23.856
currently amended.
I'm kennedy burden I oppose this

02:46:24.570 --> 02:46:26.570
bill as amended.

02:46:26.590 --> 02:46:28.527
Gary chen concord california
professional mechanical engineer

02:46:28.928 --> 02:46:31.430
was the primary home school
educator for sixteen years of

02:46:32.640 --> 02:46:33.665
right now three young adult
children I oppose this bill

02:46:37.670 --> 02:46:39.871
thank you.
Holly one fading from dick's in

02:46:40.940 --> 02:46:42.940
california. Aye we school

02:46:43.309 --> 02:46:45.309
through independent study and I

02:46:45.978 --> 02:46:47.978
oppose this bill thank you.

02:46:48.647 --> 02:46:50.748
Morganwg laden from dick's in
california.
.

02:46:52.170 --> 02:46:54.170
Independent study.

02:46:55.554 --> 02:46:57.955
I oppose this bill.
Jeanine derose candidate for

02:46:58.357 --> 02:47:00.691
state senate district six where
we're standing and I oppose this

02:47:03.195 --> 02:47:05.195
bill as amended.

02:47:05.463 --> 02:47:07.698
Hi I am robert louis extra I am
a forty year old home schooler I

02:47:08.299 --> 02:47:10.299
am hurting myself and my to

02:47:10.502 --> 02:47:12.136
parents so they can make it. And
I strongly oppose this bill.

02:47:13.938 --> 02:47:16.873
Many.
My name is nolan prior and from

02:47:17.175 --> 02:47:19.175
brentwood california I'm a home

02:47:21.477 --> 02:47:24.140
schooler and I oppose this bill.
Hi I went the echlin from orange

02:47:24.800 --> 02:47:26.816
county we currently homeschool
through a public charter that we

02:47:27.316 --> 02:47:30.220
support school choice and we
oppose this bill as amended.

02:47:30.855 --> 02:47:32.622
My name is nikki prior from
britain california homeschool

02:47:33.490 --> 02:47:36.225
creased three children and I
oppose this bill as amended.

02:47:37.270 --> 02:47:39.270
My name is wide allen and from

02:47:40.596 --> 02:47:42.965
la county and I oppose this bill.
My aim is evan car and I

02:47:43.533 --> 02:47:45.533
strongly oppose this bill even

02:47:46.203 --> 02:47:48.203
as amended.

02:47:48.338 --> 02:47:50.338
Hi I'm the gallon from la county

02:47:56.120 --> 02:47:58.130
and I put a spell for now I'm a homeschooling mom
and I strongly oppose this bill

02:47:59.382 --> 02:48:01.382
as amended.

02:48:01.451 --> 02:48:03.886
I am run a gallon from st peter
california and I am a
homeschooling mom through a

02:48:03.886 --> 02:48:06.320
public charter school and I
support school choice I oppose

02:48:06.422 --> 02:48:09.291
this bill as currently amended
thank you.

02:48:09.525 --> 02:48:11.226
Hi my name's grant loosen I
strongly.

02:48:14.230 --> 02:48:16.230
.

02:48:16.665 --> 02:48:19.334
Close the spells amended.
hi May name's heather friends I

02:48:19.502 --> 02:48:21.970
met director of the public
personalized learning charter

02:48:22.771 --> 02:48:24.771
but more importantly a home

02:48:24.773 --> 02:48:26.773
school mom aye opposed to spell.

02:48:28.243 --> 02:48:30.877
Thank you for your time today.
Hi my name is sherry slow us I

02:48:31.513 --> 02:48:33.781
am from orange county a former
fortune one hundred executive

02:48:34.616 --> 02:48:37.551
who retired to home school my
child.

02:48:38.386 --> 02:48:41.188
I am currently homeschooling
through a public charter but I

02:48:42.123 --> 02:48:44.123
am moving back to a psa. And I

02:48:45.260 --> 02:48:47.928
am adamantly opposed to this
bill even as amended thank you

02:48:48.630 --> 02:48:50.764
thank you.
Hi my name is in france I'm a

02:48:53.501 --> 02:48:54.833
thirteen year old home a gap
from school.

02:48:55.536 --> 02:48:57.671
At.
Santa ana californian I strongly

02:48:59.672 --> 02:49:01.672
oppose this bill.

02:49:04.111 --> 02:49:06.111
The figure turned.

02:49:08.714 --> 02:49:10.714
He my means lever. Interim lost

02:49:11.317 --> 02:49:13.317
interest.

02:49:16.423 --> 02:49:18.491
I persist pair welcoming.
My name's amanda shut I'm a

02:49:18.492 --> 02:49:20.493
credentialed teacher in los
angeles and they strongly oppose

02:49:21.528 --> 02:49:23.528
this bill as amended.

02:49:24.631 --> 02:49:26.631
My name's marsha.

02:49:27.267 --> 02:49:29.668
Any of los angeles.
The person spoke.

02:49:30.503 --> 02:49:32.236
My name is eric frame I am a
sacramento citizen and a

02:49:32.839 --> 02:49:34.839
candidate for state senate

02:49:35.674 --> 02:49:37.674
district six oh strongly oppose

02:49:38.244 --> 02:49:40.512
please no we're not gonna
politicking here next thank you.

02:49:40.512 --> 02:49:43.415
I'm heather obernolte big bear
lake california homeschool mom
for nine years and I strongly

02:49:48.187 --> 02:49:50.187
oppose this bill.

02:49:50.256 --> 02:49:52.256
Khimetrics infomercial

02:49:53.250 --> 02:49:55.250
california.

02:49:56.394 --> 02:49:58.595
Persist person and.
Hey my name is amanda medford

02:49:58.996 --> 02:50:01.866
from roseville california
homeschool mama five in a local

02:50:02.167 --> 02:50:04.902
and director of the council
community I oppose this bill as

02:50:05.836 --> 02:50:07.870
amended.
I'm just not heard from us will

02:50:08.472 --> 02:50:10.472
california homeschool father and

02:50:11.309 --> 02:50:14.211
I suppose this bill.
My name is dalton metric from

02:50:14.946 --> 02:50:16.946
roseville california.

02:50:17.615 --> 02:50:20.217
In a strongly opposes.
I'm lou this the barren and I'm

02:50:20.518 --> 02:50:23.120
a home schooler from hell and I
oppose this bill as amended.

02:50:23.421 --> 02:50:25.122
My name is charlotte and I'm a
home schooler and I'm from los

02:50:25.989 --> 02:50:27.989
angeles california I oppose this

02:50:28.260 --> 02:50:30.227
bill as amended.
Hello I'm alison the barren in

02:50:30.728 --> 02:50:33.163
my home school mom of four from
los angeles. And a per of

02:50:34.650 --> 02:50:36.632
private school teacher I oppose
this bill as amended.

02:50:37.368 --> 02:50:39.869
Hi my name is lara name off I'm
from pasadena california I'm a

02:50:40.771 --> 02:50:42.771
board member of a sixty five

02:50:43.472 --> 02:50:45.730
family coop called wish. And we
strongly oppose this bill as

02:50:46.610 --> 02:50:48.610
amended.

02:50:49.446 --> 02:50:51.547
Hi I am cassidy imhoff. O. Home
schooler from pasadena

02:50:53.250 --> 02:50:55.950
california and I strongly oppose
this bill doesn't.

02:50:56.386 --> 02:50:58.988
I'm a home schooler from los
angeles and I strongly oppose

02:50:59.823 --> 02:51:02.525
this bill as amended.
Hi am kathryn quick I'm educator

02:51:04.600 --> 02:51:06.600
from los angeles county and I

02:51:06.329 --> 02:51:09.230
oppose this bill as amended.
Higher and lower quick I'm from

02:51:10.200 --> 02:51:12.200
los angeles county and I oppose

02:51:13.169 --> 02:51:15.169
this bill as amended. Hi I'm

02:51:15.571 --> 02:51:17.571
here idea gray homeschooling

02:51:19.408 --> 02:51:21.408
pascoe covers season st windsor

02:51:22.478 --> 02:51:24.680
and aye opposed to spell.
Hi my name is early on to me is

02:51:24.680 --> 02:51:27.115
from here to california and I
got a classical conversations

02:51:27.616 --> 02:51:29.918
and I strongly oppose this bill.
Hi my name is noah. And I

02:51:31.654 --> 02:51:34.155
strongly in truly approach.
Opposed to spill.

02:51:35.824 --> 02:51:37.824
hi my name is kim id they a and

02:51:37.860 --> 02:51:40.610
the homes cooley and because
they spend.

02:51:40.295 --> 02:51:42.997
Hi my name is kayla do very and
I oppose bill.

02:51:43.599 --> 02:51:46.670
Hi my name is madrid mones from
hayward california I'm a

02:51:46.501 --> 02:51:49.469
homeschool mom and I oppose this
bill thank you.

02:51:50.172 --> 02:51:52.740
Hello I'm she catia do barry and
the private home school educator

02:51:53.475 --> 02:51:55.976
from hayward california and also
director over classical

02:51:56.578 --> 02:51:59.120
conversations of san lorenzo.
Home school community and I

02:51:59.714 --> 02:52:01.714
strongly oppose ab twenty seven

02:52:02.383 --> 02:52:04.383
fifty six and as it is amended

02:52:04.751 --> 02:52:07.554
they kill.
My name is us hundred and I

02:52:08.550 --> 02:52:10.550
strongly oppose this bill as

02:52:10.258 --> 02:52:12.258
amended. Penniless gabriela

02:52:13.794 --> 02:52:16.163
helen I strongly oppose this
bill is.
My name is elaine health from

02:52:16.163 --> 02:52:17.997
valley springs I'm a home
educator and I strongly oppose

02:52:19.500 --> 02:52:21.500
this bill as amended.

02:52:21.502 --> 02:52:23.502
Hi my name is shauna garvin I am

02:52:23.504 --> 02:52:25.772
a homeschool mom and they also
represent. On us as a board

02:52:27.174 --> 02:52:29.174
member a hundred plus family

02:52:29.576 --> 02:52:31.544
group a support group for home
schoolers called home builder

02:52:33.380 --> 02:52:36.248
home builders. Out of the east
contra costa county area.

02:52:36.850 --> 02:52:38.850
Hi my name is kayla barb and I

02:52:39.419 --> 02:52:41.419
suppose this bill.

02:52:41.721 --> 02:52:43.922
My name is steven garvin and I
oppose this bill and so this is

02:52:44.924 --> 02:52:47.920
mom.
My name is daniel barb with

02:52:47.494 --> 02:52:50.362
american heritage school in
jackson california. I'm a

02:52:51.197 --> 02:52:53.298
homeschool graduate homeschool
parent a deputy sheriff and I

02:52:53.865 --> 02:52:55.865
pose this bill.

02:52:56.702 --> 02:52:59.404
Hi my name's angela bar I am as
stay home mom. And I'm from

02:53:00.439 --> 02:53:02.439
jackson california and I oppose

02:53:06.744 --> 02:53:09.113
this bill even as amended.
hello my name is amelia buyer

02:53:11.450 --> 02:53:13.450
and I am from jackson california

02:53:14.486 --> 02:53:16.854
and aye opposes. This bill.
Hi my name is madeline barb and

02:53:17.588 --> 02:53:20.910
I oppose this bill.
Hello I'm sandra keller in the

02:53:20.192 --> 02:53:22.259
homeschool mom from rocklin
california and I oppose this

02:53:23.662 --> 02:53:25.663
bill.
My name's unique power and I

02:53:26.164 --> 02:53:29.650
oppose this bill.
My name is jeremiah keller and I

02:53:30.201 --> 02:53:32.468
oppose this bill.
My name is timothy snowball in

02:53:32.702 --> 02:53:35.339
the civil rights attorney with
pacific legal foundation I stand

02:53:37.375 --> 02:53:39.708
opposed to this bill.
My name is bernie gipson redpath

02:53:41.312 --> 02:53:43.145
I'm with a secular. Resource
center for.

02:53:43.714 --> 02:53:45.714
Homeschooling families in los

02:53:46.983 --> 02:53:49.352
angeles and I post this bill.
Hi my name is anna smith from

02:53:50.121 --> 02:53:52.555
los angeles leone secular
homeschooling resource and urban

02:53:53.220 --> 02:53:55.725
homeschoolers in los angeles and
I oppose this bill.

02:53:56.760 --> 02:53:58.760
Hello my name is joshua texeira

02:53:59.229 --> 02:54:01.431
I'm home schooler and I strongly
oppose this bill.

02:54:04.582 --> 02:54:06.802
Hi my name this case to share.
And feb classical come the

02:54:09.573 --> 02:54:12.341
stations and I oppose this there.
Hi my name is deborah texeira

02:54:12.642 --> 02:54:14.877
I'm from brentwood california
and a private home educator I

02:54:16.790 --> 02:54:18.781
oppose this bill.
Hi anti danielson I strongly

02:54:19.381 --> 02:54:21.381
oppose this bill.

02:54:21.583 --> 02:54:24.860
Hi I'm carolyn sapp daniel I'm a
private home school educator and

02:54:24.687 --> 02:54:27.322
I strongly oppose this bill as
amended thank you.

02:54:28.124 --> 02:54:30.124
Hi I'm tina camp I'm from los

02:54:30.760 --> 02:54:33.528
angeles am a home educator and I
oppose this bill as amended
thinking.

02:54:34.262 --> 02:54:36.262
In the van lang contra costa

02:54:36.664 --> 02:54:39.634
county I represented grass roots
collective para collective real

02:54:40.690 --> 02:54:42.604
california home school and we
oppose this bill as amended can

02:54:44.540 --> 02:54:46.774
thank you for your attention to.
I'm michelle trainer a small

02:54:47.276 --> 02:54:49.276
business owner and home school

02:54:49.578 --> 02:54:52.413
mom from contra costa county and
and the director of a local home

02:54:53.150 --> 02:54:55.150
school group east contra costa

02:54:55.651 --> 02:54:57.651
explorers. And as a group we do

02:54:57.686 --> 02:54:59.320
oppose ab twenty seven fifty six
as amended thank you for your

02:54:59.820 --> 02:55:02.190
time.
Burger barnes real home school

02:55:02.190 --> 02:55:04.190
california.

02:55:04.224 --> 02:55:06.527
I put.
Hi I'm the last person from the

02:55:09.731 --> 02:55:11.731
hallway.

02:55:11.733 --> 02:55:13.767
My name is christina sonus I
have been filing of private

02:55:14.369 --> 02:55:16.870
school affidavit since two
thousand two I still I'm filing

02:55:17.238 --> 02:55:20.173
it now for my twelve year old I
represent tri valley explorers.

02:55:20.875 --> 02:55:22.875
In alameda contra costa

02:55:23.142 --> 02:55:25.944
california and six hundred forty
families strong and we oppose

02:55:26.779 --> 02:55:29.549
this bill as amended thank you
for your time today. Thank you.

02:55:31.218 --> 02:55:33.387
.
I've heard so.

02:55:33.387 --> 02:55:36.322
It's not it's not a sports event.
.
But with that.

02:55:36.822 --> 02:55:38.822
Any comments

02:55:39.458 --> 02:55:41.458
for many the committee.

02:55:44.831 --> 02:55:46.298
Good Mister Kiley.
Well first of all.

02:55:47.499 --> 02:55:49.435
I wanna say thank you to all of
the educators

02:55:50.203 --> 02:55:52.203
and parents.

02:55:52.339 --> 02:55:54.473
Especially students.
You came from all around the

02:55:54.641 --> 02:55:56.608
state to the capital the eight
remind us that we are a

02:55:57.142 --> 02:55:59.111
government of. For and by the
people.

02:56:00.814 --> 02:56:03.180
Very important.
I wanna thank you for sharing

02:56:03.883 --> 02:56:05.883
your experiences I wanna thank.

02:56:05.885 --> 02:56:08.120
All of the thousands of home
school families throughout

02:56:09.322 --> 02:56:11.322
california. Who have made calls

02:56:12.992 --> 02:56:15.627
who have written letters who
organized
to make your voice heard and to
fight for your rights?

02:56:17.563 --> 02:56:20.265
It's been truly inspiring to see.
And we have such wonderful home

02:56:20.733 --> 02:56:22.733
school families just this last

02:56:23.402 --> 02:56:25.902
weekend aye judged aye. Public
speaking and debating tournament

02:56:26.605 --> 02:56:28.974
for aye for home school students
and man with these kids are

02:56:28.974 --> 02:56:30.974
impressive.

02:56:30.976 --> 02:56:33.945
I gotta say.
I so I am.

02:56:34.946 --> 02:56:37.615
And mr medina I just had a few
questions on this and I.

02:56:38.417 --> 02:56:41.151
I appreciate the you've amended
your bill and thank goodness.

02:56:41.418 --> 02:56:44.288
That other bill that was out
there.
Is gone.

02:56:44.889 --> 02:56:46.990
.
And you know you're someone that

02:56:47.692 --> 02:56:50.327
I I respect and I know that
you've taken the time to. To

02:56:51.429 --> 02:56:54.296
listen to all the people.
Who are opposed here I'm so I'm

02:56:54.399 --> 02:56:56.298
just curious sort of what you've
taken away from those

02:56:56.467 --> 02:56:59.200
conversations what your
understanding is as to why you

02:56:59.837 --> 02:57:02.106
think? Of all of the folks who
showed up today feel so strongly

02:57:02.106 --> 02:57:04.106
about what you're trying to do

02:57:05.709 --> 02:57:07.911
here.
Thank you Mister Kiley thank you

02:57:08.712 --> 02:57:10.712
for your comments.

02:57:11.415 --> 02:57:13.784
I did I stood here I listen to
every single comment.

02:57:13.784 --> 02:57:15.685
I I'm grateful.
.

02:57:16.218 --> 02:57:18.218
To hear.

02:57:20.390 --> 02:57:22.591
.
I I do not believe it is

02:57:23.727 --> 02:57:25.894
possible.
For government.

02:57:25.894 --> 02:57:28.230
To.
.

02:57:29.199 --> 02:57:31.899
legislate.
Away

02:57:33.169 --> 02:57:35.936
problems of our society.
But.

02:57:37.707 --> 02:57:39.707
When the turbine case happened.

02:57:39.774 --> 02:57:42.678
In and in the in the district
that I represent in the sixty

02:57:43.946 --> 02:57:45.946
first assembly district.

02:57:46.140 --> 02:57:48.140
A in the city of paris.

02:57:48.784 --> 02:57:50.784
I like many others.

02:57:51.419 --> 02:57:53.419
In my district look for.

02:57:53.889 --> 02:57:55.889
Looked in the law.

02:57:56.692 --> 02:57:59.527
Looked for out what May have
been able to have been done.

02:58:02.631 --> 02:58:04.631
To have avoided that incident.

02:58:05.299 --> 02:58:07.299
And it was there that we saw.

02:58:08.103 --> 02:58:10.103
That it had been.

02:58:10.105 --> 02:58:12.105
By law put.

02:58:12.541 --> 02:58:15.409
On fire marshals.
That they were to inspect.

02:58:16.711 --> 02:58:18.711
Private schools of six or more.

02:58:19.413 --> 02:58:21.413
Individuals.

02:58:22.150 --> 02:58:24.150
And and again I I say and and

02:58:24.552 --> 02:58:27.321
and and I thank again of my
colleague. Mister Gallagher.

02:58:29.290 --> 02:58:31.992
In in in helping me realize that
as much as we might like to.

02:58:32.960 --> 02:58:35.294
It is not in the realm of
possibility to legislate.

02:58:36.564 --> 02:58:39.132
.
The kinds of things that we'd

02:58:40.101 --> 02:58:42.602
like to avoid sometimes.
But that was what led me to

02:58:43.370 --> 02:58:45.238
first the first bill which you
made reference to.

02:58:47.740 --> 02:58:49.740
.

02:58:50.440 --> 02:58:52.440
And so again in conversation aye

02:58:52.880 --> 02:58:55.781
aye as I stand here a in front.
Of this committee.

02:58:56.550 --> 02:58:58.550
And the the parents who have

02:58:59.451 --> 02:59:02.121
been here. I would look again.
For perhaps another way

02:59:02.454 --> 02:59:04.454
and I would implore.

02:59:04.491 --> 02:59:06.491
People.

02:59:06.626 --> 02:59:09.428
Not just home school parents
but all people.

02:59:10.797 --> 02:59:12.797
To be more vigilant.

02:59:13.320 --> 02:59:15.320
To be more engaged in what goes

02:59:15.235 --> 02:59:18.203
on around them.
To report.

02:59:19.205 --> 02:59:21.205
what they see?

02:59:21.874 --> 02:59:23.874
To.

02:59:24.243 --> 02:59:27.450
Not be so hesitant to just allow.
.

02:59:27.480 --> 02:59:30.348
Strange occurrences to happen
without.

02:59:31.116 --> 02:59:33.585
But no to find someone.
And and I think if that it

02:59:34.852 --> 02:59:36.852
would've happened in my city of

02:59:37.689 --> 02:59:40.658
paris that I represent perhaps.
Of what happened with the turban

02:59:41.460 --> 02:59:44.428
family could have been avoided.
So aye aye I will in my time in

02:59:46.310 --> 02:59:48.310
the legislature continue to work

02:59:48.330 --> 02:59:50.330
with any of my colleagues who

02:59:50.435 --> 02:59:52.335
want to. A continue in that
effort I will continue to do

02:59:53.271 --> 02:59:55.271
that.

02:59:55.707 --> 02:59:57.707
However.

02:59:58.610 --> 03:00:00.778
In this bill.
In this bill twenty seven fifty

03:00:01.179 --> 03:00:03.179
six

03:00:03.181 --> 03:00:05.820
I would remind this committee
what it does and what it doesn't

03:00:06.517 --> 03:00:08.517
do.

03:00:08.953 --> 03:00:11.154
And and if I might.
In closing unless you have other

03:00:13.524 --> 03:00:15.524
questions.

03:00:17.493 --> 03:00:19.996
Well well of stuff there that.
I think that everyone here on

03:00:20.431 --> 03:00:22.766
it knowledge is how terrible the
incident that that you refer to
is.

03:00:22.766 --> 03:00:24.766
.

03:00:25.469 --> 03:00:28.337
But.
I think everyone also
acknowledges that that's an

03:00:30.730 --> 03:00:32.730
extreme out wire case.

03:00:32.142 --> 03:00:35.440
And any data set will have
extreme out wire cases.

03:00:35.611 --> 03:00:37.313
And its not generally
responsible policy making in my

03:00:38.810 --> 03:00:40.810
view.

03:00:40.684 --> 03:00:43.552
To create policy. On the basis
of the extreme out lyer case as

03:00:44.988 --> 03:00:46.988
oppose to. A looking at the

03:00:47.824 --> 03:00:50.691
entire population so I I mean
what problem is it that you see.

03:00:51.394 --> 03:00:53.962
In the home school community as
a whole.

03:00:54.797 --> 03:00:57.632
that this bill would solve. Aye
I do not see a problem. In the

03:00:58.933 --> 03:01:00.933
homeschool community at all as I

03:01:01.704 --> 03:01:03.704
said it my beginning. I respect.

03:01:03.739 --> 03:01:05.739
Parents as educators.

03:01:06.207 --> 03:01:08.207
Being an educator myself I I do

03:01:08.277 --> 03:01:11.110
not see a problem I I was trying
to. Remember.

03:01:11.180 --> 03:01:13.915
.
Gentleman who I.

03:01:15.840 --> 03:01:17.618
Had the opportunity to hear as
valid as a commencement.

03:01:18.520 --> 03:01:20.520
.

03:01:21.356 --> 03:01:23.356
Address at last year university

03:01:24.590 --> 03:01:26.727
of a young man. Of his name is
jeremiah purdy.

03:01:28.497 --> 03:01:30.698
Jeremiah purdy was home schooled.
He then went on.

03:01:31.320 --> 03:01:33.680
To prestigious private school
after that

03:01:33.680 --> 03:01:35.568
and.
Graduated.

03:01:36.704 --> 03:01:38.704
Law school I believe a dukw.

03:01:39.172 --> 03:01:41.407
And jeremiah purdy came and gave
the commencement address at last

03:01:42.800 --> 03:01:44.770
year university.
I think I've read two of his

03:01:44.379 --> 03:01:47.140
books now.
Up so I do not see a problem.

03:01:47.140 --> 03:01:49.950
With home schooling.
And.

03:01:50.785 --> 03:01:52.785
It this bill is not an attempt.

03:01:54.789 --> 03:01:56.789
To.

03:01:56.924 --> 03:01:58.924
Anyway attack home schooling.

03:01:59.159 --> 03:02:01.961
At all.
A it is not an intent.

03:02:02.162 --> 03:02:04.162
Solve a problem with home

03:02:06.565 --> 03:02:08.967
schooling.
So I guess what is that what is

03:02:09.200 --> 03:02:10.368
the point of the bill then we're
going to be.

03:02:11.905 --> 03:02:14.473
Collecting more information
about.
The.

03:02:14.708 --> 03:02:16.708
The nature.

03:02:18.512 --> 03:02:20.613
Of of each individual school on.
And what use is going to be made

03:02:21.348 --> 03:02:24.316
about information.
In my effort to.

03:02:25.952 --> 03:02:27.953
To look at what we do and what
we don't do. In the state of

03:02:27.954 --> 03:02:29.954
california.

03:02:30.523 --> 03:02:32.524
I.
Was looked somewhat.
.

03:02:34.160 --> 03:02:36.160
But.

03:02:36.728 --> 03:02:38.728
Somewhat surprised by the fact

03:02:38.930 --> 03:02:41.299
that we have no record at all
actually.

03:02:41.834 --> 03:02:44.536
Of numbers
of our parents

03:02:45.538 --> 03:02:47.972
who home school their children
I I believe that even in the

03:02:48.674 --> 03:02:51.442
staff analysis.
In the committee announces the

03:02:51.910 --> 03:02:53.910
number that is presented there

03:02:54.346 --> 03:02:56.881
is is a number that in my
understanding.

03:02:57.648 --> 03:03:00.551
Is only.
A sort of exasperated is only

03:03:01.353 --> 03:03:04.188
just
taken out of the data.

03:03:04.422 --> 03:03:07.258
Because there and I have right
here.

03:03:08.925 --> 03:03:10.925
The affidavit form.

03:03:11.960 --> 03:03:13.960
Parents fill out and no where on

03:03:13.665 --> 03:03:15.665
this forum is there anywhere to

03:03:16.234 --> 03:03:18.234
put. That they are home school.

03:03:18.336 --> 03:03:20.336
It only shows that there are.

03:03:20.571 --> 03:03:22.571
In a private school.

03:03:24.410 --> 03:03:26.576
So we do not have. Any.
Reliable number.

03:03:27.378 --> 03:03:29.444
At all.
Of how many.

03:03:30.481 --> 03:03:32.481
Parents or how many young

03:03:32.483 --> 03:03:34.483
people are home school.

03:03:35.386 --> 03:03:38.321
So that is why I said yeah in
your in answering your question.

03:03:38.989 --> 03:03:41.824
To be cognizant of what this
bill.

03:03:43.627 --> 03:03:45.627
Tries to do and doesn't do.

03:03:47.779 --> 03:03:50.320
And all it is.
Trying to do all that it asks
for.

03:03:51.334 --> 03:03:53.601
It just aggregate.
Home schooling from other

03:03:53.737 --> 03:03:55.737
private schools.

03:03:56.172 --> 03:03:58.240
And gives.
Five different a options

03:03:59.700 --> 03:04:01.700
the parents.

03:04:01.211 --> 03:04:03.211
could I read those options.

03:04:03.880 --> 03:04:06.447
Those options.
Our conventional for traditional

03:04:07.617 --> 03:04:09.618
private school.
Private schools satellite

03:04:11.286 --> 03:04:13.286
program.

03:04:13.656 --> 03:04:15.656
Private online or villages or

03:04:16.250 --> 03:04:18.893
virtual school.
Parent guardian or other

03:04:20.529 --> 03:04:22.529
individual operating a private

03:04:22.932 --> 03:04:25.533
home school.
Certified non public non

03:04:26.235 --> 03:04:28.235
sectarian

03:04:29.603 --> 03:04:32.573
school so would broaden.
Give more detailed information

03:04:33.609 --> 03:04:36.100
on the type.
School that young people are

03:04:39.347 --> 03:04:41.148
receiving.
My question though is.

03:04:41.516 --> 03:04:43.217
You know usually when we're
collecting.

03:04:43.785 --> 03:04:45.519
Data or information we do so
for a reason

03:04:46.755 --> 03:04:48.755
so what is the. Reason that we

03:04:49.322 --> 03:04:51.580
need to have this disaggregated
data what are we planning to do

03:04:51.559 --> 03:04:53.559
with I I I think it would give a

03:04:53.661 --> 03:04:56.530
better picture. Of of the
educational a landscape in the

03:04:56.697 --> 03:04:58.697
state of california.

03:04:59.100 --> 03:05:00.799
I I'd.
I disagree that.

03:05:01.801 --> 03:05:04.537
.
There's any sinister.

03:05:05.906 --> 03:05:07.540
Purpose for it.
A matter of fact

03:05:09.476 --> 03:05:11.476
a.

03:05:11.712 --> 03:05:14.380
Except reduce abrogating that
information up all that other

03:05:15.949 --> 03:05:17.949
information is already share. On

03:05:20.454 --> 03:05:23.321
the affidavit.
Well.

03:05:23.957 --> 03:05:26.250
Aye I you know I I very much do
appreciate that you've narrowed

03:05:26.593 --> 03:05:28.794
your bill but I think that when
you look at what's concerning

03:05:29.663 --> 03:05:31.731
folks here is that I think we
saw a little bit of the intense

03:05:31.731 --> 03:05:34.100
when we have a much broader
legislation.

03:05:34.100 --> 03:05:36.536
and I think that all the folks
who.

03:05:36.536 --> 03:05:38.536
Took time out of their day and

03:05:39.205 --> 03:05:41.205
traveled a long ways to be here.

03:05:41.274 --> 03:05:44.900
Feel like they're being
targeted unfairly and.

03:05:44.410 --> 03:05:46.945
And I think the right and that
you know as I said I I really

03:05:46.946 --> 03:05:49.449
respect your thinking a lot of
great contributions but I'm

03:05:49.449 --> 03:05:51.882
deeply troubled.
By the direction of this

03:05:53.152 --> 03:05:55.820
legislation and I think could be.
You know a great act for you

03:05:56.120 --> 03:05:59.570
that to be considerate and
abandon the this point so I I

03:06:00.590 --> 03:06:02.628
strongly encourage you to do so.
And if not encourage the

03:06:02.628 --> 03:06:05.329
committee to vote the bill down
thank you.
Thank you any other comments

03:06:05.864 --> 03:06:07.432
from the committee. A the seeing
nine.

03:06:08.467 --> 03:06:11.135
You we won't take motion right
now but you make clothes.

03:06:11.570 --> 03:06:14.237
I I would like to close and.
.

03:06:14.573 --> 03:06:16.840
As a the committee considers the
bill.

03:06:16.840 --> 03:06:18.840
I I want to.

03:06:19.144 --> 03:06:21.912
.
Close with a quote.

03:06:23.748 --> 03:06:25.748
And james madison.

03:06:26.417 --> 03:06:28.417
Federalist number fifty one.

03:06:28.686 --> 03:06:30.686
And he says famously.

03:06:30.788 --> 03:06:32.788
That of men were angels no

03:06:33.291 --> 03:06:35.291
government would be necessary.

03:06:36.527 --> 03:06:39.496
So as much as a.
You know we look for the best.

03:06:40.731 --> 03:06:42.731
Society.

03:06:43.300 --> 03:06:45.300
Sometimes it is the duty of

03:06:46.235 --> 03:06:48.471
government. A to intervene.
I respectfully ask the committee

03:06:49.730 --> 03:06:52.400
for and I've.
Thank you mr medina.

03:06:52.543 --> 03:06:54.310
And to those who came today
thank you for being part of the

03:06:55.450 --> 03:06:57.246
process we're not going to take
a vote how because we do not yet

03:06:58.448 --> 03:07:01.350
have a quorum in this committee.
so that vote will take later.

03:07:01.618 --> 03:07:03.953
Take place later this evening is
looking like now.

03:07:04.754 --> 03:07:06.422
With thank you for one of the
longer hearings have

03:07:07.590 --> 03:07:09.590
participated in.

03:07:09.659 --> 03:07:11.193
Period.
Ever.

03:07:12.495 --> 03:07:15.265
So so thank you thank you
Mister Medina thank you for

03:07:15.265 --> 03:07:17.265
presenting your bill again that

03:07:17.634 --> 03:07:19.368
vote will take place later. And
I don't think the sergeants who

03:07:19.802 --> 03:07:22.700
are here who helped guide
everybody and I'll help keep us

03:07:23.206 --> 03:07:25.407
very efficient. Today I two
microphones I haven't seen that

03:07:25.541 --> 03:07:27.309
before go that was very
effective I don't know who

03:07:29.770 --> 03:07:30.712
thought that that great maneuver.
So thank you are sergeants out

03:07:31.213 --> 03:07:33.914
there to.
But that a. I will turn over the

03:07:34.515 --> 03:07:36.784
Chairman Present a bill.
And then we're gonna go to

03:07:52.234 --> 03:07:54.234
Mister Arambula after that

03:08:09.951 --> 03:08:11.951
please keep moving out of your.

03:08:20.294 --> 03:08:23.290
You're exiting.
Ab twenty four eighty eight ab

03:08:23.430 --> 03:08:25.430
twenty four eighty eight.

03:08:28.602 --> 03:08:31.337
I Mister At all.
This item number fourteen

03:08:32.306 --> 03:08:34.306
assembly bill twenty four eighty

03:08:34.574 --> 03:08:36.509
eight by Mister O'donnell.
Thank you Mister Chair and

03:08:36.977 --> 03:08:38.978
members I would like to accept
the amendments identified in the

03:08:40.247 --> 03:08:42.247
committee analysis.

03:08:42.882 --> 03:08:44.882
A very capable committee staff.

03:08:45.117 --> 03:08:47.453
And chief of staff I guess to.
Ab twenty four eight

03:08:48.870 --> 03:08:50.522
establishes a pilot project for
the los angeles unified school

03:08:51.240 --> 03:08:53.590
district use task order
contracting.

03:08:53.660 --> 03:08:55.660
Again that's task order

03:08:56.129 --> 03:08:58.230
contracting similar to job order
contracting which allows come

03:08:58.631 --> 03:09:00.631
which is the committee has

03:09:00.733 --> 03:09:03.268
previously supported. La a a la
u. S. D. Will be allowed to go

03:09:03.669 --> 03:09:06.436
out to bid on contracts for
services and repairs. Before

03:09:06.906 --> 03:09:09.841
they are needed.
For example during the hot

03:09:10.509 --> 03:09:13.411
season hvac systems will break
down.

03:09:13.479 --> 03:09:15.479
Going out of it after a quick

03:09:15.981 --> 03:09:18.715
mint nam functions takes time
and will likely be costly.

03:09:19.785 --> 03:09:21.785
Simple supply and demand concept

03:09:21.887 --> 03:09:24.589
applies here. Delay repairs May
affect instruction and students

03:09:24.589 --> 03:09:26.589
ability to learn that's a no

03:09:26.590 --> 03:09:28.826
brainer. I bend a hundred ten
degree classroom.

03:09:30.280 --> 03:09:32.763
You know that's not a. Healthy
situation for learning or.

03:09:33.732 --> 03:09:35.933
People ought delay in repairs
May affect construction and

03:09:36.320 --> 03:09:39.200
students ability to learn of
course as I stated a by having

03:09:39.704 --> 03:09:42.390
contracts in place earlier.
This bill will enable elitist

03:09:42.140 --> 03:09:44.140
you to respond to requests

03:09:44.709 --> 03:09:46.810
repairs when they are needed and
will say the district money

03:09:47.745 --> 03:09:50.180
because the prices are pre.
Determined.

03:09:50.713 --> 03:09:53.216
Testifying in support is mark
hoping to hook.

03:09:54.218 --> 03:09:57.860
Who better the chief facilities
executive with the los angeles

03:09:57.954 --> 03:09:59.923
unified school district and with
that I turned over and I hope I

03:10:00.157 --> 03:10:01.824
said your name correctly and I
don't please correct?

03:10:02.391 --> 03:10:05.161
And I don't know.
Well marc cooper who we have an

03:10:05.594 --> 03:10:07.663
excellent in house work force
that does our maintenance and

03:10:08.980 --> 03:10:10.600
repair work.
But there are some situations

03:10:11.601 --> 03:10:13.601
when we need more. Than that to

03:10:14.370 --> 03:10:16.370
maintain our thousand campuses.

03:10:16.172 --> 03:10:18.507
Our. Thirteen thousand buildings
thirty thousand classrooms.

03:10:19.308 --> 03:10:21.577
Sometimes.
The workload just exceeds our

03:10:21.746 --> 03:10:24.213
capacity to work with our in
house staff it's not practical

03:10:24.981 --> 03:10:27.783
to have workers on staff
anticipated the seasonal loading

03:10:28.418 --> 03:10:30.986
that we might have.
I'm sometimes we need special up

03:10:31.320 --> 03:10:33.550
specialized skillsets but we
don't need him on a recurring

03:10:33.923 --> 03:10:36.525
basis of doesn't make sense to
have that staff on board so we

03:10:37.693 --> 03:10:40.280
have to. Look seek other means
it's not practical for us to own

03:10:40.596 --> 03:10:42.596
specialized equipment like

03:10:42.898 --> 03:10:45.990
cranes and people laughs more
specialized boring equipment.

03:10:45.100 --> 03:10:47.936
So when we need.
To have this

03:10:48.571 --> 03:10:50.772
extra help for our workforce we
have to look to the industry to

03:10:52.207 --> 03:10:54.809
contract out. Now there are.
I'm provisions now that allow us

03:10:55.444 --> 03:10:57.444
to contracted out but it's not

03:10:57.911 --> 03:11:00.848
as efficient as we could have.
Come there times when.

03:11:01.116 --> 03:11:03.651
If we contract out it might take
us longer to go get that work

03:11:03.750 --> 03:11:05.750
done because we have to go

03:11:07.901 --> 03:11:10.570
through a bidding process that
could be me clarifications
requested. Usually when we have
this requirement we need help

03:11:11.920 --> 03:11:13.920
it's urgent. And we need to have

03:11:13.226 --> 03:11:16.630
it right away it costs us more
because it's seasonal it when

03:11:16.331 --> 03:11:18.230
air conditioning goes out
usually lots of other peoples

03:11:18.533 --> 03:11:20.901
are commission got more now
competing for the contract to

03:11:21.436 --> 03:11:23.468
have his work done.
And it doesn't always give us

03:11:24.380 --> 03:11:26.606
the highest qualities I'm
sometimes we specify what we

03:11:26.874 --> 03:11:28.874
believe is the best product for

03:11:29.210 --> 03:11:31.378
material. But contractors can
come in and request a

03:11:31.745 --> 03:11:34.714
substitution of that material
wealth it's urgent for us we
don't have time to go through

03:11:35.282 --> 03:11:38.219
that evaluation process and we
have to just accept.
Something that might not be the

03:11:38.419 --> 03:11:40.419
best.

03:11:40.554 --> 03:11:42.321
I'm this bill we would still be
required to follow public

03:11:42.988 --> 03:11:45.458
contract code.
We actually like the process

03:11:46.393 --> 03:11:48.794
where we award the lowest
responsive responsible better.

03:11:49.162 --> 03:11:51.197
We just believe it would be nice
if we could do all of that

03:11:52.365 --> 03:11:55.200
preliminary work to establish.
Who that contractors gonna be

03:11:55.402 --> 03:11:57.402
prior to us needing the urgent

03:11:57.469 --> 03:11:59.571
work?
We got enough historical data

03:12:00.730 --> 03:12:02.441
now to know that we're gonna
have a couple dozen compressors

03:12:03.420 --> 03:12:05.309
that are gonna go out. We know
trees are gonna fall down we

03:12:05.378 --> 03:12:07.579
know plumbing is gonna break
which don't know which of our

03:12:08.281 --> 03:12:10.816
one thousand campuses it's going
to happen on we don't know
nguyen.

03:12:11.717 --> 03:12:13.952
But with this legislation we can
have all that work done in

03:12:14.887 --> 03:12:17.255
advance were prepared to it
immediately and urgently do that.

03:12:18.357 --> 03:12:20.258
And we would we believe other
people could benefit from this

03:12:20.392 --> 03:12:22.460
as well and would love the
opportunity to be able to

03:12:23.227 --> 03:12:25.227
demonstrate to this legislation

03:12:25.297 --> 03:12:27.297
that we can do it. Faster we can

03:12:27.766 --> 03:12:29.767
do it more costly effectively
and we can do with better

03:12:31.937 --> 03:12:34.380
quality. Thank you.
I wouldn't take a moment to

03:12:34.940 --> 03:12:36.906
establish a quorum and I'm
secretary please call the roll.

03:12:37.542 --> 03:12:39.542
O'donnell.

03:12:39.811 --> 03:12:42.313
Here. O'donnell here kiley their
family here kalra.
Pardee

03:12:43.481 --> 03:12:45.348
steinorth.
Steinorth here thurmond.

03:12:46.170 --> 03:12:48.170
Weber.

03:12:48.153 --> 03:12:50.786
I hear.
Thank you I do have other
witnesses in support of this

03:12:53.823 --> 03:12:55.392
measure.
are there any witnesses in

03:12:59.697 --> 03:13:02.330
opposition.
Anyone is in opposition op

03:13:02.330 --> 03:13:04.330
questions or comments for

03:13:05.268 --> 03:13:07.237
committee members.
Mister O'donnell would you like

03:13:07.538 --> 03:13:10.240
to close by thank you Mister
Chair this.
Bill is very simple.

03:13:11.275 --> 03:13:13.643
When one roof leaks in a school
district many roofs leak.

03:13:14.780 --> 03:13:16.544
One one air conditioner breaks
down on one side many air

03:13:16.847 --> 03:13:18.981
conditioners breakdown so this
is an attempt to address that

03:13:20.684 --> 03:13:22.351
more creative manner. Than we
have in the past aye aspirin aye

03:13:22.686 --> 03:13:24.887
vote.
We have a motion to have a
second.

03:13:25.822 --> 03:13:28.491
And I would say before actually
out we get to the vowed that I I

03:13:29.920 --> 03:13:31.193
think this is. A good idea
unfortunately I'm not be to

03:13:31.194 --> 03:13:33.395
support the bill because of the
requirement for a project labor

03:13:34.431 --> 03:13:36.932
agreement I think that it's time
when a lot of our districts are
struggling.

03:13:38.100 --> 03:13:40.235
Financially it's not good to
impose extra cost it'll just

03:13:41.638 --> 03:13:43.303
benefit one special interest
group but we have a motion and a

03:13:44.906 --> 03:13:47.741
second.
Second. We have a second out of

03:13:49.944 --> 03:13:52.781
seventy please call the roll.
O'donnell aye o'donnell aye
kiley.

03:13:53.916 --> 03:13:56.718
Number.
Kiley not voting. Kalra.

03:13:57.686 --> 03:13:59.686
Mccarty.

03:14:00.456 --> 03:14:02.456
Steinorth aye steinorth aye

03:14:04.493 --> 03:14:07.195
thurmond. Weber. Aye weber aye.
The bill is on hall I had this.

03:14:07.461 --> 03:14:09.461
Are you come back Mister

03:14:23.645 --> 03:14:25.780
O'donnell
.

03:14:25.713 --> 03:14:28.415
Thank you we're now going to go
to Mister. Arambula few.

03:14:29.450 --> 03:14:31.918
Come up.
again we have two witnesses two

03:14:32.420 --> 03:14:34.420
minutes each.

03:14:35.857 --> 03:14:37.857
And mr rambo the.

03:14:37.959 --> 03:14:39.959
I have no idea. Where we?

03:14:41.600 --> 03:14:43.597
File item number five a. B..
Two thousand two.

03:14:43.597 --> 03:14:45.799
Thank you Mister Chair and
members.

03:14:46.734 --> 03:14:49.335
Ab two thousand and two directs
the instructional quality

03:14:50.137 --> 03:14:52.805
commission and the state board
to develop model curriculum for

03:14:52.938 --> 03:14:55.508
my long history and cultural
studies.

03:14:56.141 --> 03:14:58.543
Under existing law the
legislature has encouraged

03:14:59.946 --> 03:15:01.946
instruction in social sciences

03:15:01.948 --> 03:15:03.948
that May or May not include

03:15:04.383 --> 03:15:06.383
construction on the vietnam war.

03:15:07.419 --> 03:15:09.855
Including the secret war in laos
and the role of the southeast

03:15:10.957 --> 03:15:12.957
asians in this war.

03:15:16.261 --> 03:15:18.862
As a result textbook publishers.
Have not included among

03:15:19.565 --> 03:15:21.565
contributions to the secret war

03:15:21.834 --> 03:15:24.370
in laos. Leaving students
largely unaware.

03:15:24.370 --> 03:15:27.172
Of this part of our american
history.

03:15:27.974 --> 03:15:29.974
I believe it is imperative that

03:15:30.176 --> 03:15:32.176
students have the opportunity to

03:15:32.745 --> 03:15:34.679
learn about and to develop a
deeper understanding and

03:15:36.315 --> 03:15:39.217
appreciation of the sacrifices
and service of them long and

03:15:39.351 --> 03:15:41.919
loud veterans. And their
contributions to the united

03:15:43.880 --> 03:15:45.389
states move the bill according
to the twenty ten census

03:15:46.792 --> 03:15:48.792
california has the largest mon

03:15:48.827 --> 03:15:51.729
population in the united states.
With over approximately one

03:15:53.331 --> 03:15:55.331
hundred thousand residents.

03:15:55.699 --> 03:15:57.699
Fresno is home to approximately

03:15:58.300 --> 03:16:00.237
thirty two thousand moan and has
the second largest long

03:16:00.839 --> 03:16:03.707
population in our country after
minneapolis.

03:16:04.409 --> 03:16:06.409
California's central valley has

03:16:07.145 --> 03:16:09.145
over forty seven thousand mon.

03:16:09.147 --> 03:16:12.150
the money people have a story of
courage and suffering that

03:16:12.650 --> 03:16:14.451
should be incorporated into our
curriculum and taught to

03:16:15.186 --> 03:16:17.186
students.

03:16:17.388 --> 03:16:20.190
Most students know nothing about
my own history or culture and I

03:16:20.958 --> 03:16:23.658
believe model curriculum will
help students appreciate long

03:16:25.290 --> 03:16:26.996
history and culture. Especially
in regions with large mung

03:16:27.765 --> 03:16:30.298
populations.
The monk people have made

03:16:31.268 --> 03:16:33.903
significant sacrifices and are a
rich part of our community and

03:16:34.605 --> 03:16:37.538
our state.
Ab two thousand two will provide

03:16:39.420 --> 03:16:41.844
educators with the tools to help
educate california's students

03:16:42.445 --> 03:16:45.379
about the contributions of the
money people so their sacrifices

03:16:46.214 --> 03:16:48.214
are not forgotten.

03:16:48.617 --> 03:16:51.253
Today I have church I. Bang
President Of the lao veterans of

03:16:52.420 --> 03:16:55.550
america who also served as
lieutenant in the secret war in

03:16:56.125 --> 03:16:58.527
laos. And millennial yang the
students from clovis east high

03:17:02.965 --> 03:17:04.965
school to testify in support.

03:17:05.201 --> 03:17:07.934
Good afternoon.
Honorable Chairman.

03:17:09.772 --> 03:17:11.772
O'donnell and.

03:17:12.708 --> 03:17:15.676
Committee. Members.
My manager type bang.

03:17:17.646 --> 03:17:19.646
President. National headquarters

03:17:19.915 --> 03:17:22.750
odd de la veteran up by america
incorporation.

03:17:23.852 --> 03:17:25.852
We are based in fresno.

03:17:26.188 --> 03:17:28.823
California I'm here on to be
have our basic thousand mon.

03:17:29.324 --> 03:17:31.324
Veterans

03:17:32.590 --> 03:17:34.995
supporting ab two thousand two.
This bill is.

03:17:36.131 --> 03:17:38.898
Important to the monk community
because of the los.

03:17:40.435 --> 03:17:42.435
I recognize all veteran who have

03:17:42.870 --> 03:17:44.871
sacrificed their life.
For the sake of freedom and

03:17:46.140 --> 03:17:48.140
democracy.

03:17:48.142 --> 03:17:50.142
It is important that america and

03:17:51.212 --> 03:17:53.212
no food among people are.

03:17:53.247 --> 03:17:56.820
And that over thirty thousand
soldier lost their life.

03:17:57.318 --> 03:17:59.719
During their secret war in laos
fighting as our ally of the

03:18:01.322 --> 03:18:04.230
united states.
I myself have serving a secret

03:18:04.324 --> 03:18:07.292
wall.
From not in fact different I

03:18:07.961 --> 03:18:09.961
think them defy.

03:18:11.296 --> 03:18:13.296
I was recruited it is seventeen.

03:18:13.700 --> 03:18:16.669
Biased dates here a and serve
and the second on me. Region

03:18:17.336 --> 03:18:19.805
under commended joe knowing
power.

03:18:20.540 --> 03:18:23.308
I was captured toys by committee
tropes.

03:18:24.176 --> 03:18:26.176
At any one time was tie up for

03:18:26.246 --> 03:18:28.812
nine days.
Where I have to chiu britain

03:18:29.614 --> 03:18:31.614
life and that?

03:18:32.318 --> 03:18:34.318
I was blessed to escape from

03:18:34.652 --> 03:18:36.652
captivity and sadly have to

03:18:37.423 --> 03:18:40.258
leave my home country.
Behind to come to the united

03:18:41.961 --> 03:18:44.729
states when my widow martha.
And four brothers.

03:18:47.266 --> 03:18:49.266
My father was also a soldier.

03:18:49.835 --> 03:18:51.835
In the wall and was killed when

03:18:52.336 --> 03:18:54.336
I was twelve years old.

03:18:55.274 --> 03:18:57.742
As of today there is state owned
no curriculum being poll.

03:18:59.745 --> 03:19:01.912
Regarding amongst in roman and
it's a great war in laos.

03:19:02.881 --> 03:19:04.881
Well the vietnam war conflict.

03:19:04.916 --> 03:19:07.751
Address.
Address and adequately and

03:19:08.119 --> 03:19:10.119
President.

03:19:11.655 --> 03:19:13.655
Us history class.

03:19:13.925 --> 03:19:15.925
Ab two thousand tower.

03:19:17.128 --> 03:19:19.930
How oh children and california?
To have a better understanding

03:19:22.660 --> 03:19:24.660
of their moms contribution fake

03:19:25.770 --> 03:19:28.438
tour de sica y. Summarize.
Low and more and I'm a complete

03:19:28.806 --> 03:19:31.674
vote yes in support of ab
propellant to. Thank you for

03:19:32.877 --> 03:19:34.877
allowing me to speak here today

03:19:35.746 --> 03:19:37.580
thank you well done.
Good afternoon honorable

03:19:38.182 --> 03:19:40.616
chairman o'donnell and members
of the education committee my

03:19:41.500 --> 03:19:43.420
name is melanie yeah I'm a
senior clovis these high school

03:19:43.420 --> 03:19:45.688
as a student and the
granddaughter of among better

03:19:45.956 --> 03:19:48.190
and I want to express the
importance of having in long

03:19:48.992 --> 03:19:51.761
history curriculum. Tie indicate
to twelve classrooms growing up

03:19:52.280 --> 03:19:54.280
I knew little of my heritage and

03:19:54.640 --> 03:19:56.265
was not fund of my ethnicity I
felt out of place and dislike

03:19:56.833 --> 03:19:59.768
being moved among my american
pairs. It was until recently

03:19:59.903 --> 03:20:01.969
that I became more aware of my
history through involvement in

03:20:02.305 --> 03:20:04.540
the mall community thinking gee
appreciated it is a unique

03:20:05.241 --> 03:20:07.743
culture and one with interesting
stories. Just last month in my

03:20:08.177 --> 03:20:10.879
english class you were given the
task constructed profile essay

03:20:11.914 --> 03:20:13.882
on any individual I decided to
highlight my maternal

03:20:14.217 --> 03:20:16.885
grandmother who remains a face a
little to this day because she

03:20:17.820 --> 03:20:20.322
still yearns for. And awaits the
return of her beloved husband.

03:20:21.880 --> 03:20:23.591
My grandpa he was a fighter
pilot in the war and his plane

03:20:26.295 --> 03:20:29.163
was shot down but his body never
recovered.
My grandmother's living story is

03:20:29.498 --> 03:20:32.200
one of remarkable string true
love and tremendous sacrifices

03:20:32.566 --> 03:20:35.403
as a single mother in the midst
of a long region more. Cover

03:20:36.104 --> 03:20:38.706
story is only one of many more
riveting stories dear to each

03:20:39.174 --> 03:20:41.575
month families heart. In doing
research for my assignment I was

03:20:42.430 --> 03:20:44.945
disappointed in a pots fine no
single sources available in my

03:20:45.480 --> 03:20:48.182
school library on the secret war
in laos. If I've eggman child's

03:20:48.917 --> 03:20:50.917
and not know about my people's

03:20:51.119 --> 03:20:52.986
history due to lack of were in
tax on this type at.

03:20:53.922 --> 03:20:56.240
I know there are many more out
there who have never heard of

03:20:56.240 --> 03:20:58.558
the moon and are just as
clueless I want the stories of

03:20:58.793 --> 03:21:01.195
my grandparents and the more
people to be told I want the

03:21:01.195 --> 03:21:03.195
world to know the correct

03:21:03.364 --> 03:21:05.799
sacrifices. Limon people made to
upload american ideals and

03:21:06.300 --> 03:21:09.202
incredible journey they took to
reach a new land while leaving

03:21:09.436 --> 03:21:11.871
behind all their valuables.
Chairman O'donnell and members

03:21:12.206 --> 03:21:14.707
you have the power and
responsibility to make decisions

03:21:14.942 --> 03:21:17.430
that have lasting impact on
student learning and on the

03:21:17.711 --> 03:21:20.313
development of our future
generations of america I

03:21:20.395 --> 03:21:23.182
respectfully urge you to vote
yes. In support of ab two

03:21:23.717 --> 03:21:26.385
thousand two today thank you
thank you well done others in

03:21:27.421 --> 03:21:29.923
support make a monthly their
name and because
position. Your name.

03:21:29.923 --> 03:21:31.923
Affiliation imposition of the

03:21:33.260 --> 03:21:35.561
bill.
Hello my name is cleared allow I

03:21:36.196 --> 03:21:38.430
am I I sit on the board for mo
innovating politics here in

03:21:39.980 --> 03:21:41.500
sacramento. And.
We submitted a letter of

03:21:41.701 --> 03:21:44.269
support label we are here
support and believe this is part

03:21:44.670 --> 03:21:47.239
of the legislature's committee
our commitment to ethnic studies

03:21:49.141 --> 03:21:51.141
thank you.

03:21:51.344 --> 03:21:54.179
Hello my name is amy hang I'm on
I'm here on behalf of project

03:21:54.747 --> 03:21:57.647
prevention coalition from merced
california. We also wrote a

03:21:58.249 --> 03:22:00.483
letter of support for a the two
thousand two and we strongly

03:22:00.519 --> 03:22:02.519
support this bill thank you

03:22:02.788 --> 03:22:05.556
thank you.
Hello my name's nucci her I am

03:22:06.580 --> 03:22:08.525
also here on behalf of project
prevention coalition for merced

03:22:09.394 --> 03:22:11.596
california and a strong
supporter ab two thousand two

03:22:12.831 --> 03:22:15.990
thank you.
Hello my name is doable I'm a

03:22:15.901 --> 03:22:17.601
mother and a school
administrator in fresno unified

03:22:18.203 --> 03:22:20.203
school district and I strongly

03:22:21.239 --> 03:22:23.239
support ab two thousand two.

03:22:23.508 --> 03:22:25.375
Hello my name's la washoe bang.
And.

03:22:26.611 --> 03:22:28.611
La moment right there on

03:22:28.813 --> 03:22:30.813
chapter in sacramento I support

03:22:32.550 --> 03:22:34.651
these bear.
Erika often a behalf the

03:22:34.819 --> 03:22:36.819
california school boards

03:22:38.389 --> 03:22:40.557
association in support.
My name is gregory barnes I

03:22:40.958 --> 03:22:42.859
worked with la veterans of
america they're one of my

03:22:43.627 --> 03:22:46.196
clients and when I lived in
fresno ask this kind you

03:22:46.998 --> 03:22:48.998
recognize the mas contribution

03:22:49.500 --> 03:22:51.467
which is very strong.
Thank you at any opposition to

03:22:52.836 --> 03:22:55.705
the bill.
Seen opposition is for you

03:22:56.405 --> 03:22:58.374
behind the rail here. I'm I'll
just thank you for the bill

03:22:58.575 --> 03:23:01.242
thank you for the among
contributions to america. You

03:23:01.378 --> 03:23:04.180
you make this country a better
place for sure so thank you

03:23:04.414 --> 03:23:06.414
thank you for being here today.

03:23:06.783 --> 03:23:09.518
And a any opportunity to
educate our students more about

03:23:10.153 --> 03:23:12.322
your history really our history.
I think isa good thing so

03:23:12.322 --> 03:23:15.570
thank you for being here
advocating I don't see any

03:23:15.625 --> 03:23:18.160
comment from the committee. All
entertain a motion doctor weber

03:23:18.326 --> 03:23:21.630
moves.
She signed her seconds.

03:23:23.650 --> 03:23:25.650
You May close and the motion is

03:23:25.301 --> 03:23:27.801
a to pass to appropriations
thank you Mister Chair I just

03:23:28.170 --> 03:23:30.604
want to take this opportunity to
recognize the importance of our

03:23:31.507 --> 03:23:33.575
cultural diversity.
And how much strongermy

03:23:34.900 --> 03:23:36.443
community is for the long people
being a part of it.

03:23:37.790 --> 03:23:39.747
it is a proud moment for me to
be able to present this bill and

03:23:40.150 --> 03:23:42.750
I'm gracious that you have
allowed us this time. I humbly

03:23:44.720 --> 03:23:47.622
ask for a night of.
Do passed do appropriations

03:23:47.823 --> 03:23:49.824
o'donnell aye o'donnell aye
kiley.

03:23:49.923 --> 03:23:51.923
Kalra.

03:23:51.993 --> 03:23:53.993
Mccarty.

03:23:54.529 --> 03:23:56.529
Steinorth aye steinorth aye

03:23:56.831 --> 03:23:59.990
thurmond weber. Weber aye three
votes.

03:23:59.434 --> 03:24:01.702
So the bill's on because three
votes more members will come and

03:24:02.670 --> 03:24:05.400
I'm I'm very confident they'll
be supportive of this item. Is

03:24:05.106 --> 03:24:07.207
over there out there's a lot of
committees going on right now

03:24:07.408 --> 03:24:09.760
and I'm sure they'll come back
and they'll be very supportive

03:24:09.544 --> 03:24:11.544
this item so thank thank you

03:24:12.713 --> 03:24:15.315
again today. For presenting less.
Our next author is.

03:24:15.916 --> 03:24:18.218
Miss Rubio she us.
Three items she is item number

03:24:19.200 --> 03:24:21.755
twenty five thirty three in
number twelve so when we start

03:24:28.695 --> 03:24:31.297
with item number twenty five.
Ab two six nine eight you May

03:24:36.201 --> 03:24:39.171
proceed when reading.
Good afternoon.
Mister Chairman members I'd

03:24:39.438 --> 03:24:41.974
like to present my assembly bill
a twenty six ninety eight which

03:24:43.210 --> 03:24:45.511
is also a woman's caucus parity.
Bill that enables children in

03:24:45.644 --> 03:24:48.414
the california state preschool
program to benefit from early

03:24:48.480 --> 03:24:50.480
childhood mental health

03:24:50.682 --> 03:24:53.385
consultation. I accept the a a
committee amendments to further

03:24:53.718 --> 03:24:55.718
the intent of our bill by

03:24:55.888 --> 03:24:58.290
including children serving a
family childcare home setting.

03:24:58.323 --> 03:25:00.557
This bill is about getting
resources to children and

03:25:00.959 --> 03:25:02.959
helping to address challenging

03:25:03.296 --> 03:25:05.296
behaviors as well as preventing

03:25:05.331 --> 03:25:07.866
future academic expulsion. Where
simply authorizing providers to

03:25:09.135 --> 03:25:11.135
utilize existing subsidized

03:25:11.136 --> 03:25:13.300
childcare funding to provide
these valuable mental health

03:25:14.373 --> 03:25:16.374
services which research shows
will improve outcomes for

03:25:16.640 --> 03:25:18.640
children?

03:25:18.744 --> 03:25:21.379
Nationally three and four year
olds enrolled in pre k. X. Are

03:25:22.514 --> 03:25:25.810
expelled three point two times
more frequently than k. Twelve

03:25:25.751 --> 03:25:28.180
students while californians for
preschool.

03:25:28.753 --> 03:25:31.222
I've prefix also rates are even
higher them though the national

03:25:32.900 --> 03:25:34.900
average from this data because

03:25:34.125 --> 03:25:36.559
clued at that pre cakes potions
disproportionately a fret.

03:25:37.360 --> 03:25:40.130
Children of color this bill will
make it possible for providers

03:25:41.165 --> 03:25:42.998
to pursue effective early
childhood mental health

03:25:43.701 --> 03:25:46.690
consultation models which we
know in addition to the

03:25:46.604 --> 03:25:49.106
beneficial outcomes. Can help
with reducing expulsions with

03:25:49.307 --> 03:25:51.307
existing.

03:25:51.976 --> 03:25:53.710
Contact finds here with me today
is address particulate can

03:25:54.245 --> 03:25:56.179
battle the sponsor of the bill
to talk more about early

03:25:57.248 --> 03:25:59.749
childhood mental health sir.
Held consultations

03:26:01.117 --> 03:26:04.200
and pep pipping than I would
have a hard time men how lincoln

03:26:04.989 --> 03:26:06.289
bangles research specialist to
provide.

03:26:07.658 --> 03:26:09.658
Technical support thank you.

03:26:10.270 --> 03:26:12.729
Thank you members and chair my
name's on the of cnn the senior

03:26:12.729 --> 03:26:15.596
vice President Of behavioral
health and organizational

03:26:16.266 --> 03:26:18.300
leadership back then go. Oversee
both the behavioral health

03:26:18.702 --> 03:26:21.435
department as well as early
intervention services department.

03:26:22.437 --> 03:26:24.973
Kengo is a nonprofit early
childhood education provider

03:26:25.408 --> 03:26:27.442
within the san francisco bay
area serving nearly four

03:26:28.760 --> 03:26:30.379
thousand children. Ninety five
percent of the families that we

03:26:30.647 --> 03:26:32.647
serve received free or low cost

03:26:32.782 --> 03:26:34.816
care.
Mental health consultation is

03:26:35.451 --> 03:26:37.652
important and we must do what we
can to increase and improve

03:26:38.221 --> 03:26:41.890
access to this.
Incredible resource for the

03:26:41.791 --> 03:26:43.792
ultimate benefit of all children.
This model provides crucial

03:26:44.593 --> 03:26:47.950
support for effective classroom
management and positive learning

03:26:48.630 --> 03:26:50.650
environments which include.
Strategies for supporting

03:26:50.650 --> 03:26:52.434
children with challenging
behaviors as well as other

03:26:52.434 --> 03:26:55.340
social emotional and mental
health needs.

03:26:55.537 --> 03:26:58.306
This is a true collaborative
approach between teachers

03:26:59.107 --> 03:27:01.274
consultants and parents of to
partner and improving the

03:27:02.100 --> 03:27:04.110
outcomes of all children.
So I just want to share one

03:27:04.613 --> 03:27:07.181
quick story with you it's a
transfer of its a transformative

03:27:08.160 --> 03:27:10.516
consultation outcome for the
child the classroom and is

03:27:11.520 --> 03:27:13.654
teachers.
So jackson came to school on the

03:27:14.489 --> 03:27:16.423
first day with the history that
really no four year old should

03:27:17.157 --> 03:27:20.270
ever have.
In moments of distress he was

03:27:21.950 --> 03:27:23.950
kicking hitting screaming. And

03:27:23.464 --> 03:27:25.465
that really had become his norm.
A climate of stress and

03:27:25.933 --> 03:27:28.135
overwhelm had begun to
overshadow and cloud this

03:27:28.135 --> 03:27:30.937
learning environment for all
students.

03:27:31.906 --> 03:27:34.808
His experienced team of teachers
have felt stretch to the edge of

03:27:34.942 --> 03:27:37.577
their abiliy and be needs able
to support jackson.

03:27:38.512 --> 03:27:40.512
So we partnered up with the

03:27:40.547 --> 03:27:42.649
consultant the teacher and the
parents and were able to

03:27:43.350 --> 03:27:46.860
identify jackson's a specific
needs in the classroom. Which

03:27:46.887 --> 03:27:49.121
then led to a joint creation of
a bait behavioral health

03:27:49.755 --> 03:27:52.491
enhanced support program or plan
for jackson.

03:27:52.859 --> 03:27:55.761
So with of course the
persistence and a collaboration

03:27:56.960 --> 03:27:58.996
of the teachers the consultants
and the parents.

03:27:59.631 --> 03:28:02.367
Jackson to count began being
more calm in the classroom was

03:28:02.969 --> 03:28:05.203
able to learn and have more
positive interactions with both

03:28:06.739 --> 03:28:09.673
his peers and his teachers.
So. Jackson was really on the

03:28:10.910 --> 03:28:13.812
path towards expelled expulsion.
And mental health consultation

03:28:14.847 --> 03:28:17.582
really trent made this outcome.
Difference and transformed it
for him thank you.

03:28:20.551 --> 03:28:23.354
Your next witness.
Good afternoon honorable chair

03:28:23.354 --> 03:28:25.923
o'donnell and members of the
committee my name is stocks are

03:28:26.910 --> 03:28:28.910
pine from housing and.

03:28:28.127 --> 03:28:30.994
Device present of research and
policy at can dangle I'm here to

03:28:31.730 --> 03:28:34.980
answer any technical questions
about bill if you have any thank

03:28:35.167 --> 03:28:37.167
you thank you. Thank you of

03:28:39.337 --> 03:28:41.305
others in support.
Monique also behalf of for such

03:28:43.642 --> 03:28:45.776
californians support.
Patting her on behalf of early

03:28:46.811 --> 03:28:48.946
age californians support.
Thank you other support seen

03:28:49.481 --> 03:28:52.216
others in support any opposition
say no opposition any comments

03:28:52.949 --> 03:28:54.550
from any committee members.
Seeing no.

03:28:55.486 --> 03:28:57.953
Because rare the commander
twenty members I'd do we have a

03:28:58.823 --> 03:29:00.823
motion the motion is to pass as

03:29:01.692 --> 03:29:04.270
amended to appropriations.
Mister Steinorth moves.

03:29:05.463 --> 03:29:07.463
You kiley seconds.

03:29:07.932 --> 03:29:10.200
Well okay I'm going close.
Thank you as a mother to and a

03:29:11.168 --> 03:29:13.668
former teacher I can't tell you
enough how important this is i

03:29:13.937 --> 03:29:16.539
believe that mental health
services is going to have. Help

03:29:17.107 --> 03:29:19.189
education and started in pres
pre k..

03:29:20.177 --> 03:29:22.177
Hopefully with this bill we can.

03:29:22.579 --> 03:29:24.847
Hope to put into the key twelve
system as well thank you but

03:29:25.150 --> 03:29:26.849
that I respectfully ask for your
aye vote thank you please call

03:29:27.884 --> 03:29:30.719
the roll the motion is to pass
as amended to appropriations.

03:29:30.854 --> 03:29:33.255
O'donnell aye o'donnell aye
kiley aye kiley aye kalra.

03:29:34.240 --> 03:29:36.240
Mccarty

03:29:36.226 --> 03:29:38.226
steinorth aye steinorth aye

03:29:41.290 --> 03:29:43.799
thurmond weber. Weber aye.
Cord. Care this file item number.

03:29:44.100 --> 03:29:46.100
That up I'm sorry that is out

03:29:46.169 --> 03:29:48.436
four zero so they that bill is
how we're gonna file item number
twelve.

03:29:49.500 --> 03:29:51.940
File item number twelve was ab
twenty three eighty six.

03:29:52.942 --> 03:29:54.942
Ab twenty three eighty six.

03:29:55.177 --> 03:29:56.710
And that has a support support
so he be as efficient as

03:29:57.213 --> 03:30:00.181
possible.
Absolutely your passport.
Thank you.

03:30:00.849 --> 03:30:03.251
.
Chair and members I'm presenting

03:30:03.751 --> 03:30:06.287
ab twenty three eighty six which
will establish a working group

03:30:06.355 --> 03:30:08.489
that would provide a
credentialing report for

03:30:08.524 --> 03:30:11.492
occupational and physical
therapists. To the legislature

03:30:11.760 --> 03:30:13.527
and the governor and the
superintendent of public

03:30:14.296 --> 03:30:16.296
instruction on or before January

03:30:16.430 --> 03:30:17.965
first of twenty twenty I want to
thank the chair and the

03:30:18.432 --> 03:30:20.968
committee staff for working
closely with my office on this

03:30:21.369 --> 03:30:23.237
bill. That's it I will be
accepting the committee

03:30:23.938 --> 03:30:26.373
amendments today that adds a
provision not limiting the

03:30:26.808 --> 03:30:29.109
number of persons in the working
group as well as adding the

03:30:29.109 --> 03:30:31.812
working group.
Shall consider whether or not

03:30:32.746 --> 03:30:35.682
the service of the services
credential is warranted.
I thought since the nineteen

03:30:36.784 --> 03:30:39.719
seven these both occupational
therapists and physical
therapists have.

03:30:40.540 --> 03:30:42.623
Provided therapy services to
students in public settings

03:30:42.623 --> 03:30:45.190
the federal and it.
The federal individuals with

03:30:46.425 --> 03:30:48.562
disabilities I education act.
Assures that children with

03:30:48.562 --> 03:30:51.130
special needs will receive
supportive services tailored to

03:30:51.865 --> 03:30:54.000
each individual child prior to
the implementation of this

03:30:54.968 --> 03:30:57.770
federal act. O. T. And pt
services were typically provided

03:30:58.438 --> 03:31:00.172
by taking choi aye children out
of school.

03:31:01.575 --> 03:31:03.743
To go to an o. T. Or p. T.
Appointment.

03:31:04.910 --> 03:31:06.545
Under the act the became more
sensible to have.

03:31:07.470 --> 03:31:09.648
Tease impeaches provide the
services to students on school

03:31:10.884 --> 03:31:13.485
sites working as school district
employees nay joined other

03:31:15.570 --> 03:31:17.623
health care professionals such
as speech and language
pathologist. School nurses

03:31:18.240 --> 03:31:20.240
school psychologists and others

03:31:20.250 --> 03:31:22.160
however these other providers.
.

03:31:22.695 --> 03:31:25.330
Provider professions were in the
schools prior to the inclusion

03:31:26.640 --> 03:31:28.701
of the school based o. T. Mpt
services and by that time the

03:31:28.701 --> 03:31:30.969
commission on teacher
credentialing had already

03:31:31.304 --> 03:31:33.138
established credentials for
those other healthcare.

03:31:33.939 --> 03:31:35.906
Professions
a credential position is a

03:31:36.275 --> 03:31:38.843
critical component which comes
to management opportunities and

03:31:39.979 --> 03:31:41.813
career advancement advancements.
These opportunities are

03:31:42.881 --> 03:31:44.948
typically typically only open to
these whipped up to those with

03:31:45.784 --> 03:31:48.319
credentials.
Ab twenty three eighty six asked

03:31:49.621 --> 03:31:52.156
the cdc to study the issue for
each profession through the

03:31:52.924 --> 03:31:55.593
formation of a working group.
Including but not limited to the

03:31:56.361 --> 03:31:58.796
specific individuals listed
under the bill here with me

03:31:59.698 --> 03:32:01.498
today I have to re advocates
that had been approved by the

03:32:03.660 --> 03:32:05.668
chair. Ought to present I have
done james a physical therapist

03:32:06.604 --> 03:32:09.600
from pasadena lisa tests
occupational their for

03:32:09.506 --> 03:32:12.409
therapists from la unified
school district. And erin dolan

03:32:14.780 --> 03:32:15.912
and occupational therapist from
the clovis unified school
district.

03:32:16.881 --> 03:32:18.881
Thank you.

03:32:20.484 --> 03:32:23.385
I am.
Lisa test time license

03:32:23.821 --> 03:32:25.922
occupational therapists from
both representing the

03:32:26.457 --> 03:32:28.457
occupational therapy association

03:32:28.559 --> 03:32:31.127
of california. And los angeles
unified school district in that

03:32:31.195 --> 03:32:33.661
capacity on the coordinating
therapists.

03:32:34.164 --> 03:32:36.165
We service over nine thousand
children for occupational

03:32:36.733 --> 03:32:38.733
therapy.

03:32:39.669 --> 03:32:42.238
Presently and oz was articulated
I'm I'm in support of ab twenty

03:32:42.939 --> 03:32:45.774
three eighty six.
Occupational does physical

03:32:47.142 --> 03:32:49.244
therapists are excluded from a
crewing that a services

03:32:50.980 --> 03:32:53.715
credential which means in.
Certainly in my position and we

03:32:54.583 --> 03:32:56.583
have over two and a fifty stop

03:32:57.200 --> 03:32:59.888
by my colleague my direct
administrator is a counselor. On

03:33:00.857 --> 03:33:02.857
even though we provide a lot of

03:33:03.292 --> 03:33:05.560
training for teachers and
professional development.

03:33:05.928 --> 03:33:07.928
I'm not afford it thought

03:33:08.531 --> 03:33:11.399
opportunity to up be at the
table and be able to make

03:33:12.334 --> 03:33:15.236
broader decision making that
would impact positif willie

03:33:16.271 --> 03:33:18.440
impact our children. In the
school district and especially

03:33:18.440 --> 03:33:21.109
our children with.
Identified special education

03:33:21.477 --> 03:33:23.477
needs.

03:33:23.512 --> 03:33:25.512
And for this reason by.

03:33:25.881 --> 03:33:28.581
Respectfully requesting that an
aye vote for twenty three eighty

03:33:29.217 --> 03:33:31.217
six

03:33:32.287 --> 03:33:34.322
thank you thank you next witness.
Thank you Mister Chairman and

03:33:34.322 --> 03:33:36.557
members of the committee for
allowing me the opportunity to

03:33:37.359 --> 03:33:39.660
speak to you today. My name is
don james and I'm a physical

03:33:43.460 --> 03:33:45.230
therapist and member of the
california physical therapy
association I'm speaking in
support of twenty three eighty

03:33:46.166 --> 03:33:48.668
six. As a former school physical
therapist I can speak directly

03:33:49.236 --> 03:33:51.604
to the need for this bill. One
of the primary reasons school

03:33:51.988 --> 03:33:54.373
physical therapist leave the
position as lack of a career

03:33:54.539 --> 03:33:56.809
ladder.
In fact that's the reason that I

03:33:56.910 --> 03:33:59.645
left the school district after
sixteen years despite the great

03:34:01.147 --> 03:34:03.515
benefits and retirement package.
I was asked by administrators

03:34:04.783 --> 03:34:07.352
time and time again to apply for
specials positions and serve on

03:34:08.219 --> 03:34:10.455
committees however. Because of a
lack of a credential I couldn't

03:34:12.291 --> 03:34:14.760
even apply for that position.
But despite the.

03:34:14.760 --> 03:34:17.461
Skilled background.
Skills and background that I

03:34:19.980 --> 03:34:21.633
could. Benefit students I'm aye
lack that credentialing couldn't

03:34:23.300 --> 03:34:25.360
apply and the second reason is
there personally the position as

03:34:25.537 --> 03:34:28.406
lack of understanding of our
unique roles in the education

03:34:29.775 --> 03:34:31.775
system. Otis amputees are the

03:34:32.770 --> 03:34:34.211
only licensed non credentialed
related service providers

03:34:34.778 --> 03:34:37.515
currently working in california
schools. The entry level the

03:34:38.483 --> 03:34:40.651
grief of physical therapists is
a doctorate degree.

03:34:40.919 --> 03:34:43.254
However in some cases are
represented by the classified

03:34:44.221 --> 03:34:46.590
union this important union
represents the vital needs of

03:34:46.691 --> 03:34:49.593
school employees including
transportation security and food

03:34:49.994 --> 03:34:52.229
services. However our
professional development and

03:34:52.330 --> 03:34:55.165
support means differ
significantly from these

03:34:55.666 --> 03:34:58.340
essential employees.
Additionally our administrators

03:34:58.436 --> 03:35:00.470
are often former classroom
teachers our principals who May

03:35:01.137 --> 03:35:03.773
not understand the complexities
of our documentation.

03:35:03.808 --> 03:35:05.909
Requirements continuing
education needs are practice

03:35:05.975 --> 03:35:08.878
acts
without the without the ability

03:35:09.513 --> 03:35:11.814
for voices to be heard at an
administrative level without

03:35:11.981 --> 03:35:14.684
administrators who truly
understand what we do. School

03:35:16.620 --> 03:35:17.443
og's amputees lack the
professional support needed to

03:35:18.922 --> 03:35:21.490
navigate the complex world of
special education education.

03:35:21.692 --> 03:35:23.692
Ab twenty three eighty six will
provide equity for school based

03:35:24.940 --> 03:35:27.290
physical therapists and assist
districts in the recruitment and

03:35:27.531 --> 03:35:29.999
retention of autism pt's by
bringing our unique perspectives

03:35:30.567 --> 03:35:32.935
to the education team. An
improving outcomes for children

03:35:33.470 --> 03:35:35.470
with disabilities I respectfully

03:35:35.472 --> 03:35:37.105
request your aye vote for ab
twenty three eighty six thank

03:35:39.909 --> 03:35:42.244
you.
Thank you for letting us be here

03:35:42.312 --> 03:35:44.312
today my name is doctor aaron

03:35:44.313 --> 03:35:47.140
dolan and I'm here to share my
personal story. I am an

03:35:47.116 --> 03:35:49.451
occupational therapist clovis
unified school district with

03:35:49.719 --> 03:35:52.654
over seventeen years of
experience and through my. Time

03:35:52.922 --> 03:35:55.230
working in the school district I
was driven to pursue my

03:35:55.291 --> 03:35:57.725
doctorate in educational
leadership and systems we bring

03:35:57.960 --> 03:36:00.280
such a depth and breadth of
knowledge with no motor

03:36:02.406 --> 03:36:05.166
development and learning. And a
mental health as well pursuing
my doctorate as well as

03:36:05.968 --> 03:36:07.668
completing cho at the classes
for the administrative

03:36:08.370 --> 03:36:10.439
credential. I arrived and
thought this is great I can sit

03:36:10.439 --> 03:36:12.939
at the table and have
conversations with my colleagues

03:36:13.608 --> 03:36:15.876
in an equitable fashion. When I
soon learned was that I didn't

03:36:16.311 --> 03:36:19.280
have a bass credential so I
could use my degree for nothing

03:36:20.213 --> 03:36:22.349
more than I currently am as an
occupational therapist which

03:36:23.416 --> 03:36:25.416
while that has value. There such

03:36:25.587 --> 03:36:28.522
an impact that I can have so I
am here to support ab twenty

03:36:29.255 --> 03:36:31.691
three eighty six and hopefully
request that you have.

03:36:34.595 --> 03:36:36.595
And I vote for that as well.

03:36:37.960 --> 03:36:39.960
Thank you others in support.

03:36:39.500 --> 03:36:42.334
Yes. My name is doctor julie
bissell I'm an occupational

03:36:42.770 --> 03:36:45.337
therapist with the anaheim
elementary school district for

03:36:46.106 --> 03:36:48.106
over thirty years.

03:36:49.677 --> 03:36:52.145
And I am a retired.
Associate.

03:36:52.880 --> 03:36:54.847
Retired adjunct associate
professor at the university of

03:36:55.449 --> 03:36:57.449
southern california for the past

03:36:57.718 --> 03:37:00.520
ten years and the co chair of
the. Occupational therapy

03:37:00.420 --> 03:37:03.220
association school based
practice committee and I am in

03:37:04.591 --> 03:37:07.126
support of forming a workgroup
through assembly bill twenty

03:37:09.940 --> 03:37:12.300
three eighty six to. Allow ford
I think your attention for a
john et.

03:37:12.565 --> 03:37:15.167
and very well done thank you
doctor are and others just come

03:37:15.333 --> 03:37:17.269
up see your name affiliation and
position on the bill only thank

03:37:17.936 --> 03:37:19.937
you.
Hello I'm an occupational

03:37:20.840 --> 03:37:22.773
therapist my name is andre cert
I've been in the field for

03:37:23.574 --> 03:37:25.811
thirty five years. I live in the
east bay and I worked in our

03:37:26.312 --> 03:37:29.147
schools for nine years serving
our students and I'm here in

03:37:30.749 --> 03:37:33.118
support of I don't.
I'm tim could hear from monterey

03:37:33.886 --> 03:37:35.886
county I service

03:37:36.221 --> 03:37:38.756
a. Variety of students across of
the whole county and I'm in

03:37:40.526 --> 03:37:42.627
support of bill thank you.
Good afternoon my name is more

03:37:43.228 --> 03:37:45.731
in love has an occupational
therapist and I support this
bill.

03:37:45.731 --> 03:37:47.731
Thank you.

03:37:47.931 --> 03:37:49.931
Any opposition.

03:37:57.609 --> 03:38:00.770
To the bill come forward please.
At them we need him we May need

03:38:06.449 --> 03:38:08.753
to make room for the opposition.
She needs some so many to give

03:38:08.753 --> 03:38:10.753
up their chair on the support

03:38:13.224 --> 03:38:15.224
side.

03:38:16.394 --> 03:38:18.395
Thank you.
Mister Chairman and members

03:38:18.763 --> 03:38:21.330
still are strand flores with the
california school employees

03:38:21.365 --> 03:38:23.866
association we are here in
opposition to this bill.

03:38:24.635 --> 03:38:27.168
We thought we had an agreement
on amendments as of yesterday we

03:38:28.571 --> 03:38:30.907
negotiated with the sponsors and
we thought the author was

03:38:31.241 --> 03:38:34.143
agreeable to the amendments but
we learned today. That that is

03:38:34.344 --> 03:38:37.313
not the case.
The amendments that we want.

03:38:37.748 --> 03:38:40.448
Would have accepted the
amendments that the committee

03:38:41.751 --> 03:38:44.153
staff recommended as well as put
to csea.

03:38:45.880 --> 03:38:47.590
Representatives on the work
group including one of our own

03:38:47.590 --> 03:38:49.590
school based.

03:38:49.626 --> 03:38:51.627
Occupational therapist but the
biggest one.

03:38:53.229 --> 03:38:56.980
Was that if this workgroup does
determined that the credentials

03:38:56.366 --> 03:38:58.366
warranted that my.

03:38:59.235 --> 03:39:01.235
Tease that do not want to get a

03:39:03.515 --> 03:39:05.460
credential are not forced to get
one we wanted an optional path
for that.

03:39:05.841 --> 03:39:08.608
We have occupational therapists
their work for decades in our

03:39:10.450 --> 03:39:12.413
schools without a credential and
we want them to be able to

03:39:13.470 --> 03:39:15.470
continue doing that. I have to

03:39:16.450 --> 03:39:18.251
csea oct of members here today
there occupational therapist

03:39:19.530 --> 03:39:20.423
said. A yield the rest of my
time to them.

03:39:22.324 --> 03:39:24.925
Thank you.
Good afternoon Mister Chairman

03:39:25.193 --> 03:39:27.194
and members my name is cheryl
domino on occupational

03:39:27.762 --> 03:39:29.762
therapists in the st one school

03:39:29.764 --> 03:39:32.199
district. I'm here in opposition
to the bill because it does not

03:39:32.801 --> 03:39:35.759
direct the work group to develop
an option for school based pt's
and.

03:39:36.104 --> 03:39:38.472
Tease like me who do not need a
credential.

03:39:38.740 --> 03:39:41.241
I have worked as a pediatric
occupational therapist for over

03:39:41.275 --> 03:39:44.209
twenty years without a
credential. I am licensed by the

03:39:44.345 --> 03:39:46.880
state of california qualified to
work in schools

03:39:47.415 --> 03:39:50.248
I serve on teams that developed
by a piece and collaborate with

03:39:50.850 --> 03:39:53.586
classroom teachers as well as
work directly with students who

03:39:54.188 --> 03:39:56.456
are diagnosed with the variety.
Of special needs including

03:39:57.925 --> 03:39:59.792
autism neurological impairments
and children who suffer

03:40:00.227 --> 03:40:02.527
emotionally.
I support the students in a

03:40:02.728 --> 03:40:05.198
variety of ways including
addressing motor skills are

03:40:05.399 --> 03:40:08.100
adapting their environment was
specialized equipment as well as

03:40:08.101 --> 03:40:10.302
helping them to tolerate the
century environments of the busy

03:40:10.737 --> 03:40:13.380
classroom.
The mandatory credential will

03:40:13.940 --> 03:40:16.575
make me unqualified to do a job
I had done for decades it will

03:40:17.110 --> 03:40:19.810
also force me to take additional
classes incur more costs to keep

03:40:21.140 --> 03:40:23.416
my job. This plus the fact that
I am already obligated to

03:40:23.416 --> 03:40:26.500
maintain twenty four units
continuing educations for my

03:40:26.753 --> 03:40:29.521
license will make expensive for
me to remain in the school
district.

03:40:29.922 --> 03:40:32.390
I May be forced to leave a job I
truly love.

03:40:33.159 --> 03:40:35.627
The vacancy I create will force
the school districts to contract

03:40:36.327 --> 03:40:38.229
with expensive vendors that are
not required to obtain a

03:40:38.697 --> 03:40:41.433
credential.
For all these reasons I ask for

03:40:42.601 --> 03:40:44.601
your no vote unless the bill as

03:40:45.169 --> 03:40:48.400
amended to allow an option. For
school based o. Teas and pt's to

03:40:48.273 --> 03:40:50.273
work in the schools.

03:40:51.809 --> 03:40:54.378
Thank you thank you.
Good afternoon Mister Chairman

03:40:54.645 --> 03:40:57.281
and members my name is betsy
gray and I'm an occupational

03:40:59.490 --> 03:41:01.284
therapist attack in cse a member.
And I work for san juan unified

03:41:01.685 --> 03:41:03.821
school district.
I worked in school b. Thirty for

03:41:04.789 --> 03:41:07.391
six years and I love my job and
the students I work with.

03:41:08.125 --> 03:41:10.861
I am here in opposition to ab
twenty three eighty six because

03:41:11.290 --> 03:41:13.997
this workgroup could develop are
acquired credentials. For school

03:41:15.365 --> 03:41:17.365
based in poteet and pt's this

03:41:17.367 --> 03:41:20.170
bill is about me. It's about my
career and it's about my pay and

03:41:20.505 --> 03:41:22.804
my benefits.
Moving toward a mandatory

03:41:23.600 --> 03:41:25.775
credential would put us into the
certificated salary union and on

03:41:26.510 --> 03:41:28.643
that salary schedule.
on the current certificated

03:41:29.547 --> 03:41:31.981
payscale which encompasses
teachers speech therapists

03:41:33.350 --> 03:41:35.985
nurses etcetera I having a
master's degree would be bumped

03:41:36.453 --> 03:41:38.821
back to this stepped hill and I
would make fifty four percent

03:41:40.257 --> 03:41:42.658
last. Than I currently do now.
My team members who a bachelor's

03:41:43.260 --> 03:41:45.260
degrees will be pumped further

03:41:45.295 --> 03:41:47.863
back making fifty five percent
less than their current salary.

03:41:48.310 --> 03:41:50.965
All of them have more experience
than I.

03:41:51.366 --> 03:41:54.236
I personally don't want as
service credential. I don't want

03:41:54.838 --> 03:41:56.838
to be an administrator and have

03:41:56.906 --> 03:41:59.875
to supervise other disciplines
deal with angry parents develop

03:42:00.242 --> 03:42:02.242
curriculum and work on program

03:42:02.278 --> 03:42:04.479
development. I want to work with
students as I have been trained

03:42:04.680 --> 03:42:07.449
to deal.
We had.
Tease have our specialty and I

03:42:07.450 --> 03:42:10.118
believe teachers and
administrators have theirs we

03:42:11.850 --> 03:42:13.488
can learn from one another but
we are educated in different and

03:42:14.230 --> 03:42:16.558
specific topics.
Well I support allowing.

03:42:17.893 --> 03:42:20.862
Teasing pt's who want a service
credential to get one aye

03:42:21.597 --> 03:42:24.198
opposer of acquiring all of us
to get a service credential to

03:42:24.666 --> 03:42:27.568
work in the schools especially
when private contracted agencies

03:42:27.801 --> 03:42:30.370
are exams.
I believe this credential will

03:42:31.205 --> 03:42:33.607
negatively impact our profession
and we will lose out on oh teas

03:42:34.209 --> 03:42:36.209
and the school district in favor

03:42:36.578 --> 03:42:39.460
of these contractors the exact
opposite of why this group
wanted.

03:42:39.460 --> 03:42:41.460
The credentialing in the first

03:42:41.216 --> 03:42:43.216
place I ask for your no vote

03:42:43.952 --> 03:42:45.953
thank you others in opposition.
Mister Chair members michael ya

03:42:46.520 --> 03:42:48.355
with california labor federation
were also pulls lista minutes

03:42:51.859 --> 03:42:54.594
with good option.
Hi jeanette them occupational

03:42:56.831 --> 03:42:59.199
therapist opposed.
Carrie baumgartner license

03:42:59.634 --> 03:43:02.102
occupational therapists with the
san juan unified school district

03:43:04.105 --> 03:43:06.105
and I oppose.

03:43:06.140 --> 03:43:08.140
Hi michelle peeler occupational

03:43:09.610 --> 03:43:12.512
therapist and I oppose this bill.
A from israel occupational
therapists and I oppose this

03:43:13.347 --> 03:43:15.140
bill.
Great thank you will bring it

03:43:15.516 --> 03:43:17.882
back here of my just encourage
you I would be supportive of

03:43:18.151 --> 03:43:20.151
this today.

03:43:20.187 --> 03:43:22.355
But ii I I encourage you to
find a place that where all the

03:43:22.756 --> 03:43:25.157
stakeholders can be comfortable
with this piece of legislation

03:43:25.892 --> 03:43:27.892
is we're not quite there today.

03:43:28.360 --> 03:43:29.995
I it's obvious to me sell those
conversations I'm sure will

03:43:30.630 --> 03:43:32.831
continue with that any other
comments many the committee

03:43:33.198 --> 03:43:34.999
members seeing them do we have a
motion.

03:43:35.768 --> 03:43:38.300
Yeah.
It's been moved and seconded.

03:43:38.300 --> 03:43:40.772
Okay.
I'm in the motion is to pass as

03:43:41.507 --> 03:43:43.507
amended to appropriations make

03:43:43.943 --> 03:43:45.943
clones like yeah. Yeah you you

03:43:46.112 --> 03:43:48.879
you didn't there were amendments
that were not taken is that
correct.

03:43:49.148 --> 03:43:51.481
For the purpose of the bill was
to establish a working group's

03:43:52.418 --> 03:43:54.786
all of the the opposition from
what I I heard is.

03:43:55.319 --> 03:43:57.319
About.

03:43:58.157 --> 03:44:01.157
Actually after the working
group has has been established

03:44:01.460 --> 03:44:03.460
that we included.

03:44:03.896 --> 03:44:06.497
We don't limit the number of of.
Members I can participate in

03:44:07.320 --> 03:44:09.266
the working group so this is not
establishing a credential right

03:44:09.400 --> 03:44:11.502
now it's establishing a work
group so that we can talk about

03:44:12.370 --> 03:44:14.271
the credential. And to your
point about not being there

03:44:14.773 --> 03:44:16.774
that's the purpose of the of the
working group so that we can

03:44:17.575 --> 03:44:19.978
come to an agreement as to how
this would work. And so.

03:44:19.978 --> 03:44:21.812
.
So so.

03:44:22.947 --> 03:44:25.516
The.
The end but I think the reyes

03:44:25.783 --> 03:44:28.510
issue about representation on
the committee.

03:44:28.219 --> 03:44:30.887
And so there hasn't been an an
identifiable.

03:44:31.789 --> 03:44:33.890
Number but there is a discussion
that there will be amendments to

03:44:33.991 --> 03:44:35.892
the working group I'm not
members of the various

03:44:35.993 --> 03:44:38.863
organizations that will be on
the committee yes so so the

03:44:38.863 --> 03:44:41.596
amendments that we took.
It didn't limit the amount of

03:44:41.732 --> 03:44:43.732
members on the committee that

03:44:43.799 --> 03:44:46.169
could become we can decide who
can participate in that and are

03:44:46.203 --> 03:44:48.304
working.
County would be very important

03:44:49.380 --> 03:44:51.141
obviously that they're that
they're included in a working

03:44:51.141 --> 03:44:53.210
outside as it directly affects
their profession

03:44:53.210 --> 03:44:55.945
absolutely and I'm.
Obviously I was a former

03:44:56.780 --> 03:44:59.480
teacher so I'm if something was
happening to my job I would be.

03:45:00.183 --> 03:45:02.917
Wanting to participate in that
so I I have never been opposed

03:45:03.153 --> 03:45:05.688
to that I think that's that was
the purpose of not limiting the

03:45:06.555 --> 03:45:08.992
number of of members in the
working group. And one of the

03:45:08.992 --> 03:45:11.293
one of the challenges that
assimilate amendments where it

03:45:12.762 --> 03:45:14.762
sits behind. The ad in the

03:45:15.565 --> 03:45:17.650
timeline so that. We have a lot
of bills today.

03:45:21.236 --> 03:45:23.204
Next and you're not done yet.
I do as well going to close

03:45:23.372 --> 03:45:25.907
thank you I respectfully ask for
your aye vote for the motion is

03:45:26.420 --> 03:45:28.376
to pass as amended to for
operations please call the roll.

03:45:30.746 --> 03:45:32.746
O'donnell by o'donnell aye kiley

03:45:32.781 --> 03:45:35.183
aye kiley aye kalra.
Mccarty.

03:45:37.190 --> 03:45:39.190
Steinorth steinorth aye thurmond.

03:45:39.353 --> 03:45:41.353
Weber aye weber aye.

03:45:41.456 --> 03:45:43.691
Global.
Four votes the bill is out. Of

03:45:44.660 --> 03:45:46.861
thank you.
Well if. I was ever going to

03:45:47.329 --> 03:45:49.329
move a file item number thirty

03:45:49.731 --> 03:45:51.932
three which is ab three zero
nine six this is your last every

03:45:52.167 --> 03:45:54.168
three bills.
That I believe we're going to

03:45:54.769 --> 03:45:56.769
doctor weber then I'm mr chu

03:45:56.805 --> 03:45:59.339
who's been sitting out there.
Patiently and thank you members

03:45:59.741 --> 03:46:02.442
of the committee offers I'd like
to think that chair in his
committee staffer working with

03:46:02.510 --> 03:46:05.379
my office to improve the
components of the bill. I accept

03:46:06.112 --> 03:46:08.149
the committee amendments aye and
look forward to continuing to

03:46:08.149 --> 03:46:10.750
work with stakeholders
interested in this legislation

03:46:11.117 --> 03:46:13.117
today I am presenting a. B.

03:46:13.120 --> 03:46:15.722
Thirty ninety six. A bill that
streamlines access to the school

03:46:15.955 --> 03:46:17.991
accountability report card for
stark.

03:46:18.259 --> 03:46:20.259
By making the information

03:46:20.461 --> 03:46:22.862
available online and available
to be printed if desired.

03:46:22.995 --> 03:46:25.365
Currently school and district
level staff annual to complete

03:46:25.799 --> 03:46:27.799
the stark the finger plan for

03:46:28.502 --> 03:46:30.603
student achievement s. P. S. A
local education.

03:46:32.237 --> 03:46:34.707
Agency lda plan to the and the
local control and accountability

03:46:35.308 --> 03:46:37.977
plan the el cap.
Federal title one reports civil

03:46:38.760 --> 03:46:40.579
rights data collection among
thousands of other reports

03:46:40.981 --> 03:46:42.981
required for state and federal

03:46:42.983 --> 03:46:45.484
purposes. A. B. Thirty ninety
six creates a more aligned

03:46:46.219 --> 03:46:48.752
reporting system for the start
as well as the one stop resource

03:46:49.354 --> 03:46:51.623
for parents and stakeholders to
access information about their

03:46:52.191 --> 03:46:54.590
schools.
The bill will streamlined

03:46:54.327 --> 03:46:56.193
reporting requirements by
requiring the california

03:46:56.863 --> 03:46:59.497
department of education.
To developing annually complete

03:47:00.900 --> 03:47:03.169
a stark for each school and make
the stark available online%

03:47:03.169 --> 03:47:06.104
instead of requiring school
districts to annually complete

03:47:07.173 --> 03:47:09.472
the stark as a separate report.
Here with me today are the

03:47:10.209 --> 03:47:12.510
sponsors representatives for my
bill elizabeth shepard

03:47:13.310 --> 03:47:15.980
coordinator of compliance for
the folsom cordova unified.

03:47:16.348 --> 03:47:18.348
School district here.

03:47:18.483 --> 03:47:20.885
And the here representing the
association of california school

03:47:22.788 --> 03:47:25.555
administrators and soothing and
because on these from the
california department of

03:47:25.824 --> 03:47:27.824
education to answer any

03:47:28.893 --> 03:47:30.861
technical. Questions.
Good afternoon Chairman

03:47:31.960 --> 03:47:33.864
O'donnell committee members and
staff aye melissa shephard and

03:47:34.132 --> 03:47:35.900
service the court date of
complaints in a local school

03:47:36.601 --> 03:47:38.702
district. I'm here today on
behalf of the associates

03:47:39.504 --> 03:47:42.710
association of california school
administrators in support of ab

03:47:42.807 --> 03:47:45.342
thirty ninety six.
In nineteen ninety when I

03:47:45.943 --> 03:47:48.611
started my credential program
forty to become a teacher I

03:47:48.946 --> 03:47:51.323
never imagined that we would be
sitting here today to improve

03:47:51.348 --> 03:47:53.983
the transparency to provide
student information to parents.

03:47:54.852 --> 03:47:56.852
And communities we serve based

03:47:56.854 --> 03:47:59.389
on the profound work the various
committee members like yourself

03:47:59.588 --> 03:48:02.250
have done in the past over the
last thirty years.

03:48:02.526 --> 03:48:04.927
Today I am here to express the
importance of working with all

03:48:05.495 --> 03:48:07.495
of our educational partners to

03:48:07.497 --> 03:48:09.966
be to be better collect to
better collaborate. In

03:48:10.934 --> 03:48:13.340
cooperation for student and
school data two more

03:48:15.105 --> 03:48:17.105
meaningfully passed to parents

03:48:17.107 --> 03:48:19.908
teachers and other. Committee
community members.

03:48:20.610 --> 03:48:23.178
California has previously
engaged in a similar effort when

03:48:23.712 --> 03:48:25.712
our student information system

03:48:26.983 --> 03:48:29.785
at the local level was able to.
To work with.

03:48:31.120 --> 03:48:32.821
I ep individuals with education
programs.

03:48:33.890 --> 03:48:36.825
To.
To upload information from our

03:48:37.760 --> 03:48:40.610
student information systems
as a result this allowed special

03:48:40.162 --> 03:48:42.697
education teachers and other
service providers to spend more

03:48:42.731 --> 03:48:45.200
time working with students with
special needs.

03:48:45.768 --> 03:48:48.503
And instead of duplicating data
to paperwork.

03:48:49.438 --> 03:48:51.606
This bill if passed would do the
same thing for districts and

03:48:52.107 --> 03:48:54.609
schools site administrators such
as our principles. It would

03:48:55.210 --> 03:48:57.110
allow us more time to better
support teachers and staff

03:48:57.946 --> 03:49:00.449
members in the improvement of
our instructional practices. And

03:49:00.449 --> 03:49:03.185
direct start services to
students.

03:49:03.185 --> 03:49:05.920
This bill is also great for
students because in.

03:49:05.920 --> 03:49:08.722
Because one of the biggest
schools and school districts

03:49:09.758 --> 03:49:11.758
across america california is to

03:49:11.926 --> 03:49:13.926
increase parent engagement.

03:49:14.262 --> 03:49:16.280
An active. And increase active
meaningful engagement with our

03:49:16.497 --> 03:49:19.231
parents
and transparency inconsistency

03:49:20.234 --> 03:49:22.602
of information is the first
movement to build trust and

03:49:23.337 --> 03:49:25.380
trust builds.
Meaningful participation from

03:49:25.773 --> 03:49:28.274
parents.
This enhancement of an online

03:49:28.375 --> 03:49:31.212
stark will facilitate
stakeholder engagement as there

03:49:31.212 --> 03:49:33.846
would be comprehensive
information except accessible in

03:49:33.946 --> 03:49:35.946
one place.

03:49:36.830 --> 03:49:38.651
Please autonomous.
Complemented by the california

03:49:38.919 --> 03:49:40.919
school dashboard for quick

03:49:40.954 --> 03:49:43.290
online access to accountability
for both school district reports.

03:49:43.290 --> 03:49:45.290
Thank you for your time thank

03:49:46.660 --> 03:49:48.727
you.
Good afternoon sue bang on

03:49:49.362 --> 03:49:52.331
behalf of state superintendent
of public instruction tom trucks

03:49:52.832 --> 03:49:55.100
and co sponsor of this measure.
The school accountability report

03:49:55.402 --> 03:49:58.300
card with established in
nineteen eighty eight as part of

03:49:58.771 --> 03:50:01.505
proposition ninety eight.
The last decade and especially

03:50:02.410 --> 03:50:04.708
since the adoption of the local
control funding formula in the

03:50:05.878 --> 03:50:08.380
school dashboard. Stark has
become a relic of the past

03:50:08.815 --> 03:50:11.183
personal longer referring to
start to see other schools are

03:50:11.517 --> 03:50:13.618
doing.
In the last few years the

03:50:13.686 --> 03:50:15.686
california department of

03:50:15.787 --> 03:50:18.423
education and has updated the
site template which I've handed

03:50:19.592 --> 03:50:21.592
out to you about seventeen pages

03:50:22.661 --> 03:50:25.280
long. Told climate to lcf have
however due to outdated

03:50:26.664 --> 03:50:28.664
requirements to start remains.

03:50:29.266 --> 03:50:31.266
Arm a paper copy or can be

03:50:31.268 --> 03:50:34.710
uploaded online as a pdf
composing of seventeen pages or

03:50:34.673 --> 03:50:37.641
more.
And is not user friendly as it

03:50:38.610 --> 03:50:41.544
was intended a for its audience
particularly parents.

03:50:41.880 --> 03:50:44.214
Ab thirty ninety six with
streamlined the development of

03:50:44.582 --> 03:50:46.784
the start by requiring the
department to annually

03:50:47.384 --> 03:50:49.384
completists arc for every public

03:50:49.487 --> 03:50:52.222
school. And make the stark's
available online I've also

03:50:52.557 --> 03:50:54.557
handed out.

03:50:56.794 --> 03:50:58.866
A mockup of the stark online
but what the
would look

03:50:59.730 --> 03:51:02.599
online. And parents would be
able to look at one data element

03:51:04.667 --> 03:51:07.237
at a time or expand also acted
on women's.

03:51:07.671 --> 03:51:10.730
Which would allow them to see
the entire sock report in one

03:51:10.541 --> 03:51:12.742
luck.
The department would also make

03:51:14.211 --> 03:51:16.879
stark available as part of the
california schools application

03:51:17.714 --> 03:51:19.714
and which has five thousand

03:51:20.500 --> 03:51:22.718
current users so parents can
access our. From their

03:51:24.855 --> 03:51:27.690
smartphones and their tablets.
Under a a. B. Thirty ninety six

03:51:27.872 --> 03:51:29.872
the school districts would

03:51:30.600 --> 03:51:32.995
continue to annually publicized
availability of sparks and

03:51:34.431 --> 03:51:37.399
provide hard copies to parents.
Ab thirty ninety six leverages

03:51:38.534 --> 03:51:41.203
existing data collection systems
to update in streamlined the

03:51:41.703 --> 03:51:43.805
start and bring it into the
twenty first century

03:51:44.674 --> 03:51:46.474
respectfully ask for your aye
vote as mentioned city because

03:51:47.377 --> 03:51:49.879
on is. The director of our
analysis and measurement and

03:51:49.879 --> 03:51:52.680
accountability reporting
division is here to answer any

03:51:53.581 --> 03:51:55.551
technical program questions you
May have thank you others in
support.

03:51:56.118 --> 03:51:58.385
But.
My dad doesn't have to be have

03:51:59.722 --> 03:52:01.356
access association of california
school administrator to strong

03:52:02.823 --> 03:52:05.526
support.
Indicate a watch on behalf of

03:52:06.762 --> 03:52:08.629
los angeles unified in support.
Like any other sports seen on

03:52:23.878 --> 03:52:26.680
any opposition
.
Good afternoon Mister Chairman

03:52:27.282 --> 03:52:30.217
members I'm whiskey and with
public advocates we took in

03:52:31.853 --> 03:52:34.540
oppose unless amended position.
The circus required in our

03:52:34.388 --> 03:52:36.790
constitution as you heard by
prop ninety eight and only

03:52:37.558 --> 03:52:40.590
legislation that furthers the
purpose.

03:52:40.590 --> 03:52:42.260
A prop ninety eight maybe
enacted

03:52:43.262 --> 03:52:45.262
deleting critical williams

03:52:47.559 --> 03:52:49.560
school level information that is
available no where else would

03:52:49.837 --> 03:52:52.303
detract from not further the
transparency and accountability

03:52:52.773 --> 03:52:54.773
purposes.

03:52:54.775 --> 03:52:57.476
Of ninety eight that would make
the spell unconstitutional our

03:52:58.278 --> 03:53:00.278
opposition stems from our

03:53:00.414 --> 03:53:02.414
representation of a million plus

03:53:02.415 --> 03:53:04.415
children that were in schools

03:53:04.818 --> 03:53:06.685
only in the last decade without
the bare necessities for an

03:53:09.489 --> 03:53:11.990
education.
That that would be considered

03:53:12.592 --> 03:53:15.360
equal fully credentialed
teachers properly assigned

03:53:15.828 --> 03:53:18.764
impermanent sufficient
instructional materials current

03:53:19.132 --> 03:53:21.466
and aligned to standards and
facilities that are safe

03:53:22.340 --> 03:53:24.569
functional and not a threat to
health and safety.

03:53:25.503 --> 03:53:27.503
The state admitted that it had

03:53:27.939 --> 03:53:29.939
no system to inspect

03:53:31.210 --> 03:53:33.210
detect and monitor on a systemic

03:53:33.512 --> 03:53:35.512
level whether it provides these

03:53:35.647 --> 03:53:38.381
very basic necessities and all
its schools. The chosen

03:53:38.783 --> 03:53:41.686
mechanism for collecting and
reporting this data in the

03:53:42.554 --> 03:53:44.554
william settlement legislation

03:53:44.656 --> 03:53:47.391
was the slorc while we support
this.

03:53:48.580 --> 03:53:50.580
Direction of eliminating

03:53:50.562 --> 03:53:53.163
redundant activities removing
williams the school level

03:53:53.965 --> 03:53:56.499
information is not one of them.
now more than ever the state is

03:53:57.235 --> 03:53:59.235
relying on this information for

03:53:59.936 --> 03:54:02.573
accountability under lc ff the
dashboard reports on the

03:54:03.408 --> 03:54:06.243
williams conditions. And the
guidance that department puts

03:54:07.577 --> 03:54:10.347
out directs districts to use the
stark for gathering and

03:54:10.414 --> 03:54:12.749
reporting this information to
the public.

03:54:13.216 --> 03:54:16.152
Without this critical data which
affects every school and every

03:54:17.420 --> 03:54:19.789
public school family we expose
ourselves again to a pre

03:54:21.191 --> 03:54:23.993
williams era. With all districts
checking the boxes in the

03:54:24.528 --> 03:54:26.528
dashboard that they have met the

03:54:26.663 --> 03:54:28.663
standards for decent schools but

03:54:29.298 --> 03:54:31.298
with no actual school level

03:54:31.368 --> 03:54:34.700
information at all. And
widespread inequalities

03:54:34.771 --> 03:54:36.972
obviously we will continue to
work with the author and

03:54:37.707 --> 03:54:40.309
sponsors but these are the
reasons for our opposition thank

03:54:42.279 --> 03:54:45.800
you thank you.
Kathy sure on behalf of the aclu

03:54:46.249 --> 03:54:48.183
of california a lead together
with public advocates for one of

03:54:49.118 --> 03:54:51.653
the organizations that brought
the williams litigation.

03:54:51.820 --> 03:54:54.189
To address.
Severe inequities and and.

03:54:54.824 --> 03:54:56.824
.

03:54:57.260 --> 03:54:59.260
Lacking facilities and

03:54:59.595 --> 03:55:02.300
textbooks of for many of
california school children.

03:55:03.650 --> 03:55:05.733
I want to emphasize that that
the information that's required

03:55:06.101 --> 03:55:09.300
under the william settlement is
not some kind of add on to

03:55:09.104 --> 03:55:12.400
what's in the stark. It's
information that is essential to

03:55:12.708 --> 03:55:15.209
assessing how well school is
doing its job.

03:55:15.976 --> 03:55:18.312
To give some examples in the
early two thousands before the

03:55:18.579 --> 03:55:20.948
william settlement there were
one point eight million school

03:55:21.550 --> 03:55:24.251
kids in california without the
books they needed for homework.

03:55:24.586 --> 03:55:26.821
One point nine million were in
classrooms that were too hot or

03:55:27.422 --> 03:55:29.790
cold.
I one point six million were in

03:55:30.525 --> 03:55:32.525
schools infested with roaches

03:55:32.560 --> 03:55:34.962
rats or mice and one million
were in schools with non working

03:55:35.997 --> 03:55:38.932
bathrooms are close bathrooms.
Kids cannot learn under these

03:55:39.267 --> 03:55:41.969
conditions they are equally
important to their education as

03:55:41.969 --> 03:55:44.704
our.
Teachers or anything else you

03:55:44.737 --> 03:55:47.372
might think of as essential to
education.

03:55:47.441 --> 03:55:49.943
We've made a lot of progress
since then because of william's

03:55:50.344 --> 03:55:53.178
and because of the information
that is now available.
Through.

03:55:53.613 --> 03:55:56.349
.
Through the william settlement.

03:55:56.684 --> 03:55:58.852
And in the stark it allows
families and advocates to

03:55:59.353 --> 03:56:01.821
monitor how districts are doing
in making sure that facilities

03:56:02.289 --> 03:56:04.924
are maintained and and books and
materials are available.

03:56:05.859 --> 03:56:08.493
We are open to discussion and
have begun discussions.

03:56:09.463 --> 03:56:12.164
With the sponsors and the
authors office as to how the

03:56:12.731 --> 03:56:15.501
information gets put into the
sar. But it needs to continue to

03:56:16.203 --> 03:56:18.671
be in the sar so that parents
and communities know what they

03:56:18.805 --> 03:56:20.739
need to know about the
conditions of their local

03:56:21.341 --> 03:56:23.909
schools it cannot simply be
eliminated.

03:56:24.100 --> 03:56:26.780
We look forward to working with
the authors and sponsors on this

03:56:26.980 --> 03:56:28.313
issue.
Thank you.

03:56:29.148 --> 03:56:31.883
Other is not an apprentice
strong senior director children
now.

03:56:32.418 --> 03:56:35.120
We look for to work with the
author we are also oppose listen

03:56:35.453 --> 03:56:37.322
and think.
Thank you I don't bring it back.

03:56:38.256 --> 03:56:40.825
.
Let me ask what are your only

03:56:41.327 --> 03:56:43.327
concerns the williams lawsuit.

03:56:45.798 --> 03:56:47.798
Yeah.

03:56:48.600 --> 03:56:51.690
The details of that are reported
at the school site level as a

03:56:51.603 --> 03:56:53.603
result of the william settlement

03:56:53.672 --> 03:56:56.207
and better and the legislation
more different from what's in
the.

03:56:58.210 --> 03:56:59.677
In in the dashboard so yes and
those are the only.

03:57:00.679 --> 03:57:03.147
.
The only things that the

03:57:03.648 --> 03:57:06.517
department.
Currently can't populate because

03:57:06.618 --> 03:57:08.618
it doesn't collect that

03:57:09.354 --> 03:57:11.354
information at the state level.

03:57:11.423 --> 03:57:13.757
So I'm sorry. What information
do they not collect they don't

03:57:14.959 --> 03:57:17.928
collect information about the
actual text and instructional

03:57:18.663 --> 03:57:21.631
materials whether they are
aligned to standards and whether

03:57:23.132 --> 03:57:25.368
they are current? Law they don't
collect the information about

03:57:26.137 --> 03:57:28.905
that's what you're seeking.
That's part of it there's other

03:57:28.939 --> 03:57:30.772
facilities like is the bathrooms
of and yet right facility

03:57:31.442 --> 03:57:33.442
fifteen years ago that's right

03:57:34.545 --> 03:57:36.545
well. In the facilities a area.

03:57:37.181 --> 03:57:39.181
Each school goes through by.

03:57:39.616 --> 03:57:41.616
Facilities inspection review or

03:57:43.520 --> 03:57:45.888
something. Right. And sometimes
up well they're required to

03:57:46.823 --> 03:57:48.823
report whether facilities that

03:57:50.292 --> 03:57:52.894
have been inspected are in fair
good or poor condition. What

03:57:54.970 --> 03:57:56.298
we've seen is that doesn't match
up to what the report in the

03:57:56.932 --> 03:57:59.368
dashboard and I don't know who
it is my state here comports

03:57:59.602 --> 03:58:01.937
with what you're looking at by
think you ought to be careful
some of this because?

03:58:02.305 --> 03:58:04.273
I know in my own classroom
setting.

03:58:05.241 --> 03:58:07.241
every child had a text book to

03:58:07.477 --> 03:58:09.544
take home that we did but it was
a different textbook that we

03:58:10.112 --> 03:58:12.412
assign work out of a home. So we
don't even have those textbooks

03:58:12.915 --> 03:58:14.915
available classroom.

03:58:14.917 --> 03:58:17.850
So I just.
Be careful aye nice hope we're

03:58:17.920 --> 03:58:19.554
we're we're careful about how
this impacts logistics on the

03:58:20.870 --> 03:58:22.323
ground.
On the might of to text for

03:58:23.158 --> 03:58:25.394
class they might know only.
Not not have enough in the

03:58:25.394 --> 03:58:27.428
schools district might not by
enough I have to have an in

03:58:27.996 --> 03:58:30.598
class at that's where I really.
Became frustrated in my own

03:58:32.100 --> 03:58:34.101
experience they had a home. You
know you don't bring your club

03:58:34.168 --> 03:58:36.337
bring your textbook to aye well
you know you're an eighth grade

03:58:38.473 --> 03:58:40.473
you might. Okay so. In our

03:58:40.775 --> 03:58:42.443
conference I just hope we're not
getting to particular and

03:58:43.440 --> 03:58:45.713
and walking out opportunities
for students to learn rather

03:58:46.347 --> 03:58:48.982
than unlocking the men.
You know a assembly member chair

03:58:49.951 --> 03:58:52.486
o'donnell we looked we talked
about those issues in the

03:58:53.154 --> 03:58:55.154
settlement discussions.

03:58:55.556 --> 03:58:57.556
And so the legislation says a

03:58:57.625 --> 03:58:59.625
textbook to use in class and to

03:58:59.726 --> 03:59:02.696
take home but it does not
require two sets.

03:59:04.231 --> 03:59:06.231
All it was a but it was about

03:59:06.500 --> 03:59:08.801
ensure and or. If it got that or
words pretty important.

03:59:09.969 --> 03:59:12.405
It it was about making sure that
students in the lowest resource

03:59:12.906 --> 03:59:14.906
schools.

03:59:15.420 --> 03:59:17.420
Had materials too used to refer

03:59:17.845 --> 03:59:20.379
to for homework because we found
that they could not. Really

03:59:20.881 --> 03:59:23.648
acceptable position eyes that
were or might be some media

03:59:24.284 --> 03:59:26.786
think about because.
Anderson at home that can use in

03:59:27.454 --> 03:59:29.421
the classroom and you need to
use in the classroom right. You

03:59:29.923 --> 03:59:31.889
know.
That that's what happens okay

03:59:33.460 --> 03:59:35.862
thank you thank you.
Or that mr graham did any of the

03:59:35.862 --> 03:59:37.862
folks and supports one.

03:59:38.310 --> 03:59:40.532
Respond to this notion that
they'll be lasts a usable.

03:59:43.102 --> 03:59:45.237
Data available with this with
this change are seeking.

03:59:45.370 --> 03:59:47.370
I have my nerves under control

03:59:47.540 --> 03:59:49.540
yes it's very important that

03:59:49.976 --> 03:59:51.976
under priority one in the lc f.

03:59:54.151 --> 03:59:56.481
F. We are able to document in a
narrative the exact amount of.
Afford that we put in our start

03:59:57.349 --> 03:59:59.551
at this time.
And it would not it would just

04:00:00.219 --> 04:00:02.520
be day clear instructions from
the california department of

04:00:02.686 --> 04:00:04.255
education is as to how we do
that with our professional

04:00:05.724 --> 04:00:07.592
development.
And that's in the district

04:00:09.194 --> 04:00:11.728
loaded area that they upload.
Skinner jewish to come.

04:00:13.564 --> 04:00:15.866
Yes I.
I would say that the direction

04:00:16.468 --> 04:00:18.567
from the department in its
technical manual.

04:00:19.370 --> 04:00:21.370
Guidance on the local

04:00:21.273 --> 04:00:23.841
indicators is to use the stark
information.

04:00:25.443 --> 04:00:28.278
So the local indicators would be
at this point are district level

04:00:29.245 --> 04:00:31.245
reports.

04:00:32.160 --> 04:00:34.160
And they're not school level

04:00:34.284 --> 04:00:36.987
data which is what the williams
settlement requires

04:00:37.755 --> 04:00:39.755
remember the state said we don't

04:00:40.723 --> 04:00:43.125
have school level information.
Except for the stark and that's

04:00:43.794 --> 04:00:45.562
why.
These.

04:00:46.664 --> 04:00:48.664
Metrics these indicators were

04:00:50.267 --> 04:00:51.934
put into the stark.
So let me ask you questions act

04:00:52.368 --> 04:00:54.368
like. So so she's talking about

04:00:54.504 --> 04:00:56.504
district level I think you're

04:00:56.573 --> 04:00:58.573
talking about school level.

04:00:59.760 --> 04:01:01.642
bonta iowa plaster of costumes.
That had it been a monopoly has

04:01:02.680 --> 04:01:04.480
an impact does okay.
To me that's my because I'm I'm

04:01:05.915 --> 04:01:08.717
I'm more concerned about and
that is important to be wrong.

04:01:09.419 --> 04:01:12.188
But I wanna know what tools I
have when I walk in the
classroom in the morning.

04:01:12.520 --> 04:01:14.520
And even for my own children and

04:01:14.723 --> 04:01:16.723
outside of moscow under williams

04:01:16.794 --> 04:01:19.727
teachers and staff also have the
opportunity for these learning

04:01:20.762 --> 04:01:22.731
and teaching conditions. And
that was made very clear in the

04:01:23.699 --> 04:01:25.699
legislation around the uniform

04:01:26.168 --> 04:01:28.870
complaint procedure.
Thank you aye so I hope you'll

04:01:30.172 --> 04:01:32.205
continue to have conversations.
It's our commitment thank you

04:01:33.208 --> 04:01:35.843
know yes I just I just wanted to
of thank you for bringing that

04:01:35.843 --> 04:01:37.843
to our attention.

04:01:38.800 --> 04:01:40.948
We should never minimize
importance of the williams case.

04:01:41.116 --> 04:01:43.483
It is an extremely important
case and I don't think anyone at

04:01:44.190 --> 04:01:46.420
the state level or even at the
local level want to have to open

04:01:46.855 --> 04:01:48.855
it up again.

04:01:49.580 --> 04:01:51.592
Because it is very serious and
it really gets down to the most

04:01:52.861 --> 04:01:55.396
basic levels of inequality that
exists in california we know

04:01:56.970 --> 04:01:58.532
that and the outcomes of that.
So those of us who lived through

04:01:59.367 --> 04:02:02.100
the williams case at one level
of the other realized just how

04:02:02.237 --> 04:02:05.720
important is and.
And sark is really the only

04:02:05.907 --> 04:02:07.808
place where the data is found.
And so it's really important

04:02:08.109 --> 04:02:10.677
some I know that.
Of our brough assembly member

04:02:11.780 --> 04:02:13.780
will work with you to make sure

04:02:13.314 --> 04:02:15.582
that we don't eliminate what is
so extremely important

04:02:15.983 --> 04:02:18.318
absolutely abductor where but
just for clarification I know

04:02:18.586 --> 04:02:20.553
that both of us are educators i
spent sixteen years in the

04:02:21.255 --> 04:02:23.857
classroom. Understand the
williams act on the williams and

04:02:23.857 --> 04:02:25.458
we're not trying to eliminate
though though williams

04:02:26.226 --> 04:02:27.959
inspections that throughout the
year.

04:02:28.228 --> 04:02:29.662
When I was a classroom teacher
we had.

04:02:30.430 --> 04:02:32.832
Scheduled visits and we also
had I'm I'm scheduled it's

04:02:33.333 --> 04:02:35.735
visits when they so that's not
going to be eliminated this is

04:02:35.769 --> 04:02:37.769
about the data that's collected

04:02:37.871 --> 04:02:40.838
so. So so we're working on the
data but the the requirements

04:02:41.341 --> 04:02:43.341
for the williams is not going to

04:02:51.184 --> 04:02:53.686
be eliminated and the williams visit that's
very separate. So we're not

04:02:53.686 --> 04:02:56.221
trying to get rid of the
williams.
Act.

04:02:57.122 --> 04:02:59.570
We're still visiting schools we
have groups teams that will

04:02:59.357 --> 04:03:01.860
visit the schools and the
reporting will be done it's

04:03:02.960 --> 04:03:04.960
still required by the counties

04:03:05.464 --> 04:03:08.234
is still required by all cff. So
we have all this requirement the
purpose of this bills to

04:03:08.234 --> 04:03:10.335
streamline the information and I
absolutely committed to working

04:03:10.436 --> 04:03:13.710
with the opposition to figure
out how we can make this work

04:03:13.237 --> 04:03:15.638
but this is about streamlining
not eliminating the williams.

04:03:17.342 --> 04:03:20.311
Lawsuit which is two different
things yeah I I think the

04:03:20.312 --> 04:03:23.114
concern was with an up the data
would be reflected in the stock

04:03:23.715 --> 04:03:25.715
report right that even though

04:03:27.585 --> 04:03:29.919
the visits occur the data is
collected is it going to be all

04:03:31.722 --> 04:03:33.722
sold. Out reported in that

04:03:34.859 --> 04:03:37.940
because there really is. Very
few other places are not please

04:03:37.597 --> 04:03:40.630
really where you can find the
report from the from the

04:03:40.865 --> 04:03:42.865
williams investigations at the

04:03:43.534 --> 04:03:45.534
current schools so I know you

04:03:46.204 --> 04:03:48.872
work on it so thank you. Thank
you doctor weber great up thank

04:03:51.900 --> 04:03:53.475
you you know lawsuits data all
you know I get at the same time
still really concerned about how

04:03:58.916 --> 04:04:01.170
this reflects what's going on on
the ground.

04:04:01.117 --> 04:04:03.687
In the classroom the student
experience the class and the

04:04:03.687 --> 04:04:06.656
teacher experience the classroom
so that we can all can succeed.

04:04:08.125 --> 04:04:10.125
Are there any other comments.

04:04:11.261 --> 04:04:13.729
I see no further comments I do
we have a motion that we did.

04:04:14.899 --> 04:04:17.299
So move.
If the move and seconded by
Mister Steinorth.

04:04:17.500 --> 04:04:19.680
The motion is to pass as
amended to appropriations

04:04:19.703 --> 04:04:22.571
you May close.
Respectfully ask for your vote
thank you.

04:04:23.373 --> 04:04:25.390
Please call the roll to pass as
amended to appropriations as the

04:04:25.775 --> 04:04:27.775
motion.

04:04:30.478 --> 04:04:31.980
O'donnell aye o'donnell aye jeff and matt doctor weber is
going to go and then.

04:04:32.615 --> 04:04:34.615
Chiu.

04:04:34.984 --> 04:04:36.984
Look so happy out there is next

04:04:46.610 --> 04:04:48.610
after doctor weber.

04:04:48.230 --> 04:04:50.298
Of for allowing us to go we have
some individuals who've been

04:04:52.734 --> 04:04:54.969
here all day. And up to the long
hearing and they have a flight

04:04:55.304 --> 04:04:57.304
to catch so I want to make sure

04:04:57.638 --> 04:04:59.638
that they. Don't Miss That mommy

04:05:01.275 --> 04:05:03.310
just were up this is a file item.
Baloney.

04:05:03.978 --> 04:05:05.678
S. Here.
File I'm twenty two twenty two

04:05:07.480 --> 04:05:08.816
yes twenty six fifty seven and
I'm twenty two a. B..

04:05:09.751 --> 04:05:11.751
Twenty six fifty seven twenty

04:05:12.187 --> 04:05:14.187
six fifty seven. Right okay.

04:05:14.255 --> 04:05:16.490
Before I begin I want except
the committees amendments and

04:05:16.624 --> 04:05:19.192
thank both chaired the committee
staff for their hard work to

04:05:19.527 --> 04:05:21.862
improve the bill. Amendments
were largely technical in a

04:05:22.697 --> 04:05:25.299
clarify several definitions and
will make implementation much

04:05:27.101 --> 04:05:29.669
easier. Ump ab twenty six fifty
seven provides guidance on how

04:05:30.171 --> 04:05:32.171
to keep children especially

04:05:32.439 --> 04:05:35.730
children with disabilities and
african american children safe

04:05:36.410 --> 04:05:38.677
in schools. Of your having a two
documents two hands out the

04:05:39.712 --> 04:05:42.248
handouts past you at this time
of that come from the the

04:05:43.550 --> 04:05:46.285
sponsors of the bill. But decade
saw educators advocates and

04:05:46.887 --> 04:05:49.540
legislators have work to ensure
that students with with

04:05:49.755 --> 04:05:51.755
challenging behaviors. Are

04:05:51.957 --> 04:05:54.930
educated with dignity and
supportive learning environments

04:05:54.160 --> 04:05:56.362
in fact california was once the
leader in addressing students

04:05:56.795 --> 04:05:59.665
with challenging behaviors
enacting legislation in nineteen

04:05:59.732 --> 04:06:02.233
ninety the hughes app ab twenty
five eighty six.

04:06:02.502 --> 04:06:04.835
That address the needs of
students in special education

04:06:06.239 --> 04:06:08.672
with severe behavior challenges
however as a response to the

04:06:09.874 --> 04:06:12.377
recession the legislature's part
of the twenty thirteen budget.

04:06:13.111 --> 04:06:15.246
Repealed a long standing
regulations implementing the

04:06:16.480 --> 04:06:18.483
huge real and codified a list of
emergency interventions

04:06:18.884 --> 04:06:21.751
previously prohibited under the
hughes bill including locked

04:06:22.254 --> 04:06:25.230
occlusion and mechanical
restraining. For all liam

04:06:25.790 --> 04:06:27.991
science simultaneously
department of education best

04:06:28.127 --> 04:06:30.861
against reports and parents
reports document that current

04:06:32.196 --> 04:06:33.931
law fails to control the use of
restraints and seclusion in

04:06:34.466 --> 04:06:37.101
school. Students continue to
suffer trauma and emotional and

04:06:37.803 --> 04:06:39.803
physical harm.

04:06:39.870 --> 04:06:41.939
Special education students tend
to be targeted more for

04:06:42.272 --> 04:06:44.273
restraint and seclusion
restraint and seclusion just

04:06:44.442 --> 04:06:46.909
reports on a pack children with
disabilities in african american

04:06:48.246 --> 04:06:51.113
boys. As analysis points out in
the last month the us general

04:06:51.683 --> 04:06:53.917
accountability office confirms
that these two populations of

04:06:54.886 --> 04:06:57.530
target fiscal discipline.
We have passed out to documents

04:06:57.121 --> 04:06:59.121
to help you understand why this

04:06:59.189 --> 04:07:02.580
bill is so important. California
used to be a leader as I pointed
out.

04:07:02.693 --> 04:07:04.928
In the behavior interventions
of the firstside of tried one

04:07:05.463 --> 04:07:07.765
handed out describes eleven
policies to reduce the amount of

04:07:08.231 --> 04:07:10.231
restraints and seclusion in

04:07:10.301 --> 04:07:12.670
schools. California scored a
three out of eleven

04:07:12.803 --> 04:07:15.505
demonstrating that we are no
longer a leader in positive

04:07:15.906 --> 04:07:17.907
behavior intervention.
The other hand out provides a

04:07:18.208 --> 04:07:20.543
brief description of activities
that have taken place in schools

04:07:20.744 --> 04:07:23.379
in different parts of the state
over the last few years. These

04:07:24.214 --> 04:07:26.214
all come from disability rights

04:07:26.216 --> 04:07:28.950
california investigations
although the names have been
changed.

04:07:29.254 --> 04:07:31.386
This bill stresses positive
-
behavior intervention over

04:07:31.621 --> 04:07:33.922
dangerous disciplinary
techniques for provide the

04:07:34.757 --> 04:07:37.590
school protocols on the use of
restraint and seclusion in

04:07:37.827 --> 04:07:40.496
schools. I want to stress that
this bill does not prohibit

04:07:41.630 --> 04:07:43.630
restraint and seclusion we're

04:07:43.431 --> 04:07:45.432
talking about minimum safeguards
for example if you have a

04:07:45.768 --> 04:07:48.268
student as well and you know the
student has asthma. You should

04:07:48.738 --> 04:07:51.241
not push the student down on the
floor in a promo straight

04:07:51.241 --> 04:07:53.641
restraint that will restrict
breathing. If there's an

04:07:54.760 --> 04:07:56.844
emergency were student behavior
presents an imminent danger of

04:07:57.580 --> 04:08:00.114
school physical harm to is to
self or others then the use of

04:08:00.649 --> 04:08:02.884
restraints permissible. For most
students are other ways to

04:08:03.350 --> 04:08:05.219
improve behavior and you will
hear testimony to to confirm

04:08:06.455 --> 04:08:08.956
that. This bill is supported by
disability rights california to

04:08:09.990 --> 04:08:12.392
testify today in support of ab
twenty six fifty seven is leslie

04:08:12.794 --> 04:08:15.396
morrison the director of
investigations with disability

04:08:15.829 --> 04:08:17.829
rights california. And eduardo

04:08:18.533 --> 04:08:21.169
miguel miguel from port feel
academy.

04:08:21.169 --> 04:08:23.637
You can thank you for the
opportunity to address the

04:08:23.705 --> 04:08:26.140
committee today I'm leslie
morrison I'm director of the

04:08:26.741 --> 04:08:29.420
investigations unit at
disability rights california.

04:08:29.777 --> 04:08:31.845
Disability rights california's
the proud sponsor of this bill

04:08:32.112 --> 04:08:34.714
and we thank doctor weber for
authoring ab twenty six fifty

04:08:35.449 --> 04:08:37.651
seven.
I started my career as a

04:08:37.885 --> 04:08:40.553
registered nurse and I have a
master's degree in psychiatric

04:08:40.754 --> 04:08:42.754
nursing in a used to run in

04:08:43.357 --> 04:08:45.692
patient acute psych programs
that use restraint and seclusion.

04:08:46.460 --> 04:08:48.461
I saw first hand the dangers and
trauma that resulted from these

04:08:49.297 --> 04:08:51.397
practices.
I now on the division of

04:08:51.932 --> 04:08:54.333
disability rights california
that conducts investigations

04:08:55.200 --> 04:08:57.770
into allegations of abuse
neglect and we have done dozens

04:08:58.638 --> 04:09:00.638
and dozens of cases involving

04:09:00.841 --> 04:09:03.508
injuries and deaths. Resulting
from restrain seclusion

04:09:04.344 --> 04:09:06.679
including injuries to children
in schools they hand out the

04:09:07.447 --> 04:09:10.347
doctor weber mention is just a
handful we counted on nearly a

04:09:11.500 --> 04:09:13.584
thirty five cases that we've
done. It disability rights

04:09:14.454 --> 04:09:17.356
california alone. These are
dangerous practices that can

04:09:18.157 --> 04:09:20.559
cause injury and death.
As doctor weber said this bill

04:09:21.600 --> 04:09:23.695
does not prohibit the use of
restraints seclusion we want to

04:09:24.497 --> 04:09:26.665
keep children safe and nothing
in this bill limits are

04:09:27.333 --> 04:09:29.901
prohibits staff from using
restraint seclusion to stop

04:09:30.736 --> 04:09:33.270
imminently dangerous behavior.
It provides protocols to help

04:09:34.390 --> 04:09:36.841
guide the safe use of restraints
seclusion in the rare instance

04:09:37.443 --> 04:09:40.244
where it is required.
It applies the same statutory

04:09:40.945 --> 04:09:42.945
language that we see in other

04:09:43.415 --> 04:09:45.683
california laws that extend to
other places were restrained

04:09:46.251 --> 04:09:48.251
seclusion is used including

04:09:48.353 --> 04:09:51.187
hospitals nursing homes group
homes community centers. Mental

04:09:51.756 --> 04:09:53.756
health facilities and state

04:09:54.259 --> 04:09:56.994
facilities.
It sets minute the bill sets

04:09:57.362 --> 04:09:59.563
minimum safeguards and
protections for water known

04:10:00.198 --> 04:10:01.355
dangerous techniques but it does
-

04:10:02.265 --> 04:10:04.901
not stop teachers from intervene
to keep a child safe.

04:10:05.436 --> 04:10:08.205
Children in schools serve the
same protections that other

04:10:08.940 --> 04:10:11.841
individuals receive when they're
subjected to restrain seclusion

04:10:11.908 --> 04:10:14.110
and it's especially in for
important for children because

04:10:14.412 --> 04:10:16.613
they're a particular risk of
injury and death from the these

04:10:17.547 --> 04:10:20.830
practices.
As doctor weber mention

04:10:20.618 --> 04:10:23.519
california has fallen behind
where we will once a leader and

04:10:23.554 --> 04:10:25.554
how to handle children with

04:10:25.856 --> 04:10:28.623
challenging behaviors. This bill
would bring california law up to

04:10:29.293 --> 04:10:31.293
date with the reforms enacted by

04:10:31.294 --> 04:10:33.461
dozens of other states and that
are consistent with the u. S.

04:10:33.764 --> 04:10:36.664
department of education
guidelines. And that's the other

04:10:37.650 --> 04:10:39.835
hand of the doctor weber.
Provided you.

04:10:40.337 --> 04:10:42.703
It's time to meet these minimum
national standards and bring

04:10:43.905 --> 04:10:45.974
california in line with
standards adopted throughout the

04:10:46.541 --> 04:10:48.376
country. It's time to provide
children with the same

04:10:49.679 --> 04:10:52.114
protections everyone else.
Exposed to these potentially

04:10:53.216 --> 04:10:55.983
dangerous practices receive
likely certainly summers I urge

04:10:56.850 --> 04:10:59.540
your aye vote and I'm available
for technical questions thank
you and keep it two minutes

04:11:01.991 --> 04:11:04.126
please.
Assembly members miners doctor

04:11:04.126 --> 04:11:06.394
ever miguel and I'm board
certified behavior analysts in a

04:11:07.610 --> 04:11:09.697
doctor of education. How the
foods of serving que to twenty

04:11:09.864 --> 04:11:12.500
two students with intellectual
and developmental disabilities

04:11:12.935 --> 04:11:15.236
as a founder and principal for
few preparatory?

04:11:15.938 --> 04:11:17.704
A nonpublic school with campuses
an orange and san bernardino

04:11:18.600 --> 04:11:20.508
counties.
We serve over thirty different

04:11:20.676 --> 04:11:22.676
school districts who rely on us

04:11:22.712 --> 04:11:25.413
to educate up to hundred forty
five students at a time. Was

04:11:26.180 --> 04:11:28.349
severe challenging behaviors.
My national training and

04:11:29.818 --> 04:11:32.190
experience included using
seclusion room demonstrates as

04:11:32.687 --> 04:11:35.556
part of a strategy.
I saw first hand how dangerous

04:11:35.590 --> 04:11:38.158
and term dramatic these
techniques are in building

04:11:38.225 --> 04:11:41.280
relationships. And keeping kids
safe.

04:11:41.362 --> 04:11:43.430
Now having educated students
without the use of such

04:11:43.531 --> 04:11:46.990
emotionally and physically
harmful techniques for several

04:11:46.699 --> 04:11:49.301
years and proving it works I can
confidently say that there's a

04:11:50.638 --> 04:11:52.605
better way. A more humane way
for students to thrive beyond

04:11:53.574 --> 04:11:55.809
restraint.
The behavior that we see a poor

04:11:55.910 --> 04:11:58.711
bureau who student biting
themselves until severe bleeding

04:12:00.114 --> 04:12:02.180
occurs reclined sutures.
Punching themselves in the place

04:12:02.549 --> 04:12:04.382
until they bleed or bones are
broken.

04:12:04.918 --> 04:12:07.553
Pulling their hair out of their
head smearing feces attempted

04:12:07.654 --> 04:12:10.421
he'd harmful items including
feces.

04:12:11.458 --> 04:12:14.226
Property destruction urinating
stripping naked just to name a
few.

04:12:14.660 --> 04:12:17.129
There's almost always repeat
behaviors at a predictable and

04:12:17.764 --> 04:12:20.666
can be anticipated as a students
reaction to certain stimuli.

04:12:21.340 --> 04:12:23.869
The majority of students that
are referred to us have

04:12:24.737 --> 04:12:27.730
histories of being restrained.
In some cases several times per

04:12:27.730 --> 04:12:29.641
day and over thirty times per
month.

04:12:30.900 --> 04:12:32.711
Our focus is to allow our
students to learn and grow.

04:12:33.800 --> 04:12:35.714
We do this without restraint or
seclusion because it doesn't

04:12:36.916 --> 04:12:39.818
work it doesn't teach but it
does injure and it does kill.

04:12:40.218 --> 04:12:42.819
This bill takes into account
what no student should have to

04:12:42.890 --> 04:12:45.157
experience in a learning
environment. Which includes

04:12:45.157 --> 04:12:47.292
students being restrained or
secluded where the risk of

04:12:48.127 --> 04:12:50.127
injury or death is substantially

04:12:50.696 --> 04:12:53.231
increased. Ab two six five seven
promotes positive accountable

04:12:53.632 --> 04:12:56.330
learning and prohibits students
from being held down and

04:12:57.350 --> 04:12:59.603
dangerous positions being
isolated and unobserved.

04:13:00.305 --> 04:13:02.773
Restrained by multiple people
and for long periods in an

04:13:03.808 --> 04:13:05.808
effort to punish children colors

04:13:06.645 --> 04:13:09.146
children extort children or as a
means of convenience.

04:13:12.298 --> 04:13:14.251
The bill recognizes emergency
interventions such as restraint
and seclusion May be needed and

04:13:14.652 --> 04:13:16.987
does not prevent staff from
using straight or seclusion when

04:13:17.789 --> 04:13:20.557
the risk of injury or death is
imminent.

04:13:20.857 --> 04:13:23.326
Emergency intervention should
only be utilized all

04:13:24.829 --> 04:13:27.496
intervention spill and only in
emergency situations thank you

04:13:28.320 --> 04:13:30.320
doctor weber for bringing this

04:13:30.267 --> 04:13:32.168
important legislation is my hope
that you'll support thank you

04:13:33.304 --> 04:13:34.704
others is for me come forward
state your name.

04:13:35.973 --> 04:13:38.674
Affiliation and position on the
bill only please good evening
married there with the county

04:13:39.309 --> 04:13:40.943
behavioral health directors and
where pleased to support this

04:13:43.747 --> 04:13:45.882
legislation.
Good evening terrace a much out

04:13:45.882 --> 04:13:48.317
of her common sense kids action
also in support.

04:13:48.351 --> 04:13:50.618
Critics california's a
disability rights in mental

04:13:52.923 --> 04:13:55.524
health client in strong support.
Gen jahmal a california land to

04:13:55.725 --> 04:13:57.725
john family services and support

04:13:58.395 --> 04:14:00.395
as amended.

04:14:00.763 --> 04:14:02.764
Journalists member california's
us state council on

04:14:02.898 --> 04:14:04.898
developmental disabilities

04:14:04.899 --> 04:14:06.934
longtime teacher and parent of
young adult with autism in

04:14:09.272 --> 04:14:11.539
support thank you.
Eric rather stay counseling

04:14:11.539 --> 04:14:13.539
developmental disabilities the

04:14:17.130 --> 04:14:19.681
councils in support.
Crises above average that with
educate advocate empower family

04:14:20.815 --> 04:14:22.815
california and a parent of a

04:14:23.752 --> 04:14:25.752
special needs child in support.

04:14:25.787 --> 04:14:28.423
Wendy kiedy parent of a child
with autism in support.

04:14:32.194 --> 04:14:34.194
Thank you any opposition.

04:14:34.563 --> 04:14:36.997
Gov or.
Us center borrero california

04:14:38.980 --> 04:14:40.501
school employees association we
are not opposed to this bill a

04:14:41.503 --> 04:14:44.104
we have concerns and we are
working with the authors office.

04:14:44.472 --> 04:14:46.740
We only recently raise the
scoobies concerns so all I

04:14:46.875 --> 04:14:49.543
wanted to acknowledge the
authors office willing to

04:14:49.576 --> 04:14:51.576
address them.

04:14:51.846 --> 04:14:54.810
Our concerns involved a staff
person that's form behavior

04:14:54.282 --> 04:14:57.500
restraintbeing President The
meeting thank you thank you

04:14:57.752 --> 04:14:59.719
great. Other spree boxing no
other opposition.

04:15:00.955 --> 04:15:03.823
You can help me understand this
bill because I'm.

04:15:03.958 --> 04:15:06.326
You know me doctor weber I have
concerns about things like this

04:15:06.660 --> 04:15:09.396
my concern is that we try and
micromanage school sites.

04:15:09.997 --> 04:15:12.398
From sacramento does me that
that's what you're trying to do
here.

04:15:12.766 --> 04:15:15.533
I think what you're trying to
get staff train.

04:15:16.103 --> 04:15:18.204
I think what you're trying to do
is.

04:15:18.938 --> 04:15:20.938
Be proactive.

04:15:21.475 --> 04:15:24.310
And not react to not punish kids
by restraint punished but I

04:15:24.611 --> 04:15:26.979
don't want to.
Tied down anything like that.

04:15:27.347 --> 04:15:29.381
But I come from the real world
quote unquote where I see kids

04:15:30.483 --> 04:15:33.217
get in fights.
Right at lunch time girls of the

04:15:34.887 --> 04:15:36.887
worst by the way ramen legal and

04:15:37.900 --> 04:15:39.291
it May have a go at it.
Them this advice is true.

04:15:39.291 --> 04:15:41.492
And the the motions are
and right and.

04:15:42.328 --> 04:15:43.962
And so help me understand from
from someone who works at a

04:15:45.364 --> 04:15:47.766
school why this is a good idea
to get. I get that I don't want

04:15:48.533 --> 04:15:50.635
someone.
Give a hand cupped anything for

04:15:51.504 --> 04:15:54.105
for hours for punishment I mean
like that. I'm more concerned

04:15:55.643 --> 04:15:58.411
about.
Cool says some at a school sites

04:15:59.178 --> 04:16:01.779
ability to intervene. And
control situation

04:16:01.947 --> 04:16:04.820
then the punishment's on the
punish site picked up is that

04:16:05.150 --> 04:16:07.585
not what about. I'm more
concerned about the intervention

04:16:08.520 --> 04:16:10.520
you got two kids going at it.

04:16:10.654 --> 04:16:12.390
You know you got.
Several thousand kids out there

04:16:12.657 --> 04:16:15.159
and lunch time you've gotta stop
the situation quickly because

04:16:16.610 --> 04:16:18.462
it's going to grow if you don't.
If you don't react.

04:16:19.297 --> 04:16:21.366
That maybe a bigger problem
here you just can't sit there

04:16:21.699 --> 04:16:24.368
watch kids fight and is this
going to have a chilling effect.

04:16:25.300 --> 04:16:27.871
On our steps willingness and
ability to interact with kids

04:16:27.905 --> 04:16:29.905
into control situations that

04:16:30.641 --> 04:16:32.975
might already. Be out of hand.
I'm not sure if we're actually

04:16:33.311 --> 04:16:35.879
talking about fights and at the
playground at lunch time those

04:16:36.412 --> 04:16:38.814
things May happen in and
oftentimes there of security

04:16:39.417 --> 04:16:42.250
folks that it there. To handle
those particular issues and to

04:16:42.753 --> 04:16:45.356
and to and to engage it we're
probably talking more in terms

04:16:45.356 --> 04:16:47.356
of students with special needs

04:16:48.900 --> 04:16:50.760
weber. Of who basically are a
and classrooms who need various

04:16:51.728 --> 04:16:54.596
kinds of activities done to keep
them from.
Basically hurting themselves or

04:16:55.498 --> 04:16:58.301
hurting someone else and so it's
a but as pointed out. But we're

04:16:58.802 --> 04:17:01.370
not taking away the ability to
do restraints if that's

04:17:02.105 --> 04:17:04.607
necessary ought to basically
engage at that level but we're

04:17:05.108 --> 04:17:07.108
saying that it is important that

04:17:08.345 --> 04:17:10.345
as a. Educator in a classroom
and anna school side if you're

04:17:10.680 --> 04:17:12.748
out in the school site that you
know that there are other ways

04:17:13.783 --> 04:17:16.450
that you can use to not have to
restrain children. To tie them

04:17:17.252 --> 04:17:20.870
down into to those kinds of
things and I think our expert

04:17:20.288 --> 04:17:22.925
witness here who has a school
who's dealt with those. Children

04:17:22.925 --> 04:17:24.925
and if you want to respond to

04:17:25.127 --> 04:17:27.195
the question of has demonstrated
that there are other ways that

04:17:27.729 --> 04:17:29.664
we need to do it. You know one
of the sad things often to

04:17:30.299 --> 04:17:32.299
happenings is as we say do we

04:17:32.534 --> 04:17:34.302
really need to do this what we
really do because.

04:17:35.137 --> 04:17:37.570
If oftentimes we have become lax
in it when we moved away from

04:17:38.172 --> 04:17:40.700
the one we did have resources
hopefully to probably to train

04:17:40.776 --> 04:17:43.770
people. And as a result when you
don't say things and you have

04:17:43.712 --> 04:17:46.180
new population the people coming
into the schools to work.

04:17:46.348 --> 04:17:48.682
You haven't given them the
information and the and the

04:17:48.817 --> 04:17:51.119
guidelines in the things that
they need. So therefore things

04:17:51.119 --> 04:17:53.487
go awry.
Then we're confronted with the

04:17:53.487 --> 04:17:56.880
situation something horrible
happens.

04:17:56.624 --> 04:17:58.624
Then people come up to us and

04:17:58.827 --> 04:18:00.827
ask us why is it some child died

04:18:01.127 --> 04:18:03.797
on a campus wide to some kid was
hospitalized y. The some. Here

04:18:03.866 --> 04:18:05.866
have their back broken or

04:18:06.200 --> 04:18:07.902
something from people sitting on
them and trying to hold them on

04:18:08.736 --> 04:18:11.271
the ground I mean wipe y.
Because we have not provided a

04:18:13.107 --> 04:18:15.407
positive. Approach to it affront
preventing rather than waiting

04:18:15.808 --> 04:18:18.244
to after the fact of try to cure
something.
And that's what this bill is

04:18:19.580 --> 04:18:21.647
about.
And hell if you will be very

04:18:21.647 --> 04:18:23.616
when his comments because you in
a savings don't don't you have a

04:18:23.751 --> 04:18:26.219
particular.
Do chiu syrup particular.

04:18:26.653 --> 04:18:28.486
A particular part our student
population at your school site

04:18:29.122 --> 04:18:31.724
or you have.
All types of students in your

04:18:33.930 --> 04:18:35.930
school. We serve arm all the way

04:18:35.495 --> 04:18:37.495
from severely disabled to modern

04:18:38.365 --> 04:18:40.320
design so similar question reach
on I'm gonna I'm gonna get that

04:18:40.900 --> 04:18:43.568
you talk with. That's my concern
is I I think.
It seems that what we're talking

04:18:43.568 --> 04:18:45.568
about is students with special

04:18:46.473 --> 04:18:48.540
needs student ip six address.
And I get I get that.

04:18:49.675 --> 04:18:52.511
But I'm also concerned about
students without ip students

04:18:52.745 --> 04:18:55.681
that are not special needs it
seems pretty broad. And I don't

04:18:56.349 --> 04:18:58.683
want again any student to be
restrained.

04:19:00.386 --> 04:19:02.854
Especially for punishment. Of
my concerns were talking we seem

04:19:04.288 --> 04:19:06.324
to be focusing on. A you know
ste just some of our student

04:19:07.226 --> 04:19:09.260
population and yet if the bill
applies to all of our student

04:19:09.762 --> 04:19:12.300
population.
If I could just jump in this

04:19:12.598 --> 04:19:14.999
bill really does not allow a
does not prohibit a teachers

04:19:15.200 --> 04:19:17.401
from jumping in to break up the
kind of a fight that you would.

04:19:17.903 --> 04:19:19.903
You're describing it doesn't

04:19:20.720 --> 04:19:22.390
stop a teacher from grabbing a
five year old is running into

04:19:23.241 --> 04:19:25.843
traffic what it does stop is
using particularly dangerous

04:19:26.344 --> 04:19:28.845
techniques that we know ensuring
kill that are prohibited

04:19:29.214 --> 04:19:31.248
everyplace all to restrain
seclusion are used.

04:19:31.248 --> 04:19:33.248
So.

04:19:33.785 --> 04:19:35.785
It doesn't prohibit the kind of.

04:19:36.540 --> 04:19:37.821
Just it you know incidents that
you're describing.

04:19:38.456 --> 04:19:40.891
.
Part of the reason why we have

04:19:41.590 --> 04:19:43.794
an and disability rights
california has done dozens and

04:19:44.280 --> 04:19:46.897
dozens of cases where kids to
restrain secluded not because

04:19:47.500 --> 04:19:49.599
they pose an image imminent risk
because. They wouldn't stay

04:19:50.301 --> 04:19:52.235
seated in their chair for an
hour during.

04:19:53.738 --> 04:19:56.172
A classroom exercise on that
that that's what I get I get I

04:19:56.440 --> 04:19:58.174
get that component I'm just
worried bout the much broader

04:19:59.609 --> 04:20:02.512
picture approached this bill has
today. So this bill again does

04:20:03.614 --> 04:20:05.614
not prevent teachers from

04:20:06.416 --> 04:20:09.180
intervening on it just prohibits
particularly dangerous practices

04:20:10.354 --> 04:20:12.354
and it requires that the child's

04:20:12.555 --> 04:20:14.555
behavior pose a risk before. A

04:20:14.825 --> 04:20:17.293
teacher intervene.
And the reason why it's not just

04:20:17.794 --> 04:20:20.329
a special education bill as we
think that these protections

04:20:21.130 --> 04:20:23.899
should apply to all students. On
data collected by the us

04:20:24.670 --> 04:20:26.670
department of education shows

04:20:26.201 --> 04:20:28.201
that general ed students are

04:20:28.738 --> 04:20:31.730
exposed to these practices just
as much as special ed students

04:20:31.406 --> 04:20:33.475
are least exposed.
We certainly know some of the

04:20:33.743 --> 04:20:35.743
data shows that special ed

04:20:35.912 --> 04:20:38.213
students are exposed much more.
Thank you thank you art dot

04:20:38.380 --> 04:20:41.116
continued says I just today I'm
not convinced.

04:20:41.183 --> 04:20:43.818
That I'm worried that this is
too broad.

04:20:44.787 --> 04:20:47.221
And I understand when is an iep
and you know you've got only

04:20:47.890 --> 04:20:50.910
students of a you know. Of up
only a specific part are stern

04:20:50.826 --> 04:20:52.826
population or school I think.

04:20:52.828 --> 04:20:54.828
This is a better fit. I wonder

04:20:55.498 --> 04:20:57.932
if it's the best fit.
For for all of our student

04:20:58.834 --> 04:21:01.302
population and again.
Let me clarify I don't want

04:21:01.937 --> 04:21:04.672
anyone restraint but at the same
time. And when you have students

04:21:05.205 --> 04:21:07.941
that are violent violent
situation interactions said you

04:21:08.943 --> 04:21:11.146
just have to have some ability.
To to to and that.

04:21:11.146 --> 04:21:13.146
that.

04:21:13.280 --> 04:21:15.949
Interaction.
That thank you. And I think the

04:21:16.500 --> 04:21:18.719
in the bill allows that to
happen you know but oftentimes a

04:21:19.319 --> 04:21:21.788
restraint to use not because a
person is of a danger to

04:21:22.722 --> 04:21:24.457
themselves or someone else. You
know I've been its schools went

04:21:25.226 --> 04:21:27.661
bites of occurred and as a
school board member actually got

04:21:28.996 --> 04:21:31.699
him stop the fight.
_ I didn't know anybody yes

04:21:31.699 --> 04:21:33.967
I'd never go anybody on the
ground. Low but they were

04:21:34.535 --> 04:21:37.337
fighting in nearby act like they
was scared so I went broke them
up.

04:21:39.373 --> 04:21:42.400
You know of.
You know but out at the same
time.

04:21:42.743 --> 04:21:45.770
You know I've also seen people
take kids implemented brown

04:21:45.346 --> 04:21:47.346
because a kid kept toponymic
couldn't stop him from talking.

04:21:47.414 --> 04:21:49.448
You know they had to get the
last word in and they were

04:21:49.783 --> 04:21:51.783
running their mouth and the

04:21:52.840 --> 04:21:54.987
teacher got upset to include kid
against a wall and thurmond
grounded sat on a. And those

04:21:55.188 --> 04:21:57.657
kinds of things oftentimes of
the person to student wasn't a

04:21:57.657 --> 04:21:59.657
danger to.

04:21:59.793 --> 04:22:01.827
But anybody else and they just
run into my house and sometimes

04:22:01.828 --> 04:22:04.960
this is the only way they know
how to stop of one restrain

04:22:04.897 --> 04:22:06.897
whatever it was. So it's not

04:22:07.500 --> 04:22:09.768
always the fact that the person
is that is is.

04:22:09.801 --> 04:22:11.770
All is is hurting themselves of
someone else's that this is a

04:22:12.238 --> 04:22:14.539
strategy that should not be used
unless there is a situation of

04:22:15.700 --> 04:22:17.343
danger. And you're to prevent
something from her happening

04:22:17.343 --> 04:22:19.343
that's their.

04:22:19.645 --> 04:22:21.278
You know we as a society have
to begin to.

04:22:22.480 --> 04:22:24.115
acknowledge the fact it's
oftentimes there's

04:22:24.650 --> 04:22:27.552
disproportionate treatment and
we recognize that in the federal

04:22:27.686 --> 04:22:30.870
guidelines that have come out of
federal reports have shown that

04:22:30.321 --> 04:22:32.791
african american males are more
likely to be thrown on the

04:22:32.791 --> 04:22:35.758
ground and to be. The only gets
wall so it shouldn't surprise us

04:22:35.827 --> 04:22:37.960
when we see what happens when
they become adults.

04:22:38.463 --> 04:22:40.965
They're more likely to have
those levels of restraints and

04:22:41.499 --> 04:22:44.200
and activities that it there and
office also there more often

04:22:44.401 --> 04:22:46.336
likely to be classified a
special live why because

04:22:46.904 --> 04:22:49.105
behavior problems. Not
necessarily because of academic

04:22:49.574 --> 04:22:52.342
problems but because of behavior
problems so if we're going to

04:22:52.475 --> 04:22:55.178
address that begin to address
this early in life we have to

04:22:55.613 --> 04:22:58.115
start in the schools and make
this a part of it. And the

04:22:58.481 --> 04:23:01.251
hughes bill that passed in
nineteen ninety was really one

04:23:01.385 --> 04:23:03.687
of the first steps toward us
recognizing the fact that we

04:23:03.988 --> 04:23:06.356
could do something better.
In the state and you look at

04:23:06.524 --> 04:23:08.825
the list and you see where all
the states are who using the

04:23:09.727 --> 04:23:11.628
various kinds of restraints and
who have certain policies in

04:23:12.262 --> 04:23:14.262
place. California's at the

04:23:14.997 --> 04:23:16.733
bottom of we have given up our
place what we once were the

04:23:17.167 --> 04:23:19.702
premier place in terms of
special education and meeting

04:23:19.870 --> 04:23:21.870
the needs of kids and we have to

04:23:22.500 --> 04:23:24.140
begin to once again. Go back to
that and rebuild it and

04:23:25.742 --> 04:23:27.843
disability rights organization
recognizes of.

04:23:28.411 --> 04:23:30.512
Clearly that it happened
significantly but kids would

04:23:31.790 --> 04:23:33.790
specially but also sometimes for

04:23:33.183 --> 04:23:35.651
others but it doesn't take away
the right to do restraints if it

04:23:35.819 --> 04:23:37.819
smells like you any any others

04:23:37.987 --> 04:23:39.987
from the committee wish to call.

04:23:40.523 --> 04:23:42.725
To kiley out so I'm struggling
with the child like charm from

04:23:42.725 --> 04:23:45.360
this a little bit too I it it
seems that you know there is a

04:23:45.360 --> 04:23:47.360
general principle here that

04:23:47.363 --> 04:23:49.631
we're all. Agreeing on and
that's the restraints are
seclusion.

04:23:51.199 --> 04:23:53.701
Should not be used except.
You know in in exit

04:23:54.435 --> 04:23:57.338
he's over there is an emergency
I don't have a fairly
comprehensive sort of menu of.

04:23:58.540 --> 04:24:00.375
Policy limitations
that.

04:24:01.810 --> 04:24:03.676
Appear to be a comedy varying
degrees in different states I'm

04:24:04.847 --> 04:24:06.814
spent wondering where these
particular.

04:24:07.749 --> 04:24:09.749
Policy limitations

04:24:09.751 --> 04:24:12.686
come from and why I'm having
trouble can it judging okay I
did are these

04:24:12.854 --> 04:24:15.555
dozen or however many there are
in this bill.
The right ones that we won't

04:24:15.690 --> 04:24:18.425
have in place in order to.
Change practice in a positive

04:24:18.959 --> 04:24:21.328
way so this policy
recommendations came that from

04:24:21.863 --> 04:24:24.532
the us department of education
they issued a guidance a fifteen

04:24:24.532 --> 04:24:26.532
recommended.

04:24:26.901 --> 04:24:29.234
Guidelines that states should
implement and so we.

04:24:30.437 --> 04:24:32.939
Then looked at the u. S.
Department of education's

04:24:34.274 --> 04:24:36.910
analysis of how every state is
doing and put it together a

04:24:36.911 --> 04:24:39.770
chart form said these are the
recommendations from the us

04:24:39.413 --> 04:24:42.480
department of education about
what schools. A state should

04:24:43.684 --> 04:24:45.684
adopt.

04:24:49.230 --> 04:24:51.230
Alright thank you.

04:24:51.692 --> 04:24:53.692
Seeing no further comment.

04:24:54.261 --> 04:24:56.280
Mr them.
claims chair I appreciate the.

04:24:56.395 --> 04:24:58.395
.

04:24:58.465 --> 04:25:00.832
Consternation and and people
who've raise concerns about

04:25:01.668 --> 04:25:03.668
balance I would just say that.

04:25:03.904 --> 04:25:06.637
I think that this bill is moving
in the direction of where really

04:25:07.540 --> 04:25:09.341
the sectors have been going to
say that.

04:25:09.843 --> 04:25:12.444
We should be using restraint on
their kids.

04:25:12.911 --> 04:25:15.800
Even for kids who have severe
needs that there are other ways

04:25:15.982 --> 04:25:17.982
to redirect behavior.

04:25:18.985 --> 04:25:21.286
And and that unfortunately when
out restraint has been relied

04:25:22.455 --> 04:25:24.455
upon there have been serious

04:25:24.590 --> 04:25:26.590
incidents and that have led to

04:25:26.959 --> 04:25:28.959
serious here injury. And trauma.

04:25:29.128 --> 04:25:31.496
For me and so while we always
struggle how to intervene in an

04:25:32.498 --> 04:25:34.933
emergency situation I think we
have to say. That.

04:25:35.501 --> 04:25:37.501
We want to limit the

04:25:37.635 --> 04:25:40.104
circumstances were asking
someone to put their hands on
some.

04:25:41.373 --> 04:25:43.373
As a way of redirecting.

04:25:43.674 --> 04:25:45.776
Behavior that is either typical
behavior for that student

04:25:46.244 --> 04:25:48.790
regardless of what that students
level of.

04:25:50.514 --> 04:25:52.315
Practice behavior function is
but we we when we put our hands

04:25:52.851 --> 04:25:55.320
on kids and
I if there isn't one already
Miss Charo make a motion to move

04:25:55.320 --> 04:25:57.320
this.

04:26:00.240 --> 04:26:02.659
Thank you.
To move to second it up please

04:26:03.610 --> 04:26:05.329
close thank you very much I
appreciate all of your comments

04:26:06.970 --> 04:26:08.398
and your concerns and as pointed
out these are. You know these

04:26:08.733 --> 04:26:10.833
are guidelines that have come
from the federal government as

04:26:10.968 --> 04:26:13.336
to how we should be acting in
our schools and what states have

04:26:14.705 --> 04:26:17.208
adopted. And where we stand you
know in this in this building we

04:26:17.208 --> 04:26:20.176
have passed an awful lot of.
Bills talking about mental

04:26:20.945 --> 04:26:22.711
health.
And help look it would just pass

04:26:23.130 --> 04:26:25.582
one a day in terms of counseling
in mental health and all the

04:26:25.582 --> 04:26:28.217
things we want to do in our
schools. And how our kids are

04:26:28.519 --> 04:26:31.320
suffering from trauma and that's
so true the last thing we want

04:26:31.888 --> 04:26:34.789
to do is to create more trauma
or didn't accentuate the trauma

04:26:35.591 --> 04:26:37.591
and so I respectfully ask the

04:26:37.694 --> 04:26:40.563
aye vote. Of for it ab twenty
six fifty seven.

04:26:41.765 --> 04:26:43.765
Rethinking the motion is to pass.

04:26:46.403 --> 04:26:49.371
As amended to appropriations.
O'donnell no.

04:26:52.475 --> 04:26:54.475
O'donnell no kiley.

04:26:54.944 --> 04:26:56.944
Kiley not voting. Kalra.

04:26:56.946 --> 04:26:58.946
Mccarty.

04:27:00.160 --> 04:27:02.160
Mccarty aye steinorth.

04:27:02.518 --> 04:27:04.518
Thurmond.

04:27:09.358 --> 04:27:11.358
Thurmond aye weber aye weber aye.

04:27:13.729 --> 04:27:15.228
Bills three votes it is on call.
With that will go to.

04:27:16.131 --> 04:27:18.131
.

04:27:18.500 --> 04:27:21.350
Mister Chiu. That's ab seventeen
sixty three file item number

04:27:36.518 --> 04:27:38.518
three file item number three

04:27:48.663 --> 04:27:50.663
.

04:27:53.968 --> 04:27:55.968
See.

04:27:56.300 --> 04:27:58.300
Please proceed took a very much.

04:27:58.906 --> 04:28:00.906
Mister Chair and members amy

04:28:01.375 --> 04:28:04.343
seventeen sixty three. Requires
all high school to provide

04:28:05.579 --> 04:28:07.579
information on college options

04:28:08.115 --> 04:28:10.816
creek school options and public
and private financial aid. To

04:28:11.750 --> 04:28:13.750
every student at least once to

04:28:14.254 --> 04:28:16.254
integrate night to twelve. It

04:28:16.989 --> 04:28:19.725
provides flexibility to schools
on how this information could be

04:28:21.294 --> 04:28:23.294
provided. As study shows that.

04:28:23.997 --> 04:28:25.997
Educated worker earns more than

04:28:27.000 --> 04:28:29.340
seventy percent more dan does
was only a high school degree.

04:28:30.360 --> 04:28:32.904
And this is also an increased
demand and skilled workers

04:28:33.705 --> 04:28:35.705
a big of vocational school is

04:28:36.175 --> 04:28:38.175
just an important s. College.

04:28:38.309 --> 04:28:40.309
Because college is not for

04:28:40.613 --> 04:28:42.613
everyone letting kids know the

04:28:42.615 --> 04:28:45.160
option that they are available
to them couldhelp them make

04:28:45.783 --> 04:28:47.783
better decisions regarding to

04:28:47.953 --> 04:28:49.953
your. Career path here with me

04:28:50.556 --> 04:28:53.524
today in support is eserver
though gus garcia was who

04:28:54.927 --> 04:28:56.927
california teachers association.

04:28:58.196 --> 04:29:00.197
And during the us germiston us
was just a buildings and

04:29:02.567 --> 04:29:04.567
construction trades council.

04:29:04.668 --> 04:29:07.338
Good afternoon Mister Chairman
members I'm isabel garcia on

04:29:07.572 --> 04:29:09.540
behalf of the california
teachers association we urge

04:29:10.375 --> 04:29:12.375
your support for a bi seventeen

04:29:13.944 --> 04:29:15.944
sixty three. Cta us supports the

04:29:15.946 --> 04:29:18.915
critical a rule a certificated
counselorsas they provide

04:29:20.685 --> 04:29:22.985
academic and career counselling
to guide our students for their

04:29:24.288 --> 04:29:26.288
course taking to graduate and

04:29:26.422 --> 04:29:28.725
for their post graduation
interests.

04:29:29.593 --> 04:29:31.593
Unfortunately many school sites

04:29:32.960 --> 04:29:34.764
lack the sufficient finding.
I for the appropriate number of

04:29:34.999 --> 04:29:37.666
counselors for their student
ratios.

04:29:38.202 --> 04:29:40.636
So this bill helps fill in the
gaps of information for our

04:29:41.238 --> 04:29:44.140
students.
The bill underscores.

04:29:44.775 --> 04:29:47.542
The importance of knowledge of
of career and college

04:29:48.450 --> 04:29:50.379
preparedness for our students
and their families throughout

04:29:51.381 --> 04:29:54.116
the educational system but but
especially. In middle school and

04:29:54.918 --> 04:29:57.853
high school.
In short cta supports the bill's

04:29:59.289 --> 04:30:02.570
focus for increased access
to academic concurrent formation

04:30:02.959 --> 04:30:05.294
to better prepare students to
succeed and our state and

04:30:06.610 --> 04:30:08.610
national economy.

04:30:08.663 --> 04:30:10.632
So we urge arrival.
Thank you Mister Chairman birth

04:30:10.700 --> 04:30:13.660
committee jeremy smith here
behalf of the state building and

04:30:13.569 --> 04:30:16.500
construction trades council. We
are out happy to support this

04:30:16.500 --> 04:30:18.500
bill today.

04:30:18.340 --> 04:30:20.375
We we we we've been talking for
many many years.

04:30:20.709 --> 04:30:23.178
That.
High schools need to get back

04:30:24.179 --> 04:30:26.881
to what they used to do. Which
was prepare kids for college and

04:30:27.316 --> 04:30:30.251
career.
Everything from the home ec

04:30:30.384 --> 04:30:32.785
classes.
To the aye member of my learn

04:30:33.355 --> 04:30:35.822
to write well balanced checkbook
in high school to their cte

04:30:36.291 --> 04:30:38.859
courses that let you work with
your hands and and and realize

04:30:39.660 --> 04:30:41.629
the world of work out there that
that does involving university

04:30:42.764 --> 04:30:44.798
self. Unhappy is for the bill
today and I would urge everybody.

04:30:44.799 --> 04:30:47.601
On this committee to also
support our efforts you.

04:30:48.101 --> 04:30:50.804
Increase more.
Ridiculous education center

04:30:51.172 --> 04:30:53.739
grant funding to the kids
connection of classes.

04:30:54.809 --> 04:30:56.809
That this bill aims to out to

04:30:59.447 --> 04:31:01.447
tell about thank you.

04:31:02.416 --> 04:31:04.416
Other witnesses on support.

04:31:05.152 --> 04:31:07.152
When this is in opposition.

04:31:09.210 --> 04:31:11.592
They were home.
Campbell in them.

04:31:11.592 --> 04:31:13.592
Question the comments from

04:31:15.796 --> 04:31:17.796
committee members.

04:31:17.898 --> 04:31:20.566
I have one question the.
Chiu so it seems like there is

04:31:21.500 --> 04:31:23.936
already in the education code.
A similar.

04:31:25.304 --> 04:31:28.730
Provision that requires.
This sort of information be

04:31:28.808 --> 04:31:31.243
sent out actually every year.
This is education code.

04:31:32.746 --> 04:31:34.613
Five one two two nine are you
familiar with this and what is

04:31:35.580 --> 04:31:37.782
yes I think that.
Required

04:31:37.782 --> 04:31:40.217
school to send out a notice to
the parent.

04:31:41.154 --> 04:31:43.154
And I'd information does not

04:31:43.990 --> 04:31:46.925
include the financial assistance
three possible port forward to

04:31:48.494 --> 04:31:50.494
financial eight. So does bill

04:31:52.645 --> 04:31:54.370
will of would required to school
to send it directly to the
student.

04:31:55.990 --> 04:31:57.869
And also provides home for nay
if of financial aid assistance

04:32:02.700 --> 04:32:04.340
information.
Thanks art we will have real

04:32:05.377 --> 04:32:07.745
good control. Of what did
movement.

04:32:08.347 --> 04:32:10.347
It happened in their home so I

04:32:10.381 --> 04:32:12.160
want to student who received the.
The style of their parents to

04:32:12.684 --> 04:32:14.684
receive.

04:32:16.555 --> 04:32:18.889
I see so goes to student rather
than the parents and I have two
young.

04:32:19.557 --> 04:32:21.158
Notice to the parents every
artist knows to students at

04:32:21.826 --> 04:32:23.826
least once.

04:32:24.362 --> 04:32:26.362
Right and that and also we added

04:32:26.798 --> 04:32:28.798
though do you get financial aid.

04:32:29.467 --> 04:32:32.202
The information a small.
Okay we don't because. Of thank

04:32:32.637 --> 04:32:34.637
you very much idea respectfully

04:32:35.706 --> 04:32:37.574
ask for your arrival.
Months of trying to motions do

04:32:38.409 --> 04:32:39.876
passed to procreation splits
cultural.

04:32:41.450 --> 04:32:43.813
O'donnell
kiley no kiley no kalra.

04:32:45.716 --> 04:32:48.617
Mccarty.
Mccarty aye steinorth.

04:32:50.190 --> 04:32:52.190
Thurmond.

04:32:53.957 --> 04:32:55.957
Thurmond aye weber. Weber aye.

04:32:56.894 --> 04:32:59.596
Three wishes.
Old we need it if. We're gonna

04:32:59.596 --> 04:33:01.596
need to do a review on that what

04:33:02.866 --> 04:33:05.000
I do have a motion and a second.
Now we do alright let's try that

04:33:06.636 --> 04:33:08.636
again.

04:33:09.137 --> 04:33:11.137
O'donnell kiley.

04:33:11.940 --> 04:33:13.940
Kiley no kalra mccarty mccarty

04:33:14.175 --> 04:33:16.175
aye steinorth.

04:33:16.479 --> 04:33:18.479
Thurmond thurmond ye weber.

04:33:19.582 --> 04:33:21.582
Weber aye.

04:33:23.553 --> 04:33:25.553
thank you very good night.

04:33:39.902 --> 04:33:41.902
The bill is on come

04:33:43.537 --> 04:33:45.406
.
Ms arlen

04:33:53.315 --> 04:33:54.570
europe.
Is.

04:33:55.684 --> 04:33:57.616
Item number.
Thirty one eighty thirty forty

04:33:58.618 --> 04:34:00.421
eight.
Thanks to.

04:34:01.689 --> 04:34:03.689
Mister Chair and mr thurman for

04:34:03.892 --> 04:34:06.326
letting me go in front ab thirty
forty eight in its simplest form

04:34:06.828 --> 04:34:08.795
seeks to streamline the process
to monitors teacher

04:34:09.263 --> 04:34:11.265
credentialing.
Currently the most school

04:34:11.265 --> 04:34:14.234
districts must provide
information about teacher
credentials and course

04:34:14.302 --> 04:34:16.803
assignments to their county
offices of education every four

04:34:17.505 --> 04:34:20.206
years.
Through a manual process in

04:34:20.573 --> 04:34:23.760
three separate databases this
information is used to identify

04:34:23.976 --> 04:34:26.212
Miss Assignments or teachers
with the credential outside of

04:34:26.914 --> 04:34:29.315
the class that they teach.
Under this bill the commission

04:34:29.450 --> 04:34:31.652
on teacher credentialing and the
department education would be

04:34:31.985 --> 04:34:34.652
able to share the data they
already have to find potential

04:34:35.389 --> 04:34:37.390
Miss Assignments.
They can then send these

04:34:37.624 --> 04:34:39.525
potential this assignments to
counties to review with the

04:34:39.860 --> 04:34:42.461
school districts.
Since this process would be

04:34:42.963 --> 04:34:45.496
automated this would allow for
yearly teacher monitoring

04:34:46.232 --> 04:34:48.300
instead of every four years.
This would be an opportunity for

04:34:48.902 --> 04:34:50.902
our educational agencies to run

04:34:50.904 --> 04:34:53.272
more efficiently lee and provide
greater oversight of our teacher

04:34:53.940 --> 04:34:56.241
assignments.
However this is a big change

04:34:56.574 --> 04:34:59.144
from the current process and
requires input from multiple

04:34:59.410 --> 04:35:01.646
stakeholders we have held
multiple meetings with the

04:35:01.813 --> 04:35:04.582
commission county school
districts teachers. And many

04:35:04.917 --> 04:35:07.752
others to create a new school
system and there is still work

04:35:08.120 --> 04:35:10.488
to be done I'd ritual I had
originally set out to streamline

04:35:12.690 --> 04:35:14.992
and onerous an outdated process.
We had a number of up productive.

04:35:16.128 --> 04:35:18.128
Meetings with stakeholders.

04:35:26.671 --> 04:35:29.540
In an attempt to recreate this.
Complicates this process as I

04:35:30.108 --> 04:35:32.575
understand certain charter
school teachers are required to

04:35:33.144 --> 04:35:35.450
hold credentials are ready but
their inclusion in this knew

04:35:35.812 --> 04:35:37.981
monitoring process is something
we could of considered once the

04:35:39.317 --> 04:35:42.152
new. System wise and place
however I will accept this and

04:35:42.387 --> 04:35:44.853
other amendments suggested by
the committee and want to thank

04:35:45.255 --> 04:35:47.624
them for all their work.
On this bill I look forward to

04:35:47.891 --> 04:35:50.327
working with all those involved
to consolidate the credential

04:35:51.894 --> 04:35:54.398
monitoring into one system and I
have with me here in support

04:35:54.398 --> 04:35:55.999
josh what sparks from the
commission on. Teacher

04:36:00.938 --> 04:36:02.370
credentialing.
Thank you.

04:36:02.940 --> 04:36:05.308
Members maybe structure speaks
and I represent the commission

04:36:05.542 --> 04:36:08.209
on teacher credentialing.
I will travesty brief this is

04:36:08.679 --> 04:36:10.980
an equity issue.
Effective and transparent

04:36:11.213 --> 04:36:13.949
assignment monitoring helps
ensure that all students get an

04:36:15.152 --> 04:36:17.387
effective in qualify teacher.
So I'll ask for your aye vote

04:36:17.387 --> 04:36:19.387
and I am happy to answer any

04:36:20.357 --> 04:36:22.357
questions you May have.

04:36:22.959 --> 04:36:24.959
Other isn't support.

04:36:33.350 --> 04:36:35.350
Witnesses in opposition.

04:36:40.376 --> 04:36:42.409
Hope.
Mister Chair members isabel

04:36:43.100 --> 04:36:45.100
garcia.

04:36:45.800 --> 04:36:47.882
With the california teachers
association with the committee

04:36:47.883 --> 04:36:49.883
amendments.

04:36:49.985 --> 04:36:52.387
We are removing our opposition
in recommending a support we

04:36:52.855 --> 04:36:55.288
want to thank the authored the
sponsor in the committee for

04:36:55.689 --> 04:36:58.659
working with us to address our
concerns regarding data privacy

04:36:59.795 --> 04:37:02.463
for teachers. And including
charter schools.

04:37:03.465 --> 04:37:06.233
Think.
So county was a witness in

04:37:07.402 --> 04:37:09.437
support now is in opposition.
Yeah I was to carry members john

04:37:09.437 --> 04:37:12.239
when you're on the other the
california charter school says
he asian.

04:37:13.274 --> 04:37:15.909
Respectfully here in opposition
with the.
Committee amendment.

04:37:15.910 --> 04:37:18.278
We believe teacher
credentialing flexibility as a

04:37:18.913 --> 04:37:20.881
core tenet of charter schools
and allows charter schools to

04:37:21.382 --> 04:37:23.382
innovate in areas such as block

04:37:23.417 --> 04:37:25.919
scheduling. Integrated
curriculum and blended learning.

04:37:26.886 --> 04:37:28.755
Confining charter school
teachers to state defined

04:37:30.890 --> 04:37:32.559
classifications inhibits the
very tentative charter schools.

04:37:33.600 --> 04:37:34.961
Currently charter schools are
required to retain all

04:37:35.829 --> 04:37:37.997
credentials in the charter
school authorized her is

04:37:38.298 --> 04:37:40.900
ultimately responsible for
monitoring complaints at the

04:37:40.901 --> 04:37:42.901
local level.

04:37:42.903 --> 04:37:45.238
Ab thirty forty eight includes
a statewide definition of core

04:37:46.506 --> 04:37:48.874
courses in charter schools this
broad application is problematic

04:37:49.408 --> 04:37:51.944
within the unique.
Charter school structure with

04:37:53.113 --> 04:37:55.681
which retains local flexibility
between the charter school and

04:37:55.682 --> 04:37:58.170
it's authorized or in
determining the appropriate

04:37:59.519 --> 04:38:01.485
designation of specific courses.
We strongly believe that the

04:38:03.423 --> 04:38:06.224
charter schools must maintain
autonomy and flexibility.

04:38:06.626 --> 04:38:09.280
Better remain successful in
producing positive results

04:38:09.280 --> 04:38:11.496
toward students.
For these reasons we must

04:38:11.564 --> 04:38:13.999
respectfully oppose.
Ab thirty forty eight with the

04:38:16.768 --> 04:38:18.768
amendments.

04:38:19.872 --> 04:38:21.404
Other witnesses in opposition.
Questions comments from

04:38:23.242 --> 04:38:25.242
committee members.

04:38:26.444 --> 04:38:28.444
Doctor what.

04:38:28.781 --> 04:38:31.149
What are the consequences of I'm
trying to find out in this in

04:38:32.184 --> 04:38:34.619
this bill what down?
For Miss Assignments of.

04:38:36.855 --> 04:38:38.855
What happens?

04:38:39.357 --> 04:38:41.357
But we actually are.

04:38:41.525 --> 04:38:43.795
With this new process trying to
focus more on providing

04:38:43.795 --> 04:38:46.328
technical assistance in
providing supports.

04:38:47.164 --> 04:38:49.833
To districts that are
struggling with that however if

04:38:50.680 --> 04:38:52.270
the bill does have language in
it that would allow us to adopt

04:38:52.270 --> 04:38:54.439
regulations.
.

04:38:54.439 --> 04:38:56.873
That would create a set of
consequence

04:38:57.308 --> 04:38:59.509
but what we are trying to focus
more.
I think in.

04:39:01.145 --> 04:39:03.880
.
In harmony with the state's

04:39:04.949 --> 04:39:07.417
overall focus on trying to
support and trying to.

04:39:09.190 --> 04:39:11.686
You know improve schools rather
than sort of you know hold out

04:39:12.189 --> 04:39:14.357
the threat of punishment to them
so that's or focusing on

04:39:14.558 --> 04:39:17.393
initially.
What do you what what would you

04:39:17.861 --> 04:39:20.296
what are you doing in terms of
of what has been asked to?

04:39:21.898 --> 04:39:23.364
Responsive schools it May not
be traditional.

04:39:24.935 --> 04:39:27.470
the number of schools that are
not traditional in terms of.
.

04:39:27.871 --> 04:39:30.306
Certification in terms
especially those who are having

04:39:31.410 --> 04:39:34.900
curriculum that goes across
several disciplines in the

04:39:34.878 --> 04:39:36.879
applied curriculum in all kinds
of innovative things how are you

04:39:37.646 --> 04:39:40.115
responding to that.
It because it May not fit into

04:39:41.150 --> 04:39:42.851
the. You know the the category
that this person is teaching

04:39:43.786 --> 04:39:46.521
history I've been to some of
those schools that have. You

04:39:46.689 --> 04:39:49.491
know with their history and
literature and science is all

04:39:49.959 --> 04:39:51.959
blended into one.

04:39:53.195 --> 04:39:55.195
Because huge o. Kind of low

04:39:55.431 --> 04:39:57.499
curriculum of love. That so I
think long beach does some of

04:39:58.200 --> 04:40:00.635
that in some of the places how
do you respond to that. Right

04:40:00.836 --> 04:40:02.836
are you specifically talk about

04:40:03.380 --> 04:40:05.340
the charter schools no this this
is some of the traditional

04:40:05.340 --> 04:40:07.340
schools I attended.

04:40:07.609 --> 04:40:09.911
They have I'm black and I can
think of the name of the term

04:40:10.779 --> 04:40:12.413
but you do a lot of long beach.
.

04:40:12.880 --> 04:40:14.880
.

04:40:15.450 --> 04:40:17.450
Would you call it.

04:40:19.604 --> 04:40:22.489
Well I mean I que at school
sometimes you'll have someone
teaching humanities which often
hello I'm just going to have a

04:40:22.991 --> 04:40:25.359
history was on signs focuses on
some rocketry.

04:40:25.460 --> 04:40:28.228
But what the literature the
history and the math and science

04:40:28.496 --> 04:40:30.496
was all in one.

04:40:30.865 --> 04:40:33.200
Huge could kind of curriculum
double didn't the american

04:40:34.235 --> 04:40:36.937
identified as it's been up the
matter things yet but it it's

04:40:40.880 --> 04:40:42.409
something it's an a if to spell
patents like this past August so.

04:40:44.545 --> 04:40:46.645
I'm I'm sorry please no no go
ahead now I know that yeah if

04:40:46.879 --> 04:40:49.160
you're caught up the public
schools ready there's or. This

04:40:49.160 --> 04:40:51.551
requirement is already in place
this is just streamlining the
requirements of whatever they

04:40:51.819 --> 04:40:53.886
were doing. Before and what was
accept acceptable for

04:40:54.720 --> 04:40:56.556
flexibility in credentialing is
still going to be done this is

04:40:58.458 --> 04:41:01.193
just really automating.
That process so would it then

04:41:01.261 --> 04:41:03.263
how does this apply to charter
says well that's that the

04:41:03.263 --> 04:41:05.263
charters.

04:41:05.797 --> 04:41:08.268
We initially had not a.
Applied this bill to charters

04:41:08.268 --> 04:41:10.736
disk there was a committee
amendment that included the

04:41:11.471 --> 04:41:12.704
charter so we have not worked
with.

04:41:14.700 --> 04:41:16.775
On the flexibility get on the
additional flexibility that

04:41:16.876 --> 04:41:18.876
they're claiming they need they

04:41:23.115 --> 04:41:24.950
say. You know we really have to
understand.

04:41:26.218 --> 04:41:28.954
Exactly what is. What they do
with credentialing before we can

04:41:30.256 --> 04:41:32.324
figure out exactly how to
include them in this year I
think? It if I could just add to

04:41:32.324 --> 04:41:34.427
that so.
Current ad code.

04:41:34.427 --> 04:41:37.262
Regarding charter schools.
Says that a.
Teacher to charter school

04:41:37.463 --> 04:41:39.497
didn't needs to hold a
certificate permit or other

04:41:39.832 --> 04:41:42.398
document that's equivalent to
that which a public school

04:41:43.135 --> 04:41:45.303
teacher would have. If they are
working and.

04:41:48.106 --> 04:41:50.106
In core or college prep courses.

04:41:50.408 --> 04:41:52.743
Arbil actually does not.
At any definition of of what

04:41:53.245 --> 04:41:55.613
core subjects are but there are
definitions of that already

04:41:55.714 --> 04:41:57.714
existing in state law.

04:41:58.516 --> 04:42:00.984
Away if they're not in a core.
Subject or if they're not in a

04:42:01.518 --> 04:42:04.320
college prep course than they do
you have. A pretty wide

04:42:05.356 --> 04:42:07.156
discretion are bill doesn't
change that that's all existing

04:42:07.992 --> 04:42:09.992
law. All this.

04:42:10.610 --> 04:42:12.929
The assignment money monitoring
process does
is.

04:42:14.265 --> 04:42:16.265
It it gives us a a more

04:42:16.667 --> 04:42:18.667
streamlined way of checking up

04:42:18.869 --> 04:42:20.869
on whether or not schools both

04:42:21.539 --> 04:42:24.374
traditional and charter. Are.
Meeting the requirements that

04:42:25.943 --> 04:42:28.676
already currently exist in state.
And add to your question about

04:42:28.677 --> 04:42:30.879
you know when when people are
coming up with blended courses

04:42:31.381 --> 04:42:33.749
or try new and innovative things.
.

04:42:35.652 --> 04:42:38.354
The commission as well as a
county offices of education.

04:42:40.900 --> 04:42:41.924
Provide technical assistance to
schools.

04:42:43.393 --> 04:42:46.261
In in positions like that.
And we we try to help advise

04:42:47.300 --> 04:42:49.164
them to remain within the
constraints of existing

04:42:50.398 --> 04:42:53.101
education code. While also.
Allowing them to be innovative

04:42:53.469 --> 04:42:54.903
and and come up with new ways to
deliver.

04:42:56.305 --> 04:42:58.305
Trading stood.

04:42:59.342 --> 04:43:01.977
So my assumption is that. As a
as since this is something added
on it begin that.

04:43:02.912 --> 04:43:05.380
.
That there are going to be some

04:43:05.381 --> 04:43:08.217
discussions about.
What needs to be done if you if

04:43:08.217 --> 04:43:10.852
they have to be clip included in
this list?

04:43:11.353 --> 04:43:13.421
I assume that this this that
much work still left to be done

04:43:14.823 --> 04:43:17.725
and not just.
Oftentimes we put it on somebody

04:43:18.293 --> 04:43:20.895
without really doing the work
the internal work as you say you

04:43:20.963 --> 04:43:23.831
hadn't given it any thought
until someone recommended it.

04:43:25.434 --> 04:43:27.268
All so I assume that there will
be some effort to.

04:43:28.690 --> 04:43:30.905
.
Discuss how they're to be

04:43:32.173 --> 04:43:34.273
incorporated in this well dirt
does like I mentioned before

04:43:34.342 --> 04:43:36.744
there have been multiple
stakeholder meetings and the

04:43:37.677 --> 04:43:40.381
charters were not stakeholders
until very recently so we have

04:43:40.381 --> 04:43:42.381
every intention to.

04:43:43.151 --> 04:43:45.151
To work with them and and and.

04:43:46.352 --> 04:43:47.988
.
You know figure out how to get

04:43:49.924 --> 04:43:51.924
into the bill.

04:43:53.728 --> 04:43:56.529
Okay. Are aye I don't. Have to
decide if I'm going to vote on
it until it's done okay thank

04:43:56.996 --> 04:43:59.432
you.
I just want to clarify the
purpose of this bill is to make

04:43:59.533 --> 04:44:01.533
sure the teachers are sign

04:44:01.769 --> 04:44:03.769
correctly is that true. Cracked

04:44:03.771 --> 04:44:06.437
okay and this really just merely
set up an automated process.

04:44:06.640 --> 04:44:08.708
For school districts across
california much easier fashion

04:44:09.309 --> 04:44:11.750
and charters
to identify whether their

04:44:11.812 --> 04:44:14.680
teachers are son correctly.
So I don't know from the charter

04:44:15.113 --> 04:44:17.113
sign what's wrong with that aye

04:44:17.484 --> 04:44:19.886
I fail to see what's wrong with
that. Other then yo've got some

04:44:19.886 --> 04:44:21.787
you don't tell us I mean it's
pretty I mean you do have more

04:44:22.522 --> 04:44:24.189
leeway.
And the traditional is already

04:44:25.580 --> 04:44:27.693
we're not attempting to change
that today so I'm I'm I'm still

04:44:28.828 --> 04:44:31.363
confused and where this argument
comes that they don't want it to

04:44:31.898 --> 04:44:34.366
artists and automated process.
Kind helps everybody identify

04:44:34.567 --> 04:44:36.567
whether or not teachers are site

04:44:36.869 --> 04:44:38.870
correctly.
And I think I should write

04:44:39.470 --> 04:44:42.700
because I will go up not where
we have not.
We are not considering them

04:44:43.142 --> 04:44:46.760
stakeholders yet because I'm
initially will bring them into
the conversation so you're

04:44:46.278 --> 04:44:48.212
committed to that thank you yeah
the skin you look like you're

04:44:48.647 --> 04:44:50.647
jumping back there you want to

04:44:53.719 --> 04:44:55.486
talk so go for it.
Whiskey and with public

04:44:56.622 --> 04:44:59.223
advocates I missed the in a in
support.

04:45:00.258 --> 04:45:02.258
Of line think you.

04:45:05.297 --> 04:45:07.766
Okay.
Okay and again you know be more

04:45:07.766 --> 04:45:10.334
conversations about this going
on down the road.

04:45:11.603 --> 04:45:14.500
Thanks so with that thank you. I
just want to give that up there
a few times close decision a

04:45:14.500 --> 04:45:16.500
chance to respond.

04:45:16.140 --> 04:45:18.942
Shares concerns are aye
question I should say aye ayes

04:45:19.577 --> 04:45:21.678
to you know why this is
something that was he trying to

04:45:23.112 --> 04:45:25.249
actually closes up because I
think she's committed to work
with them so I don't.

04:45:25.249 --> 04:45:27.917
I don't wanna continue the
debate on if I say something you

04:45:28.986 --> 04:45:30.986
say you want to it is just about

04:45:31.550 --> 04:45:33.788
over so let's not say quickly
and I trust that bradley will be.

04:45:33.891 --> 04:45:36.791
You don't lease I had.
I think I think just from from a

04:45:37.361 --> 04:45:39.696
high level perspective we just
have a issue with having a

04:45:40.429 --> 04:45:42.300
statewide definition of.
Of course is that interferes

04:45:42.666 --> 04:45:45.268
with
the local flexibility with our

04:45:45.268 --> 04:45:47.268
authorized users.

04:45:47.904 --> 04:45:49.705
Will will continue to engage
with the author but.

04:45:50.307 --> 04:45:52.473
From it's my understanding that
we've never been included in

04:45:53.877 --> 04:45:56.779
this monitoring system but.
Sounds like we have more
conversations a seat

04:45:57.447 --> 04:46:00.150
so thank you this doesn't change
any definition of any course

04:46:00.216 --> 04:46:02.840
this bill does not do that.
We've stated that for

04:46:02.452 --> 04:46:04.453
emphatically today so I don't
know where that concerns coming

04:46:04.753 --> 04:46:07.388
from but that will be part of
your conversation.

04:46:08.691 --> 04:46:11.359
With that do we have a motion.
All movement to have a second

04:46:12.161 --> 04:46:14.161
it's been moved and seconded.

04:46:14.163 --> 04:46:16.640
You the motion is support as
amended.

04:46:17.533 --> 04:46:19.533
Please close.

04:46:19.835 --> 04:46:22.680
I respectfully ask your aye the.
Please call the roll.

04:46:22.338 --> 04:46:24.338
Motion is.

04:46:25.608 --> 04:46:27.408
I'm sorry. Do pass as amended
do pass as medical.

04:46:29.110 --> 04:46:31.412
To appropriations.
O'donnell aye o'donnell aye

04:46:33.916 --> 04:46:36.651
kiley. Kiley no kalra.
Caller I mccarty.

04:46:38.952 --> 04:46:41.922
Mccarty aye steinorth.
They're meant. Thurmond aye
weber.

04:46:44.492 --> 04:46:47.461
.
Local for now and we.

04:46:50.630 --> 04:46:52.630
Okay whether I.

04:46:55.370 --> 04:46:57.304
Bob.
There's five does. The us five

04:46:57.371 --> 04:46:59.306
votes it is out next we're gonna
go to.

04:47:00.675 --> 04:47:02.675
.

04:47:03.377 --> 04:47:05.377
Mister Choose comes irwin is

04:47:08.249 --> 04:47:10.249
gone Miss Waldron.

04:47:10.317 --> 04:47:12.819
Almost I'm sorry Miss Waldron.
Mr thurman I made a previous

04:47:13.620 --> 04:47:15.254
arrangement go right before you
says he'll be official at the

04:47:16.557 --> 04:47:18.858
time.
So thank you for your patience

04:47:19.425 --> 04:47:21.861
and understanding apologies to
Miss Waldron thank you Mister

04:47:22.950 --> 04:47:24.950
Chair members of the committee.

04:47:24.264 --> 04:47:26.465
I have a witness use on a tight
schedule has to leave

04:47:27.167 --> 04:47:29.467
unfortunately but thank you. For
the opportunity to present ab

04:47:30.170 --> 04:47:32.605
twenty seven eighty eight twenty
seven eighty eight that is file

04:47:40.460 --> 04:47:43.310
item number.
Twenty some file item twenty
seven.

04:47:43.649 --> 04:47:46.184
You May proceed.
thank you Mister Chair I ab

04:47:46.652 --> 04:47:49.200
twenty seven eighty eight seeks
to help us address our teacher

04:47:50.220 --> 04:47:52.357
shortage. Aye in the state is
well documented many of our

04:47:52.758 --> 04:47:55.360
districts are experiencing
teacher shortage there many ways

04:47:56.128 --> 04:47:58.620
to to help address that but one
of the.

04:47:59.398 --> 04:48:02.100
Issues it has become a barrier
is a lack of affordable housing

04:48:03.502 --> 04:48:05.937
for educators a to live in the
districts where they work up

04:48:06.472 --> 04:48:09.600
this bill seeks to create a way
for school districts. In

04:48:09.306 --> 04:48:12.108
partnership with nonprofit
developers to build affordable

04:48:12.778 --> 04:48:15.513
housing for teachers and
classified staff so that they

04:48:15.907 --> 04:48:18.449
can remain in the communities
where they work. Historically

04:48:19.500 --> 04:48:21.784
our housing programs have not a
provide funding for programs

04:48:22.200 --> 04:48:24.421
that will go up as high as a
hundred twenty percent a a mind

04:48:26.570 --> 04:48:28.158
which is. That level where work
teachers and others in our

04:48:29.527 --> 04:48:32.129
workforce are typically.
Fall in that range.

04:48:32.662 --> 04:48:34.662
This bill would create a new

04:48:34.699 --> 04:48:36.733
program that would allow school
districts the resources they

04:48:38.135 --> 04:48:40.135
need for pre development. And

04:48:40.137 --> 04:48:42.522
development of affordable rental
housing to support.

04:48:42.773 --> 04:48:44.773
At of the building of housing

04:48:44.809 --> 04:48:46.809
for teachers and classifieds

04:48:47.143 --> 04:48:48.978
that we've seen that in many
districts including rural

04:48:49.413 --> 04:48:51.781
districts are recruiting and
retaining teachers has been a

04:48:52.750 --> 04:48:55.251
difficult challenge. I'm aware
of districts that have reported.

04:48:57.186 --> 04:48:59.455
That four years running they
have to replace as many as two

04:49:00.190 --> 04:49:02.792
hundred or more teachers every
single year we know that's a

04:49:03.326 --> 04:49:05.861
threat to closing archie me gap
of supporting our students. And

04:49:05.962 --> 04:49:07.962
so we think this is a creative

04:49:08.565 --> 04:49:11.101
way. To address the issue.
With me today to provide

04:49:11.266 --> 04:49:14.169
additional emphasis is the
superintendent of alameda county

04:49:16.104 --> 04:49:18.340
office of education karamana row.
And representing west contra

04:49:19.941 --> 04:49:22.577
costa unified is dominic dutra
from dcg strategies who was

04:49:23.379 --> 04:49:25.379
assisting that district with

04:49:25.448 --> 04:49:27.448
their efforts to build employee

04:49:28.150 --> 04:49:30.151
housing I respectfully ask you
aye vote.

04:49:32.555 --> 04:49:35.523
What does?
Good afternoon chair o'donnell

04:49:36.492 --> 04:49:38.960
and members of the committee I
it's a privilege to be before

04:49:40.461 --> 04:49:43.397
you again. This is an issue that
I am sure your quite familiar

04:49:43.788 --> 04:49:45.733
with the.
Teacher shortage we have been

04:49:46.435 --> 04:49:48.435
talking about it for the last

04:49:48.470 --> 04:49:50.638
few years now. A what were
certainly fining in alameda

04:49:53.260 --> 04:49:55.242
county is that.
We have employed strategies

04:49:55.777 --> 04:49:58.178
honor supporting legislation
that would support strategies.

04:49:59.681 --> 04:50:01.448
To attract teachers to the
profession to.

04:50:02.851 --> 04:50:04.851
Actually increase the teaching

04:50:04.953 --> 04:50:07.321
force in the fields where we
know it's needed most in the

04:50:07.821 --> 04:50:09.821
sciences and in special

04:50:10.358 --> 04:50:12.358
education. Are however without

04:50:12.527 --> 04:50:14.527
affordable housing that problem

04:50:14.962 --> 04:50:17.462
is compounded so we do a great
job of having some teachers come

04:50:17.864 --> 04:50:19.864
to places like oakland are

04:50:20.201 --> 04:50:22.635
berkeley. And then they find out
what it's going to cost actually

04:50:24.103 --> 04:50:26.720
lives there. Ought and cannot
sign the contract.

04:50:27.508 --> 04:50:29.941
Choose to go elsewhere and
quite frankly a lot of them are

04:50:30.611 --> 04:50:33.412
disillusioned of by.
This profession that they've

04:50:33.914 --> 04:50:36.148
chosen to go into.
That they can't afford to

04:50:37.351 --> 04:50:39.726
remaining in in a lot of cases
so.

04:50:40.219 --> 04:50:42.721
i for one am are quite
committed to making sure that we

04:50:43.523 --> 04:50:45.523
have places for our.

04:50:45.825 --> 04:50:47.825
Teachers and more broadly our

04:50:47.927 --> 04:50:50.600
workforce in education to live
are the only county office of

04:50:50.597 --> 04:50:53.532
education has been working to
actually use some of the land

04:50:54.801 --> 04:50:57.101
that it house for this purpose.
On we're looking at creative

04:50:58.171 --> 04:51:01.106
ways of of funding such a thing
we have.

04:51:01.339 --> 04:51:04.209
Of the land that we could invest
in this and really want to be

04:51:05.111 --> 04:51:07.111
able to us serve our districts

04:51:07.513 --> 04:51:09.414
by providing more housing for
their work force I believe this

04:51:11.483 --> 04:51:13.483
is a. Critical issue and I hope

04:51:17.210 --> 04:51:19.222
that you will support this bill.
Not dominick do try.

04:51:20.425 --> 04:51:22.393
Of from the city of fremont I
just want a brief I know you've

04:51:22.794 --> 04:51:25.290
had a long days I want to speak
briefly from a policy a

04:51:25.297 --> 04:51:27.799
professional in the and a
personal perspective. From a

04:51:27.799 --> 04:51:29.799
policy perspective.

04:51:29.834 --> 04:51:32.770
My family goes back thirty
years my dad was in the
twentieth I represented the

04:51:33.305 --> 04:51:35.739
twenty assembly district and I
was on the city council in the

04:51:35.739 --> 04:51:37.923
city of fremont.
So we have a long history of

04:51:38.141 --> 04:51:40.141
supporting affordable housing.

04:51:40.511 --> 04:51:43.246
Opportunities and projects
within the region and

04:51:48.432 --> 04:51:50.620
legislation just has simply not
caught up with what we now call
the missing middle the v. As
assembly member thurman as noted.

04:51:51.789 --> 04:51:54.900
The the gap funding and the pre
development funding is simply

04:51:54.857 --> 04:51:57.794
not there legislatively to allow
us to effectively. Build these

04:51:58.280 --> 04:52:00.197
sort of projects I know that
from a professional perspective

04:52:00.197 --> 04:52:02.197
to their family's been in the

04:52:02.366 --> 04:52:04.934
real estate industry. For thirty
plus years I've started to firm

04:52:05.602 --> 04:52:07.870
idc you strategies that focuses
since I left the city council

04:52:08.938 --> 04:52:10.538
exclusively on work by public
entities and faith bates

04:52:11.408 --> 04:52:14.243
entities. Aye using ste socially
responsible purposes for the

04:52:14.644 --> 04:52:16.712
land this is one of them. Now
just close of the personal

04:52:17.447 --> 04:52:19.248
perspective and that is my
daughter.

04:52:19.918 --> 04:52:21.918
My daughter is a teacher sees a

04:52:22.118 --> 04:52:24.618
special ed teacher. Aye she is
not only a graduate of cal

04:52:25.188 --> 04:52:27.990
berkeley but al went on and got
her master's degree she's a

04:52:28.910 --> 04:52:30.910
special education.

04:52:30.258 --> 04:52:32.427
Teachers is in her third year
he did four years national

04:52:33.830 --> 04:52:36.331
service two years with city year
in two years with teach for
america.

04:52:37.733 --> 04:52:40.680
She now I does a fantastic job
but lives in a four hundred

04:52:40.134 --> 04:52:43.710
square foot studio in santa
clara county and spends fifty

04:52:44.807 --> 04:52:47.374
percent effort gross. Wages
she'll be moving home in May.

04:52:48.210 --> 04:52:50.479
Not that she's thrilled about
that my wife and I have to have

04:52:50.479 --> 04:52:52.815
been the empty nesters are too
thrilled about that either but.

04:52:53.282 --> 04:52:55.950
I she really doesn't have much
of a choice a because of the

04:52:56.718 --> 04:52:59.587
debt that she is taking on.
So really did it this is a

04:53:01.223 --> 04:53:03.456
fundamentally important piece of
legislation I'm so thankful for

04:53:03.857 --> 04:53:05.857
assembly member thurmond taking

04:53:05.927 --> 04:53:07.927
this up. I really do believe it

04:53:08.295 --> 04:53:10.197
will provide some of the gap of
p. Development fund that we need.

04:53:11.566 --> 04:53:13.901
To make these projects not only
viable put possible in the very

04:53:14.569 --> 04:53:17.504
near future so thank you very
much for allowing us to comment.

04:53:17.772 --> 04:53:19.873
Thank you others in support.
Good evening Mister Chair

04:53:20.141 --> 04:53:22.509
members of the committee ron
rapidly half of the california

04:53:23.244 --> 04:53:26.120
federation of teachers we are
proud co sponsors of twenty

04:53:26.347 --> 04:53:28.715
seven eighty eight and%
respectfully request an aye vote

04:53:30.651 --> 04:53:32.585
thank you.
Good evening patting her rare

04:53:32.921 --> 04:53:34.921
representing oakland unified

04:53:36.190 --> 04:53:38.624
school district in support.
Cristina marcellus on behalf of

04:53:38.959 --> 04:53:40.959
the san francisco unified school

04:53:41.562 --> 04:53:44.530
district in support.
Kai jackson with sending a
unified school district in full

04:53:46.932 --> 04:53:49.333
support.
Danielle canada because our on

04:53:50.370 --> 04:53:52.370
behalf of common sense kids

04:53:53.707 --> 04:53:55.808
action in full support.
The angela reed on behalf of the

04:53:55.974 --> 04:53:57.974
santa clara county office of

04:54:00.110 --> 04:54:02.413
education strokes.
Nick roman on behalf of the

04:54:02.549 --> 04:54:04.549
school employers associationof

04:54:06.819 --> 04:54:09.389
california in support.
Air pockets the los angeles
unified school district in

04:54:09.389 --> 04:54:11.823
support.
If you.

04:54:13.910 --> 04:54:15.360
Any opposition.
Sing opposition any comments

04:54:15.461 --> 04:54:17.461
from the committee members.

04:54:17.963 --> 04:54:19.731
Are.
Thank you Mister Chairman I

04:54:20.166 --> 04:54:23.340
thank summer thurmond for the
persistence of the thirty year

04:54:23.602 --> 04:54:26.371
opening this forward but
sometimes it takes time. To get

04:54:27.720 --> 04:54:29.172
to get things done the special
on the right things into.

04:54:30.774 --> 04:54:33.578
And although I do sympathize and
understand the governor's
position.

04:54:33.811 --> 04:54:36.314
In that the lot is mayes income
to local jurisdictions and they

04:54:36.682 --> 04:54:39.500
can decide what to do with it.
The reality is that I don't lose

04:54:40.485 --> 04:54:42.852
any one of our districts that
doesn't have at the local level.

04:54:43.722 --> 04:54:45.722
Of the need for more housing for

04:54:45.990 --> 04:54:48.625
school teachers and staff I and
I I think that because of the

04:54:49.994 --> 04:54:52.863
work. That our educators and the
staff do I think it's important

04:54:53.730 --> 04:54:56.990
for us to prioritize those funds
to ensure that they can live in

04:54:56.701 --> 04:54:58.835
the communities in which they
teach and serve our children.

04:54:59.137 --> 04:55:01.137
So I'm I'm happy about this

04:55:01.571 --> 04:55:04.408
forward again I'm of the bill.
Thank you it's been moved and mr

04:55:04.408 --> 04:55:06.843
mccarty do you suck.
It's been moved and seconded.

04:55:08.179 --> 04:55:10.179
The motion is to pass to

04:55:11.782 --> 04:55:13.782
appropriations please close.

04:55:13.817 --> 04:55:16.219
Things chair thank you Mister
Kalra for your reference to.

04:55:16.720 --> 04:55:19.254
Contest the governor's made me
you know I love our governor.

04:55:20.123 --> 04:55:22.725
But he had makes an assertion
that just isn't supported that

04:55:23.226 --> 04:55:25.226
because we finally have done

04:55:25.262 --> 04:55:28.129
something to help cities built
some affordable housing. That

04:55:29.299 --> 04:55:31.634
cities have enough money to also
help our school districts

04:55:32.335 --> 04:55:34.335
that is not an assertion that

04:55:34.704 --> 04:55:37.439
has any evidence not a fact
we've reached out to cities and.

04:55:38.740 --> 04:55:40.742
Quite frankly have said they can
barely take care of their own

04:55:41.878 --> 04:55:44.179
affordable housing needs we have
seventy five percent of

04:55:44.180 --> 04:55:46.482
california school districts who
have a teacher shortage. That we

04:55:46.482 --> 04:55:48.849
think that this is a great way
to help us close that gap I

04:55:49.418 --> 04:55:52.187
respectfully ask you aye vote.
Thank you up please call the
roll motions you passed to

04:55:53.155 --> 04:55:55.689
appropriations.
O'donnell aye o'donnell aye

04:55:57.927 --> 04:56:00.629
kiley. Kiley no kalra.
Kalra im mccarty. Mccarty aye

04:56:01.764 --> 04:56:03.764
steinorth.

04:56:03.766 --> 04:56:05.766
Thurmond thurmond aye weber.

04:56:08.403 --> 04:56:11.138
Weber aye.
Those vote five votes it is out.

04:56:11.206 --> 04:56:13.941
Thank you I'll yield my other
two bills from Miss Waldron
thank you sir.

04:56:14.509 --> 04:56:16.509
Thank you.

04:56:17.112 --> 04:56:19.880
I Miss Waldron thanks you.
come forward.

04:56:25.510 --> 04:56:27.988
Miss Waldron.
We're now on a file item.

04:56:29.224 --> 04:56:31.224
Never for file item number four

04:56:39.165 --> 04:56:41.334
ab nineteen eighty three.
Thank you Mister Chairman

04:56:42.269 --> 04:56:45.105
committee.
I'm here to present ab eighteen

04:56:45.706 --> 04:56:48.374
nineteen eighty three. And the
m. Accepting the committee

04:56:49.430 --> 04:56:51.444
amendments.
And the goal of the bill is to

04:56:51.712 --> 04:56:54.213
ensure that all children are
safer at school.

04:56:55.816 --> 04:56:57.816
Currently the school districts

04:56:58.385 --> 04:57:00.385
I see are vulnerable.

04:57:00.921 --> 04:57:03.422
What the times are wide open
gates or wide open?

04:57:04.890 --> 04:57:07.359
As a mom that's of concern to
me and that's why a particular

04:57:07.526 --> 04:57:09.526
this bill.

04:57:09.629 --> 04:57:12.364
Recent chat tragedies on school
campuses necessitate the need

04:57:12.732 --> 04:57:14.732
for schools to reassess their

04:57:14.834 --> 04:57:17.736
facilities and security for
prevention of threats.

04:57:17.904 --> 04:57:19.904
And this bill is not about a

04:57:20.306 --> 04:57:22.641
safety plan but of full security
physical and operational

04:57:23.876 --> 04:57:26.278
assessment.
The bill requires local schools

04:57:26.312 --> 04:57:29.180
to collaborate with law
enforcement.

04:57:30.216 --> 04:57:32.217
For threat assessment evaluation
which would include a full

04:57:32.718 --> 04:57:35.320
security assessment of the
campus perimeter.

04:57:36.487 --> 04:57:38.487
Fencing walls gateways parking

04:57:39.825 --> 04:57:42.560
lots lighting security cameras
entryway security school

04:57:43.996 --> 04:57:45.996
building layouts diagrams.

04:57:46.465 --> 04:57:48.465
Things like that visibility

04:57:48.600 --> 04:57:50.600
blind spots or.

04:57:50.802 --> 04:57:52.802
They have the weapons detection

04:57:53.672 --> 04:57:55.672
ability or any kind of foam.

04:57:56.474 --> 04:57:58.474
Technology that's available.

04:57:58.710 --> 04:58:01.444
Smart student id's utilization
of new technologies that might

04:58:02.450 --> 04:58:04.982
be considered.
Of communication protocol

04:58:06.618 --> 04:58:08.418
between the school public law
enforcement and the

04:58:09.530 --> 04:58:11.530
effectiveness.

04:58:11.522 --> 04:58:13.522
Of the emergency plan if.

04:58:14.324 --> 04:58:17.600
They have one in affect.
Threat assessment facility

04:58:17.595 --> 04:58:19.362
protocols ensure that all
schools have feasible

04:58:20.331 --> 04:58:22.999
protections.
Infrastructure and technologies

04:58:23.901 --> 04:58:26.769
and strategies in place to
prevent threats threats

04:58:27.403 --> 04:58:29.403
that's the goal of this prevent

04:58:30.240 --> 04:58:32.575
them. Up from happening.
And as we know when something

04:58:33.477 --> 04:58:36.345
does happen.
It's in a crisis.

04:58:37.714 --> 04:58:40.481
It's vital for schools to know
how to react and respond to each

04:58:41.184 --> 04:58:43.184
crisis of law enforcement to be

04:58:43.853 --> 04:58:45.988
knowledgeable of the facility.
And the technologies the

04:58:46.156 --> 04:58:48.824
mechanisms that are in place on
the campus.

04:58:49.920 --> 04:58:51.226
Which will help them in
responding to an emergency

04:58:51.995 --> 04:58:53.995
incident.

04:58:56.599 --> 04:58:58.734
Higher chen aye vote.
Thank you any other witness

04:58:59.106 --> 04:59:01.470
isn't support seen no other
witnesses in support see no

04:59:01.871 --> 04:59:03.871
comments from the committee the

04:59:04.400 --> 04:59:07.800
bill's been moved and seconded.
Sorry of any opposition.

04:59:07.176 --> 04:59:09.176
No one's going to oppose this.

04:59:09.779 --> 04:59:11.779
So with that.

04:59:20.321 --> 04:59:22.321
Seemed opposition no conserve I urge aye vote thank you for

04:59:23.250 --> 04:59:25.693
hearing the bill please chi call
the roll to pass is amended to

04:59:26.528 --> 04:59:28.528
appropriations. O'donnell aye

04:59:29.531 --> 04:59:31.198
o'donnell aye kiley. Kiley aye
kalra.

04:59:31.579 --> 04:59:33.667
Kalra aye mccarty.
Mccarty aye steinorth.

04:59:33.668 --> 04:59:35.668
Thurmond thurmond aye weber.

04:59:36.137 --> 04:59:38.137
Weber I.

04:59:38.506 --> 04:59:40.607
Six zero.
Other the bill's out six zero

04:59:40.808 --> 04:59:42.944
next we have a.
File item number twenty four

04:59:42.944 --> 04:59:44.944
mister gibson.

04:59:46.948 --> 04:59:48.993
Ab twenty six eighty three.
Wait hold on I lied.

04:59:48.993 --> 04:59:50.993
I did.

04:59:51.652 --> 04:59:53.652
Going.

05:00:07.800 --> 05:00:09.800
Coming.

05:00:11.804 --> 05:00:13.804
Twenty twenty think so nine.

05:00:13.839 --> 05:00:16.308
This is file item twenty.
Ab twenty six oh nine Mister

05:00:18.946 --> 05:00:20.779
O'donnell please proceed.
Thank you Mister Chair and

05:00:21.414 --> 05:00:23.716
committee members the goal of
this bill is to increase our

05:00:24.184 --> 05:00:25.918
supply of credentialed stem
teachers by recruiting

05:00:26.586 --> 05:00:28.387
scientists.
Who want to become k. Twelve

05:00:29.355 --> 05:00:31.657
teachers?
California is the middle of a

05:00:32.250 --> 05:00:34.626
chronic and severe shortage of
stem teachers which means that

05:00:34.994 --> 05:00:36.994
too many of our students don't

05:00:37.630 --> 05:00:39.997
have access. To high quality
stem education both in high

05:00:40.733 --> 05:00:42.967
school and elementary school.
At the same time many of

05:00:43.135 --> 05:00:45.837
california's early career
scientists can't find secure

05:00:46.837 --> 05:00:49.741
employment in higher education
because there aren't enough

05:00:50.609 --> 05:00:52.810
faculty jobs.
These are people who want to

05:00:54.460 --> 05:00:56.448
teach this bill helps them move
into secure rewarding careers as

05:00:56.848 --> 05:00:59.150
teachers and gives our students
direct access.

05:00:59.384 --> 05:01:01.384
To california's considerable

05:01:01.553 --> 05:01:04.222
scientific talent.
This bill also lays out a plan

05:01:04.222 --> 05:01:06.891
for supporting and retaining
these new teachers

05:01:06.992 --> 05:01:08.859
and ricardo as a report to
demonstrate that the program

05:01:10.295 --> 05:01:12.329
works.
To conclude we need multiple

05:01:12.430 --> 05:01:15.165
innovative approaches for
solving ste the stem teacher

05:01:15.599 --> 05:01:18.468
shortage this kid up this bill
can be a aluable part of our

05:01:19.771 --> 05:01:22.406
tool kit for tackling. This
statewide issue.

05:01:22.707 --> 05:01:25.241
I would be today to speak in
support of this bill are jessica

05:01:25.241 --> 05:01:27.511
psycho.
Executive director of the

05:01:27.511 --> 05:01:29.946
california science teachers
association.

05:01:30.448 --> 05:01:32.448
And lots here haynes who has a

05:01:33.284 --> 05:01:35.785
phd in biomedical sciences while
from uc san diego and was

05:01:36.519 --> 05:01:38.519
recently named la unified listen

05:01:38.555 --> 05:01:40.555
to this la unified's rookie

05:01:41.291 --> 05:01:43.291
teacher of the year.

05:01:45.280 --> 05:01:47.763
Sub go head massad masako.
Thank you good evening members

05:01:47.931 --> 05:01:50.199
my name is jessica sock on I'm
the executive director for the

05:01:50.199 --> 05:01:53.169
california science teachers
association I'm here today to

05:01:53.470 --> 05:01:55.905
ask for support for a bi twenty
six oh nine. The california

05:01:56.139 --> 05:01:58.207
science teachers association
mission is to provide a high

05:01:58.541 --> 05:02:00.976
quality science education for
all students in order for

05:02:01.476 --> 05:02:03.846
students to receive a high
quality science education. They

05:02:04.470 --> 05:02:06.381
need to have well prepared well
supported and highly qualified

05:02:07.450 --> 05:02:10.520
teachers.
In two thousand thirteen the
state board adopted the next

05:02:10.453 --> 05:02:12.519
generation science standards
they are designed to be taught

05:02:12.688 --> 05:02:15.590
in a way that embraces a young
person's innate curiosity by

05:02:15.957 --> 05:02:18.727
introducing science. And
kindergarten to all students and

05:02:18.993 --> 05:02:21.297
continuing through high school
as students progressed from

05:02:21.297 --> 05:02:23.665
grace to grade the standards
built.

05:02:23.899 --> 05:02:26.768
In understanding of and complex
a concepts over time.

05:02:26.802 --> 05:02:29.370
The new standards ask that
students think and behave like

05:02:30.339 --> 05:02:32.373
scientists and engineers like
the lovely teacher sitting next
to me.

05:02:33.674 --> 05:02:35.674
.

05:02:35.844 --> 05:02:38.746
by asking questions engaging and
sensemaking and encouraging them
to emphasize.

05:02:39.214 --> 05:02:41.415
And hands on learning and
discovery when students

05:02:41.715 --> 05:02:44.184
understand how science and
engineers do their work and have

05:02:44.419 --> 05:02:46.687
opportunities to carry out
investigations and design

05:02:47.550 --> 05:02:49.490
solutions they become more
engaged in the learning and

05:02:50.580 --> 05:02:52.558
their comprehension increases.
As articulated in the committees

05:02:52.894 --> 05:02:54.895
analysis of the bill science or
stem teacher shortage in

05:02:55.730 --> 05:02:57.898
california's real ab twenty six
or nine would leverage federal

05:02:58.266 --> 05:03:00.500
funds to recruit and support
scientists who want to move from

05:03:00.833 --> 05:03:02.833
higher education where there's a

05:03:03.236 --> 05:03:05.538
surplus of people. Wanting at
competing for jobs

05:03:06.272 --> 05:03:08.608
towards a rewarding career in
teaching science and k. Twelve

05:03:09.750 --> 05:03:11.744
making the transition from a
post secondary career track to

05:03:12.246 --> 05:03:14.614
teaching in k. Twelve setting
requires intentional and careful

05:03:15.449 --> 05:03:17.550
recruitment. Access to and
participation in a fully

05:03:18.850 --> 05:03:20.351
qualified teacher preparation
program which includes content

05:03:20.854 --> 05:03:23.322
specific pedagogy in classroom
management strategies. And

05:03:23.323 --> 05:03:25.858
professional development and
mentorship opportunities ab

05:03:26.359 --> 05:03:28.360
twenty six or nine addresses
these needs and more and I

05:03:32.831 --> 05:03:35.534
respectfully ask your aye vote.
Good evening members of the
committee my name is let's hear

05:03:36.536 --> 05:03:39.710
haines I am currently a biology
and biomedical sciences teacher

05:03:39.305 --> 05:03:41.305
I'm urban and I'm really high

05:03:41.374 --> 05:03:44.420
school in south los angeles.
If you'd asked me ten years ago

05:03:44.430 --> 05:03:46.311
whether or not 'd be a high
school teacher I would have

05:03:47.246 --> 05:03:49.800
laughed at you. And I death we
never would have thought that i

05:03:49.782 --> 05:03:51.782
would love it so much.

05:03:52.510 --> 05:03:54.510
I received my phd in biomedical

05:03:54.752 --> 05:03:57.880
sciences at uc san diego I am
the first college graduate in my

05:03:59.158 --> 05:04:01.359
me family and I am also the only
scientist in my extended family.

05:04:01.860 --> 05:04:04.762
I was able to make it to this
place of educational achievement

05:04:05.330 --> 05:04:08.650
because of amazing teachers that
I had while growing up including

05:04:08.867 --> 05:04:10.867
a high school biology teacher

05:04:10.969 --> 05:04:13.604
who also had her phd.
In addition I was a part of lots

05:04:13.739 --> 05:04:15.806
of different summer programs I
was able to interact with

05:04:16.874 --> 05:04:18.474
scientists and so as I reflected
on this during my graduate

05:04:19.109 --> 05:04:21.645
career. I decided that I wanted
to inspire young people like

05:04:22.180 --> 05:04:24.214
myself who May have never
thought about becoming a

05:04:24.616 --> 05:04:26.717
scientist because of their
backgrounds in because of their

05:04:27.485 --> 05:04:30.120
lack of exposure. Info after
making this decision I had no

05:04:31.354 --> 05:04:33.589
idea what to do you I only had
to pay for the last ten years to

05:04:34.250 --> 05:04:36.626
become a scientist and so I
found this organization called

05:04:37.428 --> 05:04:39.729
encore. An encore help me every
step of the way on my road to

05:04:40.298 --> 05:04:42.298
become an educator they helped

05:04:42.900 --> 05:04:44.901
me find teaching opportunities
they also help me prepare for

05:04:45.736 --> 05:04:47.736
tests and exams and they also

05:04:47.738 --> 05:04:49.738
help me find the perfect

05:04:50.207 --> 05:04:52.476
additional program for myself.
And now I get to see enough a
scientist the teacher in front

05:04:52.476 --> 05:04:54.476
of my two hundred students every

05:04:56.213 --> 05:04:58.213
week. And many of them would not

05:04:58.615 --> 05:05:00.516
will.
Similar to me where not the then

05:05:00.749 --> 05:05:03.453
exposed to scientists if they.
Had not met me it one of my

05:05:04.221 --> 05:05:06.822
students told me she said that.
She thought off plaintiffs look

05:05:07.589 --> 05:05:09.291
like bill nye is you never
thought that she would meet a

05:05:10.527 --> 05:05:13.262
scientist. And now she knows
that because of meeting me she

05:05:13.696 --> 05:05:15.696
could be a scientist as well and

05:05:15.765 --> 05:05:17.765
so I just respectfully ask for

05:05:18.735 --> 05:05:21.269
your so I. Am vote on this bill
thank you so much.
Thank you very much that

05:05:21.269 --> 05:05:23.269
testimony other witnesses in

05:05:24.340 --> 05:05:26.341
support.
Catherine will cuts from the

05:05:27.643 --> 05:05:29.643
encore stem teachers program. In

05:05:31.580 --> 05:05:33.815
support thank you.
Mister Chair members of and stir

05:05:34.549 --> 05:05:36.549
with a california stem that work

05:05:39.186 --> 05:05:41.371
in strong support thank you.
Nick wrongly on behalf of the

05:05:41.762 --> 05:05:43.762
school employers association of

05:05:44.726 --> 05:05:47.627
californians support.
Cristina marcellus on behalf of

05:05:49.640 --> 05:05:51.640
project lead the way in support.

05:05:51.566 --> 05:05:53.134
When this is in opposition.
Questions or comments from

05:05:54.536 --> 05:05:56.838
twenty members.
Mister O'donnell just close our

05:05:56.838 --> 05:05:59.140
eyes when I think masako for
being here the executive

05:05:59.140 --> 05:06:02.420
director and of course doctor
haines thank you. And.

05:06:02.644 --> 05:06:05.110
You know I should note that
this bill has been work to the

05:06:05.413 --> 05:06:07.413
process by no I mean who is a

05:06:07.448 --> 05:06:09.983
doctor herself in neuroscience
write. Something like that

05:06:10.750 --> 05:06:13.186
something high and I am this is
a science fellow working you've

05:06:13.570 --> 05:06:15.187
seen around she is a science
fellow.

05:06:16.257 --> 05:06:18.858
Assigned to the education
committee and doing a good job.

05:06:19.860 --> 05:06:21.761
And bring your own expertise in
our own experience even to this

05:06:23.697 --> 05:06:25.565
bill so that I respectfully ask
for and I.

05:06:25.955 --> 05:06:28.568
I love this idea of putting more
pathways for our scientists into
the classroom very happy to

05:06:28.635 --> 05:06:31.138
support it we have a motion we
need a second.

05:06:31.138 --> 05:06:33.339
Secondly was a kalra motion is
do passed appropriations please

05:06:34.641 --> 05:06:37.308
call the roll.
o'donnell try madonna I kiley

05:06:38.645 --> 05:06:40.513
aye kiley aye kalra. Kalra aye
mccarty

05:06:41.947 --> 05:06:44.483
mccarty I steinorth. Thurmond
aye thurmond aye weber.

05:06:45.550 --> 05:06:47.550
Weber I.

05:06:58.630 --> 05:07:00.630
The bill is out.

05:07:01.934 --> 05:07:03.934
Mister Gipson.

05:07:10.342 --> 05:07:12.944
Ab two six eight three.
Que he's on our file item number

05:07:13.112 --> 05:07:15.112
twenty four ab two six eight

05:07:17.850 --> 05:07:20.284
three.
You May proceed when ready thank

05:07:20.686 --> 05:07:23.540
you very much.
Mister Chair and members thank

05:07:23.689 --> 05:07:26.257
you for allowing me to present
assembly bill twenty six eighty

05:07:27.240 --> 05:07:29.240
three which seeks to improve

05:07:29.260 --> 05:07:31.260
literacy rates for low income

05:07:31.228 --> 05:07:33.228
you. I would like to thank the

05:07:33.398 --> 05:07:36.333
committee. Of force efforts and
and making and offering

05:07:36.501 --> 05:07:38.501
amendments to this bill we

05:07:38.570 --> 05:07:41.400
accept amendments I'm offered by
the committee also wonders

05:07:42.600 --> 05:07:43.740
underscore that my witness had
to leave.

05:07:45.343 --> 05:07:47.343
Back due to the our.

05:07:47.645 --> 05:07:50.546
And so we won't be having to
have someone to speak in support

05:07:50.546 --> 05:07:52.546
of from that particular stamp

05:07:52.550 --> 05:07:54.550
went. In california twenty five

05:07:54.552 --> 05:07:56.552
percent of the state's six

05:07:57.221 --> 05:07:59.221
million students are unable to

05:08:00.570 --> 05:08:02.570
read above the fifth grade level

05:08:02.920 --> 05:08:04.920
in order to effectively address

05:08:04.427 --> 05:08:07.296
functional. Illiteracy we must
focus on improving literacy

05:08:07.998 --> 05:08:09.998
outcomes at home.

05:08:10.133 --> 05:08:12.133
Research showed that children

05:08:12.636 --> 05:08:14.902
armed.
Reading caucus inst competency.

05:08:16.730 --> 05:08:18.306
Strongly correlates with the
home.

05:08:19.541 --> 05:08:21.541
Literacy environment I'm sense

05:08:21.978 --> 05:08:23.978
of low income households have

05:08:24.214 --> 05:08:26.915
less access to learning
materials functional.

05:08:28.852 --> 05:08:30.852
Literacy is a challenge that is

05:08:30.986 --> 05:08:33.522
very serious in public housing
developments

05:08:33.923 --> 05:08:36.792
children who live in public
housing developments are less

05:08:38.127 --> 05:08:40.127
likely to have experience.

05:08:40.596 --> 05:08:42.596
That encourage the development

05:08:43.532 --> 05:08:45.532
of reading skills as a result of

05:08:45.700 --> 05:08:47.700
these children enter high school

05:08:47.702 --> 05:08:49.702
with an average literacy skills

05:08:50.940 --> 05:08:52.940
of five years behind. Those of

05:08:53.140 --> 05:08:55.140
high income students to help

05:08:55.410 --> 05:08:58.379
reverse this trend this bill
will enhance the literacy skills

05:08:58.847 --> 05:09:00.847
of low income.

05:09:01.850 --> 05:09:04.351
You residing in public housing
developments through a student

05:09:06.188 --> 05:09:08.188
author book publishing program

05:09:08.890 --> 05:09:10.890
this program will be a two year

05:09:11.493 --> 05:09:13.493
pilot program that will include

05:09:13.528 --> 05:09:15.528
one thousand students. Through

05:09:15.662 --> 05:09:17.662
this program students will learn

05:09:18.366 --> 05:09:20.899
to write to edit brand and also
market their own publishing

05:09:21.235 --> 05:09:23.235
books.

05:09:23.971 --> 05:09:25.971
This type of these types

05:09:25.973 --> 05:09:27.973
programs will help of reyes

05:09:28.175 --> 05:09:30.175
literacy levels and better

05:09:30.343 --> 05:09:32.944
prepare our children for post
secondary success.

05:09:33.481 --> 05:09:35.648
I would say at this point with
me I have.

05:09:37.217 --> 05:09:39.152
Witness but they have left but
I also want to.

05:09:39.887 --> 05:09:42.388
Bring out.
That the some amazing young

05:09:43.924 --> 05:09:45.658
women young girls in high school
that has written.

05:09:46.293 --> 05:09:49.600
Books.
These young girls who.

05:09:50.462 --> 05:09:53.332
Come from nixon gardens.
Imperial courts housing

05:09:53.934 --> 05:09:55.934
development God zach.

05:09:56.200 --> 05:09:58.200
Also housing development.

05:09:58.171 --> 05:10:00.171
Who has written books who are

05:10:00.573 --> 05:10:02.339
authors I'm I tended their book
signing?

05:10:03.900 --> 05:10:05.900
The book signing.

05:10:05.945 --> 05:10:08.413
Town hall where close to a
thousand people who showed up

05:10:09.882 --> 05:10:12.551
and this is amazing in terms of
boosting one's confidence.

05:10:14.153 --> 05:10:16.153
to be a young person and to be

05:10:16.489 --> 05:10:18.489
able to say that I wrote my book

05:10:18.591 --> 05:10:21.292
and is published is an awesome
aventis so with that I

05:10:21.894 --> 05:10:23.228
respectfully ask when I vote.
Thank you.

05:10:24.662 --> 05:10:26.896
Any others in support seen
others in support any opposition

05:10:27.898 --> 05:10:30.169
seeing opposition any comments
from the committee.

05:10:30.169 --> 05:10:31.536
It's been moved and seconded
thank you.

05:10:35.939 --> 05:10:38.243
You make clothes I respectfully
ask and I both do.

05:10:38.243 --> 05:10:40.444
Notice to pass as amended to
appropriations

05:10:40.912 --> 05:10:42.813
please call the roll o'donnell
aye o'donnell aye kiley aye

05:10:44.349 --> 05:10:46.349
kiley aye kalra.

05:10:46.484 --> 05:10:48.484
However I mccarty. Mccarty aye

05:10:48.953 --> 05:10:50.953
steinorth.

05:10:51.789 --> 05:10:53.789
Thurmond thurmond and weber.

05:10:53.825 --> 05:10:56.193
Weapons I think.
No six votes it is out thank you

05:10:56.327 --> 05:10:59.162
thank you very much and without
with drug moved to Mister Harper
hruska file item number thirteen

05:11:00.164 --> 05:11:01.697
twenty three in ab twenty three
ninety.

05:11:04.568 --> 05:11:06.369
It's file item thirteen.
They May very much even ready

05:11:06.971 --> 05:11:09.373
Mister Chair and members. Of
first I'd like to start by

05:11:09.373 --> 05:11:11.373
accepting the committees

05:11:11.408 --> 05:11:13.910
amendments I'm here present
assembly bill twenty three

05:11:16.313 --> 05:11:18.179
ninety. On an issue I'm sure all
of us take very seriously.

05:11:18.749 --> 05:11:20.149
This bipartisan bill require
great.

05:11:21.752 --> 05:11:24.253
Crates seven eight ninth tenth
eleventh and twelfth. Public

05:11:25.220 --> 05:11:27.556
schools charter schools in the
state of california to include

05:11:28.992 --> 05:11:31.393
the national crisis text line as
well as the national suicide

05:11:31.860 --> 05:11:33.860
prevention line line.

05:11:35.265 --> 05:11:37.698
One student identification cards.
High school prepare students for

05:11:38.568 --> 05:11:41.170
adulthood college and the work
force unfortunately there more

05:11:42.372 --> 05:11:44.973
social pressures that are placed
on young adults than ever before

05:11:45.942 --> 05:11:48.575
the status.
With the prevalence of social

05:11:49.445 --> 05:11:52.114
media apps such snapchat. In
instagram and facebook teams are

05:11:52.114 --> 05:11:54.114
finding it increasingly

05:11:54.615 --> 05:11:57.318
difficult to escape from bowling.
According to a recent study by

05:11:57.987 --> 05:12:00.522
san diego state university
between twenty ten and twenty

05:12:01.357 --> 05:12:03.357
fifteen the number of teens who

05:12:03.559 --> 05:12:05.658
felt useless joyless.
Which are typical signs of

05:12:06.361 --> 05:12:08.361
depression rose thirty three

05:12:09.640 --> 05:12:11.165
percent in national surveys.
The number of thirteen to

05:12:11.298 --> 05:12:13.901
eighteen year olds who committed
suicide. Increased thirty one

05:12:14.803 --> 05:12:17.505
percent.
This rise in depression and

05:12:18.539 --> 05:12:20.708
suicide correlates with the
growing use of smart phones as

05:12:21.710 --> 05:12:24.780
well social media.
As the usage of smartphones is

05:12:24.446 --> 05:12:26.446
increased we should provide

05:12:27.130 --> 05:12:29.130
emotional help to teens for them

05:12:29.751 --> 05:12:32.586
to use. With these devices.
Whether students want to talk to

05:12:34.254 --> 05:12:36.220
someone or texas someone there
are effective resource the

05:12:36.856 --> 05:12:38.491
mitigate suicidal thoughts and
help them handle the pressures

05:12:40.610 --> 05:12:42.796
of my school.
The nationwide crisis text line

05:12:44.650 --> 05:12:46.800
is a free confidential twenty
four hour support service that

05:12:47.401 --> 05:12:50.135
students can contact any time
via text.

05:12:50.804 --> 05:12:52.804
Since going live August twenty

05:12:52.873 --> 05:12:54.572
thirteen nearly thirty seven
million messages have been

05:12:55.209 --> 05:12:58.770
exchanged between the crisis
counselors and individuals who

05:12:58.545 --> 05:13:01.147
are in need.
Fourteenth would like to talk to

05:13:01.613 --> 05:13:04.350
someone over the phone there's
of course the national suicide

05:13:05.318 --> 05:13:08.870
prevention lifeline.
the national suicide prevention

05:13:08.622 --> 05:13:10.622
lifeline provides free and

05:13:10.623 --> 05:13:13.158
confidential emotional support.
People in suicidal crisis or

05:13:13.927 --> 05:13:15.927
emotional distress twenty four

05:13:16.396 --> 05:13:19.197
hours a day seven days a week
across the united states.

05:13:20.266 --> 05:13:23.680
Placing these two phone numbers
on high school id's May make a

05:13:24.270 --> 05:13:26.270
difference in the lives.

05:13:26.305 --> 05:13:28.640
Some of these teenagers
currently student id cards

05:13:29.141 --> 05:13:31.876
contain information related las
replacement cards. On how to

05:13:32.244 --> 05:13:34.244
order copies of the photograph

05:13:34.513 --> 05:13:36.915
on front this layout leave space
available for additional text

05:13:37.883 --> 05:13:40.250
information. So little to no
design elements will need to be

05:13:40.753 --> 05:13:43.321
removed. This bill gives
students a valuable resource to

05:13:44.289 --> 05:13:46.289
turn to when they feel that they

05:13:46.290 --> 05:13:48.793
have no options left with me
here today in support of ab

05:13:48.892 --> 05:13:51.629
twenty nine oh twenty three
ninety. Is cordoned audi from

05:13:51.630 --> 05:13:54.498
the american foundation of
suicide prevention and erica

05:13:55.330 --> 05:13:57.835
hoffman from the california
school boards association thank

05:13:58.637 --> 05:14:00.637
you for your consideration.

05:14:00.805 --> 05:14:03.273
Good evening.
Chairman O'donnell and committee

05:14:04.108 --> 05:14:06.343
members my name is gordon downey
I am a board member of the

05:14:07.345 --> 05:14:09.345
greater sn francisco bay area

05:14:09.347 --> 05:14:11.481
chapter. Of the. American
foundation for suicide

05:14:12.817 --> 05:14:14.817
prevention I also serve on to

05:14:14.886 --> 05:14:17.387
their national councils and the
state superintendent of public

05:14:17.854 --> 05:14:20.323
instruction student mental
health policy work group.

05:14:20.690 --> 05:14:22.258
Three county suicide prevention
committees.

05:14:23.427 --> 05:14:25.828
.
The advisory board of depression

05:14:26.729 --> 05:14:29.699
center is casf.
But.

05:14:30.868 --> 05:14:33.134
Most notable is that I'm a
father who lost a daughter was

05:14:34.400 --> 05:14:36.400
eighteen.

05:14:36.600 --> 05:14:38.507
I can unequivocally say that by
having this proposed contact

05:14:39.376 --> 05:14:41.809
information honor student id
card would have saved amanda's

05:14:42.579 --> 05:14:44.580
life.
But it would have given her an

05:14:45.248 --> 05:14:48.217
opportunity.
To reach out for help better

05:14:49.500 --> 05:14:51.520
time of crisis.
Suicide to third leading cause

05:14:53.288 --> 05:14:55.924
of death for ten the twenty four
year olds. And hasn't been a

05:14:56.593 --> 05:14:58.692
significant cause of death for
that age group for a number of

05:14:59.162 --> 05:15:01.630
years now.
Twenty sixteen california

05:15:02.632 --> 05:15:05.600
accounted for nine point five
percent almost ten percent of

05:15:08.569 --> 05:15:10.971
the entire nation suicides.
Resulting in the us losing

05:15:11.307 --> 05:15:13.942
someone every two hours of every
day.

05:15:14.276 --> 05:15:17.450
We no that upwards of ninety
percent of individuals who

05:15:18.847 --> 05:15:21.648
ultimately died by suicide. Were
living with a diagnosable mental

05:15:22.784 --> 05:15:25.586
health condition at the time of
their death but often these

05:15:26.188 --> 05:15:28.188
conditions when undiagnosed

05:15:28.657 --> 05:15:31.900
untreated.
To prevent suicide we need to

05:15:31.892 --> 05:15:34.795
ensure that those and crisis
have access to resources.

05:15:35.497 --> 05:15:38.980
And that they take action to
save their lives the national

05:15:39.334 --> 05:15:41.702
suicide prevention lifeline it's
a national network of over a

05:15:42.503 --> 05:15:45.205
hundred and fifty accredited
crisis center hotlines.

05:15:46.606 --> 05:15:49.576
The crisis text line is free.
Provides twenty four seven

05:15:49.977 --> 05:15:51.977
support for those in crisis

05:15:52.780 --> 05:15:54.948
allowing individuals to tax
from anywhere in the united

05:15:55.916 --> 05:15:58.718
states that tax to a trained
crisis counselor.

05:15:59.453 --> 05:16:01.988
By offering immediate counseling
to everyone that May need it.

05:16:03.289 --> 05:16:05.289
crisis live provided a valuable

05:16:05.491 --> 05:16:08.261
support at critical times
and connect individuals with

05:16:09.290 --> 05:16:11.797
local services that save their
lives I want to point out that

05:16:12.933 --> 05:16:15.801
when someone calls one eight
hundred two seven three talk. It

05:16:17.737 --> 05:16:20.400
reverts back to the area code.
And the crows closes crisis

05:16:20.907 --> 05:16:22.907
center.

05:16:23.143 --> 05:16:26.111
To that area code. To my case
are living contra costa county

05:16:27.981 --> 05:16:30.247
and miners answered waller creek.
We need to take every step we

05:16:30.884 --> 05:16:32.884
can to curb the increasing

05:16:33.190 --> 05:16:35.587
number of suicides. This bill is
just one of those steps

05:16:37.190 --> 05:16:39.658
I encourage an aye vote on ab
twenty three ninety and I thank

05:16:39.825 --> 05:16:41.825
you for your time and attention.

05:16:42.161 --> 05:16:43.962
Thank you.
This you chair members of

05:16:44.397 --> 05:16:46.297
committee erica hoffman with the
california school boards

05:16:47.333 --> 05:16:49.868
association. This is a very
simple way.

05:16:50.669 --> 05:16:53.504
To get.
Help for students into their

05:16:54.139 --> 05:16:56.139
hands when they're in crisis

05:16:56.475 --> 05:16:58.176
it's on the back of an id card.
Hopefully they'll never have to

05:16:59.678 --> 05:17:01.680
use it. But if they do.
Especially during the school day

05:17:01.680 --> 05:17:03.547
at every kid's got their id with
them.

05:17:04.848 --> 05:17:06.584
This might give them. A line to
be able to reach out for some

05:17:07.919 --> 05:17:10.554
help so we strongly support this
energy right vote on the measure
think you.

05:17:10.622 --> 05:17:13.190
Thank you and thank you sir for
sharing your story.

05:17:15.926 --> 05:17:17.694
Others in support.
County behavioral health

05:17:18.328 --> 05:17:20.297
directors association were
pleased to support this

05:17:23.000 --> 05:17:25.736
important legislation.
Eiji andreas what the steinberg

05:17:27.939 --> 05:17:30.205
institute pleased to support.
Video born representing american

05:17:31.420 --> 05:17:33.420
academy of pediatrics california

05:17:34.211 --> 05:17:37.146
division in support.
Thank you I any opposition.

05:17:37.681 --> 05:17:40.450
Senior opposition any comments
from any committee members.

05:17:40.818 --> 05:17:42.818
I do not see any do we have a

05:17:42.986 --> 05:17:45.421
motion.
In you a motion a second.

05:17:46.256 --> 05:17:48.391
So the motion is a to pass as
amended you appropriations you

05:17:48.792 --> 05:17:50.559
May close.
Thank you very much for your

05:17:51.261 --> 05:17:54.196
consideration Mister Chair and
members. I'd I'd this is a

05:17:54.231 --> 05:17:56.632
bipartisan measure I
respectfully ask for your

05:17:57.330 --> 05:17:58.934
support for this very important
data.

05:18:00.802 --> 05:18:03.204
The motion is to pass his
manager appropriations please

05:18:03.940 --> 05:18:06.675
call the roll.
Aye. O'donnell aye.

05:18:09.178 --> 05:18:11.178
Kiley aye kiley aye kalra.

05:18:11.748 --> 05:18:13.748
Kalra aye mccarty. Mccarty aye

05:18:14.820 --> 05:18:16.820
steinorth thurmond. Thurmond I

05:18:17.453 --> 05:18:20.155
weber. Weber aye.
Six go to those out thank you
thank you Mister Chairman

05:18:20.689 --> 05:18:23.158
members.
Without moving moved of.

05:18:24.125 --> 05:18:26.125
File item number ten Mister

05:18:26.128 --> 05:18:28.463
Obernolte is the President.
I don't see him so your of. You

05:18:29.865 --> 05:18:32.667
better. Walk up here you better
get up here before walks in that

05:18:33.735 --> 05:18:36.671
door. Amiss reyes.
Why item number ten or no notes

05:18:37.105 --> 05:18:39.105
on a protest by the number six

05:18:40.475 --> 05:18:42.777
number six?
It's file item number six and
it's.

05:18:43.745 --> 05:18:45.813
.
A. B..

05:18:48.316 --> 05:18:50.617
At two zero one five.
Thank you Mister Chair members

05:18:51.520 --> 05:18:53.287
of this committee I'd like to
start off by accepting that

05:18:53.888 --> 05:18:56.490
recommended amendments located
in the committees analysis.

05:18:56.691 --> 05:18:59.590
And I think the committee stuff
for all the work you've put into

05:19:00.270 --> 05:19:02.270
this bill.

05:19:02.497 --> 05:19:05.198
As amended to ab two zero one
five will require that schools

05:19:06.199 --> 05:19:09.102
offer information to students on
how to properly complete and

05:19:10.571 --> 05:19:13.390
submit the free application. For
federal student aid or the fab

05:19:13.607 --> 05:19:15.440
so.
And the caltrain dream act

05:19:16.276 --> 05:19:18.945
application.
This will happen at least once

05:19:19.746 --> 05:19:22.715
before grade twelve and as
amended. This bill provides

05:19:22.849 --> 05:19:24.849
schools with the necessary

05:19:25.218 --> 05:19:27.218
flexibility to decide how they

05:19:27.287 --> 05:19:29.889
will provide the assistance.
The transition from high school

05:19:30.357 --> 05:19:32.723
to college is crucial to a
student's educational career.

05:19:33.493 --> 05:19:36.195
Research from the national
college access network.

05:19:37.197 --> 05:19:39.197
States that ninety percent of

05:19:39.467 --> 05:19:41.467
high school seniors who complete

05:19:41.501 --> 05:19:43.869
the phelps attend college after
graduating from high school

05:19:44.570 --> 05:19:47.272
compared to just fifty five
percent. Of fraph so non

05:19:48.975 --> 05:19:51.910
completas.
Receiving assistance and
encouragement to fill out the

05:19:53.770 --> 05:19:55.347
flaps and dream act applications
can make the difference between

05:19:56.480 --> 05:19:58.817
whether a student will or will
not attend college. So we must

05:19:59.185 --> 05:20:01.185
ensure that students are given

05:20:01.820 --> 05:20:04.188
every opportunity to prepare.
Here to testify in support of

05:20:04.690 --> 05:20:06.690
the bill is david o'brien

05:20:06.892 --> 05:20:08.958
director of government affairs
for the california student aid

05:20:09.528 --> 05:20:11.528
commission.

05:20:13.310 --> 05:20:15.398
You.
Good evening turned members aye

05:20:15.734 --> 05:20:18.690
david o'brien of the california
student commission I'll be brief

05:20:18.690 --> 05:20:20.690
we're pleased to be the co

05:20:20.472 --> 05:20:23.439
sponsors of ab twenty fifteen.
And I'd like to express our
gratitude to someone memories

05:20:23.608 --> 05:20:25.876
for her leadership on this
crucial issue.

05:20:26.344 --> 05:20:29.120
Among the twenty sixteen has
graduating class about fifty six

05:20:29.880 --> 05:20:32.549
percent of senior submitted a
passerby mac application.

05:20:32.651 --> 05:20:35.352
Leaving hundreds of millions of
dollars and financially grant

05:20:36.454 --> 05:20:38.788
money on the table if all of the
students are happy instruction

05:20:39.355 --> 05:20:41.356
that this bill will provide an
world where there financially

05:20:41.892 --> 05:20:44.260
options as early as possible.
Imagine how many students will

05:20:44.295 --> 05:20:46.996
be free to pursue their dream of
a college education about been

05:20:46.996 --> 05:20:49.232
held back by the costs.
We strongly encourage your

05:20:49.233 --> 05:20:51.568
support the bill and we
appreciate the author strong

05:20:52.403 --> 05:20:54.700
support of california students
and happen answer any questions

05:20:54.805 --> 05:20:57.173
you May have.
Thank you any others in support

05:20:57.708 --> 05:21:00.900
fred jones on behalf california
council for the social studies

05:21:00.510 --> 05:21:02.745
we are registered oppose but
with the amendments worked out

05:21:04.214 --> 05:21:07.490
with staff and with the author
we are actually moving to
support.

05:21:08.840 --> 05:21:10.318
Thank you others in support.
Mister Chairman members brian

05:21:10.553 --> 05:21:12.553
reavis on behalf of the

05:21:16.826 --> 05:21:18.827
education trust western support.
Ron rapidly have for the

05:21:19.620 --> 05:21:21.620
california federation of

05:21:22.797 --> 05:21:24.733
teachers and support.
Thank you.

05:21:24.834 --> 05:21:27.634
And.
Any opposition senior

05:21:27.737 --> 05:21:29.938
opposition thank you take any
notes because they allow that

05:21:31.700 --> 05:21:33.575
flexibility.
If you understand they might not
take out phenomics till the back

05:21:34.900 --> 05:21:36.579
half of their senior year you
want to do that faster as early

05:21:36.579 --> 05:21:39.547
as possible.
So I think the committee for
working those out you want to

05:21:40.215 --> 05:21:42.984
allow for
ability have been. Not my own

05:21:43.620 --> 05:21:45.853
class kids came in and did the
faster we let them go.

05:21:46.210 --> 05:21:48.823
The counselor so I have a lot of
experience that. I believe

05:21:48.924 --> 05:21:51.659
Mister Market mccarty wanted to
speak yeah I know it's getting

05:21:52.294 --> 05:21:54.294
late but this this is a great

05:21:54.496 --> 05:21:56.496
idea just two things one. I did

05:21:56.865 --> 05:21:59.598
my graduate thesis on why people
don't go to college and there is

05:22:00.135 --> 05:22:02.804
a great study by the tomas
rivera center in your neck of

05:22:02.804 --> 05:22:05.372
the woods and interviewed.
People between eighteen and

05:22:06.441 --> 05:22:08.441
twenty. Five who didn't go to

05:22:08.509 --> 05:22:10.509
college and ask him why to go

05:22:11.245 --> 05:22:13.414
and if the answer was money.
Tennessee did you ever hear
about that caltrain entitlement

05:22:13.414 --> 05:22:16.216
program.
No.

05:22:16.684 --> 05:22:19.386
That's number one number two now
is that the chair the budget

05:22:19.620 --> 05:22:22.122
committee overseeing funding one
of the most depressing things

05:22:22.223 --> 05:22:24.891
that I see every year is when
the ca commission. Comes back

05:22:25.860 --> 05:22:28.294
and says well. You'd allocate
this much money for cal grant

05:22:29.363 --> 05:22:31.899
program. Yeah throw back in the
general fund we're could end up

05:22:31.899 --> 05:22:33.899
food who knows.

05:22:34.101 --> 05:22:36.101
Corrections were have yet.

05:22:36.503 --> 05:22:39.271
And that money was earmarked for
financial aid and.
.

05:22:39.471 --> 05:22:41.471
You can just on applying so I

05:22:42.740 --> 05:22:44.740
think this is much a much needed

05:22:44.177 --> 05:22:46.177
approach so thank you.

05:22:46.179 --> 05:22:48.179
Thank you.

05:22:48.513 --> 05:22:51.115
Thank you and I.
I hope every school is already

05:22:51.417 --> 05:22:53.417
doing this in the state account

05:22:53.453 --> 05:22:56.153
I don't know if they are.
But this is like pretty common

05:22:56.189 --> 05:22:58.790
sense to help students move
forward.

05:22:59.525 --> 05:23:01.927
and on to success out of the hut
their high school experience.

05:23:02.495 --> 05:23:05.230
Are without the motion is
support as amended I'm sorry to

05:23:05.431 --> 05:23:07.465
pass as amended to
appropriations.

05:23:09.802 --> 05:23:12.235
You May close.
I we need a motion.

05:23:12.371 --> 05:23:15.139
Mister Kalra mode.
Moves mr mccarty seconds.

05:23:16.108 --> 05:23:18.843
Please close.
Thank you and anything we can do

05:23:19.780 --> 05:23:21.780
to promote reading us for

05:23:21.180 --> 05:23:23.748
college we must do and I thank
you for I thank the committee

05:23:23.815 --> 05:23:26.184
for the amendment thank you to
pass as you pass you

05:23:26.184 --> 05:23:28.386
appropriations please call the
roll.

05:23:29.621 --> 05:23:31.621
O'donnell. O'donnell I come aye

05:23:32.357 --> 05:23:34.357
kind aye kiley aye kalra.

05:23:34.626 --> 05:23:36.626
Kalra aye mccarty. Mccarty aye

05:23:37.194 --> 05:23:39.530
steinorth thurmond.
Weber.

05:23:42.320 --> 05:23:44.233
Weber I.
Got all politically.

05:23:45.637 --> 05:23:47.838
Rules out as five votes.
Thank you without will turn

05:23:48.206 --> 05:23:50.974
Mister Obernolte has got file
item number ten ab twenty two

05:23:53.544 --> 05:23:55.544
sixty five five and number ten.

05:23:59.160 --> 05:24:01.518
You May proceed when ready.
Mister Chairman I am convinced

05:24:02.720 --> 05:24:05.221
that the coming years will see
an inflection point where

05:24:06.690 --> 05:24:08.958
science and technology will fuel.
Out explosion in human

05:24:09.920 --> 05:24:11.192
productivity in development
greater than anything the world

05:24:11.562 --> 05:24:14.280
has ever seen and we're already
starting to see this in fact

05:24:14.298 --> 05:24:17.990
careers in science and
technology related fields. Heavy

05:24:17.901 --> 05:24:20.803
job growth of over nineteen
percent whereas careers in other

05:24:21.404 --> 05:24:23.404
fields are stagnant.

05:24:24.174 --> 05:24:26.341
I however I am convinced also
that we have a growing problem

05:24:27.410 --> 05:24:29.410
where we're failing to properly

05:24:29.979 --> 05:24:32.681
prepare. Our children for
careers in these fields and.

05:24:33.148 --> 05:24:35.851
Can factor been one numerous
studies that does don that see.

05:24:36.519 --> 05:24:39.321
That show that we are under
preparing students and so the so

05:24:39.655 --> 05:24:41.891
called stem field science
technology engineering and

05:24:41.891 --> 05:24:44.590
mathematics.
This bill ab twenty two sixty

05:24:44.760 --> 05:24:46.795
five.
Is one solution to the problem

05:24:48.290 --> 05:24:50.290
it creates a new diplomacy all

05:24:50.666 --> 05:24:52.600
the seal of stem for california
high school diplomas that

05:24:53.602 --> 05:24:55.602
recognize preparation in these

05:24:56.238 --> 05:24:58.539
fields to qualify the seal as
for the seal. As our.

05:24:59.741 --> 05:25:02.610
As proposed you would need for
years of mathematics one year of

05:25:03.178 --> 05:25:05.880
which could be computer science
you need four years of a hard

05:25:06.581 --> 05:25:09.483
science such as biology.
Or physics or chemistry that

05:25:09.684 --> 05:25:12.551
you would you do achieve a
minimum gpa of three pa three

05:25:13.321 --> 05:25:15.387
point oh in those.
In those classes.

05:25:15.723 --> 05:25:18.910
I think that it's entirely
appropriate that we motivate

05:25:19.160 --> 05:25:21.627
students to choose class work in
these fields and we also moving

05:25:22.829 --> 05:25:24.765
schools to emphasize enrollment
in these classes and.

05:25:25.660 --> 05:25:27.567
I would respectfully request
your aye vote on it will be say
that.

05:25:29.300 --> 05:25:31.505
Very thankful to your staff for
working with us on the bill but

05:25:31.505 --> 05:25:33.773
we will certainly be taking the
amendments there that are

05:25:34.542 --> 05:25:37.430
proposed in the analysis.
Thank you others in support brad

05:25:37.510 --> 05:25:39.913
strong senior director for
children down support we had to

05:25:40.470 --> 05:25:42.248
have older daughter that took
advantage of the still by

05:25:43.160 --> 05:25:44.584
literacy she was went into
nursing.

05:25:45.452 --> 05:25:47.986
Analytical and college student
another student who isn't but

05:25:48.555 --> 05:25:50.788
wasn't a stamp program but
didn't have a similar

05:25:51.258 --> 05:25:53.258
opportunity with that the state

05:25:53.560 --> 05:25:56.270
seal of stem and. I do think it
is encouraging for I'm for

05:25:57.764 --> 05:25:59.764
students to. Pursue those those

05:26:01.801 --> 05:26:04.203
careers home and are we we are I
ask for your support of the stem
seal.

05:26:04.204 --> 05:26:06.700
Erica off when we have the
california school boards

05:26:06.504 --> 05:26:09.274
association also in support for
many of the same reasons.

05:26:09.507 --> 05:26:11.507
Already mentions we ask your aye

05:26:11.611 --> 05:26:14.446
vote thinking.
Thank you others in support.
Well Mister Chair members

05:26:15.346 --> 05:26:17.346
finster with the california stem

05:26:20.686 --> 05:26:23.154
network and support thank you.
Ron rapidly up the california

05:26:25.570 --> 05:26:27.592
federation of teachers we have a
supportive amended position on
this bill and are with and I

05:26:27.660 --> 05:26:30.260
know it's late I'm not going
through the amendments but we're

05:26:30.662 --> 05:26:33.598
willing to work with the author
to talk through those and. Make

05:26:33.732 --> 05:26:35.732
sure that we are come any

05:26:36.735 --> 05:26:39.503
opposition.
Any opposition on thank you I

05:26:40.500 --> 05:26:42.940
just one comment we've had a lot
of stem proposals this year. Are

05:26:43.642 --> 05:26:45.877
lot I'm sorry sealed. Different
proposes to make it people

05:26:45.877 --> 05:26:48.612
different seals one make sure
that.
We are right now we are the by

05:26:49.470 --> 05:26:51.682
literacy will make sure that we
keep that very valuable.

05:26:51.683 --> 05:26:54.484
And we don't start tracking kids
either tracking them away from

05:26:55.119 --> 05:26:57.487
stammer into the stem I just as
the difference you know seal

05:26:57.689 --> 05:27:00.158
proposals come forward I think
we make sure. It's really

05:27:00.158 --> 05:27:02.158
valuable to this really

05:27:02.293 --> 05:27:04.626
meaningful pumps with that I
thank you.
.

05:27:05.960 --> 05:27:07.960
You May go to el of mo if a

05:27:08.990 --> 05:27:10.900
motion.
Moved and seconded are motions

05:27:11.100 --> 05:27:12.535
you pass as a manager
appropriations.

05:27:13.237 --> 05:27:16.104
Miklos
well know appreciate your
support request and I don't.

05:27:18.842 --> 05:27:21.430
Thank you.
To press is a measure

05:27:21.343 --> 05:27:23.343
appropriations fiscal room

05:27:23.847 --> 05:27:26.347
o'donnell by o'donnell aye kiley
aye kiley aye kalra.

05:27:27.451 --> 05:27:30.190
Kalra aye mccarty.
Mccarty I steinorth steinorth

05:27:30.385 --> 05:27:32.922
aye thurmond.
Weber.

05:27:35.925 --> 05:27:38.494
Weber I.
The bill is out six votes thank

05:27:39.362 --> 05:27:41.520
Mister Make you. Well turn to
monsieur.

05:27:44.901 --> 05:27:46.968
Aguiar-curry.
S. You got from.

05:27:47.603 --> 05:27:49.771
Ab twenty two ninety two is
file item number eleven file

05:27:53.941 --> 05:27:56.711
item number love.
It is important you got support

05:27:57.279 --> 05:27:59.279
a sport on the so you want to be

05:27:59.380 --> 05:28:01.490
as efficient as possible because
you only lose votes the more you

05:28:02.117 --> 05:28:04.117
talk okay.

05:28:04.253 --> 05:28:06.820
I have a motion that hey I'm
just basically this is up for

05:28:09.972 --> 05:28:12.393
children and this is for
basically zero to three year
olds those that are potty
trained will now have somewhere

05:28:13.260 --> 05:28:14.962
to be ste to taken care of. So
we have a.

05:28:15.863 --> 05:28:18.299
Will increase the rate to be
paid for childcare center based

05:28:18.767 --> 05:28:20.767
programs we will creating

05:28:20.869 --> 05:28:23.500
inclusive grant program. And we
will do recruit in training of

05:28:23.500 --> 05:28:25.606
new.
Generation of family care

05:28:25.840 --> 05:28:28.809
providers.
I'll tell you in when I was a

05:28:29.543 --> 05:28:31.812
single mother as I was a single
mother would be nice to have a

05:28:32.614 --> 05:28:34.614
place to send my children. So

05:28:34.816 --> 05:28:37.484
all without I respectfully ask
your aye vote and I'd like to

05:28:37.718 --> 05:28:40.687
introduce quickly.
Our support here.

05:28:40.855 --> 05:28:42.923
Good afternoon money primeros
on behalf of first of

05:28:43.823 --> 05:28:46.425
californians support of ab two
two nine two. Just st out we

05:28:47.328 --> 05:28:49.929
have not restored infants and
toddlers since the recession we

05:28:49.930 --> 05:28:51.898
think this bill is the first
step and.

05:28:52.466 --> 05:28:54.466
All first wives including all

05:28:54.535 --> 05:28:57.236
your local first wives aren't
support of the bill as well
thank you.

05:28:58.238 --> 05:29:00.306
Thank you others in support.
Please allen javaid with the

05:29:00.774 --> 05:29:02.774
best project california in

05:29:03.430 --> 05:29:05.430
support.

05:29:05.112 --> 05:29:06.712
Margaret go to the first five
association of california in

05:29:08.281 --> 05:29:10.650
support.
Danielle can a kaiser with

05:29:10.650 --> 05:29:12.650
common sense kids action in

05:29:13.787 --> 05:29:16.155
support.
Aaron taylor on behalf of the

05:29:16.621 --> 05:29:18.690
california coalition for equity
in early care and education in

05:29:20.426 --> 05:29:23.195
strong support.
Patio where representing early

05:29:24.597 --> 05:29:26.865
edge californians support.
Dineen micheletti colbern

05:29:27.667 --> 05:29:29.667
california alternative payment

05:29:30.690 --> 05:29:31.670
program association in support.
Brad strong children now in

05:29:33.137 --> 05:29:35.241
support.
Ron probably half the california

05:29:35.241 --> 05:29:37.241
federation of teachers and

05:29:38.100 --> 05:29:40.345
support.
Pamela gives representing the

05:29:40.679 --> 05:29:42.679
los angeles county office of

05:29:44.750 --> 05:29:46.717
education in strong support.
The injury representing the

05:29:46.752 --> 05:29:48.752
santa clara county office of

05:29:49.454 --> 05:29:50.755
education in support.
Thank you.

05:29:51.523 --> 05:29:53.991
Any opposition.
Seen opposition any comments

05:29:54.626 --> 05:29:57.428
from any committee members.
mr mccarty yes excellent effort

05:29:58.496 --> 05:30:00.731
just can currently we're looking
at the reimbursement rate for

05:30:01.466 --> 05:30:04.680
infants toddlers the factor in
the budget process right now.

05:30:04.569 --> 05:30:06.936
Glad you're working on this will
be looking at that from the

05:30:07.505 --> 05:30:10.730
financial world as well we're
gonna move this together. Thank

05:30:11.800 --> 05:30:13.610
you aye mr mccarty moves and
seconded by doctor weber.

05:30:14.745 --> 05:30:17.580
Up.
The motion again is to pass to

05:30:17.580 --> 05:30:19.580
appropriations please call the

05:30:19.917 --> 05:30:21.917
roll. O'donnell.

05:30:21.986 --> 05:30:23.986
I aye o'donnell aye kiley.

05:30:24.420 --> 05:30:26.420
Kiley aye kalra.

05:30:27.124 --> 05:30:29.658
Kalra aye mccarty.
Mccarty aye steinorth aye

05:30:29.658 --> 05:30:32.228
steinorth aye thurmond.
Weber.

05:30:34.296 --> 05:30:36.732
Weber I.
Six votes is out.

05:30:37.567 --> 05:30:38.768
Without bitterness burke who
has.

05:30:41.371 --> 05:30:44.106
.
Two bills of file item number

05:30:45.410 --> 05:30:47.775
thirty. And thirty six will
start with thirty which is.

05:30:48.478 --> 05:30:51.114
Twenty nine seventy nine appears
by one number thirty.

05:30:51.114 --> 05:30:53.215
Thank you Mister Chairman reyes
at lake start by accepting the

05:30:54.150 --> 05:30:56.852
committees amendments and think
the chair and his staff are
through. Your work with my

05:30:57.720 --> 05:30:59.720
office also I'm think you for

05:30:59.722 --> 05:31:02.230
all your work on ct. Assembly
bill two twenty nine seven I

05:31:02.492 --> 05:31:04.526
establishes the state seal of
career technical education

05:31:04.859 --> 05:31:07.363
pathway completion to recognize
high school graduates. Who have

05:31:07.363 --> 05:31:09.363
attained a high level of

05:31:09.565 --> 05:31:11.332
knowledge and proficiency incur
technical?

05:31:12.501 --> 05:31:15.370
I education pathways aye aye I
heard your notes on.
.

05:31:16.238 --> 05:31:18.973
Assemblymember obernolte is bill
and we want this to be of value
seal.

05:31:19.708 --> 05:31:21.708
With that I have my witnesses

05:31:24.479 --> 05:31:26.479
who will be brief.

05:31:26.682 --> 05:31:29.150
Thank you are others in support.
Yes nicole rice california many

05:31:29.484 --> 05:31:32.453
factors and technology
association we do apologize for

05:31:33.688 --> 05:31:35.688
early position letter but we are

05:31:36.240 --> 05:31:38.826
support if amended won't go into
you of what we like those lead

05:31:39.493 --> 05:31:42.290
which changes to be but we are
supportive and concept or just

05:31:42.730 --> 05:31:44.665
working with the author. On to
tighten up some and wood

05:31:45.166 --> 05:31:47.166
eligibility language.

05:31:47.702 --> 05:31:49.702
But we do you ask for your aye

05:31:49.736 --> 05:31:52.572
vote today thank you.
Thank you Mister Chairman of the
committee Chairman Smith your

05:31:52.772 --> 05:31:54.841
behalf of the state building and
construction trades council also

05:31:54.909 --> 05:31:57.844
in support.
Thank you others in support.

05:31:59.460 --> 05:32:01.460
Fred jones california business

05:32:05.217 --> 05:32:07.920
education association thank you.
Patricia record california

05:32:09.220 --> 05:32:10.590
teachers association in support.
Thank you.

05:32:11.558 --> 05:32:13.558
See no others in support of

05:32:13.692 --> 05:32:15.929
spree impact reiterate my other
comment that you heard me say a.

05:32:15.929 --> 05:32:17.463
The queen to be careful about
about.

05:32:18.198 --> 05:32:20.131
This the seals.
Because.

05:32:20.800 --> 05:32:23.102
There I wanted to mean
something so I will sometimes

05:32:24.237 --> 05:32:26.705
wonder certification.
In some type of technology here

05:32:26.972 --> 05:32:29.942
some aptitude is better than
even a seal of the makes might

05:32:30.543 --> 05:32:33.410
make them more employable. Me
and without I of ray these this

05:32:33.780 --> 05:32:35.847
year in particular and we wanna
make sure that they really have

05:32:36.482 --> 05:32:38.830
value and I know you agree with
that said thank you.

05:32:39.850 --> 05:32:41.586
I'm without any other comments
from any of the other committee
members.

05:32:41.921 --> 05:32:44.222
I'll second the comment about
the concern about seal inflation

05:32:44.790 --> 05:32:46.790
we should I think a little.

05:32:46.992 --> 05:32:49.461
More holistically about that.
I might also suggest a friendly

05:32:49.995 --> 05:32:52.964
amendment to make it the career
education osteological to

05:32:54.466 --> 05:32:56.670
critical educations.
And I know that's assembly

05:32:56.835 --> 05:32:59.403
member kylie's one of his issues
with current the way we phrase

05:33:00.606 --> 05:33:02.606
career technical education so.

05:33:02.607 --> 05:33:05.543
Thank you for the note.
And more serious me more sharks

05:33:08.113 --> 05:33:10.113
yes and he carefully. On.

05:33:10.715 --> 05:33:12.820
Who?
So with that.

05:33:12.784 --> 05:33:14.918
.
Expect where question I you May

05:33:16.520 --> 05:33:17.888
close. I respectfully request an
aye vote okay with.

05:33:18.289 --> 05:33:20.690
With the motion is.
.

05:33:20.690 --> 05:33:23.193
Do pass as amended to
appropriations to pass as

05:33:23.693 --> 05:33:26.495
amended to appropriations please
call the roll o'donnell aye aye

05:33:27.398 --> 05:33:29.398
o'donnell aye kiley. Kind the

05:33:30.434 --> 05:33:32.902
aye kalra kalra aye mccarty.
Party aye steinorth aye

05:33:33.504 --> 05:33:35.504
steinorth aye thurmond. And

05:33:42.946 --> 05:33:45.448
weber swelling though weber aye.
Made proceed with your second

05:33:46.150 --> 05:33:47.483
bill which is on.
I apologize.

05:33:48.352 --> 05:33:50.352
It.

05:33:50.452 --> 05:33:52.210
Well I never thirty six a. B.
Thirty two to twenty eight

05:33:53.590 --> 05:33:56.326
ability.
Thank you I think Mister
Chairman what I'd like to start

05:33:56.326 --> 05:33:58.360
by accepting the committees
amendments allen in the

05:33:58.428 --> 05:34:00.396
announces something in the chair
and his staff for their work on

05:34:00.664 --> 05:34:03.365
this bill assembly bill thirty
two twenty eight. Authorizes

05:34:03.700 --> 05:34:05.801
school districts in receivership
to use revenue from the sale of

05:34:06.968 --> 05:34:09.305
surplus property for paying down
the amount owed by the state. I

05:34:09.305 --> 05:34:11.306
currently revenues from the
state a sale of surplus

05:34:11.607 --> 05:34:14.760
properties must be is defined
improvements to skilled school

05:34:14.177 --> 05:34:16.610
facilities.
I have a school district as are

05:34:16.646 --> 05:34:19.347
others that are in state
receivership and and of this

05:34:20.248 --> 05:34:22.248
will help us attains. Kind of

05:34:23.500 --> 05:34:25.500
solve some of our our financial

05:34:25.520 --> 05:34:27.520
issues without I have.

05:34:27.856 --> 05:34:30.359
Witnesses that will be sure
thank you it is in support.

05:34:30.359 --> 05:34:32.326
Good evening deborah brown on
behalf of state superintendent

05:34:32.927 --> 05:34:34.896
of public instruction tom
toilets and eight we want I

05:34:35.464 --> 05:34:38.399
think I misspoke for carrying
this measure we do think that
this does. Help.

05:34:38.900 --> 05:34:41.167
At a limited number of
districts who are in in

05:34:41.603 --> 05:34:43.603
financial distress to help them.

05:34:44.840 --> 05:34:47.406
I turn the corner so we urge
your support for the bill thank
you.

05:34:47.776 --> 05:34:50.278
Pamela gives representing the
los angeles county office of

05:34:50.278 --> 05:34:52.880
education and.
Inglewood unified school

05:34:53.246 --> 05:34:55.415
district is in our jurisdiction
we have ab twelve hundred

05:34:56.117 --> 05:34:57.884
authority I'm over them to
improve their budgets and so

05:34:58.519 --> 05:35:00.854
forth. And so we're very closely
related to them and working with

05:35:01.122 --> 05:35:03.223
them we think this would be
helpful and to improve their

05:35:03.858 --> 05:35:06.760
fiscal situation so we urge your
iphone.

05:35:06.926 --> 05:35:09.229
Patting her rare representing
oakland unified school district.

05:35:09.797 --> 05:35:12.665
We think Miss Burke for
carrying this important measure
for us we're currently

05:35:14.166 --> 05:35:16.703
evaluating our school portfolio
and our school utilization rates.

05:35:18.138 --> 05:35:20.473
And we would like the
flexibility provided in the bill

05:35:22.376 --> 05:35:24.409
thank you.
Thank you arm without any

05:35:25.445 --> 05:35:27.846
opposition.
Seeing opposition.

05:35:27.846 --> 05:35:29.846
Any comments from the committee

05:35:30.849 --> 05:35:32.849
members.

05:35:33.850 --> 05:35:35.850
We get a motion.

05:35:35.255 --> 05:35:37.688
Question are you can this is
designed to make it probably

05:35:38.525 --> 05:35:41.226
liquidator sell property is that
right nauta.

05:35:41.828 --> 05:35:44.763
Sorry it's either lease or sale
sale.
And it's for schools in

05:35:45.130 --> 05:35:47.232
receivership for obviously were
already facing financial

05:35:47.400 --> 05:35:49.868
challenges and we do have a
portfolio of real estate I'm

05:35:50.703 --> 05:35:53.271
some districts. Like my own
right now selling is probably

05:35:53.739 --> 05:35:56.274
not we're going to pry least but
it gives us the option to do

05:35:57.760 --> 05:35:59.209
some of those things. And I some
of the flexibility to make

05:35:59.678 --> 05:36:01.880
herself solvent. And are
districts so some property I

05:36:02.281 --> 05:36:04.682
hate if they sold it because
once it's sold it's gone right

05:36:05.818 --> 05:36:08.186
and skinner is. You know it's
it's it's gone yeah well I would

05:36:09.354 --> 05:36:11.688
hope that we look what we saying
or at least state buying the

05:36:12.391 --> 05:36:15.226
property from you and then
holding and possibly you. Being

05:36:16.280 --> 05:36:18.796
applied back I mean it's zero
sum game terms of money but.

05:36:20.232 --> 05:36:22.634
Of. Something that we should
think about what clearly of

05:36:22.634 --> 05:36:25.690
doing something with the
property but. I hope that's

05:36:25.837 --> 05:36:28.138
selling well our goal is just to
make sure whatever we do is a

05:36:28.840 --> 05:36:30.840
market rate yeah yeah that and

05:36:32.176 --> 05:36:34.678
that would be important thank
you very much thinks.
Thank you.
.
With that.

05:36:35.513 --> 05:36:38.315
.
the motion is us four ism that.

05:36:38.950 --> 05:36:40.950
Do pass as amended to

05:36:41.840 --> 05:36:43.787
appropriations miklos aspect
clearquest enable.

05:36:43.886 --> 05:36:45.522
Do pass is manager
appropriations please call the

05:36:46.957 --> 05:36:49.524
roll.
We don't motion.

05:36:50.628 --> 05:36:52.862
Yeah we did.
The doctor weber moves.

05:36:56.100 --> 05:36:58.902
Scar seconds.
Please call the roll. A donald.

05:36:58.902 --> 05:37:00.902
O'donnell aye kiley.

05:37:00.904 --> 05:37:03.873
Another.
Kiley not voting kalra.

05:37:04.807 --> 05:37:06.807
Kalra aye mccarty. Mccarty aye

05:37:07.210 --> 05:37:09.210
steinorth.

05:37:11.361 --> 05:37:13.361
Steinorth not voting thurmond.

05:37:13.583 --> 05:37:15.583
Thurmond aye weber. Weber aye.

05:37:21.457 --> 05:37:23.457
That.

05:37:37.740 --> 05:37:39.740
The bill is out

05:37:44.480 --> 05:37:46.514
.
We're moving on to file item

05:37:47.850 --> 05:37:49.482
thirty four ab three two zero
five Mister O'donnell you May

05:37:50.519 --> 05:37:52.787
proceed.
Thank you Mister Chair and

05:37:53.320 --> 05:37:56.223
members are as a classroom
teacher that has participated in

05:37:56.924 --> 05:37:59.393
many school lockdowns.
Some lasting as long as six

05:37:59.995 --> 05:38:02.561
hours I can attest to the need
for a teacher to have the

05:38:03.731 --> 05:38:05.731
ability to lock a classroom door

05:38:06.167 --> 05:38:08.167
from inside the classroom.

05:38:08.303 --> 05:38:10.938
Imagine this bill goes offer you
made to your made aware that you

05:38:11.204 --> 05:38:13.204
need to immediately lock the

05:38:13.541 --> 05:38:15.942
classroom door to ensure student
safety.

05:38:16.210 --> 05:38:19.440
This means you have to get out
your keys walk outside the

05:38:19.780 --> 05:38:22.716
classroom and lock the door.
This takes time and May require

05:38:23.918 --> 05:38:26.686
require teacher to step out into
a very safe environment. You May

05:38:27.254 --> 05:38:29.914
have your keys in your pocket.
Are you May not have your keys
-

05:38:29.990 --> 05:38:31.891
in your pocket you to locate
them often I would keep them

05:38:32.493 --> 05:38:34.894
oftentimes I would keep the my
desk that means I might not be.

05:38:35.361 --> 05:38:37.663
You know you can near my desk I
would have to walk over to my

05:38:38.866 --> 05:38:41.634
desk locate my keys. Go through
my keys walked to the door step

05:38:41.969 --> 05:38:44.770
outside.
Into what might be a very

05:38:45.272 --> 05:38:48.730
serious situation.
Following the columbine colorado

05:38:48.608 --> 05:38:50.976
shooting in nineteen ninety nine
where thirteen students and a

05:38:51.243 --> 05:38:53.979
teacher were killed.
The legislature passed a bill

05:38:54.547 --> 05:38:57.316
that requires all new schools to
have locks.

05:38:57.617 --> 05:38:59.617
That lock from inside the

05:38:59.786 --> 05:39:02.119
classroom.
The majority of our schools are

05:39:02.889 --> 05:39:05.423
over twenty five years old this
means that is likely that mos

05:39:06.357 --> 05:39:08.357
of our classroom doors. Do not

05:39:09.261 --> 05:39:11.796
lock from the inside.
In twenty twelve twenty two

05:39:11.963 --> 05:39:13.963
twenty six students and

05:39:14.660 --> 05:39:15.900
educators were killed at sandy
hook elementary school in

05:39:16.568 --> 05:39:19.137
connecticut.
A number of them were shot and

05:39:19.605 --> 05:39:21.605
classrooms that could only be

05:39:22.207 --> 05:39:24.742
locked from the out side.
One of the main recommendations

05:39:25.770 --> 05:39:27.770
of a commission formed after the

05:39:27.312 --> 05:39:29.312
incident was change the locks

05:39:29.548 --> 05:39:32.449
allow a teacher to lock the
classroom door from inside the

05:39:33.552 --> 05:39:36.454
classroom.
The recent tragedy and marjorie

05:39:36.988 --> 05:39:39.890
stoneman douglas high school in
parkland florida reminds us that

05:39:40.725 --> 05:39:42.725
our work is not done california

05:39:42.727 --> 05:39:45.462
must act.
This bill requires modernization

05:39:46.164 --> 05:39:48.165
projects seeking state bond
funds to include in those

05:39:48.633 --> 05:39:50.700
projects
locks on classroom doors that

05:39:51.304 --> 05:39:53.304
can be locked.

05:39:54.637 --> 05:39:57.273
From the inside of the classroom.
as a teacher and a parent I take

05:39:59.430 --> 05:40:01.344
students security very seriously.
Let's ensure that students

05:40:02.780 --> 05:40:04.780
teachers and all school staff

05:40:04.480 --> 05:40:07.250
are able to protect themselves.
Whether they are in a new school.

05:40:08.520 --> 05:40:10.787
Or an older school.
I asked for an aye vote and I
have.

05:40:10.888 --> 05:40:12.888
To witness is here with me

05:40:14.191 --> 05:40:15.791
today Mister Chair.
If they May perceive you May

05:40:16.426 --> 05:40:18.694
proceed.
Thank you good evening Mister

05:40:18.795 --> 05:40:21.630
Chairman was of the committee
ron rapidly have

05:40:21.396 --> 05:40:24.133
california federation of
teachers I actually lived five

05:40:25.168 --> 05:40:27.669
miles from columbine when that
went down both of my.

05:40:28.705 --> 05:40:31.306
Gutters were in elementary
school and it was a terrifying

05:40:31.774 --> 05:40:33.774
experience.

05:40:35.645 --> 05:40:38.213
So you know this issue has been
very important to the california

05:40:38.548 --> 05:40:40.548
federation of teachers we've

05:40:41.170 --> 05:40:43.952
sponsored a similar bill many
many times and and yet it was

05:40:45.988 --> 05:40:48.790
killed because of cost.
How can we put a cost on a child

05:40:49.859 --> 05:40:52.759
to live this is a very simple
solution believe it or not?

05:40:53.729 --> 05:40:55.729
You have to walk outside your

05:40:55.731 --> 05:40:58.332
classroom and many schools to
lock your door imagine if a

05:40:58.599 --> 05:41:00.599
shooter.

05:41:01.336 --> 05:41:03.336
Comes into the building and and.

05:41:03.739 --> 05:41:06.730
You're to walk outside so we're
putting our our teachers and our

05:41:07.375 --> 05:41:09.910
students lives in danger.
We need to take the necessary

05:41:10.412 --> 05:41:13.280
steps we think this is a very
simple strategy and. And.

05:41:13.381 --> 05:41:15.381
Certainly.

05:41:15.984 --> 05:41:18.186
One that we can afford to.
Provide for the safety of our

05:41:18.186 --> 05:41:20.186
our.

05:41:20.588 --> 05:41:22.991
Students and for our teachers
now's the time to protect our

05:41:22.991 --> 05:41:25.292
students this is a simple
strategy and like to think the

05:41:25.893 --> 05:41:27.893
author for taking the lead on

05:41:28.563 --> 05:41:30.564
this. And we respectfully
request an aye but thank you.

05:41:30.564 --> 05:41:33.660
Tony took care on behalf the
california teachers association

05:41:34.602 --> 05:41:36.602
will align our remarks with the

05:41:37.400 --> 05:41:39.672
author and the. Bus sponsors of
the bill and I ask your aye vote

05:41:42.843 --> 05:41:44.843
thank you.

05:41:46.446 --> 05:41:48.446
Other other witnesses in support.

05:41:49.416 --> 05:41:51.500
Any witnesses in opposition.
Questions or comments from the

05:41:53.487 --> 05:41:55.954
committee.
Mister Because about thank you

05:41:55.954 --> 05:41:58.624
Mister Chair aspirin aye vote on
this important measure to ensure

05:42:00.600 --> 05:42:02.828
student safety across california.
My I would we have eventually of
motion and a second.

05:42:03.530 --> 05:42:05.796
Motions do passed to
appropriations please call the

05:42:06.666 --> 05:42:08.666
roll o'donnell aye o'donnell aye

05:42:09.602 --> 05:42:11.602
kiley aye upon the aye kalra.

05:42:11.671 --> 05:42:14.172
Kalra aye mccarty.
Mccarty aye steinorth. Steinorth

05:42:14.540 --> 05:42:17.420
aye thurman.
Weber.

05:42:19.412 --> 05:42:21.246
Weber I.
Six votes the bills out.

05:42:24.417 --> 05:42:26.451
Thank you.
Thank you Mister Chairman May

05:42:32.858 --> 05:42:34.858
take up ab twenty six twenty six.

05:42:35.627 --> 05:42:37.728
That is file item twenty one.
.

05:42:38.730 --> 05:42:40.898
Okay.
Guy and I am presenting this

05:42:41.266 --> 05:42:43.266
bill on behalf of the assembly

05:42:43.335 --> 05:42:46.700
member mullin. And this is up I
think that that's what I'm sorry

05:42:47.305 --> 05:42:49.305
it is Mister Moans will.

05:42:50.742 --> 05:42:52.609
He is not here he had.
Some other duty.

05:42:53.710 --> 05:42:55.511
May have received already
double duty somewhere.

05:42:56.748 --> 05:42:59.114
This was it.
Thank you members for allowing

05:42:59.450 --> 05:43:01.450
me to present this bill on

05:43:01.452 --> 05:43:03.520
behalf of assembly member mullin.
He would like to accept the

05:43:04.655 --> 05:43:06.289
committees amendments and thanks
the committee staff for their

05:43:06.891 --> 05:43:09.726
fine work.
Ab twenty six twenty six provide

05:43:10.193 --> 05:43:12.193
some of the flexibility as order

05:43:12.228 --> 05:43:14.264
in divide individualize county
childcare subsidy plans.

05:43:15.399 --> 05:43:17.467
To the state.
And I have with me today Miss

05:43:18.369 --> 05:43:21.304
For monique romance from for a
first five california. Margot

05:43:22.239 --> 05:43:24.941
grant gould from first five
association.

05:43:25.542 --> 05:43:27.877
And julian cuevas legislative
policy representative from the

05:43:27.978 --> 05:43:30.379
california department education
and sarah.

05:43:31.481 --> 05:43:34.450
Novell morgan director of early
education and support division

05:43:35.719 --> 05:43:37.719
of cd. And I thank you Mister

05:43:37.753 --> 05:43:39.421
Chair s. From ivan I know all
the witnesses know that they do

05:43:39.889 --> 05:43:41.723
have a time.
Thank you

05:43:43.920 --> 05:43:45.494
was the.
Thank you Mister Chair committee

05:43:46.620 --> 05:43:47.996
are doing well us on behalf of
the state superintendent of

05:43:48.229 --> 05:43:50.229
public instruction.

05:43:50.299 --> 05:43:52.667
As a sponsor we are also in
support of this bill.

05:43:53.469 --> 05:43:56.238
As that you just mentioned I do
have serrano morgan the director

05:43:56.471 --> 05:43:58.906
of the early education support
division here just to answer any

05:43:58.906 --> 05:44:00.906
up for dramatic in technical

05:44:03.946 --> 05:44:06.480
question.
Good afternoon margot grant

05:44:06.480 --> 05:44:08.650
cooled with the first five
association of california would

05:44:08.650 --> 05:44:10.719
like to think I'm the state
superintendent public

05:44:10.719 --> 05:44:13.152
instruction for sponsoring this
bill. Currently thirteen

05:44:13.288 --> 05:44:15.388
counties throughout the state
have the authority to pilot

05:44:16.158 --> 05:44:18.627
stern early education policies
to better capture the child care

05:44:19.261 --> 05:44:22.280
funding that is allocated by the
legislature each year. Ab twenty

05:44:22.797 --> 05:44:25.431
six twenty six with simply scale
mental many of these policies

05:44:25.866 --> 05:44:28.135
that have been tested and proven
to the remaining two thirds of

05:44:28.369 --> 05:44:31.105
the state that currently do not
have this authority. Simply put

05:44:31.105 --> 05:44:33.273
this bill will ensure more
children and more families will

05:44:33.841 --> 05:44:36.610
receive access to high quit high
quality early education and for

05:44:37.450 --> 05:44:39.450
this we respectfully request an

05:44:39.213 --> 05:44:40.814
aye vote.
Thank you other witnesses in

05:44:42.450 --> 05:44:45.418
support.
You don't want to must somehow
first that california.

05:44:46.954 --> 05:44:49.387
In support.
Patty europe presenting early

05:44:51.158 --> 05:44:53.726
edge californians support.
Cristina marcellus on behalf of

05:44:53.994 --> 05:44:56.763
the fresno county office of
education and san diego county

05:44:59.640 --> 05:45:01.133
office of education in support.
Dini micheletti colbern

05:45:01.435 --> 05:45:04.680
representing california
alternative payment program

05:45:07.740 --> 05:45:08.974
association in strong support.
Nick roman on behalf of the

05:45:09.750 --> 05:45:11.750
santa clara county office of

05:45:12.879 --> 05:45:14.879
education and support.

05:45:14.946 --> 05:45:16.946
Cities allen java did bass and

05:45:17.117 --> 05:45:18.684
project californians support.
Brad strong children down

05:45:19.985 --> 05:45:21.985
support.

05:45:23.122 --> 05:45:24.756
Anyone is in opposition.
Questions or comments mccarty

05:45:26.392 --> 05:45:28.600
members.
Mister O'donnell slash mullin

05:45:31.764 --> 05:45:33.764
project because.

05:45:33.933 --> 05:45:35.933
Well I'm.

05:45:38.437 --> 05:45:40.437
Anyway I fast for an aye vote.

05:45:41.505 --> 05:45:43.575
We need a motion.
We mentioned the second is the

05:45:43.575 --> 05:45:45.575
past appropriations

05:45:47.143 --> 05:45:49.143
it's called the law as amended.

05:45:49.614 --> 05:45:52.415
O'donnell aye o'donnell I kiley
aye kiley aye kalra kalra aye

05:45:52.782 --> 05:45:54.782
mccarty.

05:45:55.384 --> 05:45:58.354
Mccarty aye steinorth.
Steinorth aye thurman.

05:45:58.923 --> 05:46:00.923
weber.

05:46:01.125 --> 05:46:03.125
Weber I.

05:46:17.407 --> 05:46:19.407
The bill is out

05:46:30.920 --> 05:46:32.920
.

05:46:38.260 --> 05:46:40.260
To cunningham.

05:46:40.290 --> 05:46:42.970
Is file item eighteen ab twenty
five eighty Mister Cunningham

05:46:42.398 --> 05:46:44.799
please proceed
thank you Mister Chairman and

05:46:45.301 --> 05:46:47.602
members thank you sir I'm here
to present ab twenty five eighty

05:46:48.337 --> 05:46:50.338
under current law the state. Is
charged with providing

05:46:50.773 --> 05:46:53.339
administrative hearings for
special education related

05:46:54.476 --> 05:46:56.377
disputes that cannot be resolved.
These hearings are conducted by

05:46:57.646 --> 05:47:00.480
the ministry of law judges.
Under current law or under

05:47:00.480 --> 05:47:02.830
current law either party May
request a continuance of the

05:47:02.983 --> 05:47:05.419
hearing.
Which the statute specifies

05:47:06.455 --> 05:47:08.455
shall be granted upon showing of

05:47:08.690 --> 05:47:11.191
quote unquote good because.
However unlike other areas of

05:47:11.693 --> 05:47:14.528
law the statute does not define
what good cause is.

05:47:15.330 --> 05:47:17.531
So we have situations where the
hearings are set at a time

05:47:18.990 --> 05:47:20.601
period where the school.
Is out of session for summer

05:47:21.169 --> 05:47:24.137
for winter.
Spring and you have trouble

05:47:24.972 --> 05:47:27.240
getting witnesses that her.
Employees of the school

05:47:29.760 --> 05:47:30.644
district to attend the hearing.
This.

05:47:31.212 --> 05:47:34.470
Prolongs disputes and make
settlement difficult.

05:47:34.515 --> 05:47:36.515
And it dries up cost for both

05:47:36.750 --> 05:47:39.584
sides and actually in some cases
can hamper our kids from getting

05:47:40.219 --> 05:47:43.189
special education services in a
timely way. It's this bill would

05:47:43.590 --> 05:47:46.325
do two things that would clarify
in statute the standard for good

05:47:46.894 --> 05:47:48.361
cause. For special education
hearing.

05:47:49.763 --> 05:47:51.932
.
it it would clarify the standard

05:47:51.932 --> 05:47:54.980
for because it was specified
that.

05:47:54.601 --> 05:47:56.602
They're two grounds accounts to
good cause for a one time

05:47:57.237 --> 05:47:59.772
continuation hearing.
The first one is when a material

05:48:00.440 --> 05:48:02.775
witness is absent.
Do to the hearing date being sat

05:48:02.775 --> 05:48:05.511
on a day when the school was not
in session.

05:48:05.777 --> 05:48:07.777
And the other is where both

05:48:08.448 --> 05:48:10.750
parties both parties stipulate
that extensions necessary to

05:48:10.750 --> 05:48:12.750
resolve the matter. By

05:48:12.852 --> 05:48:15.187
settlement.
A sometime school boards cannot

05:48:15.688 --> 05:48:17.889
a enact a settlement because
they're not meeting overwintered

05:48:17.990 --> 05:48:19.990
they can't.

05:48:20.626 --> 05:48:22.727
Vote on it and so you've got
hearing dates that are driving

05:48:23.362 --> 05:48:25.163
up litigation costs
really for no.

05:48:25.865 --> 05:48:28.320
For no reason.
I think it's commonsense

05:48:28.634 --> 05:48:31.436
improvement in the law.
Again is just a one time
continuous for one of these two

05:48:32.700 --> 05:48:34.572
grounds.
I think it would be good for

05:48:35.807 --> 05:48:37.807
teachers good for school staff

05:48:38.810 --> 05:48:41.112
and good for kids and hasten the
provision of services that they
need.

05:48:42.647 --> 05:48:44.647
Thank you.

05:48:47.719 --> 05:48:49.953
Anyone doesn't support.
Kristy's mother bridgette read

05:48:51.157 --> 05:48:53.157
educate advocate empower family

05:49:01.132 --> 05:49:03.133
californians part thank you.
Evelyn aba hasn't disability

05:49:03.267 --> 05:49:04.900
rights california we actually
have a supportive amended

05:49:05.870 --> 05:49:08.171
position we want to ensure that
there's equalization in the

05:49:08.938 --> 05:49:11.800
process of that. Discontinuance
is not just for one school

05:49:11.800 --> 05:49:13.800
district employees are not

05:49:13.244 --> 05:49:15.311
available but also for parents
when their material witnesses
are not available.

05:49:16.113 --> 05:49:18.114
So we've on santa letter to the
authors office I think for

05:49:18.115 --> 05:49:20.149
working with the staff to
address that issue but I just

05:49:20.317 --> 05:49:22.317
wanted to. Testify to that thank

05:49:22.920 --> 05:49:24.520
you very much.
Thank you I don't this is in

05:49:26.230 --> 05:49:28.924
opposition.
It's cunningham budget because.

05:49:30.494 --> 05:49:32.860
Sure and I did get a letter from
that group I think there

05:49:33.163 --> 05:49:35.464
proposal makes a lot of sense
were working with them it should

05:49:35.665 --> 05:49:37.665
the committee see fit to pass

05:49:37.667 --> 05:49:39.700
this bill. Along I will be
working with them to amend the

05:49:40.335 --> 05:49:42.335
bill so there's parity in the

05:49:42.906 --> 05:49:45.574
continuance for.
I respectfully ask for not.

05:49:46.774 --> 05:49:49.444
We have a motion and a second it
is due pass to appropriations

05:49:52.982 --> 05:49:55.317
please call the roll.
Motion is to passed

05:49:55.685 --> 05:49:57.685
appropriations o'donnell.

05:49:57.818 --> 05:49:59.818
Kiley.

05:50:00.540 --> 05:50:02.540
Kiley aye kalra.

05:50:02.424 --> 05:50:05.360
Kalra hive mccarty.
Mccarty aye steinorth.

05:50:06.595 --> 05:50:09.163
Store not steinorth aye thurman.
Weber.

05:50:09.331 --> 05:50:11.331
Weber I.

05:50:11.533 --> 05:50:13.533
The bill is out.

05:50:14.269 --> 05:50:16.269
And I see Mister Lazar in here.

05:50:24.879 --> 05:50:26.879
You'd like to approach.

05:50:27.749 --> 05:50:30.215
This is file item fifteen. Ab
twenty five seventy.

05:50:31.319 --> 05:50:33.452
Seed when you're ready.
Thank you Mister Chair and

05:50:33.888 --> 05:50:36.189
members I'm presenting.
Assembly bill twenty five

05:50:38.226 --> 05:50:41.270
seventy. This evening. Other
clean and healthy schools act ab

05:50:42.290 --> 05:50:44.331
twenty five seventy requires all
k. Through twelve schools with

05:50:44.665 --> 05:50:46.665
fifty or more students to switch

05:50:46.767 --> 05:50:49.402
to safer. Environmentally
preferable cleaning products

05:50:49.904 --> 05:50:52.737
environmentally preferable
cleaning products are those that

05:50:53.474 --> 05:50:56.174
are independently certified by a
third party. As having greatly

05:50:56.810 --> 05:50:59.411
reduce the facts on human health
and the environment.

05:50:59.411 --> 05:51:01.714
In two thousand fourteen the
state department of public

05:51:01.982 --> 05:51:04.150
health published a report urging
schools to switch to

05:51:04.284 --> 05:51:07.190
environmentally preferable.
Cleaning products

05:51:07.754 --> 05:51:10.540
the department also warned that
conventional cleaning products

05:51:11.240 --> 05:51:13.240
May contain chemicals associated

05:51:13.226 --> 05:51:15.226
with asthma cancer reproductive

05:51:15.762 --> 05:51:17.762
harm and and. Can indoctrinate

05:51:17.864 --> 05:51:20.365
of destruction.
While more and more school

05:51:20.767 --> 05:51:23.702
districts have switched to less
toxic environmentally preferable

05:51:24.536 --> 05:51:26.738
cleaning products conventional
cleaning products are still

05:51:27.372 --> 05:51:29.608
widely used.
The requirement to switch to

05:51:29.709 --> 05:51:31.709
environmentally preferable

05:51:32.144 --> 05:51:34.611
chemicals is only required if it
is economically feasible to the

05:51:35.281 --> 05:51:37.281
school meaning.

05:51:37.483 --> 05:51:39.483
If switching will have no net

05:51:39.918 --> 05:51:42.186
cost increase.
In reality almost every

05:51:42.388 --> 05:51:44.355
institution across the country
has actually save money

05:51:44.690 --> 05:51:47.458
switching to environmentally
preferable cleaning products.

05:51:48.227 --> 05:51:50.995
If schools or school districts
choose not to comply with these

05:51:51.495 --> 05:51:53.831
provisions than a letter
detailing the reasons why

05:51:54.800 --> 05:51:56.800
compliance is not feasible shall

05:51:57.168 --> 05:51:59.168
be posted. On the schools or

05:51:59.270 --> 05:52:01.672
school districts website.
Ab twenty five seventy will

05:52:01.972 --> 05:52:03.607
require schools and school
districts to avoid cleaning

05:52:04.275 --> 05:52:06.577
products.
That are harmful to teachers

05:52:08.246 --> 05:52:10.314
students and custodial staff.
Who have the highest level of

05:52:11.649 --> 05:52:13.950
exposure by requiring schools to
switch to environmentally

05:52:14.752 --> 05:52:16.752
preferable cleaning products if

05:52:17.154 --> 05:52:19.154
economically feasible? With me I

05:52:19.323 --> 05:52:21.323
have bill eliud with the.

05:52:21.726 --> 05:52:24.693
Sponsor environmental working
group as well as tony trick

05:52:25.596 --> 05:52:27.596
arrow. With the california

05:52:27.965 --> 05:52:30.199
teachers association.
Thank you Mister Chair and

05:52:30.267 --> 05:52:33.236
members I'm bill alejo
environmental working group and

05:52:33.904 --> 05:52:35.904
happy to sponsor the bill.

05:52:36.340 --> 05:52:38.973
Mister Nazarian said most of
what I need to say solve be
brief.

05:52:40.800 --> 05:52:42.445
The third party certifier is
that would approval lista

05:52:42.779 --> 05:52:45.548
products have been doing this
for about thirty years except

05:52:47.490 --> 05:52:49.490
for u. S. Epa safer choice.

05:52:49.185 --> 05:52:51.954
Program which is newer and
doing the same thing and they

05:52:52.922 --> 05:52:55.324
provide a list of. Dozens and
dozens of cleaning products is

05:52:55.992 --> 05:52:57.992
not creating monopoly which just

05:52:58.261 --> 05:53:00.696
those a manufacturer to who
could have that approved.

05:53:00.696 --> 05:53:02.696
We've.

05:53:02.899 --> 05:53:04.531
Take a number of amendments and
will continue work with the

05:53:07.704 --> 05:53:09.938
opposition the household and
commercial products association.
I'm and I think we're close with

05:53:11.372 --> 05:53:14.750
that. A couple other issues have
come up in the last week.

05:53:14.910 --> 05:53:17.578
Why not let a state body
certify these things of the

05:53:17.880 --> 05:53:20.460
third party with a third party
people been doing it for thirty

05:53:20.482 --> 05:53:23.284
years of doing a good job
manufacturers school districts?

05:53:23.485 --> 05:53:25.820
Our own department general
services uses them.

05:53:27.550 --> 05:53:29.550
And do we want to pay for a new

05:53:29.157 --> 05:53:31.926
state agents I new products a
program a state agency to would

05:53:33.161 --> 05:53:35.362
have to be fee based. Or come
out of the general fund I don't

05:53:35.830 --> 05:53:37.798
think so we have a good
alternative now.

05:53:38.500 --> 05:53:41.166
This there's also an accusation
sort of fires allow toxics like

05:53:42.403 --> 05:53:45.170
props sixty five chemicals to be
certified not true I've looked

05:53:46.174 --> 05:53:48.709
at their standards. They allow
no intentionally added.

05:53:55.820 --> 05:53:57.784
Mutagens carcinogens or a containing those
ingredients if there is a tiny

05:53:58.853 --> 05:54:01.187
mouse one tara hundred parts per
million or less.

05:54:01.687 --> 05:54:04.289
Lastly someone suggest why we
just this would prohibit the use

05:54:04.858 --> 05:54:06.858
of do it yourself products like

05:54:07.227 --> 05:54:09.396
vinegar and baking soda. A those
are not always benign vinegar is

05:54:09.396 --> 05:54:11.631
also an
megyn and be

05:54:12.266 --> 05:54:15.670
there's nothing in the law that
would say a teacher can't

05:54:15.869 --> 05:54:17.670
cleaner desk with baking soda
vinegar if that's what they want

05:54:19.172 --> 05:54:21.440
to do. But most school districts
we feel one use regular keening

05:54:21.675 --> 05:54:23.675
cleaning products and not start

05:54:23.844 --> 05:54:25.844
resorting to baking soda and

05:54:26.379 --> 05:54:28.547
vinegar thank you.
Mister Chair tony to care on
behalf of the california

05:54:29.217 --> 05:54:31.217
teachers association this is one

05:54:31.449 --> 05:54:33.919
of those bills where it's simply
where there's a will there's a

05:54:34.220 --> 05:54:37.189
way. Ump this.
Issue impacts everyone at the

05:54:37.457 --> 05:54:39.858
school site not just students
and teachers but all the

05:54:40.590 --> 05:54:42.590
employees there I think the

05:54:42.562 --> 05:54:44.829
analysis. On page by points out
districts that are already doing

05:54:45.531 --> 05:54:47.531
this it's a sound environmental

05:54:50.502 --> 05:54:52.502
policy we ask for your aye vote.

05:54:52.871 --> 05:54:54.706
Thank you others in support.
Mr members alice felonies

05:54:55.974 --> 05:54:57.575
felonies group on behalf of
voice for choice advocacy in

05:55:00.279 --> 05:55:02.947
support.
Cameras murderous service
employees international union we

05:55:03.415 --> 05:55:05.382
represent cost by members on the
most populous districts

05:55:05.484 --> 05:55:07.484
including janitors at work with

05:55:07.652 --> 05:55:09.652
these products nam behalf by

05:55:11.990 --> 05:55:14.758
members the students we support.
Christie's motherboards on
behalf of educate advocate and

05:55:15.627 --> 05:55:17.627
empower family california in

05:55:18.229 --> 05:55:20.763
support.
Wendy cutie parent of a child

05:55:21.132 --> 05:55:23.132
with special healthcare needs in

05:55:24.367 --> 05:55:26.103
support.
Thank you are any opposition to

05:55:41.251 --> 05:55:43.251
the bill

05:55:43.485 --> 05:55:45.822
.
Good evening a cooking unitarily

05:55:45.822 --> 05:55:48.558
half of the household and
commercial products association.

05:55:49.324 --> 05:55:51.560
I want to startby saying we
really appreciate the author's

05:55:53.630 --> 05:55:54.730
amendments that exempted. Real
products from the requirements

05:55:55.432 --> 05:55:57.399
of this bill others cleaning
products are central in our

05:55:58.401 --> 05:56:00.336
opinion for reducing bacterial
contamination on food service

05:56:00.904 --> 05:56:02.771
says preventing the spread of
flu outbreaks cleaning

05:56:03.106 --> 05:56:05.541
restaurant at ultra.
And they already go through an

05:56:07.242 --> 05:56:09.242
extensive review by the us epa

05:56:09.812 --> 05:56:12.446
and dp are before registration.
We also and recognize that the

05:56:12.881 --> 05:56:15.482
authored sponsors to believe
that usepa see for choi

05:56:15.918 --> 05:56:18.190
certification program would
qualify under third pre

05:56:18.220 --> 05:56:20.855
certifier.
We are working with the u. S.

05:56:22.158 --> 05:56:24.580
Epa however just to confirm not.
And.

05:56:24.660 --> 05:56:27.395
May look to you.
Make some changes to make that

05:56:27.930 --> 05:56:30.363
even clearer if necessary but we
do support that they are

05:56:33.680 --> 05:56:35.571
committed to making sure that is.
But it qualifies.

05:56:35.571 --> 05:56:37.104
I'm we just also I want to make
a comment that.

05:56:38.500 --> 05:56:40.608
While we support that third
party certification we would

05:56:41.510 --> 05:56:44.111
also encourage the author to
look at other systems.

05:56:44.946 --> 05:56:46.946
Available to school districts

05:56:47.315 --> 05:56:49.817
to improve their sustainable
purchasing programs.

05:56:50.283 --> 05:56:53.153
For example there's a.
And organizations sustainable

05:56:53.688 --> 05:56:56.224
purchasing leadership council
and they have a process based

05:56:56.657 --> 05:56:58.657
approach that helps.

05:56:58.693 --> 05:57:01.294
Organizations identify the
sustainability goals that they

05:57:01.829 --> 05:57:04.598
have for example if it's
important for them to reduce.

05:57:05.833 --> 05:57:07.833
Allergens and products.

05:57:08.936 --> 05:57:11.603
They can way amongst the green
sales which have better.

05:57:13.774 --> 05:57:15.774
Reductions and allergens.

05:57:16.143 --> 05:57:18.144
Versus what might have more
environmental.

05:57:18.544 --> 05:57:20.544
Benefit so.

05:57:20.678 --> 05:57:22.879
We just think this allows the
school districts to achieve

05:57:23.749 --> 05:57:25.749
their own goals.

05:57:25.885 --> 05:57:27.786
So for these reasons and other
state in our letter that I won't

05:57:28.854 --> 05:57:30.854
go into we are opposed today

05:57:31.390 --> 05:57:34.920
think you.
As chair members tim justin with
american chemistry council out

05:57:34.893 --> 05:57:37.628
just two quick points we would
like to seek some clarification

05:57:38.162 --> 05:57:40.162
on the language around

05:57:40.798 --> 05:57:42.900
disinfectants and sanitizers we
want to make sure that those
products.

05:57:43.336 --> 05:57:45.970
Are available to address
potential threats from pathogens

05:57:46.671 --> 05:57:49.407
norovirus what have you.
And then secondly as it relates

05:57:49.674 --> 05:57:51.641
to the criteria for a third
party certification we do have

05:57:52.110 --> 05:57:54.110
some some technical issues that

05:57:54.412 --> 05:57:57.181
were raised by our legal folks
we share those with Mister His
area and. A look for to work

05:57:57.916 --> 05:58:00.916
with them as the bill moves
forward thank you.

05:58:01.886 --> 05:58:03.886
Thank you any other opposition.

05:58:03.888 --> 05:58:05.989
Similar opposition warrior back.
Students are maybe you can

05:58:06.356 --> 05:58:08.859
answer my question maybe you can
step your arm when you awareness

05:58:11.195 --> 05:58:13.831
about of the safer choice
program of public she did.

05:58:13.831 --> 05:58:16.467
Could you just elaborate on what
my concerns here is that we're
being asked to pick winners and

05:58:16.467 --> 05:58:18.935
losers.
On the business side and I don't

05:58:19.690 --> 05:58:21.636
think that your intent here
today is no I'm saying as much
some.

05:58:21.837 --> 05:58:23.973
I'm worried that someone starts
a label says look you get

05:58:24.875 --> 05:58:27.823
certified by us.
You know you're gonna be gold
you're really here really
-

05:58:28.745 --> 05:58:31.130
environmentally friendly now I'm
gonna make much money number six.
Not saying that's what's

05:58:31.648 --> 05:58:33.816
happening here but that's my
concern so maybe you can address

05:58:34.316 --> 05:58:36.419
that maybe one of the.
Other the other witness could

05:58:36.419 --> 05:58:38.419
talk about the safer choice

05:58:38.622 --> 05:58:41.124
program.
Chester.

05:58:41.124 --> 05:58:43.325
I'm sure so the safer choice
program is run by the.

05:58:45.695 --> 05:58:47.963
U. S. Epa eyes so we definitely
it's ana obviously a private

05:58:48.731 --> 05:58:50.966
organization so we certainly
want to make sure that.

05:58:51.800 --> 05:58:54.690
They are a a program that's
considered date certified.

05:58:54.504 --> 05:58:56.504
Over two thousand.

05:58:56.706 --> 05:58:58.540
Products in terms of. Their
compliance.

05:58:59.976 --> 05:59:01.710
But for of many of the the
reasons you.

05:59:02.311 --> 05:59:04.878
Mentioned.
Assembly member of that's why

05:59:04.980 --> 05:59:07.649
we would also like to look at
those other programs that aren't

05:59:09.180 --> 05:59:11.786
necessarily certification based.
But more.

05:59:13.455 --> 05:59:15.490
Holistic and process based.
If I May comment bill alley with

05:59:15.591 --> 05:59:18.226
the wg.
For many years that was on the

05:59:19.361 --> 05:59:21.361
green sealing eagle logo and now

05:59:21.496 --> 05:59:23.831
it's you epsa per choices much
more robust than just a few

05:59:24.232 --> 05:59:26.232
years ago that's why we think

05:59:26.601 --> 05:59:28.870
the criteria. As expanded would
allow the men were okay with

05:59:28.870 --> 05:59:31.171
that they're not quite as
richest that they're doing a

05:59:31.673 --> 05:59:34.141
really good job to extremists
without these programs without

05:59:34.674 --> 05:59:36.710
certification they're many
school districts.

05:59:37.512 --> 05:59:40.380
That it's kind of the wild west
of a woman nine well apparent in

05:59:40.882 --> 05:59:43.384
a wooden school district. Was
complaining about chemicals and

05:59:43.384 --> 05:59:45.819
they just told her they're all
legal leave the salon these are

05:59:46.254 --> 05:59:48.588
legal cleaning products so you
have to. Districts will kind of

05:59:49.230 --> 05:59:51.757
fun there knows that these
concerns especially the

05:59:52.930 --> 05:59:54.828
janitorial staff to get the most
exposure I've seen personally

05:59:55.429 --> 05:59:57.730
how works in elk grove school
district down the road. They

05:59:58.232 --> 06:00:00.232
demonstrated also were saving

06:00:01.668 --> 06:00:03.269
money killing bacteria all good.
And they continue to do so.

06:00:05.606 --> 06:00:07.206
Okay thank you.
Any other comments from the

06:00:08.175 --> 06:00:10.175
committee members.

06:00:12.345 --> 06:00:14.312
I do we have a motion.
Been moved and seconded.

06:00:15.148 --> 06:00:17.148
.

06:00:17.183 --> 06:00:19.183
Are you May close the motion is

06:00:19.219 --> 06:00:21.453
to pass to appropriations.
Thank you Mister Chair just want

06:00:22.422 --> 06:00:24.422
to remind that more than one in

06:00:24.424 --> 06:00:26.424
five californians including six

06:00:27.260 --> 06:00:29.260
million children are. Up spend

06:00:29.295 --> 06:00:31.295
time in schools daly and.

06:00:31.697 --> 06:00:34.631
Have exposure to these products
and if there are ways that we

06:00:35.670 --> 06:00:38.300
can help curb.
Some of that exposure of or

06:00:38.371 --> 06:00:40.371
helped move along the

06:00:40.539 --> 06:00:43.740
conversation also idea.
But hate.

06:00:43.740 --> 06:00:45.875
Respectfully ask for aye vote to
help do so.

06:00:46.679 --> 06:00:48.912
thank you I do hope you continue
the conversations because I want

06:00:49.713 --> 06:00:51.349
to confuse what the.
The disconnect here is but I.

06:00:52.818 --> 06:00:54.550
Thank you.
Motion is to pastor

06:00:55.788 --> 06:00:57.788
appropriations.

06:00:58.756 --> 06:01:00.756
O'donnell. I've o'donnell kiley.

06:01:01.226 --> 06:01:03.961
Kalra.
Kalra aye mccarty.

06:01:04.930 --> 06:01:07.698
Mccarty aye steinorth.
Steinorth not voting thurmond.

06:01:08.231 --> 06:01:10.231
Weber.

06:01:14.671 --> 06:01:16.671
Weber I.

06:01:31.550 --> 06:01:32.352
Liberals out thank you
.

06:01:34.758 --> 06:01:36.758
Who?

06:01:42.566 --> 06:01:45.167
Let him go.
We'll now move to a mr mccarty

06:01:46.268 --> 06:01:48.268
who has two bills file items

06:01:48.738 --> 06:01:50.738
number two and seven.

06:01:53.810 --> 06:01:55.810
Start with file item number two.

06:01:57.380 --> 06:02:00.150
Did between.
Three bills Miss Any of three

06:02:03.486 --> 06:02:05.787
yeah michael.
File item number two ab

06:02:06.689 --> 06:02:09.424
seventeen fifty four. Thank you
first like to thank our chair in

06:02:09.926 --> 06:02:12.627
our committee staff for helping
work on this bill this bill will

06:02:14.263 --> 06:02:16.564
ensure that all. Income eligible
low income four year olds of

06:02:17.660 --> 06:02:18.967
access to early care and
education programs that

06:02:20.135 --> 06:02:22.469
california. As we know research
shows this is the most important

06:02:23.539 --> 06:02:26.720
thing we can do to make sure our
youngest learners. Are.

06:02:26.740 --> 06:02:28.308
.
Effective what's the enter

06:02:29.177 --> 06:02:31.177
kindergarten have academic

06:02:31.312 --> 06:02:34.115
success and. Hopefully I have
them on the. On a journey

06:02:34.716 --> 06:02:36.716
through a life and.

06:02:37.180 --> 06:02:39.186
Stay away from the juvenile
justice system and stay away

06:02:39.921 --> 06:02:41.988
from issues such as poverty we
know the research shows that

06:02:42.389 --> 06:02:44.858
this really makes a difference.
I with me today are.

06:02:46.394 --> 06:02:48.270
witnesses from first five
california and the advancement

06:02:50.932 --> 06:02:53.100
project.
Maybe your witnesses but.

06:02:55.360 --> 06:02:57.604
Of good evening ummc the john
job it with the best price it

06:02:57.738 --> 06:03:00.173
faster podcast forty out. Here
today not just as an advocate

06:03:00.808 --> 06:03:02.808
but a mother of a four year old

06:03:02.943 --> 06:03:04.844
who is attending a pretty
program.

06:03:05.212 --> 06:03:07.480
I won't belabor the point about
the resurgent benefits of early

06:03:08.249 --> 06:03:10.717
education. You've heard that
before and the committee

06:03:10.884 --> 06:03:13.585
analysis is done a really good
job of laying that out. I will

06:03:14.221 --> 06:03:16.221
comment on this issue as a

06:03:16.589 --> 06:03:19.425
mother. Who had who whose son is
driving because he's in a

06:03:19.760 --> 06:03:21.760
quality pre care program?

06:03:21.795 --> 06:03:24.663
I think my side is brilliant and
I might be a little biased.

06:03:24.798 --> 06:03:27.199
But he's brilliant and learning
because he has the opportunity

06:03:27.734 --> 06:03:29.734
to do so.

06:03:29.803 --> 06:03:31.803
At the age of four you can do

06:03:31.870 --> 06:03:34.239
addition subtraction he can
write a whole sentence his

06:03:34.706 --> 06:03:37.342
compassionate
critically thinks what needs to

06:03:38.344 --> 06:03:40.344
be done if he has said or done

06:03:40.513 --> 06:03:42.581
something to hurt his peers.
I can teach him that his

06:03:43.182 --> 06:03:45.851
teachers debt.
It's attractions in his school

06:03:46.352 --> 06:03:47.852
taught him to control his social
and emotional needs.

06:03:49.355 --> 06:03:52.230
To share.
Imagine forty three thousand to

06:03:52.792 --> 06:03:54.959
eighty six thousand kids.
Privately such opportunities in

06:03:55.626 --> 06:03:58.364
our state.
Private of such knowledge.

06:03:58.364 --> 06:04:00.364
Deprived of becoming perhaps

06:04:00.532 --> 06:04:02.333
brilliant.
This is what we call an

06:04:04.169 --> 06:04:06.671
opportunity gap.
When these kids step into a

06:04:07.606 --> 06:04:09.874
kindergarten classroom.
we're they're interacting with

06:04:10.800 --> 06:04:12.743
children who have had these
opportunities and then their

06:04:13.343 --> 06:04:16.145
kids her learning to still sit
still. Pay attention perhaps

06:04:16.715 --> 06:04:18.782
even learn to speak the same
language as their peers and

06:04:19.383 --> 06:04:22.119
teachers.
This Mister Chairman members.

06:04:23.210 --> 06:04:25.857
Is when the opportunity gap
becomes an achievement gap. And

06:04:25.924 --> 06:04:28.292
it process throughout their
educational career.

06:04:28.926 --> 06:04:31.261
I'm lucky that I don't have to
choose between putting food on

06:04:31.696 --> 06:04:33.620
the table for my child.
And.

06:04:33.764 --> 06:04:36.499
.
Putting my children on into a

06:04:36.734 --> 06:04:38.835
quality early learning setting
but many parents have to make

06:04:39.270 --> 06:04:41.971
that choice.
Reality is that parents can

06:04:42.673 --> 06:04:45.175
afford to do so bill proprietor
bet provide the best education

06:04:46.210 --> 06:04:48.210
for their children.

06:04:48.212 --> 06:04:50.513
Many parents can't do that.
And this is where the state

06:04:51.810 --> 06:04:53.850
needs to comment. It is the
state's responsibility o make

06:04:54.952 --> 06:04:57.585
things equitable and mitigate
these gaps earlier on.

06:04:58.221 --> 06:05:00.790
It doesn't project is in strong
support of any fully summarized

06:05:02.359 --> 06:05:03.926
yes almost unheard. Of pre k.
For all in the state of

06:05:05.328 --> 06:05:07.328
california until then we need to

06:05:07.630 --> 06:05:09.630
provide these opportunities for

06:05:09.766 --> 06:05:11.665
a going concern to you. Next but.
Good evening members of the

06:05:11.968 --> 06:05:14.269
committee my name is margaret
gould I'm here from the first

06:05:14.837 --> 06:05:17.205
five association of california
on behalf of all the first lives

06:05:17.540 --> 06:05:19.274
across the state including our
state agency for spike

06:05:19.809 --> 06:05:22.577
california here in strong
support of the bill. As we all

06:05:23.144 --> 06:05:25.680
know there's overwhelming
evidence and.

06:05:26.315 --> 06:05:28.550
and decades of research that
shows that investing in high

06:05:29.183 --> 06:05:31.384
quality preschool programs can
lead to promoting brain

06:05:31.786 --> 06:05:33.786
development preventing the

06:05:33.821 --> 06:05:36.491
achievement gap. And preventing
long term effects like poverty.

06:05:36.992 --> 06:05:39.327
Simply put ab seventeen fifty
four would codify california's

06:05:39.860 --> 06:05:41.762
preschool promise and ensure
that all four year olds

06:05:42.297 --> 06:05:44.365
regardless of that all four year
olds who are income eligible

06:05:44.665 --> 06:05:47.300
would receive high quality
subsidized care.

06:05:48.300 --> 06:05:50.903
Enclosing able to share that
there are a few broader issues

06:05:51.806 --> 06:05:54.174
that we know arms are are.
Our barriers in order to

06:05:54.541 --> 06:05:57.378
achieving the preschool promised
that promise that simply bar too

06:05:57.779 --> 06:06:00.415
far too many children from
accessing care the two critical

06:06:00.415 --> 06:06:02.415
pieces that would just like to

06:06:02.450 --> 06:06:04.151
share one the lack of facilities
into the lack of personal

06:06:05.219 --> 06:06:07.354
support. We greatly appreciate
assembly member mccarty is

06:06:07.855 --> 06:06:10.590
leadership around expanding
quality preschool and we see ab

06:06:11.580 --> 06:06:13.580
seventeen fifty four as the

06:06:13.590 --> 06:06:15.195
critical first step in ensuring
that all four year olds do you

06:06:15.496 --> 06:06:18.198
have have access to these high
quality programs. For these

06:06:18.699 --> 06:06:21.534
reasons we respectfully request
your aye vote on this bill.

06:06:22.136 --> 06:06:24.503
Thank you others in support.
Patty herero representing early

06:06:24.503 --> 06:06:26.973
at californians support thank
you.

06:06:27.400 --> 06:06:29.275
Cat de burke with the health
officer's association of

06:06:31.678 --> 06:06:33.713
californians support.
Do you could watch on behalf of

06:06:34.810 --> 06:06:36.683
los angeles unified school
district in support.

06:06:36.683 --> 06:06:38.683
Brad strong children now strong

06:06:39.618 --> 06:06:42.190
support.
Danielle canada kaiser with

06:06:45.387 --> 06:06:48.260
common sense kids action in
strong support.
Jeff bock of representing the
riverside county superintendent

06:06:49.929 --> 06:06:52.564
of schools in support.
Stena marcellus representing a

06:06:52.697 --> 06:06:54.697
san francisco unified school

06:06:55.334 --> 06:06:57.403
district support.
Means the read on behalf of

06:06:57.403 --> 06:06:59.403
california association for the

06:07:00.573 --> 06:07:02.841
gifted in support.
Nick roman on behalf of the san

06:07:03.341 --> 06:07:05.900
bernadino county district
advocates for better schools and

06:07:06.478 --> 06:07:08.478
support.

06:07:08.579 --> 06:07:10.148
Ron rapoport have the california
federation of teachers and

06:07:15.619 --> 06:07:17.989
support.
I don't have a housing display

06:07:22.561 --> 06:07:25.261
rates californians part.
Dini micheletti colbern for

06:07:26.131 --> 06:07:28.265
actually in a watch position and
we're hoping to flip to support

06:07:31.301 --> 06:07:33.871
thank you.
I really opposition.

06:07:34.439 --> 06:07:36.807
See no opposition any other
comments really committee member

06:07:38.943 --> 06:07:41.678
seeing on to have a motion.
Moved and seconded all seconded.

06:07:42.513 --> 06:07:44.314
.
You May close to motions to

06:07:44.916 --> 06:07:47.584
passed.
Do passed you appropriations

06:07:48.252 --> 06:07:50.954
thank you this is that cree que
for all acting california and

06:07:51.288 --> 06:07:53.669
hope this is the year that we
can get it passed thank you for

06:07:54.525 --> 06:07:56.594
your consideration.
Thank you.

06:07:56.594 --> 06:07:59.228
Please call the roll to pass to
appropriations.

06:08:00.230 --> 06:08:02.230
O'donnell by o'donnell aye kiley.

06:08:02.566 --> 06:08:04.566
Kalra.

06:08:04.868 --> 06:08:07.300
Kalra aye mccarty aye mccarty
aye steinorth. Steinorth aye

06:08:07.271 --> 06:08:09.405
thurmond.
Weber.

06:08:12.275 --> 06:08:14.877
Weber I.
Bills for votes it is out.

06:08:15.377 --> 06:08:17.377
When I moved to file item number

06:08:17.714 --> 06:08:20.683
seven two zero nine a pilot.
File number seven.

06:08:27.900 --> 06:08:30.570
Two zero ab two zero nine.
Which when you send mr Jr. But

06:08:30.658 --> 06:08:32.995
two zero nine eight okay thank
you. Again like to think that

06:08:32.995 --> 06:08:35.397
you're on the committee for
working with us on the bill we

06:08:36.766 --> 06:08:39.601
have before us the. Kids code
program we talked earlier about

06:08:40.436 --> 06:08:43.370
the issues was stem in
california not having enough.

06:08:43.839 --> 06:08:46.741
Individuals to to to participate
in the workforce.

06:08:47.609 --> 06:08:50.311
We also know not enough low
incomes and underrepresented

06:08:50.646 --> 06:08:52.646
kids are participating so we

06:08:52.848 --> 06:08:54.549
have a creative idea. Pilot
project and department of

06:08:55.517 --> 06:08:57.985
education with our after school
programs are there everyday

06:08:58.553 --> 06:09:00.688
between three and six.
This will give them an exciting

06:09:01.723 --> 06:09:03.723
thing to do and that teach them

06:09:04.458 --> 06:09:07.328
about coding and stem and. And
really provide a win win for the.

06:09:09.300 --> 06:09:11.300
For the kids for california and

06:09:11.650 --> 06:09:13.650
for industry as well with me is.

06:09:13.670 --> 06:09:14.635
Comptia to prison per to.
.

06:09:15.403 --> 06:09:17.403
Provide some testimony.

06:09:17.572 --> 06:09:20.341
Thank you your first witness.
Great thank you good evening

06:09:20.341 --> 06:09:23.900
Chairman Will members of the
committee my name with terrible

06:09:23.411 --> 06:09:26.460
ash and the director of state
government affairs that comitia

06:09:26.247 --> 06:09:29.140
were formerly known as the
computing technology industry

06:09:29.816 --> 06:09:32.850
association. First off we'd like
to think the assembly member

06:09:32.319 --> 06:09:34.319
staff in the department of

06:09:34.421 --> 06:09:37.123
education for their guidance and
expertise in this important

06:09:39.910 --> 06:09:41.561
issue. We are here today as co
sponsors with tech net

06:09:41.929 --> 06:09:43.929
I am representing the price of

06:09:44.640 --> 06:09:46.432
the technology industry on ab
twenty ninety eight which would

06:09:46.967 --> 06:09:49.333
establish that three year after
school coating program had a

06:09:50.503 --> 06:09:53.380
program. I'm under the current
existing east this framework as

06:09:53.873 --> 06:09:56.408
industry leaders we urge the
state to investing efforts to

06:09:56.876 --> 06:09:59.545
equalize access to computer
science encoding courses

06:10:00.212 --> 06:10:02.314
starting with the lowest income
students in the state.

06:10:03.140 --> 06:10:05.951
California leads the nation and
technology jobs innovation an

06:10:06.451 --> 06:10:09.321
average wage
according to kant tias twenty

06:10:10.223 --> 06:10:12.691
eighteen fiver states report.
It quantifies the size and scope

06:10:12.792 --> 06:10:15.327
of the tech industry in the top
workforce.

06:10:15.961 --> 06:10:18.295
Across multiple vectors
employment in california's

06:10:19.231 --> 06:10:21.418
technology industry expanded by
an estimated thirty three

06:10:21.800 --> 06:10:24.769
thousand jobs in twenty
seventeen. And contributed more

06:10:25.237 --> 06:10:27.971
to three hundred fifty billion
to the state's economy.

06:10:28.340 --> 06:10:30.340
According to the u. S. Bureau of

06:10:30.509 --> 06:10:32.509
labor statistics it is predicted

06:10:32.511 --> 06:10:34.511
that by year twenty twenty four

06:10:34.546 --> 06:10:36.514
point six million jobs will be
in computing our information

06:10:37.716 --> 06:10:39.716
technology which is more than

06:10:40.151 --> 06:10:42.347
all other science technology.
Engineering and mathematics the

06:10:43.653 --> 06:10:46.190
combined however it the number
of students graduating with a

06:10:46.490 --> 06:10:48.490
computer science degree is

06:10:48.560 --> 06:10:51.528
minuscule compared to the number
of available tech jobs. And more

06:10:51.920 --> 06:10:54.831
importantly as it relates to
this bill. There remains a large

06:10:55.867 --> 06:10:58.301
disparity between students from
affluent schools and students

06:10:59.470 --> 06:11:01.671
from low income schools with
access to quoting course that.

06:11:02.530 --> 06:11:04.530
The california after school

06:11:04.240 --> 06:11:06.605
computer coding grant palette
program provides critically

06:11:07.511 --> 06:11:09.811
needed exposure and access.
The coding for after school

06:11:09.847 --> 06:11:12.482
youth who are less likely to
learn.

06:11:13.283 --> 06:11:15.752
To code in schools are out home
please summarize.

06:11:16.320 --> 06:11:18.453
We believe education holds the
key to preparing the next

06:11:19.189 --> 06:11:20.923
generation learner to thrive and
succeed in the digital

06:11:22.250 --> 06:11:24.927
marketplace. And with those.
Comments and others that we

06:11:25.195 --> 06:11:27.630
respectfully ask your aye vote
think you.

06:11:31.130 --> 06:11:33.968
.
Any opposition
or other support any others.
Mister Chairman reyes laura

06:11:34.104 --> 06:11:36.238
bennett with tech net we of the
co sponsors of this measure

06:11:36.306 --> 06:11:38.941
would come to yeah he simply
associate those comments with

06:11:39.575 --> 06:11:41.710
other come to yeah we ask your
aye vote thank you.

06:11:42.578 --> 06:11:45.412
Others in support.
But Mister Chair members have
been straight with the

06:11:46.582 --> 06:11:49.217
california stem network we have
a watch position on this bill.

06:11:49.585 --> 06:11:51.887
But we are also part of the.
California or the computer

06:11:51.887 --> 06:11:54.756
science for california
initiative and believe that this
would go a long way to

06:11:55.570 --> 06:11:57.192
increasing access to computer
science education encoding thank

06:11:58.427 --> 06:12:00.962
you.
Any opposition to the bill seen

06:12:01.597 --> 06:12:03.765
opposition the comments from the
commanders you.

06:12:04.566 --> 06:12:06.601
We have a motion.
It's been moved and seconded the

06:12:06.635 --> 06:12:08.635
motion is to pass to

06:12:09.370 --> 06:12:11.370
appropriations you May cause.

06:12:11.740 --> 06:12:14.175
Just ask the driver thank you.
Please call the roll to pass

06:12:14.442 --> 06:12:17.378
through appropriations o'donnell.
O'donnell aye kiley kiley aye

06:12:19.147 --> 06:12:21.147
kalra. Kalra hike mccarty aye

06:12:21.248 --> 06:12:23.248
mccarty aye steinorth steinorth

06:12:24.118 --> 06:12:26.118
aye thurman. Thurmond aye weber.

06:12:26.221 --> 06:12:28.221
Weber I will go to file item

06:12:28.456 --> 06:12:30.456
twenty eight yeah thats ab

06:12:30.658 --> 06:12:33.910
twenty eight twenty.
Thank you last bill here and

06:12:33.361 --> 06:12:35.527
again think the us here in the
committee for working with us

06:12:35.963 --> 06:12:38.198
and we will like to note that
the committee analysis noted a

06:12:38.499 --> 06:12:40.565
few issues that we want to
continue working on as we go

06:12:40.967 --> 06:12:43.470
through the process.
Similarly at our successful

06:12:44.305 --> 06:12:46.371
today this will create the
community engagement in school

06:12:46.941 --> 06:12:48.606
claim it.
Continuous improvement block

06:12:49.430 --> 06:12:51.810
grants
to help to help make sure we

06:12:52.444 --> 06:12:54.914
have.
Adequate community engagement

06:12:55.983 --> 06:12:58.784
relate to our el caps
and.
Basically.

06:12:59.485 --> 06:13:01.787
Community dialogue relate to
school conditions and climate

06:13:02.122 --> 06:13:04.122
that we all know the after four

06:13:04.191 --> 06:13:06.558
years of lcf that it's a start
but there's not. And not

06:13:07.627 --> 06:13:10.327
stakeholder engagement in this
is what this bill. Is that

06:13:11.730 --> 06:13:13.115
guided to do aye with me today.
Are.

06:13:13.733 --> 06:13:16.567
.
I californians for justice and

06:13:17.303 --> 06:13:19.303
that mr robert green eleventh

06:13:19.705 --> 06:13:21.705
grader it from he words unified

06:13:25.311 --> 06:13:28.450
school mount haydn high school.
You're good to go of think.

06:13:29.181 --> 06:13:30.982
Hi good afternoon help you stay
awake.

06:13:31.183 --> 06:13:33.183
At their mercy.

06:13:33.519 --> 06:13:35.519
I'm honored to speak in front

06:13:36.550 --> 06:13:38.923
of this committee. I am my name
is robert greene I'm a student

06:13:39.291 --> 06:13:41.925
leader from california's from
justice.

06:13:42.995 --> 06:13:44.995
Now I am going to be the future

06:13:44.997 --> 06:13:46.497
President Of united states of
america.

06:13:48.333 --> 06:13:51.235
This is why I am here to say it
is time for the state to poor

06:13:52.504 --> 06:13:55.720
aye students family engagement.
and school crime in in the same

06:13:55.140 --> 06:13:57.875
way that we invest in other
state priorities.

06:13:58.800 --> 06:14:00.800
Students and families are

06:14:00.644 --> 06:14:02.644
experts in our education and no

06:14:03.114 --> 06:14:04.915
one has more at stake in our
schools then.

06:14:06.170 --> 06:14:08.385
We do.
I never believed that I would

06:14:09.787 --> 06:14:11.887
ever go to a college because
none of my family have done

06:14:12.722 --> 06:14:14.722
before.

06:14:14.759 --> 06:14:17.600
I assumed it wasn't from me.
But in my sophomore year and

06:14:17.461 --> 06:14:19.829
metal levin teacher Miss
Eastward.

06:14:19.830 --> 06:14:22.532
She was so supportive and
amazing.

06:14:23.100 --> 06:14:25.100
She changed my mind about

06:14:25.736 --> 06:14:28.671
college and give me resources
like tutoring.

06:14:29.400 --> 06:14:31.606
Positive relationships with
teachers and staff is critical

06:14:32.743 --> 06:14:35.111
for student success.
Slightly for low income students

06:14:35.812 --> 06:14:37.812
of color.

06:14:38.181 --> 06:14:40.583
However school climate surveys
show that one out of three

06:14:42.252 --> 06:14:44.252
students can identify a single

06:14:44.754 --> 06:14:46.754
caring widowed at school.%

06:14:46.956 --> 06:14:49.491
this school climate data is what
my fellow students and have

06:14:51.427 --> 06:14:53.996
shared. With my district to push
them to change this reality in.

06:14:55.198 --> 06:14:56.698
And guess what.
They are listening and

06:14:57.333 --> 06:14:59.333
partnering.

06:14:59.869 --> 06:15:02.437
With us to find solutions.
They are listening because

06:15:04.624 --> 06:15:06.741
through oakland's el cap parent
student advisory committee we

06:15:07.543 --> 06:15:10.478
have been able to build trusting
collaborative.

06:15:12.854 --> 06:15:15.750
The relationship with district
staff are super. And school
board members.

06:15:16.752 --> 06:15:18.752
My stern show that local control

06:15:19.221 --> 06:15:21.689
and accountability. Can work but
let's face it.

06:15:23.792 --> 06:15:25.792
Most districts are not there yet.

06:15:26.940 --> 06:15:28.696
we asked you to vote yes for a.
B. Twenty eight twenty. To

06:15:29.798 --> 06:15:32.660
improve community engagement and
so climb in.

06:15:32.133 --> 06:15:34.133
We are better when we lead to

06:15:36.137 --> 06:15:37.517
gather.
Thank you.

06:15:38.139 --> 06:15:40.139
Others in support.

06:15:41.876 --> 06:15:43.910
I am very.
I'm terry issued executive

06:15:44.102 --> 06:15:47.130
director of californians for
justice representing a coalition

06:15:47.548 --> 06:15:49.548
of student parent organizations

06:15:50.941 --> 06:15:52.721
have been working on ltfs and
thirty districts.
They are helping to defend in

06:15:54.910 --> 06:15:57.757
mel's and mend ltfs and I've
also served on the department
school conditions in climate

06:15:58.192 --> 06:16:00.426
work group which prepared this
report that we've.

06:16:00.995 --> 06:16:03.262
Shared behind me.
First off thank you to the ag

06:16:03.963 --> 06:16:06.566
committee staff up for the
feedback on our bill.

06:16:07.167 --> 06:16:09.669
Californians for justice public
advocates and the department

06:16:10.370 --> 06:16:12.370
have shared amendments on monday

06:16:13.238 --> 06:16:15.574
that address staff's concerns.
We're at a major crossroads with

06:16:15.775 --> 06:16:18.544
althea benefits a hoof you know
well and we find the biggest

06:16:18.612 --> 06:16:21.213
threat.
To the success of lc ff the

06:16:22.715 --> 06:16:25.250
biggest threat equity in lc ff
is actually the lack of capacity

06:16:25.517 --> 06:16:28.186
for community engagement and
school claiming.

06:16:29.555 --> 06:16:31.890
Research and our experience in
thirty district shows the

06:16:32.658 --> 06:16:35.260
requirement to address parent
student engagement and school

06:16:35.760 --> 06:16:37.760
climate in lc ff is a

06:16:39.232 --> 06:16:41.467
significant shift for eloise.
Most of which were not prepared

06:16:41.467 --> 06:16:44.350
with the skill sets and
practices necessary to do this

06:16:44.503 --> 06:16:47.237
work ab twenty eight twenty
would provide one time funding

06:16:48.390 --> 06:16:50.875
to build the capacity at all
levels of the system to improve

06:16:51.743 --> 06:16:54.113
communication and school climate.
Funding would accelerate and

06:16:54.678 --> 06:16:57.381
scale innovative models ensure
the state evaluates and shares

06:16:58.350 --> 06:17:01.850
best practices widely and
strengthens counties. That they

06:17:01.786 --> 06:17:03.786
can carry this work on beyond

06:17:04.321 --> 06:17:06.555
the state investment.
These two things are deeply

06:17:07.157 --> 06:17:09.660
intertwined and are the lynchpin
of al cff as you heard from

06:17:10.662 --> 06:17:12.796
robert school climate surveys
combined with community

06:17:13.498 --> 06:17:15.498
engagement can lead to really

06:17:15.694 --> 06:17:17.694
powerful chains.

06:17:19.873 --> 06:17:21.906
Our framework here this report
shows that school climate
surveys assess safety

06:17:21.906 --> 06:17:24.875
relationships conditions for
teaching and learning and
engagement.

06:17:25.142 --> 06:17:27.142
The state has put hundreds of

06:17:29.817 --> 06:17:31.797
millions of dollars.
To build capacity in the system
for new in major changes like

06:17:32.116 --> 06:17:34.817
common core now is the time to
put that same investment into

06:17:35.953 --> 06:17:38.888
the new and major change around
school crime and engagement.

06:17:39.490 --> 06:17:41.756
Because this is what will foster
let's trying in collaborative

06:17:41.925 --> 06:17:43.793
relationships at the heart of
ltfs.

06:17:43.959 --> 06:17:45.959
Thank you for listening.

06:17:47.764 --> 06:17:49.932
If you others and so.
Whiskey and with public

06:17:50.534 --> 06:17:52.534
advocates in support.

06:17:53.336 --> 06:17:55.336
Also of representing the aclu

06:17:57.107 --> 06:17:59.408
thank you thanks.
Others is seen others in support

06:18:00.910 --> 06:18:03.111
any opposition.
Get up to the microphone because

06:18:03.513 --> 06:18:06.910
I fourth yeah any of us get some
apparently there were sacramento

06:18:06.816 --> 06:18:08.816
aka mulholland here for all to

06:18:08.985 --> 06:18:11.718
schools where my children goal.
In support.

06:18:12.540 --> 06:18:14.560
Democrat on behalf of state
superintendent of public

06:18:14.560 --> 06:18:16.225
instruction tom tillotson and
support.

06:18:16.225 --> 06:18:18.225
Brown's strong children now in

06:18:18.627 --> 06:18:21.162
support.
Ron rapidly after california

06:18:21.355 --> 06:18:23.355
federation of teachers and

06:18:24.398 --> 06:18:26.398
support.

06:18:26.535 --> 06:18:28.234
We think any opposition.
Seeing opposition.

06:18:29.360 --> 06:18:31.370
Thank you missed mccarty for
the bill is there's a lot of

06:18:31.940 --> 06:18:33.958
work here that probably should I
happened a long time ago quite
frankly.

06:18:34.976 --> 06:18:37.276
.
You know I just we want to be

06:18:37.345 --> 06:18:39.547
careful here I want to show this
is a money grab a non profits

06:18:39.548 --> 06:18:41.882
que.
Because we are watch where prop

06:18:42.284 --> 06:18:45.190
ninety eight dollars go so who
watch that as we go through.

06:18:45.453 --> 06:18:48.388
Different iterations of the bill
moving forward on this is one of

06:18:50.580 --> 06:18:51.960
my key concerns
ab you know the proper. My ghost

06:18:52.727 --> 06:18:55.195
to educate children and those
efforts associated with

06:18:55.195 --> 06:18:57.996
educating children any other
comments.

06:18:58.176 --> 06:19:00.832
Seeing no other comments we have
a motion.

06:19:02.203 --> 06:19:04.700
And moved all second.
Please call the roll the motion

06:19:05.606 --> 06:19:07.841
is.
To pastor program nine to read

06:19:09.422 --> 06:19:12.277
the list for there's a long list
here of challenges with this
bill. Just just to respond

06:19:13.580 --> 06:19:16.149
Mister Chair there's always a
tomorrow in this business.

06:19:16.984 --> 06:19:18.716
And so we will take well you
know how hard it was the answer

06:19:20.914 --> 06:19:22.788
that I to.
And there are the last week in
the last month.

06:19:23.155 --> 06:19:25.458
We will go to the appropriations
committee.

06:19:26.460 --> 06:19:29.193
Anti and up as you know this one
going to fact without. On some

06:19:30.330 --> 06:19:32.965
type of that budget action so
we'll make sure these issues are
addressed thank you.

06:19:33.767 --> 06:19:35.767
Let's call the roll.

06:19:37.203 --> 06:19:39.203
O'donnell. O'donnell aye kiley.

06:19:39.739 --> 06:19:42.507
Kiley not voting kalra.
Kalra aye mccarty aye aye

06:19:43.376 --> 06:19:45.376
mccarty aye steinorth.

06:19:45.678 --> 06:19:47.678
Steinorth not voting thurmond.

06:19:50.416 --> 06:19:52.818
Thurmond aye weber. Weber aye.
Thanks it was Mister Thurman

06:19:52.818 --> 06:19:54.919
which one did you push present
first.

06:19:56.655 --> 06:19:59.356
Twenty one eighty six.
Twenty one eighty six by mr

06:20:01.827 --> 06:20:03.827
thermos file item number. Eight.

06:20:08.932 --> 06:20:10.932
Eight.

06:20:12.499 --> 06:20:14.937
Thank you Mister Chair and
members stuff for allowing me to
present this bill so there are
witnesses there who needs to.

06:20:16.172 --> 06:20:18.840
Apart candice's ab twenty one
eighty six this is a stand grant.

06:20:19.231 --> 06:20:21.709
Bill.
We've been talking about stem

06:20:22.578 --> 06:20:25.130
lots night of this is a bill
that seeks to get directly how

06:20:25.181 --> 06:20:27.415
we prepare our students for the
jobs of tomorrow. Our

06:20:28.500 --> 06:20:30.500
educational system has fallen

06:20:31.447 --> 06:20:33.823
behind.
Where the projections and stem
job say that we need to go our

06:20:33.823 --> 06:20:35.823
students need more computer

06:20:41.226 --> 06:20:43.609
science? We need more teachers
who have had professional
development around stem related

06:20:43.609 --> 06:20:45.982
topics
I and they need access in

06:20:46.372 --> 06:20:48.372
communities that are hard to

06:20:48.566 --> 06:20:50.566
serve. Up like our rule

06:20:52.767 --> 06:20:54.944
communities many of which don't
have access to wifi lista truck
pulls up in a hot spot. This is

06:20:54.944 --> 06:20:57.139
california and we can do better
for our kids in this is an
opportunity to move the ball in
the right direction. At this

06:20:57.334 --> 06:20:59.334
bill would provide resources for

06:21:03.525 --> 06:21:05.687
professional development for
teachers and stem areas aye it
would also provide.

06:21:05.687 --> 06:21:07.483
Dollars for.
Into.
Instructional materials.

06:21:07.871 --> 06:21:09.267
To help support new teacher
recruitment of with a

06:21:10.491 --> 06:21:12.491
scholarship up teacher retention.

06:21:13.689 --> 06:21:15.930
In in the areas of stem
additional computer science

06:21:15.930 --> 06:21:17.930
related.

06:21:18.666 --> 06:21:20.666
Support a and an emphasis on

06:21:21.100 --> 06:21:23.336
resources for rural communities.
.

06:21:23.504 --> 06:21:26.172
I brought some witnesses who
wish to provide emphasis

06:21:26.740 --> 06:21:29.275
some of whom you've met earlier
tonight and they will give brief

06:21:30.544 --> 06:21:32.779
emphasis on how this can help we
have been stewart executive

06:21:35.167 --> 06:21:36.983
director of the california stem
network.
Jessica sock out the executive

06:21:37.918 --> 06:21:39.918
director of the california

06:21:40.554 --> 06:21:42.554
science teachers association and

06:21:44.157 --> 06:21:46.157
respectfully ask your aye vote.

06:21:48.345 --> 06:21:50.522
Thank you this is twenty one
eighty six by the way twenty one
eighty six wasn't a number not

06:21:50.522 --> 06:21:53.650
anyone eighty six and.
You tell me to will accept

06:21:54.266 --> 06:21:56.266
whatever amendments you has it.

06:21:58.438 --> 06:22:01.406
Yeah.
But. I think you Mister Chairman

06:22:04.777 --> 06:22:07.149
members on the committee I'm
vince stuart the executive
director of the california stem

06:22:07.149 --> 06:22:10.340
network in the proud sponsor of
ab twenty one eighty six.
Were statewide network

06:22:10.820 --> 06:22:12.617
affiliated with thirteen
regional networks around the

06:22:12.952 --> 06:22:15.453
state that support this
legislation as well. I'd like to

06:22:16.480 --> 06:22:17.889
start by thanking the chair of
the committee and the author for

06:22:18.323 --> 06:22:20.792
the amendments we believe it
improves this a proposal.

06:22:21.326 --> 06:22:24.295
Substantially.
I think the author really went

06:22:24.663 --> 06:22:27.365
through what the bill does.
So given the hour I will not

06:22:27.899 --> 06:22:30.100
belabor the point in just a
respectfully request an aye vote

06:22:31.837 --> 06:22:33.971
thank you.
Good evening jessica soccer

06:22:34.406 --> 06:22:36.406
representing california science

06:22:37.594 --> 06:22:40.511
teachers association simply
wanting to add that with the
gaining momentum of the
implementation of the next

06:22:40.578 --> 06:22:42.613
generation science standards
now's the time to make this

06:22:42.914 --> 06:22:45.482
critical investment in support
of science and stem education

06:22:46.551 --> 06:22:49.119
respectfully ask your about.
Thank you others in support.

06:22:49.887 --> 06:22:51.887
Cristina marcellus on behalf of

06:22:53.220 --> 06:22:55.580
project lead the way in support.
Nick roman on behalf of the

06:22:55.593 --> 06:22:57.193
california educational
technology professionals in

06:22:59.262 --> 06:23:01.698
support.
The injury done behalf of san

06:23:02.790 --> 06:23:04.790
francisco unified school

06:23:04.867 --> 06:23:07.370
district it's part.
Danielle can a kaiser on behalf

06:23:07.538 --> 06:23:09.538
of common sense kids action in

06:23:10.574 --> 06:23:12.754
support.
Lara bennett with technician

06:23:13.643 --> 06:23:16.412
support.
Karrueche with cantiere were in

06:23:16.413 --> 06:23:18.647
the process of formulating a
support position.

06:23:20.150 --> 06:23:22.383
You any opposition.
Seeing no opposition.

06:23:24.560 --> 06:23:27.890
A concert by any other
committee members that we have a
motion.

06:23:27.157 --> 06:23:29.925
It's mccarty mousse Mister Carr
seconds.

06:23:30.960 --> 06:23:33.729
I you May close the motion is to
pass as amended to
appropriations I respectfully

06:23:33.796 --> 06:23:35.796
ask your aye vote.

06:23:35.898 --> 06:23:38.300
It's call the roll.
O'donnell time o'donnell aye

06:23:39.602 --> 06:23:41.602
kiley.

06:23:42.380 --> 06:23:44.380
Kiley not voting kalra.

06:23:44.206 --> 06:23:46.206
Kalra aye mccarty.

06:23:46.741 --> 06:23:49.770
mccarty aye steinorth.
Steinorth not voting thurmond.

06:23:49.780 --> 06:23:51.780
Thurmond aye weber.

06:23:52.259 --> 06:23:54.259
Weber I.

06:23:56.450 --> 06:23:57.824
Hopefully.
Luis five votes it is our in our

06:23:58.520 --> 06:24:01.188
removed a file item number eight.
Pine river eight it's ab twenty

06:24:01.957 --> 06:24:04.492
one sixty eight you May perceive
in writing. Thinkers chair

06:24:04.659 --> 06:24:06.894
members of the school's ab
twenty one sixty eight that

06:24:07.362 --> 06:24:09.830
seeks to help us. With the
retention of special education

06:24:10.131 --> 06:24:12.633
teachers we've talked a great
deal about the need to make

06:24:12.834 --> 06:24:15.701
improvements in special
education this bill provides.

06:24:17.772 --> 06:24:20.274
Resources to support a mentor
teacher program where.

06:24:21.750 --> 06:24:23.276
Teachers in special ed would be
bent toward.

06:24:23.878 --> 06:24:25.878
By teachers aye it would

06:24:26.130 --> 06:24:28.114
support stipends curriculum.
And development of other

06:24:28.299 --> 06:24:30.299
programs.

06:24:30.451 --> 06:24:32.451
To support the program I

06:24:32.953 --> 06:24:35.522
respectfully ask your aye vote.
You know this in support I'm
sure.

06:24:36.523 --> 06:24:39.224
I. Apologize out with me tonight
is deborah brown of for the

06:24:39.326 --> 06:24:42.950
company department of education
to provide decimal.

06:24:42.129 --> 06:24:45.630
Good evening de around on behalf
of state superintendent of
public contracting instruction

06:24:45.299 --> 06:24:47.899
top products and it is not that
this bill does. Seek to provide

06:24:48.350 --> 06:24:50.427
some support for teachers have
made the commitment to help our

06:24:50.502 --> 06:24:53.105
highest need students and so we
think that having. Mentorship

06:24:53.573 --> 06:24:56.375
programs will really provide us
on some sports we can't keep

06:24:57.611 --> 06:25:00.441
those teachers in the classroom
energy of your aye vote thank
you.

06:25:00.979 --> 06:25:03.148
Thank you others in support.
Whiskey and with public

06:25:06.686 --> 06:25:09.540
advocates in support.
Ab evenly injury down biafra

06:25:09.220 --> 06:25:11.220
santa clara county office of

06:25:13.257 --> 06:25:15.727
education support.
Daniel candor kaiser on behalf

06:25:15.727 --> 06:25:17.727
of common sense kids action in

06:25:20.598 --> 06:25:22.598
support.

06:25:22.934 --> 06:25:25.169
He looked.
Have ana hasn't display right

06:25:25.470 --> 06:25:27.536
californians park we do have a
couple questions working with

06:25:27.537 --> 06:25:29.506
the others up stick in
addressing think you.

06:25:31.750 --> 06:25:33.243
.
No the motions to pass as

06:25:34.110 --> 06:25:36.414
amended to appropriations unseen
comments ready committee members

06:25:36.414 --> 06:25:38.848
that we have a motion on this.
Would it.

06:25:39.383 --> 06:25:41.951
So you May close respectfully
ask your aye vote thank you to

06:25:42.553 --> 06:25:44.718
pass as amended appropriations
please call the roll. O'donnell

06:25:45.770 --> 06:25:47.455
aye.
O'donnell aye kiley aye kiley

06:25:48.759 --> 06:25:51.561
aye kalra.
Kalra aye mccarty.

06:25:52.731 --> 06:25:54.965
Mccarty aye steinorth steinorth
aye thurmond aye thurmond aye

06:25:54.965 --> 06:25:56.965
weber.

06:25:57.667 --> 06:25:59.668
Weber I.
Bills out.

06:26:03.338 --> 06:26:05.338
Thank you.

06:26:08.445 --> 06:26:11.113
I don't mind right.
So with.

06:26:11.247 --> 06:26:13.247
Let's go ahead not take up the

06:26:13.615 --> 06:26:15.183
consent calendar.
Do we have a motion on the

06:26:17.153 --> 06:26:19.153
consent calendar.

06:26:19.989 --> 06:26:22.290
Moved and seconded.
The consent items are as follows

06:26:22.525 --> 06:26:24.759
file item number one ab
seventeen forty four by mr

06:26:25.795 --> 06:26:27.462
mccarty file item number four ab
eighteen eighty semi Mister

06:26:28.197 --> 06:26:30.665
India. Thailand number eleven ab
twenty to thirty nine by Mister

06:26:31.567 --> 06:26:33.934
Garcia.
Follow over thirteen ab twenty

06:26:34.300 --> 06:26:36.300
two ninety one by Mister Chiu

06:26:36.537 --> 06:26:38.537
file item or sixteen ab twenty

06:26:39.107 --> 06:26:41.107
four forty nine airstream put.

06:26:41.143 --> 06:26:44.780
Is that okay these are not the
gazette. Thank.

06:26:45.147 --> 06:26:47.147
Well only three okay.

06:26:47.149 --> 06:26:49.415
File item number twenty nine ab
twenty eight ninety one.

06:26:50.318 --> 06:26:52.920
Mister Holton do the motions to
pass to appropriations.

06:26:53.888 --> 06:26:56.655
File item number thirty two ab
three zero five eight o'donnell

06:26:56.958 --> 06:26:59.458
to pass to approach it
appropriations is the motion.

06:27:00.195 --> 06:27:02.429
Filing or thirty seven ab thirty
two thirty three by mr carl the

06:27:02.864 --> 06:27:04.864
motion as you pass as amended to

06:27:06.200 --> 06:27:07.868
appropriations.
Please do we have a motion on

06:27:08.803 --> 06:27:11.471
that. Removed and second please
call the roll o'donnell by

06:27:12.473 --> 06:27:14.473
o'donnell aye kiley aye kiley

06:27:15.242 --> 06:27:18.111
aye kalra. Kalra aye mccarty.
Mccarty aye steinorth steinorth

06:27:19.380 --> 06:27:21.380
aye thurman thurmond aye weber.

06:27:26.153 --> 06:27:28.254
Weber I.
Okay so strict with sickle but

06:27:28.254 --> 06:27:30.254
violent file a motion on file

06:27:30.424 --> 06:27:32.424
item with that so good your file

06:27:37.496 --> 06:27:39.496
item.

06:27:40.100 --> 06:27:42.868
One file item number one.
Wears a cave by mr medina do we

06:27:50.900 --> 06:27:52.900
have a motion.

06:27:57.316 --> 06:28:00.118
Phone number to the motion.
Are we do not have a motion so

06:28:01.120 --> 06:28:03.120
the file item number one fails.

06:28:06.490 --> 06:28:08.892
Moved to. Where we go next?
Go to the bill's on call file

06:28:09.929 --> 06:28:12.330
item number two.
Phone number three I'm sorry

06:28:12.431 --> 06:28:14.799
file on number three ab
seventeen sixty three by Mister

06:28:15.100 --> 06:28:17.100
Chiu.

06:28:19.370 --> 06:28:21.370
Is call the roll.

06:28:21.473 --> 06:28:23.473
O'donnell aye o'donnell aye

06:28:23.508 --> 06:28:25.508
kiley aye coat kiley no and

06:28:27.100 --> 06:28:29.246
kalra.
I am kalra aye.

06:28:29.848 --> 06:28:31.848
Steinorth.

06:28:32.784 --> 06:28:34.784
Steinorth by.

06:28:35.386 --> 06:28:37.386
Seventeen severely three.

06:28:38.289 --> 06:28:41.224
so it's out it has.
Through the file and river for.

06:28:42.260 --> 06:28:44.260
Five fund rifai file item number

06:28:44.962 --> 06:28:47.529
five. A. B. Two thousand two by
Mister Rammell this ab two

06:28:47.632 --> 06:28:49.632
thousand two.

06:28:50.968 --> 06:28:52.968
Please call the roll.

06:28:58.409 --> 06:29:01.177
Kiley aye kiley aye kalra.
Kalra aye mccarty.

06:29:01.745 --> 06:29:03.745
Mccarty I thurmond.

06:29:05.648 --> 06:29:08.840
Thurmond I.
File item number fourteen

06:29:10.620 --> 06:29:13.189
fourteen.
In cologne and with it is who's

06:29:14.890 --> 06:29:17.491
that.
I am fourteen it's o'donnell.

06:29:18.280 --> 06:29:20.728
Three file item forty twenty
four eighty eight ab twenty four

06:29:21.564 --> 06:29:23.564
eighty eight o'donnell.

06:29:25.401 --> 06:29:28.360
Please call the roll.
Twenty four eighty eight.

06:29:30.106 --> 06:29:32.106
Kalra.

06:29:32.108 --> 06:29:34.643
Kalra aye mccarty.
Mccarty I thurmond.

06:29:37.880 --> 06:29:39.880
Thurmond I.

06:29:44.754 --> 06:29:47.188
This bill is out with six votes.
If I and number twenty two

06:29:47.256 --> 06:29:50.191
that's a by doctor whether
that's a. B. Twenty three fifty

06:29:50.726 --> 06:29:52.726
seven ab twenty three fifty

06:29:52.995 --> 06:29:55.963
seven.
Twenty six fifty seven
starscream twenty six fifty

06:29:56.298 --> 06:29:58.298
seven.

06:29:59.366 --> 06:30:02.103
My doctor weber.
Is call the roll.

06:30:02.637 --> 06:30:04.637
And kalra.

06:30:04.839 --> 06:30:07.807
Kalra aye.
Steinorth.

06:30:10.512 --> 06:30:12.780
Steinorth not voting.
It has for both the bill's eyes

06:30:15.617 --> 06:30:17.617
for vote.

06:30:17.719 --> 06:30:19.719
File item thirty three thirty

06:30:20.354 --> 06:30:21.887
three by mr mccarty.
I know I is having this

06:30:24.900 --> 06:30:26.900
recording.

06:30:27.228 --> 06:30:29.429
I can't worst thirty three.
And now we are para of I Miss

06:30:30.497 --> 06:30:33.132
Rubio file item thirty three
it's a. B..

06:30:34.134 --> 06:30:36.936
i believe three zero nine six.
Three zero nine six.

06:30:39.173 --> 06:30:41.173
I was rubio.

06:30:42.376 --> 06:30:44.777
And kalra.
Kalra I. Mccarty. Mccarty aye

06:30:44.911 --> 06:30:47.480
thurmond.
Thurmond I.

06:30:53.119 --> 06:30:54.885
Since.
We've dug up in just

06:31:10.336 --> 06:31:12.336
this hearing is adjourned